Parallax

4 October, 1853

The Ottoman Empire declares war on Russia

A quarrel between monks over the keys to a church in Bethlehem ended with the sultan’s council voting for war against the largest army in Europe. Within six months Britain and France had joined in, and three-quarters of a million men would not come home.

Constantinople (Istanbul), Ottoman Empire

For three months Russian troops had been sitting in the Ottoman provinces of Moldavia and Wallachia, north of the Danube. Tsar Nicholas I had sent them across the river Pruth at the start of July 1853, not, he said, to make war but to hold a pledge until the sultan met his demands. The demand that mattered was a formal Russian right to protect the Orthodox Christians of the Ottoman Empire, some twelve million people, about a third of the sultan’s subjects. Prince Menshikov had presented it in Constantinople that spring in a deliberately insulting manner and had gone home in May without an answer he could accept.

The summer was spent in diplomacy. Ministers of Britain, France, Austria and Prussia, meeting in Vienna, drafted a note meant to satisfy the tsar without humiliating the sultan. Nicholas accepted it. The Ottoman government, which had not been consulted on the text, proposed amendments to make clear that the protection of its Christian subjects rested with the sultan alone. Russia refused them, and a leaked Russian commentary then showed that St Petersburg read the note as granting exactly what the Ottomans feared.

In Constantinople patience had run out. Theology students from the religious schools filled the streets in September demanding war, and there was talk of deposing Sultan Abdulmecid if he gave way. British and French warships lay at the mouth of the Dardanelles. On 26 September a grand council of ministers, generals and religious dignitaries, more than 160 men, met and resolved on war. The sultan approved, and on 4 October the declaration was published. The commander on the Danube, Omer Pasha, a Croatian-born convert who had built the nearest thing the empire had to a modern army, sent the Russian general Gorchakov a demand to leave the principalities within fifteen days.

No reply came that could be accepted. On 23 October Ottoman batteries fired on Russian gunboats on the Danube, and days later Omer Pasha put troops across the river. At Oltenitza on 4 November they beat off a Russian attack, the first Ottoman success against Russia in living memory.

It was the events of 30 November that brought in the western powers. A Russian squadron under Admiral Nakhimov caught an Ottoman flotilla at anchor in the Black Sea harbour of Sinope and destroyed it with explosive shells, killing some three thousand sailors. It was a legitimate act of war. The London press called it a massacre. In March 1854 Britain and France declared war on Russia, and in September their armies landed in the Crimea.

How it came to this

Russia had been advancing south at Ottoman expense for a century and a half, and by a treaty of 1774 claimed a vaguely worded right to speak for the sultan’s Orthodox subjects. Nicholas I believed the Ottoman state was near collapse. In January 1853 he told the British ambassador, Sir Hamilton Seymour, that they had a sick man on their hands and should agree in advance how to dispose of his estate. Britain, which wanted the Ottoman Empire kept alive as a barrier on the route to India, declined.

The immediate spark was in Palestine. Catholic and Orthodox clergy had long disputed control of the holy places, above all the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem. Napoleon III, needing Catholic support at home, pressed the sultan to favour the Latins, and in December 1852 they received a key to the main door and placed a silver star in the grotto. Nicholas took it as an affront to Orthodoxy and to himself. He also assumed that Austria, whose throne he had saved from the Hungarian revolution in 1849, would stand by him, and that Britain and France could never act together. He was wrong on both counts.

How each side saw it

Nicholas I and Russian opinion

The tsar saw himself as the protector of fellow believers under Muslim rule, claiming nothing that treaties had not already given him, and he was sincere enough in this to be astonished when Christian powers sided with the sultan. The historian Mikhail Pogodin wrote memoranda, which Nicholas annotated with approval, listing French and British conquests from Algeria to India and asking why Russia alone was forbidden to act for its interests. Slavophile writers called it a holy war for the liberation of the Balkan Christians. Austria’s hostile neutrality was felt in St Petersburg as a betrayal, and it shaped Russian policy for the next sixty years.

The Ottoman government

Ottoman state papers, studied in detail by the Turkish historian Candan Badem, show a government that regarded Menshikov’s demand as the end of its sovereignty: a foreign ruler would have had standing to intervene on behalf of a third of the population. Ministers were divided between a war party and reformers such as Mustafa Resid Pasha who feared the cost, and the declaration was made under pressure from the street and with the hope, not the promise, of western help. The Ottoman army did much of the fighting on the Danube and in the Caucasus, a fact largely absent from British and French accounts.

Britain and France

Lord Aberdeen, the prime minister, did not want war and thought the Ottomans had been reckless. Palmerston, the press and much of the public did, seeing Russia as a despotism threatening India and European liberty alike. The ambassador in Constantinople, Lord Stratford de Redcliffe, was accused then and since of encouraging Ottoman resistance beyond his instructions. Napoleon III wanted to break the alliance of conservative powers that had contained France since 1815. Opponents such as John Bright and Richard Cobden argued in Parliament that Britain was spending lives to prop up a tyranny, and were burned in effigy for it.

The peoples in between

The Romanians of the occupied principalities, the Bulgarians, Greeks and Serbs in whose name Russia claimed to act, and the Muslim Tatars of the Crimea had no voice in the decision. Greek volunteers rose in Thessaly and Epirus in 1854 and were put down after British and French forces occupied Piraeus. The Crimean Tatars, suspected by Russian officials of sympathy with the invaders, were pressed to leave after the war; some 200,000 emigrated to Ottoman lands, about two-thirds of their community. Their story is known mainly through Russian administrative records and later Tatar memory.

