Parallax

12 October, 1915

Edith Cavell is shot at dawn

A Norfolk vicar’s daughter running a nursing school in occupied Brussels admitted everything she was charged with. Germany’s decision to execute her within hours of the verdict handed its enemies the propaganda gift of the war.

Schaerbeek, Brussels, Belgium

Edith Cavell was forty-nine and had lived in Brussels since 1907, when the surgeon Antoine Depage hired her to found Belgium’s first training school for lay nurses. When the Germans took the city in August 1914 she stayed. That autumn two British soldiers cut off in the retreat from Mons were brought to her door, and she hid them. Over the next nine months her clinic in the Rue de la Culture became a station on an escape line organised by Belgian and French civilians, among them the Prince and Princess de Croÿ, the architect Philippe Baucq and the schoolteacher Louise Thuliez. Around 200 Allied soldiers and men of military age passed through on their way to the Dutch frontier.

The network was careless and the German secret police were patient. Baucq and Thuliez were arrested on 31 July 1915 and Cavell on 5 August. Interrogated in the prison of Saint-Gilles, she did not deny what she had done. She signed statements naming those who had worked with her and confirming that men she helped had written to thank her from England, which showed they had rejoined the enemy.

Thirty-five defendants were tried together by court martial on 7 and 8 October. Cavell’s lawyer, assigned by the court, had not been allowed to see her beforehand. The charge was conducting soldiers to the enemy, which German military law treated as a form of war treason carrying death. On the afternoon of 11 October five were condemned. That night Hugh Gibson of the American legation and the Spanish minister, the Marquis of Villalobar, went to the German political department and pleaded for a delay. The military governor, General von Sauberzweig, refused.

The English chaplain, Stirling Gahan, was allowed into her cell at about ten. They took communion and said ‘Abide with me’ together. Gahan wrote down what she told him: that she had no fear, that she was grateful for ten weeks of quiet, and that, standing as she did in view of God and eternity, she realised that patriotism is not enough, and she must have no hatred or bitterness towards anyone.

She and Baucq were driven to the national rifle range, the Tir National, and shot by two firing squads at about seven in the morning of 12 October. The German army chaplain present, Paul Le Seur, said she went calmly.

How it came to this

Germany had invaded neutral Belgium in August 1914 and governed most of it under military occupation for four years. In the first weeks its troops shot some 5,500 Belgian civilians in reprisals for supposed sniping. By 1915 the regime had settled into requisitions, deportations, an electrified fence along the Dutch border and a military court system that treated help given to the Allies as a capital crime. Thousands of Belgians nonetheless ran escape lines, clandestine newspapers and train-watching networks for British intelligence.

Cavell, born in 1865 at Swardeston near Norwich, had trained at the London Hospital and worked in poor-law infirmaries before going abroad. As a British subject she could have been repatriated. Belgium’s interests were represented in Brussels by neutral diplomats, chiefly the American minister Brand Whitlock, who was ill in bed during the trial; the German authorities assured his legation that it would be told the outcome, and then did not tell it until the sentence was hours from being carried out.

How each side saw it

The German authorities

Berlin’s case was set out by Arthur Zimmermann, under-secretary at the Foreign Office: Cavell had confessed, the law was clear, and a state at war could not let women run recruiting channels for its enemies with impunity because they were women. The military governor wanted an example made quickly, before pleas could arrive. German officials noted, fairly, that France also shot women convicted of helping the enemy. But the civil governor’s political staff saw the damage at once, and the Kaiser afterwards ordered that no woman be executed without his personal confirmation. The others condemned with her, including Louise Thuliez, had their sentences commuted.

British propaganda

In Britain and the United States she became within days an innocent girl-nurse butchered by Huns. Posters and postcards showed a young woman in uniform lying beneath a spiked-helmeted officer with a pistol, a scene that never happened: she was shot by riflemen and died at once. Recruiting figures rose sharply in the weeks after. Her family and her chaplain disliked the hatred preached in her name, and when her statue was unveiled near Trafalgar Square in 1920 it carried only ‘Humanity’. The words about patriotism were added four years later at the urging of the National Council of Women.

Belgians in the network

Cavell did not run the escape line; she was one link in an organisation built by Belgians and French citizens, most of whom the Allied press ignored. Philippe Baucq, shot beside her, left a wife and two daughters and is little known outside Belgium. Louise Thuliez and Princess Marie de Croÿ survived prison and wrote memoirs describing how the line worked and how exposed Cavell’s frankness under interrogation had left them, though neither blamed her. Gabrielle Petit, a Belgian shop assistant shot in 1916 for spying, had no neutral diplomats pleading for her and became a national heroine only after the war.

What is disputed

Was she only a nurse? In 2015 Stella Rimington, the former head of MI5, reported finding Belgian archive evidence that the network also carried military intelligence, some of it sewn into clothing; how much Cavell knew or did herself is not established, and the Germans did not charge her with espionage. Her biographer Diana Souhami accepts that she helped fighting men return to fight. Several execution legends are false: that she fainted and was finished off by an officer, and that a soldier named Rammler was shot for refusing to fire. Why she confessed so fully, from principle or because she was told others had already talked, is unknown.

