In the dark before dawn on 23 October 1917 the men of C Battery, 6th Field Artillery, manhandled one of their guns through the mud to a position on a hillside east of Nancy. There was a rivalry among the American batteries moving into the line that week over who would fire first, and Captain Idus McLendon did not intend to wait for horses. The gun was a French 75, the quick-firing field piece with which the American army had been equipped on arrival, having brought almost no modern artillery of its own.
At five minutes past six, as the light came up, Sergeant Alexander Arch pulled the lanyard. Arch was a regular soldier from South Bend, Indiana, who had come to America from Hungary as a child. The shell went off towards a German battery position a few kilometres away. Nobody recorded what, if anything, it hit. The brass case was picked up, engraved, and sent to President Wilson.
The gunners belonged to the 1st Division, the first American formation to reach France. It had landed at Saint-Nazaire in late June, a division in name, hastily assembled from regular regiments filled up with recruits, many of whom had never fired their rifles. A battalion had been marched through Paris on the Fourth of July to show the French that the Americans had come. Then the division went into camp at Gondrecourt and spent the summer learning trench warfare from French mountain infantry.
By October General John Pershing judged it ready for a first taste of the front, under supervision. The French chose the Sommerviller sector, a stretch of line in Lorraine where both sides had long since settled into an unspoken agreement to leave each other alone. One American battalion at a time from each regiment went in for ten days alongside the French 18th Division, with French officers in command.
The quiet did not last. German intelligence soon knew who had arrived. Before dawn on 3 November a Bavarian assault company laid a box barrage around an isolated platoon post of the 16th Infantry near Bathelemont and raided it. In a few minutes of fighting in the dark three Americans were killed, Corporal James Gresham and Privates Thomas Enright and Merle Hay, and eleven were taken back across no man’s land as prisoners. They were the first soldiers of the American Expeditionary Forces to die in combat in their own army’s line. The French general Paul Bordeaux spoke over their graves, asking that the mortal remains of these young men be left in France.
How it came to this
The United States had stayed out of the European war for nearly three years, selling and lending to the Allies while President Wilson offered to mediate. What ended neutrality was Germany’s decision, taken in January 1917, to resume unrestricted submarine attacks on all shipping bound for Britain, American included. The German naval staff calculated that Britain could be starved into peace within months, before American intervention could matter. The interception of the Zimmermann telegram, in which Berlin proposed an alliance with Mexico, did the rest. Congress declared war on 6 April.
The country had a regular army of about 130,000 men, smaller than Portugal’s, with no tanks, few machine guns and hardly any aircraft fit for combat. Conscription was introduced in May. Building, training and shipping a mass army would take a year. The Allies could not wait that long in comfort: the French army had mutinied after the failed Nivelle offensive in the spring, the British were sinking into the mud at Passchendaele, and Russia was dropping out of the war. Sending one division early was above all a gesture.