Parallax

1 November, 1503

The cardinal who bought the papacy and then outlawed buying it

Giuliano della Rovere won the shortest conclave on record by promising Cesare Borgia everything. As Julius II he kept none of it, went to war in armour, and hired Michelangelo.

Rome, Papal States

The cardinals who walked into the Vatican on the last day of October 1503 expected a short conclave, and they got the shortest in the history of the papacy. There was barely a contest. Giuliano della Rovere, cardinal of San Pietro in Vincoli and almost sixty, had spent the previous fortnight making sure of it. By the time the doors closed he had the Italians, he had the French, and, most surprisingly, he had the bloc of Spanish cardinals who took their orders from Cesare Borgia, the son of the pope della Rovere had hated most.

The Borgia deal was the key. Alexander VI had died in August, and his successor, the frail Pius III, had lasted twenty-six days. Cesare was ill and losing his grip on the Romagna, but he still controlled those votes. On 29 October della Rovere met him and promised to confirm him as captain-general of the Church and to leave him his conquests. Niccolo Machiavelli, in Rome as the envoy of Florence, watched with professional interest and reported home that the duke was letting himself be carried away by confidence, and believed another man’s word to be worth more than his own had ever been. Other cardinals were promised benefices, offices and money. Johann Burchard, the papal master of ceremonies, noted the bargaining in his diary without much surprise.

The vote was a formality. Within hours of the opening della Rovere had all but two or three voices, and on the morning of 1 November, All Saints’ Day, the result was proclaimed. He took the name Julius. Contemporaries assumed he was thinking less of the obscure fourth-century Pope Julius I than of Caesar.

Cesare Borgia learned the value of the promise within weeks. Julius had him arrested, made him hand over the passwords to his fortresses, and let him be shipped to a prison in Spain. The new pope then turned to what he considered his real work, recovering the lands of the Church. In 1506 he led his army in person to take Perugia and Bologna. He joined France against Venice, then Venice and Spain against France. In the snow of January 1511, at sixty-seven, he entered the breached fortress of Mirandola by climbing a ladder.

Between campaigns he spent as no pope had spent before on stone and paint. In 1506 he laid the foundation stone of a new St Peter’s to Bramante’s design, pulling down the thousand-year-old basilica of Constantine to make room. He set Raphael to work on his private apartments and bullied Michelangelo, who wanted to carve the papal tomb, into painting the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel instead. The finished ceiling was shown at the feast of All Saints in 1512, nine years after the election. Julius died less than four months later.

How it came to this

Giuliano della Rovere was born in 1443 at Albisola, near Savona on the Ligurian coast, into a family of no great means. His fortune was his uncle Francesco, a Franciscan friar who became Pope Sixtus IV in 1471 and within months made his nephew a cardinal, loading him with bishoprics and abbeys in Italy and France. Giuliano never pretended to much interest in pastoral work. He fathered at least one daughter, Felice, built fortresses, and learned how conclaves were won.

He expected to win the conclave of 1492. Instead Rodrigo Borgia outbid him and became Alexander VI, and della Rovere, fearing for his life, left for France. He came back to Italy in 1494 with the invading army of Charles VIII, urging the French king to call a council and depose the pope. That failed, and he spent most of the next decade in exile or out of reach. The Italy he returned to in 1503 was a battlefield for France and Spain, much of the Papal States had been carved into a duchy for Cesare Borgia, and the papacy itself was widely regarded as a prize to be bought.

How each side saw it

Julius and his defenders

Julius left no memoir, but his bulls and the reports of ambassadors make his case plain enough. The pope was an Italian prince as well as a priest, and a pope without territory was the chaplain of whichever king held Rome. He saw himself as taking back what belonged to St Peter from Borgia adventurers, Venetian encroachers and foreign armies, and unlike Alexander he took it for the Church and not for his relatives. His decree against simony, drawn up in 1505, declared any papal election bought as his own had been to be void. Admirers at his death called him the liberator of Italy.

Erasmus and the reformers

Erasmus was in Bologna in 1506 when the pope entered the city in triumph, and he never forgot the sight of the vicar of Christ at the head of an army. The satire Julius Excluded from Heaven, printed anonymously after the pope’s death and almost certainly his, has Julius arriving at the gate of paradise in armour, smelling of wine, and finding that his key does not fit because it opens only his money chest. For Luther, who visited Rome in the winter of 1510-11, and for the generation that followed, the warrior pope and the indulgence he proclaimed to pay for St Peter’s became evidence that the institution could not reform itself.

Cesare Borgia, the French and the Venetians

The Borgia view survives mostly through others. Machiavelli, who had admired Cesare’s ruthlessness, judged in The Prince that the duke’s one great error was to allow the election of a man he had injured, since anyone who thinks new favours make the great forget old injuries deceives himself. The French, whose cardinal Georges d’Amboise had wanted the tiara and stood aside, came to see Julius as a turncoat, and Louis XII sponsored a rival council at Pisa in 1511 to depose him. Venetian diarists such as Marin Sanudo recorded each change of alliance from the receiving end.

Italian historians since

Francesco Guicciardini, writing a generation later, said Julius would have deserved the highest glory had he been a secular prince, and that he had nothing of the priest about him but the dress and the name. Nineteenth-century Italian nationalists claimed him as a forerunner who wanted the foreigners out, and the cry ‘out with the barbarians’ was put in his mouth. Modern scholars such as Christine Shaw point out that he invited foreign armies in as often as he drove them out, and that his wars ended with Spain, not any Italian power, dominant in the peninsula.