What followed

Her body was brought home in May 1919, given a service in Westminster Abbey and buried beside Norwich Cathedral. A mountain in the Canadian Rockies, hospitals, streets and a generation of girls were named after her. In Paris a monument to her was destroyed in 1940 on Hitler’s orders. Her last statement proved more durable than the wartime cult: it was taken up by pacifists and internationalists between the wars, and the nursing profession she had helped establish in Belgium kept her memory on its own terms.

Read further

  • Diana Souhami, Edith Cavell (2010)
  • Rowland Ryder, Edith Cavell (1975)
  • Katie Pickles, Transnational Outrage: The Death and Commemoration of Edith Cavell (2007)
  • Hugh Gibson, A Journal from Our Legation in Belgium (1917)
  • Brand Whitlock, Belgium under the German Occupation: A Personal Narrative (1919)

Same day, other years

539 BC

The Persian army enters Babylon

Babylon, MesopotamiaMiddle East

A clay tablet known as the Nabonidus Chronicle records that on the sixteenth day of the month Tashritu, in the seventeenth year of King Nabonidus, the troops of Cyrus of Persia under a commander named Ugbaru entered Babylon without a battle. The date converts to 12 October 539 BC in the Julian reckoning. Days earlier the Persians had beaten the Babylonian army at Opis on the Tigris and, the chronicle says, slaughtered people there. Nabonidus was captured. Cyrus himself entered the city seventeen days later, and the greatest city of the age, with its empire from the Gulf to the borders of Egypt, passed to a dynasty from the Iranian plateau.

Seen from elsewhere. The Cyrus Cylinder, composed for the conqueror by Babylonian priests, says the god Marduk chose him to rescue the city from an impious king. Jewish tradition honours him for letting the exiles go home. Herodotus tells of a river diverted and a city taken during a festival. Nabonidus’s own view survives only in his earlier inscriptions.

1492

Columbus’s ships reach the Bahamas

Guanahani, BahamasThe Americas

About two hours after midnight on 12 October 1492 a lookout on the Pinta, remembered as Rodrigo de Triana, saw white sand in the moonlight. Thirty-three days out from the Canaries, Christopher Columbus’s three ships had reached an island its Lucayan Taíno inhabitants called Guanahani. He landed that morning, claimed it for Castile and renamed it San Salvador. He believed he was off Asia. His journal, which survives only in a summary made by Bartolomé de las Casas, describes people who swam out with parrots and cotton thread, and remarks that they would make good servants and could easily be made Christians. He took several away with him as guides.

Seen from elsewhere. The Lucayans left no account. Within about twenty-five years Spanish slave raids for the mines and pearl beds had emptied the Bahamas of them. Which island Guanahani was is still disputed. The date is Spain’s national day, and has been renamed for Indigenous peoples or resistance in much of the Americas.

1968

Equatorial Guinea becomes independent

Santa Isabel (Malabo), Equatorial GuineaAfrica

Spain’s only colony south of the Sahara, the island of Fernando Po and the mainland enclave of Río Muni, became independent on 12 October 1968, a date chosen in Madrid to coincide with Spain’s own national day. Francisco Macías Nguema, a former colonial clerk who had won the elections on an anti-Spanish platform, was sworn in as president. Within five months he had used a failed coup as grounds to kill his rivals. He abolished other parties, made himself president for life, closed churches and schools and ruled through relatives from his home district. By 1979, when his nephew Teodoro Obiang overthrew and shot him, perhaps a third of the population had been killed or had fled.

Seen from elsewhere. Macías presented himself as freeing the country from colonial exploitation, and Franco’s government responded by classing all news from its former colony an official secret. Estimates of the dead range from 20,000 to 80,000 and cannot be verified. Obiang, who had commanded his uncle’s most feared prison, has ruled ever since.

1999

Pakistan’s army takes power from the air

Karachi and Islamabad, PakistanAsia

On the afternoon of 12 October 1999 Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif announced on state television that he had dismissed the army chief, General Pervez Musharraf, who was at that moment on a commercial flight home from Sri Lanka with about 200 other passengers. The airliner was refused permission to land at Karachi and told to leave Pakistani airspace. The army’s senior commanders moved first. Troops climbed the gates of the television station in Islamabad, surrounded the prime minister’s residence and seized Karachi airport. The plane landed with a few minutes of fuel remaining. By the small hours Musharraf was on television in uniform announcing that the armed forces had moved in as a last resort.

Seen from elsewhere. Sharif held that an elected prime minister had lawfully removed a general, and blamed Musharraf for the Kargil war with India that summer. The army called his order attempted murder; he was convicted of hijacking and exiled. Many Pakistanis welcomed the coup, and the Supreme Court validated it under the ‘doctrine of necessity’.

Also on 12 October