Parallax

8 October, 1918

Corporal York walks 132 prisoners out of the Argonne

A Tennessee mountain farmer who had asked to be excused from the war because his church forbade killing came back from a patrol with most of a German battalion staff. What exactly happened in that ravine has been argued over ever since, by the Germans, by his own comrades and by rival teams of archaeologists.

Near Chatel-Chehery, Argonne Forest, France

At ten past six on the morning of 8 October 1918 the 2nd Battalion of the 328th Infantry, 82nd Division, went forward from Hill 223 into a funnel-shaped valley west of the village of Chatel-Chehery. Its objective was a light railway two miles off that supplied the German line in the Argonne. The promised barrage did not arrive. Machine guns on the ridges to the front and left caught the Americans in the open, and the attack stopped.

Sergeant Bernard Early was told to take three squads, seventeen men, around the left flank and silence the guns on the far ridge. One of his corporals was Alvin York, thirty years old, from Pall Mall in the Tennessee mountains. They slipped through the brush behind the German front, crossed a stream, and walked into a clearing where a group of Germans, among them a battalion commander, Lieutenant Paul Vollmer, were at breakfast with their arms laid aside. Taken for the head of a larger force, the Americans accepted a surrender almost without a shot.

Then a machine gun on the slope above, perhaps thirty yards away, swung round and fired into the clearing. The prisoners dropped flat. Six Americans were killed and three wounded, including Early, who was hit several times. York, the senior man still on his feet, found himself slightly apart from the rest and nearest the guns.

By his own account he fired from where he was, prone and then standing, picking off each German who raised his head to aim, as he had shot turkeys at home. He kept calling on them to come down. At one point an officer and several men charged him with bayonets. He had fired off his rifle clip, drew his pistol and shot them from the rear man forward, so that the leaders would not see the others fall. Vollmer, who had lived in Chicago and spoke English, is said to have offered to order the guns to surrender if York would stop shooting.

York and the seven unwounded privates formed the prisoners into a column, with the German officers at the front and the wounded Americans carried in the middle, and marched back through the German lines, picking up more groups as they went. A lieutenant at battalion headquarters counted 132 prisoners, four of them officers. ‘Well, York, I hear you have captured the whole damned German army,’ the brigade commander said. York replied that he had only 132.

How it came to this

York was born in 1887, the third of eleven children in a two-room cabin, and grew up a blacksmith’s son, a farm labourer and by his own admission a drinker and brawler. In 1915, after a friend was killed in a bar fight, he joined the Church of Christ in Christian Union, a small sect that took the commandment against killing literally. When the draft came in 1917 he wrote on his registration card: ‘Don’t want to fight.’ His claim for exemption was refused because his church had no formal creed recognised by the board.

In training in Georgia he proved the best shot in his company and told his officers he could not use the skill on men. His battalion commander, Major George Buxton, and his captain, Edward Danforth, argued scripture with him for a night and then sent him home on leave to think. He came back saying he was satisfied that God meant him to fight. The Meuse-Argonne offensive, which opened on 26 September 1918, was the largest battle in American history, with more than a million men engaged and over 26,000 killed in six weeks. The 82nd Division was put in on 7 October to relieve pressure on a surrounded unit known as the Lost Battalion.

How each side saw it

The other Americans in the patrol

Seven privates came through unhurt, and the army’s investigation in early 1919 took sworn statements from them supporting York’s account. Some later felt written out of it. Bernard Early and Corporal William Cutting, who had enlisted under that name and was really Otis Merrithew, both wounded in the clearing, said for decades that the fight had been a group action and that York had taken the credit. Merrithew campaigned through the 1920s and 1930s for recognition. Early received the Distinguished Service Cross in 1929 and Merrithew a Silver Star in 1965. York himself always said that the others had guarded the prisoners while he fought.

The German officers

In 1929, after York’s story had spread, the German national archives collected statements from Vollmer and other officers of the units involved, Wurttemberg reservists and Prussian guardsmen worn down by weeks of fighting. They described a confused morning in which exhausted, intermingled troops were surprised from the rear by what they believed was a strong American force, and rejected the idea that one man had beaten a battalion. Vollmer said he surrendered men who had already laid down their arms. The German account accepts that the prisoners were taken; it disputes how many guns were firing and how much one rifleman decided.

The army, the press and the public

York’s division investigated on the ground, with York present, and its officers swore affidavits before recommending the Medal of Honor. He was hardly known until George Pattullo published an article about him in the Saturday Evening Post in April 1919. The appeal was the man as much as the deed: a backwoods pacifist turned reluctant soldier, who then refused offers to profit from his fame and went home to raise money for a school. He resisted a film for twenty years and agreed in 1940. Sergeant York, with Gary Cooper, was released in 1941 as the United States debated entering another war.

What is disputed

The figures in the Medal of Honor citation, 132 prisoners and 35 machine guns silenced, are from American counts on the day; the number of Germans York killed, usually given as about 25, is an estimate and may include men shot by others. Marshal Foch’s reported verdict, that it was the greatest thing done by any soldier of all the armies of Europe, rests on York’s own recollection. The location is contested. Douglas Mastriano and a team led by Thomas Nolan each claim to have found the site, some hundreds of metres apart, on the evidence of cartridge cases and artefacts, and each rejects the other’s methods. Mastriano’s research has also been challenged by other historians.

