Parallax

17 October, 1483

Torquemada’s writ is extended across Spain

A papal brief gave one Dominican friar authority over heresy in Aragon as well as Castile. It made the Inquisition the only institution that answered to no frontier inside Spain.

Rome and the kingdoms of Castile and Aragon

On 17 October 1483 Pope Sixtus IV issued a brief naming Tomas de Torquemada, prior of the Dominican house of Santa Cruz in Segovia, as inquisitor for Aragon, Valencia and Catalonia. Torquemada already held the same office for Castile. Ferdinand of Aragon and Isabella of Castile ruled two crowns with separate laws, parliaments, coinages and customs posts. From this day they had one tribunal whose authority ran through both, and one man at the head of it, chosen by them and removable in practice only by them.

The Pope had not wanted it this way. He had authorised the monarchs to appoint inquisitors in Castile by a bull of 1 November 1478, which is the real founding date of the Spanish Inquisition. The first two friars began work in Seville in 1480, and on 6 February 1481 six people were burned there in the first auto de fe. Within a year complaints were reaching Rome. In January 1482 Sixtus wrote that the inquisitors had imprisoned people without proper proof, tortured them and seized their goods. In April he went further and issued a bull condemning the tribunal in Aragon as driven by greed rather than zeal for the faith, and granting the accused the right to know their accusers and to appeal to Rome.

Ferdinand’s reply was blunt. He told the Pope he did not believe such concessions could have been granted, and that he would not allow them to take effect in his kingdoms. Sixtus, who needed Spanish support in Italian politics, suspended his own bull within months. The brief of October 1483 was the end of his resistance.

Torquemada was then in his early sixties, an austere friar who had been one of Isabella’s confessors. Chroniclers say he ate no meat and wore no linen. He gave the tribunal its shape. His Instructions, issued at Seville in November 1484, set out the procedure that would last for three centuries: a period of grace in which people could confess and denounce others, secret testimony, the names of witnesses withheld from the accused, confiscation of the property of the condemned, and the handing over of the unrepentant to the royal courts for burning.

The people it pursued were not Jews, over whom a church court had no jurisdiction, but conversos: baptised Christians of Jewish descent, many of them the grandchildren of people converted during the massacres of 1391. They were accused of keeping the Sabbath, avoiding pork, or changing their linen on a Friday. Aragon resisted on legal grounds. Teruel shut its gates against the inquisitors in 1484, and in September 1485 the inquisitor Pedro Arbues was stabbed while praying in Zaragoza cathedral. The murder turned opinion against the conversos and broke the opposition. Torquemada held office until his death in 1498.

How it came to this

Medieval Spain had held the largest Jewish population in Europe. In 1391 riots that began in Seville spread across Castile and Aragon; thousands were killed and tens of thousands accepted baptism to save their lives. Further waves of conversion followed the preaching campaigns of Vincent Ferrer and the Disputation of Tortosa in 1413-14. As Christians, the converts and their children could enter professions, city councils and the church, and many rose fast. Resentment followed. In Toledo in 1449 rebels passed a statute barring anyone of Jewish descent from public office, the first of the ‘purity of blood’ laws.

A papal inquisition had existed since the thirteenth century and had operated, feebly, in Aragon; Castile had never had one. What Ferdinand and Isabella obtained in 1478 was new: inquisitors appointed by the crown, not by Rome or the bishops. The monarchs had just won a civil war and were about to begin the conquest of Muslim Granada. Friars such as Alonso de Hojeda in Seville told the queen that secret Judaism was rife among the converts, and she was persuaded.

How each side saw it

The conversos

Most of what the accused said survives only in the trial records kept by their judges, which is the central difficulty. Some certainly kept Jewish practices in private. Many others protested that they were sincere Christians denounced by servants, debtors or rivals. One converso voice from outside the courtroom is Hernando del Pulgar, the queen’s own secretary and chronicler. In a letter to Cardinal Mendoza he argued that the thousands of young conversos in Andalusia had never been properly taught the faith, and that instruction, not fire, was the remedy. He was himself attacked for writing it, and later estimated that some two thousand people had been burned by 1490.

The crown and the inquisitors

Ferdinand and Isabella held that a baptised Christian who returned to Jewish rites was a heretic, and that heresy was a crime against God and a danger to the realm, as every Christian government of the age agreed. The priest and chronicler Andres Bernaldez, who admired the tribunal, described the Seville conversos as a people who had never truly left Judaism and wrote that the fire, once lit, would burn until the wood was consumed. To its supporters the tribunal was lawful, followed written procedure, and offered mercy to all who confessed within the term of grace.

The Jewish communities

Unbaptised Jews were outside the tribunal’s reach but not its consequences. Inquisitors argued that conversos would never be true Christians while Jews lived alongside them, and Jews were expelled from Andalusia in 1483. In 1492 the Alhambra decree ordered all Jews in Castile and Aragon to convert or leave. Isaac Abravanel, the financier and biblical commentator who went into exile, recorded his attempts to have the decree withdrawn. Solomon ibn Verga’s Shevet Yehudah, written by an exile in the next generation, set the expulsion within a long history of persecutions and asked why they kept happening.

The papacy

Sixtus IV’s bulls of 1482 are the strongest contemporary criticism of the early tribunal, and they come from the man who authorised it. He objected to secret witnesses, to the denial of appeal and to the profit motive. His successors continued to receive appeals from wealthy conversos and to issue absolutions, which Ferdinand refused to recognise. Rome never recovered control. Catholic historians have pointed to this record to argue that the Spanish Inquisition was a royal instrument rather than a papal one; critics reply that the popes yielded, and kept yielding.

