Parallax

20 October, 1935

The Long March reaches northern Shaanxi

About 86,000 people had set out a year before. Perhaps one in ten of them arrived. A military disaster was about to become the founding story of a state.

Wuqi, Shaanxi, China

In the third week of October 1935 a column of some seven or eight thousand soldiers came down out of the hills of the Shaanxi-Gansu border into Wuqi, a poor town of cave dwellings cut into yellow loess cliffs. They wore straw sandals or rags tied round their feet. On the walls they found slogans painted by the local Communist guerrillas, and knew they had reached friendly country. Mao Zedong, who was with them, is said to have learned of the existence of this northern base only weeks before, from a Nationalist newspaper picked up on the road.

They had started twelve months earlier from the other end of China. In October 1934 the main Communist army, hemmed into its base in Jiangxi province by a ring of Nationalist blockhouses, broke out to the west with about 86,000 people. They carried printing presses, a mint, X-ray equipment and the party archives on shoulder poles. At the Xiang River, at the end of November, the Nationalists caught the slow-moving column at a crossing, and within a week more than half the force was dead, captured or had gone home.

The disaster discredited the men in charge, among them the Comintern’s German military adviser, Otto Braun. At a meeting in the town of Zunyi in January 1935 Mao, who had been sidelined for two years, returned to the military leadership. The army shed its baggage and turned to manoeuvre: back and forth across the Chishui River, a feint at the provincial capital of Guiyang, a crossing of the upper Yangtze in a handful of ferry boats. In late May it forced the chain bridge over the Dadu River at Luding.

Then came the mountains of western Sichuan, crossed in summer clothing at over four thousand metres, and in August the high grasslands on the edge of Tibet, a week of bog with nothing to eat but wild plants and boiled leather. Men sat down to rest and did not get up. A reunion with a larger Communist army under Zhang Guotao ended in a quarrel over where to go and who should lead, and Zhang took his troops south.

Mao’s column went north, broke through the Lazikou pass in September and walked into Wuqi on about 19 October. A few days later it beat off the Muslim cavalry that had been following it. In December Mao told a party meeting that the march had been a manifesto, a propaganda force and a seeding-machine. The claim that it had covered 25,000 li, about eight thousand miles, dates from the same period.

How it came to this

The Chinese Communist Party and the Nationalist Party of Chiang Kai-shek had been allies until April 1927, when Chiang turned on the Communists in Shanghai and had thousands killed. The survivors went to the countryside. In the hills of southern Jiangxi Mao and the soldier Zhu De built a base that by 1931 called itself the Chinese Soviet Republic, with several million inhabitants, its own currency and a programme of confiscating land from landlords.

Chiang launched five ‘encirclement campaigns’ against it. Four failed. The fifth, begun in late 1933 with advice from German officers, abandoned pursuit for a slow strangulation: lines of concrete blockhouses linked by new roads, advancing a few miles at a time, with an economic blockade that cut off salt and medicine. The Communist leadership, by then dominated by Moscow-trained men, chose to meet it with positional warfare and lost heavily. By the summer of 1934 the base had shrunk to a few counties, and the decision was taken, in secret, to leave. The sick and wounded and a rearguard of about 28,000 were left behind.

How each side saw it

The Communist Party’s account

In the party’s telling the march was a triumph of will over nature and the enemy, proof that the Red Army could not be destroyed and that Mao’s leadership was correct. This version reached the world through the American journalist Edgar Snow, who interviewed Mao in 1936 and published Red Star Over China the following year. Its set pieces, above all the twenty-two volunteers crawling along the bare chains of the Luding bridge under fire, have been taught to every Chinese schoolchild since 1949. Veterans of the march governed China for half a century, and their memoirs were written within the limits the party set.

The Nationalists

To Chiang Kai-shek the events of 1934-35 were a successful campaign. The Communist state in Jiangxi was destroyed and its army reduced to a remnant in one of the poorest corners of the country. The pursuit also served another purpose: it took central government troops into Guizhou, Yunnan and Sichuan, provinces run by semi-independent warlords, and brought them under Nanjing’s control for the first time. Nationalist historians have long argued that only the Japanese invasion of 1937, and the forced truce that preceded it, saved the Communists from being finished off.

Those left behind and those along the route

The rearguard in Jiangxi was hunted for three years; Mao’s younger brother Zetan and the former party leader Qu Qiubai were among those killed. The thirty or so women who marched with the main column included Mao’s wife He Zizhen, who was badly wounded by a bomb and gave birth on the road to a daughter who was left with a peasant family and never found. The Tibetan and Yi communities the army passed through had little food to spare. Marchers interviewed decades later by the writer Sun Shuyun described taking grain from Tibetan villages and monasteries because the alternative was to starve.

The rival Red armies

Mao’s was one of several columns. Zhang Guotao’s Fourth Front Army was larger and suffered more: after the split it spent a winter in the Tibetan borderlands, and a detachment sent west in 1936 was wiped out by Muslim cavalry in the Gansu corridor. Zhang lost the argument inside the party, defected to the Nationalists in 1938 and wrote his memoirs in exile, accusing Mao of having slipped away north by night and broken the army’s unity. The official history gives the opposite account, in which Zhang was the splitter.

