Parallax

15 October, 202 BC

Scipio defeats Hannibal at Zama

After sixteen years undefeated in Italy, Hannibal fought his last battle on his own soil against a younger man who had studied him. The only accounts we have were written by the winners.

Inland from Carthage, in modern Tunisia

Hannibal Barca had left Africa as a boy of nine. He came back in his mid-forties, in the autumn of 203 BC, recalled from the toe of Italy by a city that had run out of other generals. A Roman army under Publius Cornelius Scipio, thirty-three years old, had been in Africa for more than a year. It had burned two Carthaginian camps in a single night, won a pitched battle on the Great Plains, and put its own candidate, Masinissa, on the throne of Numidia. A truce had collapsed after Carthaginians seized Roman supply ships driven ashore in a storm.

The two armies met the following year several days’ march inland. Polybius says the commanders first met between the lines with interpreters, and that Hannibal offered Spain and the islands for peace; Scipio answered that Carthage had broken its word and must fight or surrender. Then they drew up. Hannibal had more infantry, perhaps 36,000 to Scipio’s 29,000, and eighty elephants, but he was short of the weapon that had won him Cannae. Masinissa had brought Rome 4,000 Numidian horsemen and 6,000 foot.

The elephants went first. Scipio had left lanes between his maniples, masked by light troops, instead of the usual chequerboard. Horns and trumpets panicked some of the animals back into Hannibal’s own left wing; others ran down the lanes and out the rear. Masinissa on the right and Gaius Laelius on the left then drove the Carthaginian cavalry off the field and disappeared in pursuit.

That left the infantry. Hannibal had arranged his in three lines: mercenaries from Liguria, Gaul, the Balearics and Mauretania in front, Carthaginian and Libyan levies behind them, and at the rear, held well back, the veterans he had brought from Italy. The first two lines were ground down in turn, and Polybius says they came to blows with each other when the second would not open its ranks. Across ground slippery with blood and heaped with bodies, Scipio halted, re-formed his three lines into one long front, and advanced on the veterans.

The two sides were now equal in numbers, spirit and weapons, and neither gave way until Laelius and Masinissa returned and charged into the Carthaginian rear. Polybius gives 20,000 Carthaginian dead and as many captured, for 1,500 Romans. Hannibal rode with a few horsemen to the coast, and then to Carthage, where he told the council there was no hope except in peace.

How it came to this

Rome and Carthage had first fought, over Sicily, from 264 to 241 BC, and Carthage had lost its fleet and the island. Hannibal’s father Hamilcar rebuilt its power in Spain, and in 218 Hannibal, provoked or provoking over the town of Saguntum, marched from Spain across the Alps into Italy. He destroyed Roman armies at the Trebia, Lake Trasimene and, in 216, Cannae, where perhaps 50,000 Romans and allies died in an afternoon. But Rome’s Italian alliance mostly held, Carthage sent him little, and he could not take the city.

Scipio’s father and uncle were both killed commanding in Spain. Given that command in 210 at an age when he was legally too young for it, he took New Carthage in a surprise assault, beat the Carthaginian armies at Baecula and Ilipa, and cleared Spain by 206. Against the opposition of the old Fabius Maximus, who wanted Hannibal dealt with in Italy first, he then persuaded the Senate to let him carry the war to Africa, and crossed from Sicily in 204.

How each side saw it

Carthage

No Carthaginian account survives. Hannibal took Greek historians with him, Sosylus of Sparta and Silenus, and their works are lost apart from a scrap of papyrus; Carthage’s own libraries were dispersed when Rome destroyed the city in 146 BC. What we know of Hannibal’s reasoning comes through Polybius, a Greek who lived in the household of Scipio’s adopted grandson, and through Livy, who wrote two centuries later for a Roman public. Both make Hannibal generous in defeat and prophetic about fortune. Even his famous oath of eternal enmity to Rome is a story his enemies preserved.

Numidia

For the Numidians of the interior the war was a contest between two of their own princes, Syphax of the Masaesyli, who sided with Carthage, and Masinissa of the Massyli, who had fought for Carthage in Spain and changed sides when it backed his rival. Masinissa’s cavalry decided the battle, and he was its largest beneficiary: Rome confirmed him as king of a united Numidia and he ruled for more than fifty years, steadily taking Carthaginian land. In modern Algeria and among Amazigh activists he is honoured as a founder of North African statehood. Roman authors are, again, almost our only source for him.

Rome’s own doubters

Not every Roman admired the victor. Scipio took the name Africanus, the first Roman general called after a land he had conquered, and the peace he granted, which left Carthage standing, struck some senators as lenient. Cato the Elder, who had served under him and loathed his Greek tastes and free spending, pursued him and his brother through the courts in the 180s over money received from King Antiochus. Scipio is said to have torn up the account books before the Senate. He withdrew to his farm at Liternum and died there, in about 183, having asked not to be buried in Rome.

What is disputed

The day of the battle is unknown; 15 October is one traditional guess, 19 October another, the latter built on a late report of a solar eclipse. Even the season is inferred. The site has never been found: Polybius names Margaron and Livy Naraggara, and several Tunisian towns were called Zama. The meeting of the generals may be a literary invention, though Polybius was well informed. Eighty elephants is more than Carthage is likely to have had trained in time. Some scholars think the casualty figures and the neat return of the cavalry too tidy, and a minority have suggested the battle was smaller than the tradition claims.

