Parallax

16 October, 1793

Marie Antoinette goes to the guillotine

Tried in two days on charges that ranged from treason to incest, the former queen of France was taken through Paris in an open cart with her hands tied. She was thirty-seven. The court had no proof of her real offence, which was real.

Place de la Révolution, Paris, France

The verdict came at about four in the morning on 16 October 1793. Marie Antoinette, described in the indictment as the widow Capet, had been before the Revolutionary Tribunal for the better part of two days and a night, in a hall of the old Palace of Justice a few steps from her cell in the Conciergerie. Some forty witnesses had been heard. Her two lawyers, Chauveau-Lagarde and Tronson du Coudray, had been appointed less than two days before the trial opened. The jury found unanimously that she had conspired with foreign powers and plotted civil war. She showed no reaction and walked back to her cell without help.

The public prosecutor, Antoine Fouquier-Tinville, had accused her of sending French millions to her brother the emperor, of directing the king’s attempted flight in 1791, and of ordering the Swiss Guards to fire on the people in August 1792. The journalist Jacques Hébert added something else: that she had sexually abused her eight-year-old son, on the strength of a statement the boy had signed in the Temple prison under the tutelage of his keeper. Pressed by a juror to answer, she said that nature refused to answer such a charge made against a mother, and appealed to all the mothers present. The gallery, which had come to jeer, murmured in her favour.

Back in the cell she wrote to her sister-in-law Élisabeth, asking pardon of those she had wronged and commending her children to her. The letter was never delivered. It was found years later among the papers of Robespierre.

At about eleven the executioner Henri Sanson cut her hair and tied her hands behind her back. Louis XVI had gone to his death nine months earlier in a closed carriage; she was put in an open cart, seated backwards on a plank, with a priest who had sworn the constitutional oath and from whom she would not take absolution. She wore a white dress and cap. The painter Jacques-Louis David, a member of the Convention, sketched her from a window in the Rue Saint-Honoré as she passed: upright, thin, the mouth turned down.

The cart took about an hour to reach the Place de la Révolution. She climbed the scaffold quickly, and the blade fell at a quarter past twelve. Sanson’s assistant showed the head to the crowd, which shouted ‘Vive la République’. The body was taken to the cemetery of the Madeleine and buried in a common grave under quicklime.

How it came to this

Maria Antonia, fifteenth child of the Empress Maria Theresa, was sent to France in 1770 at fourteen to marry the heir to the throne and seal an alliance between two dynasties that had been enemies for centuries. The marriage went unconsummated for seven years. As queen from 1774 she spent heavily, favoured a small circle and withdrew from court ritual to her retreat at the Trianon. Paris pamphleteers made ‘the Austrian woman’ the subject of a flood of obscene libels, and the diamond necklace swindle of 1785, in which she was the victim, convinced much of the public that she was guilty.

After 1789 she pressed the king to resist the Revolution and was the moving force behind the family’s failed escape to Varennes in June 1791. When France declared war on Austria in April 1792 she was, in the eyes of Paris, an enemy within. The monarchy was overthrown on 10 August 1792 and the family imprisoned in the Temple. Louis was executed on 21 January 1793. In July her son was taken from her, and in August she was moved to the Conciergerie as France faced invasion, civil war in the Vendée and the start of the Terror.

How each side saw it

The revolutionary government and the Paris sections

To the Jacobins and the sans-culottes she was the head of the ‘Austrian committee’ that had tried to deliver France to its invaders. Hébert’s newspaper, Le Père Duchesne, had demanded her head for months in the language of the street. The Committee of Public Safety had for a time kept her as a bargaining counter with Vienna; by October, with the Republic at war on every frontier and the Paris crowd pressing the Convention, her trial was a political necessity, like the trial of the Girondin deputies that followed within days. Robespierre is reported to have been furious at Hébert’s accusation of incest, as a blunder that won her sympathy.

Royalists and the Catholic tradition

Edmund Burke had lamented her treatment in 1790, writing that the age of chivalry was gone, and after 1793 émigrés and royalists made her a martyr. Her last letter, with its Christian forgiveness of her enemies, was published under the restored monarchy in 1816 and read from pulpits. Louis XVIII had her remains and the king’s exhumed in 1815 and reburied at Saint-Denis, and built the Chapelle Expiatoire over the old cemetery. In this tradition the trial is judicial murder of a mother and a foreigner, and the incest charge the proof of what the Revolution had become. The Austrian court, her own family, had done little to save her.

Modern historians

Research in the Vienna archives has shown that she did what the prosecution could not prove. In the spring of 1792 she passed the French army’s plans of campaign to the Austrians through her old adviser Mercy-Argenteau and her confidant Axel von Fersen. Historians who accept that nonetheless agree that the trial was a formality with the verdict settled in advance. Lynn Hunt and Chantal Thomas have studied the pornographic pamphlets and argue that the hatred fixed on her was also a fear of women’s influence in public life: within two weeks the Convention closed the women’s political clubs, and Olympe de Gouges and Madame Roland were guillotined in early November.

What is disputed

She almost certainly never said ‘Let them eat cake’. Rousseau attributes the remark to an unnamed ‘great princess’ in a passage of the Confessions written when Marie Antoinette was a child in Vienna, and no contemporary pinned it on her. Her reported apology for treading on the executioner’s foot comes from secondhand tradition. The story that her hair turned white overnight is unverifiable, though witnesses agree it had whitened in prison. Details of her last morning rest on the recollections of a prison servant, Rosalie Lamorlière, taken down decades later. Whether her son’s statement was coached, forced or simply forged in his name is unknown.

