Parallax

13 October, AD 54

Claudius dies and Nero is hailed emperor

Every ancient writer who tells the story says the emperor was poisoned by his wife, with mushrooms. They agree on almost nothing else, and some modern historians doubt there was a murder at all.

Rome

Tiberius Claudius Caesar Augustus Germanicus died in the palace on the Palatine in the first hours of 13 October AD 54. He was sixty-three and had ruled the Roman world for almost fourteen years. The announcement was held back until midday. In the meantime, according to Tacitus, the palace gates were shut, prayers were offered as if he were still ill, and troupes of comic actors were brought in, supposedly to entertain a recovering patient.

The historians who describe the death wrote between fifty and a hundred and seventy years afterwards, and they are sure who was responsible: Agrippina, the emperor’s niece and fourth wife. In the version Tacitus gives, she chose a moment when the freedman Narcissus, Claudius’s most loyal secretary, was away taking the waters for his gout. She obtained a poison from Locusta, a woman already convicted of such work, and had it sprinkled on a dish of mushrooms served by the eunuch Halotus, the emperor’s taster.

Then the accounts part company. Tacitus says the dose worked slowly and seemed to be failing, so that Agrippina turned to the court physician, Xenophon of Cos, who on the pretext of helping the emperor vomit put a feather dipped in a quicker poison down his throat. Suetonius, reading the same lost sources, admits he cannot say whether the meal was a banquet of priests on the Capitol or a family dinner, or whether a second dose came in gruel or by enema. Cassius Dio has a single poisoned mushroom and a man carried out apparently drunk.

What happened at noon is less in doubt. The doors opened and Nero, Agrippina’s sixteen-year-old son by an earlier marriage, walked out beside Afranius Burrus, commander of the Praetorian Guard. The cohort on duty cheered him. Some soldiers, Tacitus says, looked round and asked where Britannicus was, Claudius’s own son, who was not quite fourteen and had been kept in his room with his sisters. Nero was carried to the guards’ camp, promised each man a large bounty, as Claudius himself had done in 41, and was accepted by the Senate that afternoon.

Claudius was voted divine honours and given a funeral modelled on that of Augustus. His will was never read out. Tacitus thought the reason plain: a document that set the stepson above the son might have stirred resentment, whatever it actually said. Britannicus appears in the record of that day only as a boy embraced and detained by his stepmother.

How it came to this

Claudius had come to power by accident. Born with a limp, a stammer and a tremor, he had been kept out of public life by his family and survived the reigns of Tiberius and Caligula by being thought harmless. When Caligula was assassinated in January 41, guardsmen found his uncle in the palace and made him emperor against the wishes of the Senate. He proved an energetic ruler: he annexed Britain, Mauretania and Thrace, built a harbour at Ostia, and ran the administration through capable former slaves, which senators resented.

His marriages were his undoing. In 48 his third wife, Messalina, went through a form of marriage with a consul-designate and was killed on Narcissus’s orders. Within months Claudius married Agrippina, daughter of his brother Germanicus, after the Senate obligingly legalised unions between uncle and niece. In 50 he adopted her son, who took the name Nero and, being three years older than Britannicus, became the senior heir. In 53 Nero married Claudius’s daughter Octavia. By 54, the sources say, Claudius was showing signs of regret and of renewed favour to his own son.

How each side saw it

Agrippina

Agrippina wrote memoirs of her own life and her family’s misfortunes. Tacitus and Pliny the Elder consulted them; they are lost, and with them the only account from her side. She was a great-granddaughter of Augustus, had been exiled by her brother Caligula, and knew what became of imperial women whose sons were passed over. In the surviving record she is the scheming stepmother, a stock figure of Roman rhetoric, written up by men who found a woman receiving embassies and appearing on the coinage beside the emperor an affront in itself. Her defenders note that every detail of the poisoning comes from a tradition formed after her own son had murdered her.

The Senate’s tradition

The senatorial class remembered Claudius without affection. Suetonius counts thirty-five senators and more than two hundred knights put to death in his reign, many after hearings held behind closed doors. Seneca, whom Claudius had exiled to Corsica for eight years, wrote Nero’s graceful funeral speech and then, for private circulation, the Apocolocyntosis, a skit in which the dead emperor limps up to heaven, is refused admission by the gods and ends as a law clerk in the underworld. The skit says he died listening to comic actors. It was this class that wrote the histories, and its contempt for a ruler governed by wives and freedmen shapes all we read.

Modern historians

Scholars divide roughly into three camps. Barbara Levick, in the standard biography, thinks murder likely: the timing suited Agrippina too well, with Britannicus months from manhood and Narcissus absent. Others point out that a man of sixty-three with a long history of illness may simply have died, perhaps of heart disease or malaria in an unhealthy autumn, and that rumours of poison attached themselves to nearly every imperial death. A third suggestion is an accidental meal of death cap mushrooms. Anthony Barrett, Agrippina’s biographer, concludes that the question cannot be settled and that the varying ancient versions look like guesswork around a core of gossip.

