Parallax

14 October, 1944

Rommel is given a choice of deaths

Two generals arrived at a house in Swabia at noon with a message from Hitler and a cyanide capsule. Within the hour Germany’s most celebrated soldier was dead, and the public was told his war wounds had killed him.

Herrlingen, near Ulm, Germany

Field Marshal Erwin Rommel was at home in Herrlingen, a village outside Ulm, recovering from a fractured skull. On 17 July 1944 a British fighter had strafed his staff car on a road in Normandy and thrown him into a ditch. Three days after that a bomb exploded under the map table at Hitler’s headquarters in East Prussia, and in the weeks of arrests and interrogations that followed his name began to appear in Gestapo files. His former chief of staff, Hans Speidel, was arrested on 7 September. Rommel noticed men watching the house and began carrying a pistol on his walks.

On 7 October he was ordered to Berlin for a conference and declined, citing his doctors. On 13 October a telephone call announced that two generals would visit the next day. They arrived at noon on 14 October in a small green car: Wilhelm Burgdorf, head of the army personnel office, and his deputy Ernst Maisel. Rommel’s fifteen-year-old son Manfred, on leave from his anti-aircraft battery, had been walking with his father that morning. The visitors asked to speak to the field marshal alone.

The interview lasted less than an hour. Rommel then went upstairs to his wife, Lucie. Manfred later wrote down what his father said to him a few minutes afterwards: that he had been named by officers involved in the plot of 20 July, that Hitler offered him either a trial before the People’s Court or poison, and that if he took poison his family would be left alone and given a pension. He had been told the house was surrounded. He would be dead, he said, in a quarter of an hour.

He put on his Africa tunic, took his cap and his marshal’s baton, said goodbye to his son and his aide, Hermann Aldinger, and got into the back of the car. An SS driver took it a few hundred metres up the road towards Blaubeuren and stopped. The driver and Maisel walked away. When they came back Rommel was slumped over, the capsule already taken. About twenty minutes after he left the house, the telephone rang to tell his wife that he had suffered a seizure and been taken to a hospital in Ulm.

The announcement spoke of an embolism brought on by his injuries. At the state funeral in Ulm on 18 October Field Marshal von Rundstedt read a eulogy saying that Rommel’s heart had belonged to the Führer.

How it came to this

Rommel was Hitler’s creation as much as the army’s. A decorated infantry officer of the First World War and author of a well-known book on tactics, he commanded Hitler’s escort in 1939, was given a panzer division for the invasion of France, and in 1941 was sent to Libya to rescue the Italians. Two years of advance and retreat across the desert, ending in defeat at El Alamein and surrender in Tunisia after his recall, made him a hero of Goebbels’s newsreels and, unusually, a figure respected by his enemies.

By 1944 he commanded the army group defending the French coast and no longer believed the war could be won. After the Allied landings he told Hitler to his face, twice, that the front would collapse and that political conclusions should be drawn. Conspirators in the western command, including Speidel and Caesar von Hofacker, sounded him out. After the bomb failed, Hofacker was tortured, and at least one statement from the investigation placed Rommel among those who knew.

How each side saw it

The Rommel family

The detailed account of the last day comes from Manfred Rommel, who gave it to Allied officers in 1945 and published it in The Rommel Papers, and from his mother and Captain Aldinger. In their telling the field marshal accepted poison to spare his wife and son the camps and his staff the gallows, and chose not to shoot his way out. Lucie Rommel insisted until her death that her husband had not joined a plot to murder Hitler, a distinction that mattered to her as a matter of a soldier’s oath. Manfred, later mayor of Stuttgart for twenty-two years, said his father had come to see Hitler as a criminal too late.

The Nazi leadership

For the regime the difficulty was that it had made him. Putting the most popular general in Germany before Roland Freisler’s court, three months after announcing that only a small clique of officers had betrayed the Führer, would have told the public that the best-known soldier in the country thought the war lost. The evidence, as far as it survives in the reports sent to Martin Bormann, was that he had known of plans for a change of regime and had not reported them. A quiet death and a state funeral preserved the legend for the regime’s use. Burgdorf killed himself in Hitler’s bunker in May 1945.

British admirers and later critics

Churchill told the Commons in January 1942 that Britain faced ‘a very daring and skilful opponent’ and ‘a great general’. After the war Desmond Young’s biography, Basil Liddell Hart’s edition of the papers and a Hollywood film made Rommel the model of the decent German officer, useful to a West Germany that was rearming inside NATO. Historians since the 1990s have been cooler. Ralf Georg Reuth stresses how long he remained loyal to Hitler and how much propaganda inflated him. Others point to what his campaign carried with it: forced labour for Tunisian Jews, and an SS unit waiting in Athens to operate in Egypt and Palestine had he broken through.