What followed

The peace of 201 BC stripped Carthage of its overseas territory, its elephants and all but ten warships, imposed 10,000 talents payable over fifty years, and forbade it to make war in Africa without Rome’s consent, which left it helpless against Masinissa. Hannibal, elected chief magistrate, reformed its finances so well that the indemnity could have been paid off early; his enemies denounced him to Rome and he fled east in 195, taking poison in Bithynia about twelve years later. In 149 Rome found a pretext, and in 146 it levelled Carthage. Rome was thereafter without a rival in the western Mediterranean.

Read further

  • Polybius, The Histories, Book 15
  • Livy, History of Rome, Book 30
  • Adrian Goldsworthy, The Fall of Carthage: The Punic Wars 265-146 BC (2003)
  • Dexter Hoyos, Hannibal’s Dynasty: Power and Politics in the Western Mediterranean, 247-183 BC (2003)
  • Richard Miles, Carthage Must Be Destroyed: The Rise and Fall of an Ancient Civilization (2010)

Same day, other years

1582

Ten days vanish from the calendar

Rome, Spain, Portugal and PolandWorldwide

The calendar Julius Caesar introduced assumed a year of 365 and a quarter days, about eleven minutes too long. By the sixteenth century the spring equinox, on which the date of Easter depends, had slipped ten days from where the Council of Nicaea had found it. Pope Gregory XIII adopted a reform devised by the Calabrian physician Aloysius Lilius and worked out by the Jesuit mathematician Christopher Clavius: drop ten days at once, and in future omit three leap years in every four centuries. In the Papal States, Spain, Portugal and Poland, Thursday 4 October 1582 was followed by Friday 15 October. Teresa of Ávila died during that night.

Seen from elsewhere. Protestant states suspected a papal trick and held out, most of Germany until 1700 and Britain until 1752. Orthodox churches still calculate Easter by the Julian calendar. The tale of English mobs demanding their eleven days back rests largely on a Hogarth print and an election slogan.

1917

Mata Hari is shot at Vincennes

Vincennes, near Paris, FranceEurope

Margaretha Zelle, a hatter’s daughter from Leeuwarden in the Netherlands, had reinvented herself in Paris in 1905 as Mata Hari, a dancer of supposedly Javanese temple rites. By the war she was forty, short of money and living on wealthy lovers of several nationalities. In 1916 she accepted 20,000 francs from a German consul to gather information, and soon afterwards agreed to spy for the French officer Georges Ladoux. In February 1917 the French arrested her, citing intercepted German radio messages from Madrid about an agent designated H21. A closed military court convicted her in July after deliberating for less than an hour. She was shot on the morning of 15 October and is reported to have refused a blindfold.

Seen from elsewhere. The prosecution blamed her for the deaths of tens of thousands of soldiers and produced no evidence of any secret she had passed. Many historians think France, shaken by mutinies in 1917, needed a spy to punish. German files confirm that she was enrolled and paid, and suggest she delivered nothing of value.

1987

Thomas Sankara is killed in Ouagadougou

Ouagadougou, Burkina FasoAfrica

Captain Thomas Sankara took power in Upper Volta in 1983 at the age of thirty-three and renamed it Burkina Faso, ‘land of upright people’. In four years his government vaccinated millions of children, planted trees against the advancing desert, built schools and a railway with volunteer labour, banned forced marriage and female genital cutting, sold the ministerial Mercedes fleet and told African leaders not to repay their foreign debts. On the afternoon of 15 October 1987 soldiers burst into a meeting at the Conseil de l’Entente compound and shot him and twelve colleagues. His closest friend and deputy, Blaise Compaoré, took over and ruled for twenty-seven years. The death certificate gave natural causes.

Seen from elsewhere. Compaoré said Sankara had been about to arrest his comrades and that the revolution needed ‘rectification’. Trade unionists, chiefs and teachers dismissed or jailed under Sankara’s revolutionary committees had their own grievances. In 2022 a military court in Ouagadougou convicted Compaoré in his absence of complicity in the murder. A French role has long been alleged and not proved.

2003

China puts an astronaut in orbit

Jiuquan, Gansu, ChinaAsia

At nine in the morning on 15 October 2003 a Long March 2F rocket lifted off from the Jiuquan launch centre in the Gobi desert carrying Shenzhou 5 and Lieutenant Colonel Yang Liwei, a thirty-eight-year-old fighter pilot. He circled the Earth fourteen times in a little over twenty-one hours, ate, slept briefly, showed the flags of China and the United Nations to the camera, and landed on the grasslands of Inner Mongolia early the next day. China became the third country, after the Soviet Union in 1961 and the United States in 1962, to send a person into orbit with its own rocket. The programme, approved in 1992, had flown four uncrewed tests.

Seen from elsewhere. The launch was not broadcast live, in case it failed. Yang later wrote that violent vibration during the ascent made him think he would die. Critics at home and abroad questioned the cost for a country with many rural poor, and since 2011 United States law has barred NASA from cooperating with China.

Also on 15 October