Parallax

23 October, 1917

The first American shell of the Western Front

Six months after declaring war, the United States fired one 75-millimetre round at the German lines in Lorraine. The gun was French, the sergeant who fired it was born in Hungary, and the shell case was posted to the President.

Near Bathelemont, Lorraine, France

In the dark before dawn on 23 October 1917 the men of C Battery, 6th Field Artillery, manhandled one of their guns through the mud to a position on a hillside east of Nancy. There was a rivalry among the American batteries moving into the line that week over who would fire first, and Captain Idus McLendon did not intend to wait for horses. The gun was a French 75, the quick-firing field piece with which the American army had been equipped on arrival, having brought almost no modern artillery of its own.

At five minutes past six, as the light came up, Sergeant Alexander Arch pulled the lanyard. Arch was a regular soldier from South Bend, Indiana, who had come to America from Hungary as a child. The shell went off towards a German battery position a few kilometres away. Nobody recorded what, if anything, it hit. The brass case was picked up, engraved, and sent to President Wilson.

The gunners belonged to the 1st Division, the first American formation to reach France. It had landed at Saint-Nazaire in late June, a division in name, hastily assembled from regular regiments filled up with recruits, many of whom had never fired their rifles. A battalion had been marched through Paris on the Fourth of July to show the French that the Americans had come. Then the division went into camp at Gondrecourt and spent the summer learning trench warfare from French mountain infantry.

By October General John Pershing judged it ready for a first taste of the front, under supervision. The French chose the Sommerviller sector, a stretch of line in Lorraine where both sides had long since settled into an unspoken agreement to leave each other alone. One American battalion at a time from each regiment went in for ten days alongside the French 18th Division, with French officers in command.

The quiet did not last. German intelligence soon knew who had arrived. Before dawn on 3 November a Bavarian assault company laid a box barrage around an isolated platoon post of the 16th Infantry near Bathelemont and raided it. In a few minutes of fighting in the dark three Americans were killed, Corporal James Gresham and Privates Thomas Enright and Merle Hay, and eleven were taken back across no man’s land as prisoners. They were the first soldiers of the American Expeditionary Forces to die in combat in their own army’s line. The French general Paul Bordeaux spoke over their graves, asking that the mortal remains of these young men be left in France.

How it came to this

The United States had stayed out of the European war for nearly three years, selling and lending to the Allies while President Wilson offered to mediate. What ended neutrality was Germany’s decision, taken in January 1917, to resume unrestricted submarine attacks on all shipping bound for Britain, American included. The German naval staff calculated that Britain could be starved into peace within months, before American intervention could matter. The interception of the Zimmermann telegram, in which Berlin proposed an alliance with Mexico, did the rest. Congress declared war on 6 April.

The country had a regular army of about 130,000 men, smaller than Portugal’s, with no tanks, few machine guns and hardly any aircraft fit for combat. Conscription was introduced in May. Building, training and shipping a mass army would take a year. The Allies could not wait that long in comfort: the French army had mutinied after the failed Nivelle offensive in the spring, the British were sinking into the mud at Passchendaele, and Russia was dropping out of the war. Sending one division early was above all a gesture.

How each side saw it

The French and British commands

The Allies wanted American men, not an American army. Their proposal, pressed repeatedly through 1917 and 1918, was ‘amalgamation’: feed American battalions into experienced French and British divisions, where they could fight at once under staffs that knew the work. Marshal Petain’s summary of French strategy after the mutinies was that he was waiting for the tanks and the Americans. Pershing, backed by Wilson, refused almost every such request and insisted on an independent force under its own flag. Allied generals thought this cost lives and months; Pershing thought the alternative would cost the United States its voice at the peace.

The German high command

The head of the naval staff, Henning von Holtzendorff, had assured the Kaiser that not one American would set foot on the Continent. When they began to arrive, General Erich Ludendorff drew the opposite conclusion from the same fact: Germany must win in the west in the spring of 1918, with divisions freed from the Russian front, before the Americans came in numbers. His memoirs present the offensives of March to July 1918 as that gamble. German raiding parties were ordered to take American prisoners early, and intelligence reports on them noted good physique, poor training and high confidence.

Black American soldiers

About 380,000 African Americans served in the wartime army, in segregated units. Most of the 200,000 sent to France were assigned to labour battalions unloading ships and building roads. Of the combat regiments, four, including the 369th from Harlem, were handed to the French army, the one amalgamation Pershing readily allowed. They wore French helmets, fought under French command and won French decorations. W. E. B. Du Bois, who had urged Black Americans to close ranks for the war, went to France in 1919 to collect their testimony and published it in The Crisis, along with an American military memorandum advising the French not to treat Black officers as equals.

What is disputed

What counts as the first American shot is a matter of definition. On 7 April 1917 Marines on Guam fired on a launch from an interned German cruiser, and on 19 April the naval gun crew of the merchant ship Mongolia fired on a submarine in the Channel. Americans had been fighting and dying since 1914 as volunteers in the French Foreign Legion, the Lafayette flying squadron and the Canadian and British armies, and American army doctors attached to British hospitals were killed by air raids in September 1917. The famous line ‘Lafayette, we are here’ was spoken in Paris on 4 July 1917 by Colonel Charles Stanton, not by Pershing.

