Parallax

31 October, 1517

Luther sends out his Ninety-five Theses

A friar and professor in a small Saxon university town wrote to his archbishop to complain about a sales campaign for indulgences. Within weeks his Latin propositions were being reprinted across Germany.

Wittenberg, Electoral Saxony

On 31 October 1517, the eve of All Saints, Martin Luther sat down in the Augustinian friary at Wittenberg and wrote a letter to Albrecht of Brandenburg, archbishop of Mainz and the most powerful churchman in Germany. It was respectful in form and alarming in content. Preachers working under the archbishop’s authority, Luther wrote, were telling the people that buying a letter of indulgence would make their salvation certain and release souls from purgatory the moment the coin dropped into the chest. He begged Albrecht to rein them in, and enclosed a set of propositions for academic debate.

Luther was thirty-three, a doctor of theology and professor of the Bible at the new university founded by the elector of Saxony, Frederick the Wise. His propositions, ninety-five of them, were written in Latin for scholars. The first declared that when Christ said ‘repent’, he meant the whole life of a believer to be one of repentance. Others warned that indulgences made people complacent, that the pope could remit only penalties he himself had imposed, and that a Christian who gave to the poor did better than one who bought a pardon.

The preacher Luther had in mind was Johann Tetzel, a Dominican friar and an experienced salesman of indulgences, who had been working the towns of Juterbog and Zerbst just over the border. Frederick would not allow the campaign in Saxony, partly because it competed with the indulgences attached to his own great collection of relics in the Castle Church at Wittenberg. So Luther’s parishioners walked across the border to buy, and came back expecting forgiveness without confession or amendment.

According to a long tradition, Luther also nailed the theses to the door of the Castle Church that day, the university’s usual notice board. The scene has been painted and carved countless times. Whether it happened is uncertain, but either way the theses were soon out of his control. Albrecht sent them to Rome in December. By the end of the year printers in Nuremberg, Leipzig and Basel had produced editions, and a German translation followed. Luther, who had expected a debate among academics, found himself read by people who had never been to a university.

Many of the theses asked the questions ordinary buyers were asking. Why, one of them asked, did the pope, whose wealth exceeded that of the richest Roman, not build the basilica of St Peter with his own money rather than with that of poor believers? It was put as a question laymen might raise and the Church must be able to answer. Rome’s answer, when it came, was not about money but about authority.

How it came to this

An indulgence was a grant by the Church remitting the temporal punishment still owed for sins already forgiven, in this life or in purgatory. In theory it required true contrition and confession; in practice, by 1500, indulgences were sold on a large scale, extended to the dead, and used to fund crusades, churches, bridges and hospitals. Leo X’s indulgence of 1515 was meant to pay for the rebuilding of St Peter’s basilica in Rome, which had been under way since 1506.

In Albrecht’s lands it had a second purpose. Already archbishop of Magdeburg and administrator of Halberstadt, Albrecht had been elected archbishop of Mainz in 1514 and needed a costly papal dispensation to hold so many sees at once. He borrowed the money from the Fugger bank of Augsburg. Under a private arrangement, half of what the indulgence raised in his provinces would go to repay that loan, with Fugger agents present when the chests were opened. Luther seems not to have known this in 1517, but it explains why the archbishop pushed the campaign so hard.

How each side saw it

Rome and its theologians

To the papal court, Luther at first looked like a quarrelsome friar in a dispute between religious orders. The papal theologian Sylvester Prierias replied in 1518 that whoever denied that the Church of Rome could do what it did regarding indulgences was a heretic, which moved the argument from practice to the authority of the pope. Catholic theologians held that indulgences were a legitimate exercise of the Church’s power to bind and loose, and that preachers’ excesses did not make the doctrine wrong. The Council of Trent later abolished the office of indulgence-seller while upholding the doctrine.

Tetzel and the indulgence preachers

Tetzel denied preaching that money alone freed souls, and the famous jingle about the coin and the soul springing from purgatory is known chiefly from Luther, who quotes it in his twenty-seventh thesis as something preachers said. Tetzel published counter-theses in 1518, written with the theologian Konrad Wimpina, defending the doctrine. Whatever he said in the pulpit, the official instructions Albrecht issued to preachers did promise remission for the dead without contrition by the buyer, which supported Luther’s complaint.

Catholic and Protestant historians

For Protestant tradition 31 October became the beginning of the Reformation, celebrated as such from the first centenary in 1617. Catholic historians such as Joseph Lortz in the twentieth century accepted that Luther had reacted to real abuses while arguing that he misunderstood the Catholic theology of his day. Recent historians, among them Diarmaid MacCulloch and Eamon Duffy, prefer to speak of many reformations, Catholic and Protestant, and warn against making one day and one man the hinge of so large a change.