What followed

Madame Élisabeth was guillotined in May 1794. The boy, Louis XVII to royalists, died in the Temple in June 1795, aged ten, of tuberculosis and neglect; DNA tests on his preserved heart in 2000 ended two centuries of claims that he had escaped. His sister Marie-Thérèse was exchanged for French prisoners that December. Hébert went to the guillotine in March 1794 and Fouquier-Tinville in May 1795. The queen has since been remade by each generation, as martyr, as frivolous cause of revolution, as victim of misogyny and as a figure of fashion, and remains the most recognisable face of the old regime.

Read further

  • Antonia Fraser, Marie Antoinette: The Journey (2001)
  • Evelyne Lever, Marie Antoinette: The Last Queen of France (2000)
  • Stefan Zweig, Marie Antoinette: The Portrait of an Average Woman (1932)
  • Chantal Thomas, The Wicked Queen: The Origins of the Myth of Marie-Antoinette (1999)
  • Lynn Hunt, The Family Romance of the French Revolution (1992)

Same day, other years

1555

Latimer and Ridley are burned at Oxford

Oxford, EnglandEurope

Hugh Latimer, once bishop of Worcester and the best-known preacher in England, and Nicholas Ridley, bishop of London, had helped make the English church Protestant under Edward VI. When the Catholic Mary I came to the throne in 1553 both were arrested, and after a disputation and a trial for heresy at Oxford they were burned back to back at one stake in the town ditch outside Balliol College on 16 October 1555. Latimer, who was about seventy, died quickly. The wood around Ridley was packed too tightly and burned only his legs until a bystander pulled it aside. Thomas Cranmer, the archbishop, was made to watch from his prison, and was burned at the same spot five months later.

Seen from elsewhere. To Mary’s bishops these were obstinate heretics lawfully condemned after being given every chance to recant. Latimer’s famous words about lighting a candle that would never be put out first appear in the 1570 edition of John Foxe’s martyrology, not the first. Eamon Duffy has argued that the burnings were more effective than Protestant memory allows.

1905

Bengal is partitioned

Calcutta and Dacca, British IndiaAsia

On 16 October 1905 the viceroy, Lord Curzon, divided Bengal, a province of nearly eighty million people, in two. The eastern districts were joined with Assam under a new capital at Dacca, with a Muslim majority; the west, with Bihar and Orissa, kept Calcutta and left Bengali speakers a minority in their own province. The stated reason was administrative convenience. In Calcutta the day was kept as one of mourning: shops shut, crowds bathed in the Ganges, and at Rabindranath Tagore’s suggestion people tied threads on one another’s wrists as a sign of unity. The boycott of British cloth that followed, the Swadeshi movement, was the first mass campaign of Indian nationalism. Britain reversed the partition in 1911.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Muslims of eastern Bengal, led by Nawab Salimullah of Dacca, welcomed a province in which they would no longer be overshadowed by Calcutta’s Hindu landlords and lawyers; the Muslim League was founded at Dacca a year later. A senior official, H. H. Risley, had minuted that Bengal united was a power and divided would pull several ways.

1964

China tests its first atomic bomb

Lop Nur, Xinjiang, ChinaAsia

At three in the afternoon Beijing time on 16 October 1964 a uranium implosion device on a steel tower at Lop Nur, in the desert of Xinjiang, exploded with a force of about twenty-two kilotons. China became the fifth nuclear power. The project was code-named 596, for June 1959, the month the Soviet Union went back on its promise to supply a sample bomb; when Moscow withdrew its advisers in 1960 the Chinese finished the work themselves, through the famine years. Premier Zhou Enlai announced the result that evening to the cast of a revolutionary pageant and told them not to jump so hard that the floor gave way. The government declared it would never be the first to use such weapons.

Seen from elsewhere. Washington had considered and rejected a strike on the test site. India, defeated by China in 1962, began moving towards its own bomb. China conducted forty-five tests at Lop Nur up to 1996; Uyghur exiles and some researchers allege serious harm to people living downwind, which Beijing denies and outsiders cannot check.

1998

Pinochet is arrested in a London clinic

London, EnglandThe Americas

Late on 16 October 1998 Metropolitan Police officers entered the London Clinic, where General Augusto Pinochet, aged eighty-two, was recovering from back surgery, and arrested him on a warrant issued at the request of the Spanish judge Baltasar Garzón. Pinochet had overthrown Chile’s elected president, Salvador Allende, in 1973 and ruled until 1990; Chilean truth commissions later counted more than 3,000 people killed or disappeared and tens of thousands tortured under his government. He was held in England for sixteen months. The Law Lords ruled that a former head of state had no immunity for torture, a landmark for international law, but the home secretary released him in March 2000 as unfit to stand trial.

Seen from elsewhere. Chile’s elected government protested that its sovereignty and its negotiated transition were being overridden. Margaret Thatcher and Pinochet’s supporters said he had saved Chile from Marxism and helped Britain in the Falklands war. Victims’ families saw the first crack in his impunity. He died in Santiago in 2006, facing charges but never convicted.

Also on 16 October