Parallax

25 October, 1415

Agincourt: an army caught in the mud

A sick and hungry English army trying to reach Calais was cornered in a ploughed field in Artois, and by nightfall much of the French nobility lay dead or captive.

Azincourt, Artois, France

On the night of 24 October 1415 two armies camped within earshot of each other in the rain. Henry V’s men had been marching for more than two weeks from Harfleur, which they had taken after a five-week siege, towards English-held Calais. Dysentery had killed or invalided home a large part of the force. The French had broken the bridges on the Somme and forced them far upstream to find a crossing, food had run short, and now a French army stood across the road north. Henry ordered silence in his camp. The French, by English accounts, spent the night in noise and confidence.

The morning of the 25th, the feast of Saints Crispin and Crispinian, found the armies facing each other across a field of newly sown wheat, soaked by the rain and narrowed by the woods of Agincourt and Tramecourt on either side. Henry’s army was mostly archers, with a thin line of dismounted men-at-arms in the centre. Each archer carried a sharpened stake to drive into the ground against horsemen. The French commanders, the Constable Charles d’Albret and Marshal Boucicaut, had planned for mounted squadrons to ride down the archers while the main body of dismounted nobles struck the English centre. For hours neither side moved.

It was Henry who broke the deadlock. Late in the morning he had the stakes pulled up, walked his whole line forward to within long bowshot, replanted them and loosed. The provocation worked. The French cavalry charged before they were fully assembled, too few to do the job, and were shot down or turned by the stakes, their wounded horses plunging back through their own advancing infantry. The dismounted French vanguard came on through the churned mud under arrow fire, heavily armoured and packed tighter with every step as the field narrowed between the woods.

What followed was less a fight than a crush. Men who fell could not rise, and those behind pushed forward onto them. English archers, their arrows spent, ran in with mallets, axes and daggers against knights who could barely lift their arms. The Dukes of Alencon, Bar and Brabant were killed; the young Duke of Orleans was pulled alive from a heap of bodies. On the English side Edward, Duke of York, died in the press, as did the young Earl of Suffolk.

Then came the act that has troubled readers ever since. With a great many prisoners standing behind his lines, Henry learned that his baggage camp had been raided and saw French troops forming for a fresh attack. He ordered the prisoners killed. Several chroniclers say his men were unwilling, since every prisoner was a ransom, and that an esquire with two hundred archers was sent to do it. The killing stopped when the French drew off. By evening the English held the field, and the battle took its name from the castle nearby.

How it came to this

English kings had claimed the French crown since Edward III in 1340, through his French mother, and had won famous victories at Crecy in 1346 and Poitiers in 1356. By 1400 most of those gains had been lost. Henry V, crowned in 1413 in his mid-twenties, revived the claim at a moment of French weakness. Charles VI suffered recurrent bouts of madness, and his kingdom was split between two princely factions, the Burgundians and the Armagnacs, who had been at war with each other since agents of the Duke of Burgundy murdered the king’s brother, Louis of Orleans, in a Paris street in 1407.

Henry bargained with both factions while preparing to invade, demanding Normandy, Aquitaine and more, together with a French princess. When talks stalled he crossed with perhaps 12,000 men in August 1415 and besieged Harfleur, the port at the mouth of the Seine. It surrendered on 22 September, but disease had cost him dearly and the campaigning season was nearly over. Rather than sail home, Henry chose to march overland to Calais through hostile country, a gesture of defiance that very nearly destroyed him.

How each side saw it

Henry’s chaplain and the English court

The fullest English account, the Gesta Henrici Quinti, was written by a royal chaplain who watched from the baggage train and says he sat on a horse praying while the battle was fought. He presents Agincourt as God’s verdict on a just claim and on French pride, and Henry as a pious king who had offered peace. The Gesta was finished within a couple of years, probably to support the king’s demands for taxes and further war, and it handles awkward matters carefully: the killing of prisoners gets a brief mention and is blamed on the renewed French threat.

French chroniclers

French writers were shaken and looked for reasons. The monk of Saint-Denis who kept the royal chronicle blamed the pride of the nobles, who pushed their crossbowmen and common infantry to the rear so as to claim the honour of the front rank, and who had turned down offers of troops from Paris. Writers of each faction blamed the other. Enguerrand de Monstrelet and Jean de Waurin, both in the Burgundian orbit, wrote of a disaster under Armagnac leadership; Waurin fought on the French side, and Jean Le Fevre, whose account runs close to his, was with the English army.

The captives

For the nobles taken alive, Agincourt began a long exile. Charles, Duke of Orleans, was held in England for twenty-five years, partly because Henry’s dying instructions forbade his release while the war lasted. He wrote much of his poetry in captivity, in French and in English, and his ballades of longing for France are among the few voices from the losing side. John, Duke of Bourbon, died a prisoner in 1434. The ordinary prisoners killed behind the English lines left nothing of their own; we know of them only through chroniclers on both sides.

Modern historians

Anne Curry, working from English muster rolls and pay records, argues that Henry had close to 9,000 men and the French perhaps 12,000, a real disadvantage but nowhere near the odds of four or five to one in the chronicles and in Shakespeare. Juliet Barker and Clifford Rogers, giving more weight to the narrative sources, keep a much larger French superiority. The numbers matter because the size of the odds has carried the legend, from the play of 1599 to Laurence Olivier’s film of 1944, made as wartime propaganda.