What is disputed

The Inquisition was not founded on this day: the founding bull is dated 1 November 1478, and 17 October 1483 is the extension of Torquemada’s authority to the Crown of Aragon. The numbers are contested. Juan Antonio Llorente, a former official of the tribunal writing after 1800, put the burnings under Torquemada at about 8,800, a figure now thought too high; Henry Kamen and William Monter suggest roughly 2,000 executions in the first fifty years. Historians also disagree about the victims. Yitzhak Baer and Haim Beinart held that most conversos were secretly Jewish; Benzion Netanyahu argued they were largely sincere Christians and that the motive was racial and political.

What followed

After the conversos the tribunal turned to Moriscos, Protestants, mystics, bigamists and blasphemers, and its courts were established in Mexico, Lima and Cartagena. A study of nearly 45,000 cases between 1540 and 1700 found that under two in a hundred ended in execution, far fewer than in the first decades. It was abolished by Joseph Bonaparte, restored, and finally suppressed on 15 July 1834. The ‘purity of blood’ statutes it helped to enforce outlived it in some institutions. In 2015 Spain offered citizenship to descendants of the Jews expelled in 1492.

Read further

  • Henry Kamen, The Spanish Inquisition: A Historical Revision (1997)
  • Benzion Netanyahu, The Origins of the Inquisition in Fifteenth Century Spain (1995)
  • Haim Beinart, Conversos on Trial: The Inquisition in Ciudad Real (1981)
  • Henry Charles Lea, A History of the Inquisition of Spain (1906-07)
  • Joseph Perez, The Spanish Inquisition: A History (2004)

Same day, other years

1806

Dessalines is ambushed at Pont-Rouge

Near Port-au-Prince, HaitiThe Americas

Jean-Jacques Dessalines, born into slavery, had commanded the army that defeated Napoleon’s expedition and on 1 January 1804 declared Haiti independent, the first state founded by people who had freed themselves. He took the title Emperor Jacques I. His rule was hard: he ordered the killing of most of the remaining French colonists in 1804, kept former field workers bound to the plantations under military discipline, and began checking land titles in a way that threatened wealthy landowners of mixed descent. On 17 October 1806, riding south to put down a revolt, he was shot by his own officers at Pont-Rouge. His body was mutilated and, by tradition, gathered up for burial by a woman named Defilee.

Seen from elsewhere. The conspirators, linked to Alexandre Petion, called it the removal of a tyrant, and Haiti promptly split into a northern state under Henry Christophe and a southern republic. Later generations reversed the verdict. Dessalines is honoured as the founder of the nation, the national anthem bears his name, and 17 October is a public holiday in his memory.

1945

The crowd in the Plaza de Mayo frees Peron

Buenos Aires, ArgentinaThe Americas

Colonel Juan Peron had used the labour ministry of Argentina’s military government to grant wage rises, paid holidays and union recognition, and had become the most powerful man in the regime. On 9 October 1945 rival officers forced him out and then sent him to the prison island of Martin Garcia. On 17 October workers from the meat-packing plants and factories of the southern suburbs walked into the centre of Buenos Aires and filled the Plaza de Mayo, some cooling their feet in the fountains. The crowd, usually put in the hundreds of thousands, would not leave. Near midnight Peron appeared on the balcony of the Casa Rosada. He won the presidential election four months later.

Seen from elsewhere. Peronists keep the date as Loyalty Day, the moment the working class entered politics. Opponents saw a mob mobilised for a would-be dictator who admired Mussolini; one deputy later called the marchers a ‘zoological flood’. Historians also doubt the later legend that Eva Duarte organised the march. She seems to have played little part.

1961

Paris police attack an Algerian march

Paris, FranceEurope

In the last year of the Algerian war the Paris police prefect, Maurice Papon, imposed a night curfew that applied only to ‘French Muslims from Algeria’. The National Liberation Front called a peaceful protest for the evening of 17 October 1961 and ordered marchers to carry no weapons. Between twenty and thirty thousand men, women and children came in from the shanty towns of the suburbs. Police met them at the bridges and metro exits. Demonstrators were beaten, shot, and in some cases thrown into the Seine. More than eleven thousand were arrested and held for days in sports stadiums, where the beatings continued. The official statement spoke of three dead.

Seen from elsewhere. The police said they had been fired on, which no inquiry has borne out, though FLN gunmen had killed several officers in the preceding weeks. The death toll remains contested: Jean-Paul Brunet estimated thirty to fifty, Jean-Luc Einaudi more than two hundred. The French state denied the killings for decades; in 2021 President Macron called them inexcusable crimes.

1973

Arab oil producers decide to cut supply

Kuwait City, KuwaitMiddle East

Eleven days into the war that Egypt and Syria had launched against Israel, the oil ministers of the Arab exporting countries met in Kuwait. On 17 October 1973 they agreed to reduce production by five per cent a month until Israel withdrew from the territories occupied in 1967. The Gulf producers had raised their posted price by seventy per cent the day before. When President Nixon asked Congress for 2.2 billion dollars in military aid to Israel, Saudi Arabia and others stopped shipments to the United States altogether, and later to the Netherlands. By January the price of oil had roughly quadrupled. The embargo was lifted in March 1974; the price stayed.

Seen from elsewhere. The producers saw oil as their one peaceful lever, and the price rise as correcting decades in which Western companies had set the terms. Importing governments called it blackmail. Economists still argue over how far the queues at petrol stations were caused by the embargo itself and how far by price controls and panic.

Also on 17 October