Parallax

3 October, 1226

Francis of Assisi dies on the bare ground

Nearly blind, marked with wounds his followers took for Christ’s own, the merchant’s son who had given away everything asked for one last thing: to be laid naked on the earth. His brothers were already arguing about what he had meant.

The Porziuncola, near Assisi, Italy

By the summer of 1226 Francis was about forty-four and could barely see. An eye disease, probably picked up in Egypt, had been treated by doctors at Rieti with hot irons applied to his temples, which did nothing. He had haemorrhages and dropsy, and for two years he had carried wounds in his hands, feet and side that he tried to keep hidden. The bishop of Assisi took him into his palace, and the town posted guards around it, less for his safety than to make sure that no rival city carried off a living saint before he could become a dead one.

When a doctor from Arezzo told him plainly that he would not see the winter, Francis is said to have stretched out his arms and welcomed Sister Death. He added a verse about her to the Canticle of the Creatures, the hymn in Umbrian dialect that he had composed the year before, and had the brothers sing it. Then he asked to be carried down the hill to the Porziuncola, the small chapel in the woods where the order had begun. On the way he had the litter set down and turned towards Assisi so that he could bless a town he could no longer see.

In his last days he dictated a Testament. It recalls how he had once found lepers too bitter to look at, and how the Lord had led him among them. It insists that the brothers hold no property, ask no privileges from Rome, and add no clever glosses to the Rule. He also sent for a Roman noblewoman, Jacoba dei Settesoli, who arrived with a shroud, candles and the almond cakes he liked. Women were forbidden inside the friary. Francis had her admitted as Brother Jacoba.

On the evening of Saturday 3 October he had himself stripped and laid on the ground. The guardian then ordered him, under obedience, to accept a borrowed tunic, so that he would die owning nothing. He asked for the Passion from John’s Gospel to be read, and the brothers sang Psalm 142 with him. He died after dark. Thomas of Celano records that larks, birds of the morning, gathered and sang over the roof.

The next day the body was carried up to Assisi with branches and trumpets. The procession turned aside at San Damiano so that Clare and her sisters, who lived enclosed there, could see him through the grille and touch the wounds. He was buried in the church of San Giorgio. Within two years the pope had declared him a saint and a vast basilica was rising over a new tomb.

How it came to this

Francis was born in 1181 or 1182, the son of Pietro di Bernardone, a prosperous cloth merchant of Assisi. He was a popular and free-spending young man who went to war against Perugia, spent a year as a prisoner, and came home ill. Over the following years he turned from his old life by stages: he embraced a leper, heard a crucifix in the ruined chapel of San Damiano tell him to repair the church, and sold his father’s cloth to pay for it. Hauled before the bishop in 1206, he handed back his clothes and walked away naked.

Companions joined him, and in 1209 or 1210 Pope Innocent III gave verbal approval to a way of life based on a few Gospel verses: own nothing, work or beg, preach penance. Rome was then fighting movements that preached poverty outside its authority, and Francis’s obedience made him useful. By 1220 there were several thousand friars, far too many to live as a band of wandering brothers. Francis, back from an attempt to convert the sultan of Egypt during the Fifth Crusade, resigned the leadership. A formal Rule was approved in 1223, and in 1224, on Mount La Verna, he received the stigmata.

How each side saw it

Brother Elias and the leadership of the order

Elias of Cortona, who was governing the order, announced the death in a circular letter that is the earliest written witness to the stigmata: Francis, he wrote, had appeared as one crucified, with the five wounds of Christ. For Elias and for the cardinal protector Ugolino, who became Pope Gregory IX, the dead founder was the patron of a great institution that needed churches, schools and papal privileges to do its work. In 1230 Gregory ruled that the Testament did not bind the friars. Elias built the basilica at Assisi with money collected from across Europe, to the anger of brothers who thought the building itself a betrayal.

The companions and the Spirituals

Brother Leo, Francis’s confessor and secretary, and others who had known him kept a different memory, written down in the collections known as the Legend of the Three Companions and the Assisi Compilation. In it Francis grieves over brothers who want books, houses and offices. Their heirs, the Spirituals, held that the Testament was binding and that absolute poverty was the heart of the Gospel. The dispute outlasted everyone who had known him. In 1318 four Spiritual friars were burned at Marseille for refusing to submit, and in 1323 Pope John XXII declared it heresy to say that Christ and the apostles had owned nothing.

Clare and the sisters of San Damiano

Clare of Assisi had run away from a noble household in 1212 to follow Francis and had lived enclosed at San Damiano ever since. Her own Testament calls herself his little plant and records his promise that he and his brothers would always care for her sisters. After his death she spent twenty-seven years resisting popes who wanted to give her community property and a conventional rule, at one point refusing absolution from her vow of poverty when Gregory IX offered it. Her Rule, the first written by a woman for women, was approved by Innocent IV two days before she died in 1253.

Modern historians

Paul Sabatier, a French Protestant pastor, published a life in 1894 that presented Francis as a free evangelical spirit captured and tamed by the Roman church; it was placed on the Index and began a century of argument known as the Franciscan question. Catholic scholars replied that Francis’s loyalty to pope and priests runs through everything he wrote. More recent biographers such as Augustine Thompson and Andre Vauchez try to strip away both versions, and find a man harder, stranger and less concerned with nature and social reform than his modern admirers suppose.