What is disputed

Numbers are the central argument. Chroniclers give the French anywhere from about 10,000 to well over 100,000, and modern estimates still run from about 12,000 to 25,000 or more against some 6,000 to 9,000 English. French dead are put in the thousands, English losses at a few hundred at most, though English writers claimed far fewer. Whether killing the prisoners broke the customs of war is debated; contemporaries recorded it with less outrage than later readers. Shakespeare’s speeches are his own: ‘Once more unto the breach’ is set at Harfleur, not Agincourt, and the Crispin’s Day speech is invented.

What followed

Henry returned to a triumphal entry into London in November 1415. The battle did not win France by itself; that took the conquest of Normandy from 1417 and the Burgundian alliance that followed the murder of Duke John the Fearless in 1419. The Treaty of Troyes in 1420 made Henry heir to the French throne and married him to Catherine of Valois. He died in 1422, weeks before Charles VI, and within thirty years the English had lost everything in France except Calais. Agincourt survived as one of England’s founding stories.

Read further

  • Anne Curry, Agincourt: A New History (2005)
  • Anne Curry, The Battle of Agincourt: Sources and Interpretations (2000)
  • Juliet Barker, Agincourt: The King, the Campaign, the Battle (2005)
  • John Keegan, The Face of Battle (1976)
  • Frank Taylor and John S. Roskell (eds.), Gesta Henrici Quinti: The Deeds of Henry the Fifth (1975)

Same day, other years

1854

The Light Brigade rides down the wrong valley

Balaclava, CrimeaEurope

Early in the Crimean War a Russian attack on the British supply port at Balaclava produced three famous episodes in one day: the stand of the 93rd Highlanders, the successful charge of the Heavy Brigade, and the destruction of the Light. An ambiguous order from the commander, Lord Raglan, carried by Captain Louis Nolan, was read by Lord Lucan and Lord Cardigan as an instruction to attack the Russian guns at the far end of a valley rather than the captured redoubts Raglan had in mind. Some 670 light cavalrymen rode into fire from three sides. Around 110 were killed, many more were wounded or captured, and about 375 horses were lost.

Seen from elsewhere. Russian accounts treat Balaclava as a success: their troops kept the captured redoubts and squeezed the British supply road. Lucan, Cardigan and Raglan’s defenders argued over the blame for decades, and Nolan, killed early in the charge, could not answer. Tennyson’s poem, published weeks later, turned a blunder into a national legend of obedience.

1945

Japan hands Taiwan to the Republic of China

Taipei, TaiwanAsia

In Taipei’s public hall, General Chen Yi, appointed governor by Chiang Kai-shek’s government, accepted the surrender of Japanese forces on the island from Governor-General Ando Rikichi. Japan had ruled Taiwan for fifty years, since China ceded it under the Treaty of Shimonoseki in 1895. The Republic of China declared the island restored to Chinese rule and marked the day as Retrocession Day. Many Taiwanese welcomed the change. Within eighteen months, after corruption, requisitioning and runaway inflation under Chen Yi’s administration, an island-wide uprising broke out in February 1947 and was crushed by troops from the mainland, with deaths usually estimated in the thousands.

Seen from elsewhere. Beijing and the Kuomintang both treat 1945 as the return of Chinese territory. Supporters of Taiwanese independence argue that Japan renounced the island in the 1951 San Francisco treaty without naming a recipient, so sovereignty was never formally transferred. The 1947 killings, the 228 Incident, shaped Taiwanese identity for decades.

1971

The UN gives China’s seat to Beijing

New York, United StatesWorldwide

By 76 votes to 35, with 17 abstentions, the UN General Assembly adopted Resolution 2758, recognising the representatives of the People’s Republic of China as the only lawful representatives of China and expelling ‘the representatives of Chiang Kai-shek’. Since 1949 the government in Taipei had held China’s seat, including its permanent place on the Security Council, with American backing. A group of states led by Albania, supported by many newly independent countries in Africa and Asia, had pressed the change for years. The Taipei delegation walked out before the vote. It came while Henry Kissinger was in Beijing preparing Richard Nixon’s visit.

Seen from elsewhere. Beijing reads the resolution as settling that Taiwan is part of China. Taipei, and more recently the United States, argue that it decided only who held China’s seat and said nothing about Taiwan’s status. Taiwan has been outside the UN system ever since, a question that still shapes access to bodies such as the World Health Organization.

1983

American troops land on Grenada

GrenadaThe Americas

Six days after Grenada’s prime minister, Maurice Bishop, was shot by soldiers loyal to a rival faction of his own New Jewel Movement, United States forces, eventually more than 7,000 of them, landed on the island with a small contingent from neighbouring Caribbean states. Ronald Reagan cited the safety of some 600 American medical students and a request from the Organisation of Eastern Caribbean States. Resistance came from the Grenadian army and from Cuban construction workers and soldiers at the new airport at Point Salines. The island was secured within days. Nineteen Americans, about 45 Grenadians and 25 Cubans were killed.

Seen from elsewhere. The UN General Assembly condemned the invasion as a flagrant violation of international law, and Margaret Thatcher, whose queen was Grenada’s head of state, objected to Washington. Many Grenadians, shocked by Bishop’s killing, welcomed the troops, and 25 October is a public holiday on the island called Thanksgiving Day.

Also on 25 October