What is disputed

The date itself is loose: Mao’s column entered Wuqi on about 19 October 1935, and 20, 21 and 22 October are all given; the other armies did not arrive until October 1936. The distance is disputed. Two Britons who walked the First Army’s route in 2002-03 measured about 6,000 kilometres, roughly half the traditional figure, and were criticised in China for saying so. Jung Chang and Jon Halliday claimed that there was no real fight at Luding bridge and that Chiang deliberately let the Communists escape; most specialists reject the second claim and think the bridge was defended, but lightly, by a warlord’s troops.

What followed

The survivors moved to Yan’an, which remained the Communist capital until 1947. In December 1936 Chiang was kidnapped at Xi’an by his own generals and forced to accept a united front against Japan, which gave the Communists the breathing space in which their forces grew from tens of thousands to about a million. They took power in 1949. The march became the central legend of the People’s Republic, invoked by Mao against his colleagues in the Cultural Revolution and by his successors since, and ‘a new Long March’ remains a stock phrase of Chinese politics.

Read further

  • Edgar Snow, Red Star Over China (1937)
  • Harrison E. Salisbury, The Long March: The Untold Story (1985)
  • Sun Shuyun, The Long March (2006)
  • Otto Braun, A Comintern Agent in China, 1932-1939 (1982)
  • Benjamin Yang, From Revolution to Politics: Chinese Communists on the Long March (1990)

Same day, other years

1827

An Ottoman fleet is destroyed at Navarino

Navarino Bay, GreeceEurope

Six years into the Greek revolt against Ottoman rule, Britain, France and Russia had agreed to impose an armistice. The Sultan refused it, and an Egyptian army under Ibrahim Pasha went on laying waste the Peloponnese. On 20 October 1827 a combined squadron under the British admiral Sir Edward Codrington sailed into the bay where the Ottoman and Egyptian fleet lay anchored in a horseshoe, and anchored among them. A boat sent to ask a fireship to move was shot at. The battle that followed lasted four hours at point-blank range. About sixty Ottoman and Egyptian vessels were sunk or burned and several thousand men killed. The allies lost no ships. It was the last major battle fought entirely under sail.

Seen from elsewhere. None of the three powers was at war with the Sultan, who called it an unprovoked attack and demanded compensation. The British government agreed that it was awkward: the King’s Speech termed it an ‘untoward event’ and Codrington was recalled. For Greeks it is the day that made independence certain.

1944

Guatemala’s October Revolution

Guatemala City, GuatemalaThe Americas

General Jorge Ubico had ruled Guatemala for thirteen years on behalf of the coffee planters and the United Fruit Company when strikes by teachers and students forced him out in July 1944. His successor, General Ponce, tried to carry on as before. On 20 October junior officers led by Jacobo Arbenz and Francisco Arana, joined by armed students and workers, attacked the garrisons of the capital and had won by evening. Free elections in December brought a schoolteacher and philosopher, Juan Jose Arevalo, to the presidency with a large majority. The decade that followed saw votes for most adults, a labour code, social security and, under Arbenz from 1952, the redistribution of unused estate land.

Seen from elsewhere. United Fruit, the largest landowner, and the Eisenhower administration saw a Soviet foothold; a CIA operation overthrew Arbenz in 1954. Historians such as Piero Gleijeses accept that Arbenz was close to the Communists but describe his programme as capitalist reform. The civil war that grew out of the coup killed some 200,000 people, most of them Maya.

1952

A state of emergency is declared in Kenya

Nairobi, KenyaAfrica

For two years a movement the British called Mau Mau had been spreading among the Kikuyu of central Kenya, bound by oaths and driven by the loss of land to white settlers. After the killing of a senior chief loyal to the government, the new governor, Sir Evelyn Baring, signed an emergency proclamation on the evening of 20 October 1952. Before dawn troops and police arrested Jomo Kenyatta and about 180 other African political figures. Kenyatta was convicted of managing Mau Mau on evidence later admitted to be perjured. The emergency lasted until 1960. Tens of thousands of Kikuyu passed through detention camps, more than a million were moved into guarded villages, and 1,090 were hanged.

Seen from elsewhere. Settlers and officials described a savage cult; Mau Mau fighters killed 32 European civilians and at least 1,800 Africans, and many Kikuyu fought for the government. Estimates of Kikuyu deaths range from the official 11,000 to Caroline Elkins’s far higher figures, which demographers dispute. In 2013 Britain paid compensation to over five thousand survivors of torture.

2011

Muammar Gaddafi is captured and killed

Sirte, LibyaAfrica

Gaddafi had ruled Libya since a coup in 1969. An uprising that began in Benghazi in February 2011 became a civil war, and from March NATO aircraft bombed his forces under a United Nations resolution authorising the protection of civilians. Tripoli fell in August. Gaddafi held out in his home town of Sirte until 20 October, when his convoy tried to break out and was struck from the air. He was found sheltering in a drainage culvert by fighters from Misrata. Mobile phone footage shows him alive, bleeding and being beaten. He was dead within the hour. His body was laid out in a meat store in Misrata, where people queued for days to see it.

Seen from elsewhere. The new authorities said he died in crossfire; Human Rights Watch found evidence that he, his son Mutassim and dozens of his escort were killed after capture. Russia, China and the African Union argued that NATO had turned a mandate to protect civilians into regime change. Libya has not had a single effective government since.

Also on 20 October