What followed

York was promoted to sergeant, received the Medal of Honor and the French Croix de Guerre, and came home in May 1919 to a parade in New York. Tennessee gave him a farm. He spent much of his life and money on a school for mountain children at Jamestown, fell into debt and trouble with the tax authorities, and died in 1964. The war had ended five weeks after his patrol. In the United States he remains the best known enlisted man of the First World War, and the argument over his feat is a standing case study in how battlefield legends are made and tested.

Read further

  • Alvin C. York, Sergeant York: His Own Life Story and War Diary, edited by Tom Skeyhill (1928)
  • David D. Lee, Sergeant York: An American Hero (1985)
  • Edward G. Lengel, To Conquer Hell: The Meuse-Argonne, 1918 (2008)
  • Douglas V. Mastriano, Alvin York: A New Biography of the Hero of the Argonne (2014)

Same day, other years

AD 451

The Council of Chalcedon opens

Chalcedon (Kadikoy, Istanbul), Eastern Roman EmpireMiddle East

Several hundred bishops, nearly all from the Greek-speaking east, met in the church of St Euphemia across the Bosphorus from Constantinople, summoned by the new emperor Marcian and his wife Pulcheria. Their task was to undo a council held two years earlier at Ephesus, where the patriarch of Alexandria, Dioscorus, had forced through a doctrine stressing the single divine nature of Christ. Over the following weeks Dioscorus was deposed, a letter from Pope Leo I was acclaimed, and a definition was adopted that Christ is one person ‘in two natures’, divine and human, without confusion or separation. The council also ranked Constantinople second only to Rome, which Leo’s delegates refused to accept.

Seen from elsewhere. Most Christians of Egypt and Syria, and later the Armenian and Ethiopian churches, rejected Chalcedon as a betrayal of Cyril of Alexandria’s teaching of one incarnate nature of the Word. They call themselves miaphysite, not monophysite, and regard Dioscorus as a saint. These Oriental Orthodox churches remain separate, though modern dialogues suggest the two formulas may express the same faith.

1856

The Arrow is boarded at Canton

Canton (Guangzhou), ChinaAsia

Chinese officers looking for a pirate boarded a small cargo vessel, the Arrow, lying off Canton and took away twelve of her Chinese crew. The Arrow was owned by a Chinese resident of Hong Kong and registered there, with a young Irishman as nominal master. The acting British consul, Harry Parkes, claimed that the British flag had been hauled down and demanded the men’s return with a public apology. The imperial commissioner, Ye Mingchen, sent the men back but would not apologise. Two weeks later the Royal Navy began bombarding the city. France joined in, citing the execution of a missionary, and the war went on until Anglo-French troops entered Beijing in 1860.

Seen from elsewhere. Ye maintained that the ship and crew were Chinese and no flag had been flying. The Arrow’s Hong Kong registration had in fact expired, as the governor privately admitted. The House of Commons censured the government over the affair; Palmerston called an election and won. The historian J. Y. Wong argues that the incident was a pretext for widening trade and legalising opium.

1895

The queen of Korea is murdered in her palace

Gyeongbokgung Palace, Seoul, KoreaAsia

Before dawn a party of Japanese civilians with swords, Japanese legation guards and Korean soldiers trained by Japanese officers broke into the Gyeongbok Palace. They went through the women’s quarters, cutting down court ladies until they were sure they had found Queen Min, the consort of King Gojong and the most determined opponent at court of Japanese control. Her body was carried into a nearby grove, soaked in kerosene and burned. The operation had been organised by the Japanese minister in Seoul, Miura Goro, a retired general. Japan had just won its war with China, and the queen had been turning to Russia as a counterweight. She was forty-three.

Seen from elsewhere. Miura’s version was that the king’s father, the Daewongun, and disaffected Korean troops had staged a palace coup. An American military adviser and a Russian architect had seen the attackers. Japan recalled Miura and some fifty others and tried them in Hiroshima, where all were released for lack of evidence. In Korea she is honoured as Empress Myeongseong, a title given in 1897.

1967

Che Guevara is captured in Bolivia

Quebrada del Yuro, near La Higuera, BoliviaThe Americas

After eleven months in the hills of south-eastern Bolivia, Ernesto ‘Che’ Guevara’s guerrilla column was down to seventeen hungry men. On 8 October Bolivian Rangers, trained that summer by American special forces, trapped them in a ravine called the Quebrada del Yuro. Guevara was hit in the leg and his rifle was wrecked by a bullet. He was taken with a Bolivian comrade and marched to the village of La Higuera, where he was held overnight in the mud-walled schoolhouse. The next day, on orders radioed from the high command in La Paz, a sergeant who had volunteered for the task shot him. He was thirty-nine. His body was displayed, then buried in secret.

Seen from elsewhere. The Bolivian government first said he had died of wounds in battle. A CIA officer present, Felix Rodriguez, says Washington wanted him alive for questioning. Guevara’s diary records that not one local peasant had joined him. To admirers he died a martyr of revolution; Cuban exiles remember him as the man who signed death sentences at La Cabana prison in 1959.

Also on 8 October