What followed

A year later there were two million American soldiers in France. Their arrival, at a rate of a quarter of a million a month in mid-1918, convinced the German command that the war could not be won. About 53,000 Americans were killed in action and more than 60,000 died of disease, most in the influenza pandemic; some 200,000 were wounded. The gun fired on 23 October was brought home as a relic. The bodies of Gresham, Enright and Hay were returned to the United States in 1921, and a French monument at Bathelemont, destroyed by the Germans in 1940, was later rebuilt.

Read further

  • John J. Pershing, My Experiences in the World War (1931)
  • Edward M. Coffman, The War to End All Wars: The American Military Experience in World War I (1968)
  • David M. Kennedy, Over Here: The First World War and American Society (1980)
  • Erich Ludendorff, My War Memories, 1914-1918 (1919)
  • Chad L. Williams, Torchbearers of Democracy: African American Soldiers in the World War I Era (2010)

Same day, other years

1086

The Almoravids defeat Castile at Zallaqa

Near Badajoz, IberiaEurope

When Alfonso VI of Leon and Castile took Toledo in 1085, the rulers of the small Muslim kingdoms of al-Andalus, who had been paying him tribute, concluded that they would be next. They sent across the straits to Yusuf ibn Tashfin, emir of the Almoravids, a Berber movement of strict religious reformers that had conquered Morocco from the Sahara. Yusuf landed with an army, joined the forces of Seville, Granada and Badajoz, and on Friday 23 October 1086 met Alfonso north of Badajoz at a place the Arabic sources call Zallaqa and the Christian ones Sagrajas. The Castilian heavy cavalry broke the Andalusi front line but was then enveloped. Alfonso escaped wounded with a few hundred horsemen.

Seen from elsewhere. Christian chronicles give the defeat a few lines; the detail comes from Arabic writers, including the memoirs of Abd Allah, the last Zirid king of Granada. He had cause to regret the invitation. Within five years Yusuf returned, deposed the Andalusi kings as lax and luxurious, and sent Abd Allah and the poet-king of Seville into exile in Morocco.

1955

Diem wins a referendum with 98 per cent

South VietnamAsia

The Geneva accords of 1954 had divided Vietnam at the seventeenth parallel. In the south the head of state was still the former emperor Bao Dai, who lived on the French Riviera, and the prime minister was Ngo Dinh Diem, a Catholic nationalist with American backing. On 23 October 1955 Diem asked voters to choose between them. His brother Nhu ran the campaign. Ballots for Diem were red, the colour of good fortune; those for Bao Dai were green. The announced result gave Diem 98.2 per cent. In Saigon he was credited with about 605,000 votes from roughly 450,000 registered voters. Three days later he proclaimed the Republic of Vietnam with himself as president.

Seen from elsewhere. Diem’s supporters say that Bao Dai, tainted by service to the French and the Japanese, would have lost any honest vote. American advisers are reported to have urged a more believable margin and been ignored. Hanoi called the vote illegal. Diem then refused the nationwide elections due in 1956, arguing that no free vote was possible in the Communist north.

1956

Budapest rises

Budapest, HungaryEurope

On the afternoon of 23 October 1956 students marched through Budapest to the statue of Jozef Bem, a Polish general of 1848, in sympathy with reforms just won in Poland. They carried a list of sixteen demands that included the withdrawal of Soviet troops, free elections and the return of the reforming Communist Imre Nagy. By evening some two hundred thousand people were outside Parliament. A crowd pulled down the huge bronze statue of Stalin, leaving only the boots. At the radio building, security police fired on demonstrators trying to have the demands broadcast; soldiers sent to restore order handed over their weapons. By morning there were Soviet tanks in the streets and an armed uprising across the country.

Seen from elsewhere. For thirty-three years the Hungarian government called it a counter-revolution led by fascists and Western agents; in 1989 it was officially redefined as a popular uprising. The Soviet leadership wavered, deciding on 30 October to withdraw and reversing itself a day later. The second invasion on 4 November killed some 2,500 Hungarians. Nagy was hanged in 1958.

1983

The Beirut barracks bombings

Beirut, LebanonMiddle East

At 6.22 on a Sunday morning a lorry carrying explosives equivalent to several tonnes of TNT drove through the wire at Beirut airport, past sentries whose weapons were unloaded under their rules of engagement, and into the lobby of the building where a battalion of United States Marines was sleeping. The explosion lifted the four-storey block off its foundations and collapsed it. It killed 241 American servicemen. Minutes later a second bomb destroyed a building two miles away that housed French paratroopers, killing 58. Both contingents belonged to a multinational force sent to Lebanon the year before, after the massacre of Palestinians at Sabra and Shatila. The Americans withdrew to their ships in February 1984.

Seen from elsewhere. A group calling itself Islamic Jihad claimed the attacks. American courts have held Iran and the nascent Hezbollah responsible; both have denied it. The Marines had come as peacekeepers, but weeks earlier American warships had shelled militias fighting the Lebanese army, and many Lebanese Muslims had come to see them as one more party to the civil war.

Also on 23 October