What is disputed

Some accounts date the declaration to 5 October, and the Russian calendar of the time put it twelve days earlier, in September; fighting did not begin until 23 October, and Russia’s own declaration followed on 1 November. Nicholas’s remark is usually quoted as ‘the sick man of Europe’, a phrase he did not use. Historians still argue about responsibility. A. J. P. Taylor saw a war that nobody wanted, produced by mutual fear. David Goldfrank places the main blame on Nicholas’s miscalculations, others on Stratford or on Napoleon III. Orlando Figes argues that religion, usually treated as a pretext, was a real motive on all sides.

What followed

The war ended in 1856 with the Treaty of Paris, which closed the Black Sea to warships and removed the Russian protectorate. Perhaps 750,000 soldiers died, most of them Russian and most from disease. Defeat pushed Alexander II to abolish serfdom in 1861. The Ottoman Empire took its first foreign loans to pay for the war and was bankrupt within twenty years. Florence Nightingale and Mary Seacole became famous, the telegraph and the war correspondent changed how wars were reported, and the peninsula itself has been fought over again since.

Read further

  • Orlando Figes, Crimea: The Last Crusade (2010)
  • Candan Badem, The Ottoman Crimean War, 1853-1856 (2010)
  • David M. Goldfrank, The Origins of the Crimean War (1994)
  • Trevor Royle, Crimea: The Great Crimean War, 1854-1856 (1999)
  • A. W. Kinglake, The Invasion of the Crimea (1863-87)

Same day, other years

1582

Ten days are struck from the calendar

Rome, Papal StatesEurope

People in Italy, Spain, Portugal and Poland went to bed on Thursday 4 October and woke on Friday 15 October. Pope Gregory XIII had ordered the jump in a bull issued that February, to correct a calendar that had drifted since Julius Caesar’s time: the Julian year was about eleven minutes too long, and the spring equinox, on which the date of Easter depends, had slipped to 11 March. The fix, worked out by the Calabrian physician Aloysius Lilius and the Jesuit astronomer Christopher Clavius, dropped ten days and removed three leap years in every four centuries. Teresa of Avila died during that night, which is why her feast is kept on 15 October.

Seen from elsewhere. Protestant and Orthodox states refused a reform decreed by a pope. Britain and its colonies held out until 1752, Russia until 1918 and Greece until 1923, and most Orthodox churches still reckon Easter by the old calendar. The English riots demanding ‘give us our eleven days’ are largely a later legend drawn from a Hogarth print.

1824

Mexico adopts a federal constitution

Mexico City, MexicoThe Americas

Three years after independence from Spain and a year after the fall of the short-lived emperor Agustin de Iturbide, a constituent congress proclaimed the Federal Constitution of the United Mexican States. It created a republic of nineteen states and several territories with a president, a two-chamber congress and a supreme court. Its authors drew on the constitution of the United States and on the liberal Spanish constitution written at Cadiz in 1812. Catholicism remained the only permitted religion, and the clergy and army kept their separate courts. Guadalupe Victoria, a veteran of the insurgency, took office days later as first president, and was the only one in the next three decades to complete his term.

Seen from elsewhere. Centralists such as Lucas Alaman and the priest Servando Teresa de Mier warned that a federation copied from a neighbour with a different history would pull a huge, thinly governed country apart. Federalists answered that the provinces would accept nothing else. The charter was scrapped in 1835, and Texas, Yucatan and other regions rebelled against the centralist system that replaced it.

1957

Sputnik goes into orbit

Tyuratam (Baikonur), Kazakh SSR, Soviet UnionAsia

A converted intercontinental missile lifted off from the Kazakh steppe late in the evening, Moscow time, carrying a polished metal sphere 58 centimetres across with four trailing aerials. It weighed about 84 kilograms and did nothing but transmit a beep, which radio amateurs around the world could pick up as it passed overhead every 96 minutes. The first artificial satellite had been built in a few weeks, after a more ambitious scientific craft fell behind schedule, because its chief designer feared the Americans would launch first. His name, Sergei Korolev, was a state secret until his death. The batteries lasted three weeks. Sputnik burned up in the atmosphere in January 1958.

Seen from elsewhere. The Soviet press at first gave it a few paragraphs; the scale of the reaction abroad surprised Moscow. In the United States it was taken as proof of a missile gap and a failing school system. President Eisenhower was calmer in private: a Soviet satellite had settled, in America’s favour, whether spacecraft could legally overfly other countries.

1992

Mozambique’s civil war ends in Rome

Rome, Italy, and MozambiqueAfrica

President Joaquim Chissano and the rebel leader Afonso Dhlakama signed a general peace agreement after more than two years of talks hosted by a Catholic lay community, Sant’Egidio, in a former convent in Rome. The war between the Frelimo government and Renamo had lasted fifteen years. About a million people are thought to have died, from fighting and from the famine it caused, and more than five million were driven from their homes in a country of some fifteen million. Drought, the end of the Cold War and the approaching end of apartheid had left both sides without the means to go on. United Nations troops supervised demobilisation, and elections were held in 1994.

Seen from elsewhere. Frelimo had called Renamo armed bandits, created by Rhodesian intelligence and sustained by South Africa to wreck an independent black state. Renamo said it fought a Marxist one-party regime that had forced peasants into communal villages. A report for the US State Department in 1988 attributed most atrocities to Renamo. There was no truth commission, and fighting resumed for a time after 2013.

Also on 4 October