What is disputed

How far Rommel was involved in the conspiracy remains open. David Irving argued in 1977 that he knew nothing of it; Reuth holds that he wanted a separate peace in the west but opposed assassination; Maurice Philip Remy and Peter Lieb have argued from later-found testimony that he supported the plotters more directly in the final weeks. The key witnesses were executed or, like Speidel, had reasons after 1945 to place him on the right side. The story that the dying General von Stülpnagel blurted out his name is poorly attested. Also debated is the ‘clean Wehrmacht’ image that his reputation helped to sustain.

What followed

Lucie Rommel drew her pension and the family was not harmed. The truth came out in April 1945 when Manfred, captured by French troops, told his story. Speidel survived to command NATO’s land forces in central Europe. The Bundeswehr named barracks after Rommel, and his memorial at Heidenheim has been repeatedly contested; in 2020 a sculpture of a landmine victim was placed beside it. He remains the German commander of the Second World War whom most people abroad can name, and the test case for how a professional soldier in a criminal state should be judged.

Read further

  • B. H. Liddell Hart (ed.), The Rommel Papers (1953)
  • Desmond Young, Rommel: The Desert Fox (1950)
  • David Fraser, Knight’s Cross: A Life of Field Marshal Erwin Rommel (1993)
  • Ralf Georg Reuth, Rommel: The End of a Legend (2005)

Same day, other years

1066

Harold falls at Hastings

Near Hastings, Sussex, EnglandEurope

King Harold II had destroyed a Norwegian invasion at Stamford Bridge near York on 25 September 1066 when he learned that Duke William of Normandy had landed in Sussex. He marched some 250 miles south and on Saturday 14 October drew up his army on a ridge seven miles from Hastings. The English fought on foot behind a wall of shields; the Normans had archers and mounted knights. The battle lasted from about nine in the morning until dusk, unusually long for the period. Norman retreats, real or pretended, drew parts of the English line down the slope to be cut off. Late in the day Harold was killed, with his brothers Gyrth and Leofwine, and the line gave way.

Seen from elsewhere. Norman writers such as William of Poitiers presented a lawful heir punishing a perjurer under a papal banner. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle says William came upon Harold before his army was in order, and blames the people’s sins. Whether Harold died from an arrow in the eye, as the Bayeux Tapestry may show, or was cut down by knights is disputed.

1956

Ambedkar leads a mass conversion to Buddhism

Nagpur, IndiaAsia

B. R. Ambedkar was born into the Mahar community, treated as ‘untouchable’ under the Hindu caste order, and became a lawyer, economist and the chief draftsman of India’s constitution. In 1935 he had declared that although born a Hindu he would not die one. On 14 October 1956, at a field in Nagpur now called Deekshabhoomi, he took the Buddhist refuges and precepts from the Burmese monk U Chandramani, then turned to the crowd and administered them himself, adding twenty-two vows that renounced Hindu gods and rites. Estimates of those who converted with him that day and the next run from 365,000 to half a million. He died seven weeks later.

Seen from elsewhere. Hindu nationalists including V. D. Savarkar dismissed the move as a change of sect within the Hindu family. Some traditional Buddhists questioned Ambedkar’s reinterpretation of doctrine as social emancipation. Converts found that the state withdrew the benefits reserved for Scheduled Castes, a rule not changed for Buddhists until 1990.

1973

Bangkok’s students bring down the generals

Bangkok, ThailandAsia

Thailand had been under military rule almost without a break since 1947, latterly under Field Marshals Thanom Kittikachorn and Praphas Charusathien. In October 1973 the arrest of thirteen people for handing out leaflets demanding a constitution brought hundreds of thousands of students and townspeople on to Ratchadamnoen Avenue around the Democracy Monument. The government gave way on the prisoners, but early on 14 October police clashed with demonstrators dispersing near the royal palace, and the army moved in with tanks and helicopters. The official toll was seventy-seven dead and more than 800 injured. That evening King Bhumibol announced on television that Thanom had resigned. The two field marshals and Thanom’s son left the country.

Seen from elsewhere. The army’s defenders said communists had steered the crowd. The civilian period that followed lasted three years, until the massacre of students at Thammasat University on 6 October 1976 and another coup. How decisive the king’s intervention was, and what the palace’s role became afterwards, is still argued by Thai historians.

2017

A truck bomb kills hundreds in Mogadishu

Mogadishu, SomaliaAfrica

On the afternoon of Saturday 14 October 2017 a lorry packed with military and home-made explosives was stopped in traffic at the Zoobe junction, known as Kilometre 5, one of the busiest crossroads in Mogadishu. The driver accelerated through a barrier and the bomb went off beside a fuel tanker. The fireball destroyed a hotel, shops, buses and cars across several blocks. A committee appointed by the Somali government put the dead at 587, with hundreds more injured and many victims never identified. It was the deadliest attack in Somalia’s history and among the deadliest bombings anywhere this century. Tens of thousands marched through the city in protest in the days that followed.

Seen from elsewhere. The government blamed the Islamist group al-Shabaab, which, unusually, never claimed the attack. Reporting at the time said the bomber came from Bariire, where a raid by Somali and United States forces had killed ten civilians that August, and suggested revenge as a motive. One man was executed for his part in 2018.

Also on 14 October