What is disputed

Luther never mentioned nailing the theses in his own writings, and the first account comes from Philip Melanchthon after Luther’s death in 1546; Melanchthon was not in Wittenberg in 1517. In 1961 the Catholic historian Erwin Iserloh argued that no posting took place. In 2006 a note by Luther’s secretary Georg Rorer came to light saying that the theses were posted on the doors of the Wittenberg churches on the eve of All Saints, which revived the case for it, though perhaps with paste rather than nails. The book behind this entry makes Luther thirty-four and calls St Peter’s a cathedral; he was thirty-three, and it is a basilica.

What followed

Luther was summoned to Rome, examined by Cardinal Cajetan at Augsburg in 1518, debated at Leipzig in 1519, condemned in a papal bull in 1520 and excommunicated in January 1521. At the Diet of Worms that April he refused to recant and was put under the ban of the empire. The churches that followed him, and the wars between them and Rome, divided Europe for centuries. On 31 October 1999 Lutheran and Catholic representatives signed a joint declaration at Augsburg on the doctrine of justification, the question at the heart of the quarrel.

Read further

  • Lyndal Roper, Martin Luther: Renegade and Prophet (2016)
  • Heiko A. Oberman, Luther: Man between God and the Devil (1989)
  • Andrew Pettegree, Brand Luther: 1517, Printing, and the Making of the Reformation (2015)
  • Diarmaid MacCulloch, Reformation: Europe’s House Divided, 1490-1700 (2003)
  • Erwin Iserloh, The Theses Were Not Posted (1968)

Same day, other years

1956

Britain and France bomb Egypt

EgyptMiddle East

Three months after Gamal Abdel Nasser nationalised the Suez Canal Company, Israel invaded Sinai on 29 October. Britain and France then demanded that both sides withdraw from the canal zone, an ultimatum Egypt was bound to reject, and on the evening of the 31st their aircraft began bombing Egyptian airfields. Nasser blocked the canal by sinking ships in it. Anglo-French paratroops and seaborne forces landed at Port Said on 5 and 6 November, but under American financial pressure and Soviet threats the two governments accepted a ceasefire with the canal only partly taken.

Seen from elsewhere. Anthony Eden told the Commons he had had no foreknowledge of Israel’s attack; in fact the three governments had agreed the plan at Sevres a week earlier. Egyptians call it the Tripartite Aggression, and Port Said’s resistance is a national memory. The crisis ended Britain’s pretensions as an independent great power.

1961

Stalin is carried out of Lenin’s tomb

Red Square, MoscowEurope

Since his death in 1953 Stalin’s embalmed body had lain beside Lenin’s in the mausoleum on Red Square. At the twenty-second party congress Khrushchev renewed his attack on Stalin’s crimes, and an old Bolshevik, Dora Lazurkina, who had spent years in the camps, told the delegates that Lenin had appeared to her in a dream and said he did not like lying next to Stalin. The congress voted to remove him. On the night of 31 October, with Red Square closed off, the body was taken out and buried by the Kremlin wall under a layer of concrete. His name was removed from the mausoleum.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Soviet citizens, especially in Georgia, resented the humiliation of a leader they credited with victory in the war, and China’s leaders condemned the campaign against him. Stalin’s reputation in Russia has since partly recovered, and the question of whether Lenin too should be buried is still unresolved.

1984

Indira Gandhi is shot by her bodyguards

New Delhi, IndiaAsia

On her way across the garden of her official residence to be interviewed by Peter Ustinov, India’s prime minister was shot by two of her Sikh bodyguards, Beant Singh and Satwant Singh. They acted in revenge for Operation Blue Star in June, when she had sent the army into the Golden Temple at Amritsar to remove the armed preacher Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale and his followers, a battle in which hundreds died and the shrine was badly damaged. Her son Rajiv was sworn in that evening. Over the following days mobs killed thousands of Sikhs in Delhi and other cities.

Seen from elsewhere. Official figures put the Sikh dead in Delhi at about 2,800; human rights groups give higher totals. Survivors accused Congress party politicians of leading the mobs, and convictions came decades later, Sajjan Kumar’s in 2018. Some Sikhs honour the assassins as martyrs; most Indians remember Gandhi as a leader murdered for defending the state.

1992

The Vatican closes the Galileo case

Vatican CityEurope

Addressing the Pontifical Academy of Sciences, Pope John Paul II received the report of a commission he had set up to re-examine the condemnation of Galileo Galilei in 1633 for teaching that the earth moves around the sun. He acknowledged that the theologians who judged Galileo had erred in failing to distinguish faith from a scientific question, spoke of a tragic mutual incomprehension, and recognised Galileo as a more perceptive reader of Scripture than his judges. It was the most formal admission of the Church’s error in the case in 359 years.

Seen from elsewhere. Critics said it was not a full apology: blame fell on unnamed theologians rather than on Pope Urban VIII or the institution, and the commission’s report suggested Galileo had also overstated his proofs. Some Catholic writers argued in turn that the affair had long been exaggerated into a myth of science against faith.

Also on 31 October