What is disputed

Francis died after sunset on 3 October; because the medieval day began at nightfall the church counted it as 4 October, which is his feast. The sources are the deeper problem. In 1266 the order adopted Bonaventure’s official life and ordered earlier ones destroyed, so that the writings of Thomas of Celano and the companions survived only in stray copies, and scholars still argue over which preserves the real man. The stigmata were doubted in his own century, and modern explanations range from miracle to leprosy to self-inflicted wounds. The prayer beginning ‘Lord, make me an instrument of your peace’ is not his: it first appeared in a French magazine in 1912.

What followed

Gregory IX canonised Francis on 16 July 1228 and laid the foundation stone of the basilica the next day. In 1230 the body was moved there and hidden so well that it was not found again until 1818. The order he founded became one of the largest in the Catholic church, supplying missionaries, inquisitors, scholars and popes, and never settled its quarrel over poverty; it remains divided into separate families. Francis was named patron of Italy in 1939 and of ecology in 1979, and in 2013 a pope took his name for the first time.

Read further

  • Thomas of Celano, The Life of Saint Francis (1228-29)
  • Bonaventure, The Major Legend of Saint Francis (1263)
  • Paul Sabatier, Life of St Francis of Assisi (1894)
  • Augustine Thompson, Francis of Assisi: A New Biography (2012)
  • Andre Vauchez, Francis of Assisi: The Life and Afterlife of a Medieval Saint (2012)

Same day, other years

1283

The last prince of Wales is hanged, drawn and quartered

Shrewsbury, EnglandEurope

Dafydd ap Gruffydd had spent much of his life fighting his own brother, Llywelyn, prince of Wales, sometimes in the pay of the English king. In 1282 he changed sides for the last time, attacking Hawarden castle on Palm Sunday and starting the war in which Llywelyn was killed. Dafydd held out in Snowdonia for six months as prince until he was betrayed and captured in June 1283. Edward I summoned a parliament to Shrewsbury to judge him. He was dragged through the streets behind a horse, hanged, cut down alive, disembowelled and quartered, and the pieces were sent to four English towns. His head went to the Tower of London, beside his brother’s.

Seen from elsewhere. To Edward he was a vassal who had been sheltered, knighted and given lands, and had repaid it with treason; the elaborate death was devised to match. Welsh poets mourned the end of the house of Gwynedd. Dafydd’s two young sons were imprisoned at Bristol for life and his daughters were sent to English convents, so that the line would end.

1932

Iraq becomes independent

Baghdad, IraqMiddle East

The League of Nations admitted the Kingdom of Iraq as a member, ending the mandate under which Britain had governed the country since the First World War. It was the first mandated territory anywhere to become a sovereign state. Britain had assembled Iraq from three Ottoman provinces, put down a large revolt in 1920, and installed Faisal, a Hashemite prince from Arabia, as king the following year. The path to independence ran through a treaty signed in 1930, which bound Iraq to consult Britain on foreign policy for twenty-five years, gave British forces the right of passage, and kept two Royal Air Force bases on Iraqi soil. The oil concession stayed in foreign hands.

Seen from elsewhere. Iraqi nationalists called it independence in name only, and the treaty was a grievance until the monarchy was overthrown in 1958. Assyrian and Kurdish leaders had petitioned the League against being left to an Arab government without guarantees. Ten months later the Iraqi army killed hundreds of Assyrian villagers at Simele.

1935

Italy invades Ethiopia

Mareb River, Eritrea-Ethiopia borderAfrica

At five in the morning, without a declaration of war, some 100,000 Italian and Eritrean troops under General Emilio De Bono crossed the Mareb river from Eritrea into Ethiopia, one of only two African states never colonised. Mussolini had used a skirmish at the Walwal wells the previous December as his pretext and had spent ten months shipping an army through the Suez Canal. Adwa, where Ethiopia had destroyed an Italian army in 1896, fell within three days. The League of Nations named Italy the aggressor and imposed sanctions that left out oil. Italian aircraft dropped mustard gas on soldiers and villages. Addis Ababa was occupied on 5 May 1936.

Seen from elsewhere. Fascist Italy presented the war as revenge for Adwa and a civilising mission that abolished slavery. Haile Selassie told the League in Geneva in June 1936 that his people’s fate would be Europe’s. Italy admitted the use of gas only in 1996. Ethiopia has put its dead from the war and occupation at 760,000, a figure historians treat as uncertain.

1990

Germany is reunited

Berlin, GermanyEurope

At midnight a large black, red and gold flag was raised in front of the Reichstag in Berlin, and the German Democratic Republic ceased to exist. Its five reconstituted states and East Berlin joined the Federal Republic under an article of the West German constitution, eleven months after the Berlin Wall had opened and forty-one years after two German states had been founded. The four wartime Allies had given up their remaining rights in a treaty signed in Moscow in September, and the Soviet Union had agreed that a united Germany could stay in NATO. The West German mark had already replaced the eastern one in July, at a rate that favoured savers.

Seen from elsewhere. East German civil-rights activists who had brought down the regime had wanted a new constitution written by both sides, not accession to the western one. Margaret Thatcher and Francois Mitterrand privately feared a stronger Germany. In the east, the sale and closure of state firms cost several million jobs, and many came to speak of a takeover.

Also on 3 October