What is disputed

That the election was bought is not seriously contested; what the buying meant is. Ludwig von Pastor, the Catholic historian of the popes, conceded the simony and argued that the reign redeemed it. The conclave is dated 31 October to 1 November, and it was settled so quickly that sources differ on whether the decisive vote fell on the evening of the first day or the morning of the second. The motto ‘out with the barbarians’ rests on later tradition. That he chose his name for Caesar is an inference from his conduct. Stories about his private life, including syphilis and relations with men, come from hostile pamphlets and cannot be tested.

What followed

Julius died on 21 February 1513, and Romans queued to kiss the feet of the corpse. His successor, the Medici pope Leo X, renewed the St Peter’s indulgence, and in 1517 its preaching in Germany provoked Luther’s ninety-five theses. The Papal States that Julius assembled lasted until 1870. The basilica took 120 years to finish. His tomb, planned with some forty statues, shrank to a wall monument in San Pietro in Vincoli, where Michelangelo’s Moses sits. The pope himself is not in it: he was buried in St Peter’s, and his grave was plundered in the sack of Rome in 1527.

Read further

  • Christine Shaw, Julius II: The Warrior Pope (1993)
  • Ludwig von Pastor, The History of the Popes from the Close of the Middle Ages, volume 6
  • Niccolo Machiavelli, The Prince (1532)
  • Francesco Guicciardini, The History of Italy
  • Erasmus (attributed), Julius Excluded from Heaven (c. 1517)

Same day, other years

1755

Lisbon is destroyed on All Saints’ morning

Lisbon, Portugal, and the coast of MoroccoEurope

At about twenty to ten, with the churches full for the feast day, an earthquake centred under the Atlantic shook Lisbon for several minutes. Survivors who ran to the open quays were met by a tsunami, and fires started by fallen candles and hearths burned for the best part of a week. Most of the city, the royal palace, its library and the new opera house were lost. Deaths in Lisbon are usually put between 30,000 and 50,000, with thousands more along the Algarve and in Moroccan ports from Tangier to Agadir. The king’s minister, the future Marquis of Pombal, took control of relief and rebuilt the centre on a grid with buildings designed to flex.

Seen from elsewhere. The Jesuit Gabriel Malagrida preached that the disaster was God’s punishment and that rebuilding without repentance was impious; Pombal’s pamphlets said it was a natural event, and Malagrida was later executed. Voltaire used Lisbon against the idea of a benevolent providence. Rousseau replied that nature had not packed people into tall houses.

1922

The Ottoman sultanate is abolished

Ankara, TurkeyMiddle East

After six centuries the house of Osman lost its throne by a vote of the Grand National Assembly in Ankara. The occasion was an Allied invitation to peace talks at Lausanne addressed to both the sultan’s government in occupied Constantinople and the nationalist one that had just won the war against Greece. Mustafa Kemal told a hesitant committee that sovereignty had been taken by the nation by force and that the only question was whether heads would roll in recognising it. The assembly separated the sultanate from the caliphate and abolished the first. Mehmed VI left the city on 17 November aboard the British battleship Malaya.

Seen from elsewhere. Mehmed VI insisted from exile that he had not abdicated and had left only to save his life. Some of Kemal’s own wartime colleagues, among them Rauf Orbay and Kazim Karabekir, were uneasy at the break. When the caliphate too was abolished in 1924, Muslims in India who had campaigned for it were dismayed.

1954

The Algerian war begins with a night of attacks

AlgeriaAfrica

In the early hours of All Saints’ Day a few hundred poorly armed men of a new organisation, the National Liberation Front, attacked police posts, barracks, farms and depots at dozens of points across Algeria, most heavily in the Aures mountains. Fewer than ten people died, among them a young French teacher and a pro-French Muslim official taken off a bus. A proclamation broadcast from Cairo demanded the restoration of a sovereign Algerian state. The French government sent reinforcements and declared, in the words of the interior minister Francois Mitterrand, that Algeria was France. The war lasted until 1962, brought down the Fourth Republic and ended with independence.

Seen from elsewhere. To the million European settlers and to Paris this was terrorism in three French departments, not a colonial war, and France did not officially call it a war until 1999. Algeria counts 1.5 million dead; French historians generally estimate 300,000 to 400,000. The FLN also fought rival nationalists loyal to Messali Hadj.

1984

Sikhs are hunted through Delhi

Delhi, IndiaAsia

Indira Gandhi was shot on 31 October by two of her Sikh bodyguards, four months after she sent the army into the Golden Temple at Amritsar. From the next morning, and for three days, mobs moved through Delhi neighbourhoods such as Trilokpuri and Sultanpuri pulling Sikh men from houses, buses and trains, and burning many alive with kerosene and tyres. The official count for the capital is about 2,800 dead, and more than 3,300 nationwide; other estimates are far higher. Survivors and civil liberties investigators reported that attackers carried voter lists and were led by local Congress politicians, while police stood aside or disarmed Sikhs.

Seen from elsewhere. The government long described the killings as a spontaneous outburst of grief, and Rajiv Gandhi remarked that when a big tree falls the earth shakes. Sikh organisations call them an organised pogrom or genocide. After ten commissions and committees, convictions were few; the former MP Sajjan Kumar was sentenced only in 2018.

Also on 1 November