What is disputed

The day is secure; the cause is not. The contemporaries are of little help: Seneca’s skit implies a natural death, and Josephus, writing about forty years later, says only that poisoning was ‘reported by some’. Pliny the Elder, who lived through the reign, does state that Agrippina used a mushroom. The detailed versions in Tacitus, Suetonius and Dio contradict one another on the place, the poisoner and the method. Nero’s supposed joke that mushrooms were the food of the gods, since Claudius became a god by eating one, is reported by Suetonius and Dio and may be a later invention. Whether Claudius really meant to restore Britannicus is also unprovable.

What followed

Narcissus was driven to suicide within weeks. Britannicus died at dinner in the palace in February 55, the day before he would have come of age; the same sources say Locusta supplied the poison. Agrippina’s influence over her son faded, and in 59 he had her killed by sailors after an attempt to drown her in a collapsing boat failed. Nero’s own suicide in 68 ended the dynasty of Augustus. The Roman literary portrait of Claudius the fool lasted until the twentieth century, when inscriptions, papyri and Robert Graves’s novels, in different ways, made him a more serious figure.

Read further

  • Tacitus, Annals, Book 12
  • Suetonius, The Twelve Caesars, ‘Claudius’ and ‘Nero’
  • Barbara Levick, Claudius (1990)
  • Anthony A. Barrett, Agrippina: Sex, Power, and Politics in the Early Empire (1996)
  • Josiah Osgood, Claudius Caesar: Image and Power in the Early Roman Empire (2011)

Same day, other years

1307

The Templars are arrested across France

Paris, FranceEurope

At dawn on Friday 13 October 1307 royal officers throughout France opened sealed orders sent a month earlier and arrested every Knight Templar they could find, including the grand master, Jacques de Molay, taken at the order’s fortress in Paris. King Philip IV accused the order of denying Christ at secret initiations, spitting on the cross, worshipping an idol and practising sodomy. Under torture directed by royal agents and inquisitors, most of those questioned confessed, Molay among them. When dozens later withdrew their confessions, fifty-four were burned as relapsed heretics in 1310. Pope Clement V dissolved the order in 1312 and Molay was burned on an island in the Seine in 1314.

Seen from elsewhere. Most historians, following Malcolm Barber, think the charges were fabricated by a king deep in debt to the order. A parchment rediscovered in the Vatican archives in 2001 shows that Clement privately absolved the leaders in 1308. The link between this day and unlucky Fridays is a modern notion.

1884

The world agrees on Greenwich

Washington, DC, United StatesWorldwide

Delegates from twenty-five countries met in Washington in October 1884 to choose a single meridian from which the world would reckon longitude and time. Railways and telegraphs had made the old muddle of local times and rival national meridians costly, and about two thirds of the world’s shipping already used charts based on the Royal Observatory at Greenwich. On 13 October the conference voted by twenty-two to one to recommend Greenwich as the prime meridian. San Domingo voted against; France and Brazil abstained. The conference also proposed a universal day beginning at Greenwich midnight. Nothing in the resolutions was binding, and countries adopted them one by one over the following forty years.

Seen from elsewhere. France had argued for a neutral meridian passing through no great power, and saw the vote as a British and American commercial victory dressed as science. It kept Paris time until 1911, and then defined legal time as Paris time less nine minutes and twenty-one seconds, without mentioning Greenwich.

1990

Syrian forces end Lebanon’s civil war by force

Baabda, LebanonMiddle East

At seven in the morning of 13 October 1990 Syrian aircraft bombed the presidential palace at Baabda, above Beirut, and Syrian troops with allied Lebanese units advanced on the enclave held by General Michel Aoun. Aoun, the army commander, had headed a rival government since 1988, had declared a ‘war of liberation’ against Syria and rejected the Taif Agreement under which Lebanon’s parliament had agreed to end the war. Within hours he took refuge in the French embassy and told his men by radio to stop fighting. Several hundred soldiers and civilians were killed that day. The fall of Baabda is usually taken as the end of a fifteen-year war that had cost well over 100,000 lives.

Seen from elsewhere. Aoun’s supporters saw the start of an occupation, and accuse Syrian troops of executing soldiers who had surrendered; some of the missing have never been traced. Supporters of Taif saw a mutiny ended. Washington, needing Damascus in its coalition against Iraq, raised no objection. Syrian troops stayed until 2005.

2010

Thirty-three miners come up at Copiapó

San José mine, Atacama, ChileThe Americas

The roof of the San José copper and gold mine in Chile’s Atacama desert collapsed on 5 August 2010, sealing thirty-three men about 700 metres underground. For seventeen days nobody knew whether they were alive, until a drill bit came back to the surface with a note taped to it saying that all thirty-three were well in the refuge. Three rescue shafts were then bored at once. Shortly after midnight on 13 October a steel capsule named Fénix brought up the first man, Florencio Ávalos; the shift foreman, Luis Urzúa, came out last that evening after sixty-nine days. An estimated billion people watched on television.

Seen from elsewhere. The mine had a record of accidents and had been reopened after an earlier closure without a required escape route. Prosecutors closed their investigation of the owners and the regulator in 2013 without charges, which the miners called a disgrace. Many of the men later reported trauma, unemployment and quarrels over money and film rights.

Also on 13 October