Parallax

27 October, AD 312

Constantine’s sign on the eve of the Milvian Bridge

Camped north of Rome before the battle that would make him master of the West, Constantine had his soldiers mark a Christian symbol on their shields. What he actually saw, and when, has been argued over ever since.

Via Flaminia, north of Rome, Italy

In the autumn of 312 Constantine was camped on the Via Flaminia a few miles north of Rome with an army that had marched from Gaul over the Alps. It had been a fast and successful campaign. He had stormed Susa, beaten Maxentius’s heavy cavalry outside Turin, and besieged and taken Verona, where Maxentius’s best general was killed. Now the road ran straight to the capital, defended by the Aurelian walls and by a man who had already watched two emperors fail to take it.

Maxentius had held Rome since 306. His plan was to sit behind the walls, as he had against Severus and Galerius, and he had cut the stone Milvian Bridge over the Tiber to slow any attacker. But Rome was hungry and restless, and according to Lactantius the crowd at the circus jeered that Constantine could not be beaten. Maxentius consulted the Sibylline Books, the city’s ancient oracles, and was told that on the day of battle the enemy of the Romans would perish. He chose to fight in the open. A bridge of boats was thrown across the river and his army crossed to the north bank.

Before the battle, Lactantius writes, Constantine was told in his sleep to mark the heavenly sign of God on his soldiers’ shields. Lactantius describes it as a letter X with its top bent round, which most scholars take to be a Chi-Rho, the first two letters of Christ’s name in Greek, or a cross with a looped top. The soldiers painted it on. This is the earliest account, written within three or four years by a Christian teacher who later tutored Constantine’s eldest son.

The battle was fought on 28 October, the sixth anniversary of Maxentius’s accession. His army stood with the Tiber at its back near Saxa Rubra and the bridge. Constantine’s cavalry broke the enemy horse, and the infantry gave way behind it. The Praetorian Guard, Maxentius’s own creation, largely died where it stood. The rest fled for the bridge of boats, which gave way under the crowd. Maxentius was drowned in the Tiber with many of his men.

His body was pulled from the river and his head cut off and carried on a spear through Rome when Constantine entered the city the next day. The Senate welcomed the victor, renamed the great basilica Maxentius had been building in his honour, and voted him an arch. Constantine disbanded the Praetorians and razed their camp, and before long he was giving the Christian bishop of Rome imperial property at the Lateran.

How it came to this

Diocletian had divided the empire between four rulers in the 290s, two senior Augusti and two junior Caesars. The arrangement did not survive his abdication in 305. In 306 Constantine was proclaimed emperor by his father’s army at York, and a few months later Maxentius, son of the retired emperor Maximian, was proclaimed at Rome by the Praetorians and the city, which resented losing its tax exemptions. By 310 there were, at times, five or six men claiming the purple, and alliances shifted constantly. Constantine had married Maxentius’s sister Fausta, and later forced Maximian, her father, to suicide.

Religion ran through these quarrels. Diocletian and Galerius had launched the Great Persecution of Christians in 303. Constantine’s father had enforced it lightly in the West, and Maxentius ended it in his own territories and restored property to the Roman church. Galerius himself issued an edict of toleration on his deathbed in 311. Constantine had been known for devotion to the sun god, and a pagan orator in 310 described him seeing Apollo in a temple in Gaul. The question in 312 was not whether Christians would be tolerated, but which god the winner would credit.

How each side saw it

Lactantius and Eusebius

The two Christian accounts do not agree. Lactantius, writing On the Deaths of the Persecutors around 314 or 315, describes a dream and a sign painted on shields, and treats the victory as God’s punishment of tyrants. Eusebius of Caesarea, in his Life of Constantine written after the emperor’s death in 337, says Constantine told him on oath, years later, of a cross of light above the sun at midday, seen by the whole army, with words meaning ‘by this, conquer’, followed by a dream in which Christ explained it. Eusebius’s earlier Church History, written soon after the battle, mentions no vision at all.

The pagan Senate

The Senate’s arch, dedicated in 315 and still standing beside the Colosseum, says Constantine won ‘by the prompting of the divinity’ and the greatness of his mind, without naming which divinity. Its reliefs show the battle and the bridge but no Christian symbol. A Latin panegyric delivered at Trier in 313 likewise speaks of a divine power guiding him and of the Tiber swallowing the tyrant, again in terms a pagan could accept. For Rome’s senatorial class the victory was a deliverance from Maxentius, and the god involved was left politely vague.

Maxentius and his memory

Maxentius left no account of himself. Everything we have was written by the winning side, which condemned him as a tyrant, a persecutor and a sexual predator, and had his statues and inscriptions removed or rededicated. Yet he had stopped the persecution of Christians in Italy and Africa, built on a grand scale in Rome, including the basilica on the Forum and a circus on the Appian Way, and was popular with the city at first. Modern historians such as Mats Cullhed have argued that he presented himself as a conservative restorer of Rome, a programme his rival simply took over.

Modern historians

Jacob Burckhardt in 1853 saw Constantine as a political calculator who used the Church. Timothy Barnes argued that he was a sincere Christian from 312 who pursued a consistently Christian policy. Others, among them Raymond Van Dam, show how the story of the vision was shaped and reshaped over decades to suit later needs. The physicist Peter Weiss proposed that the sight described by Eusebius was a solar halo, a natural phenomenon that can form cross-like patterns, and suggested Constantine saw it in Gaul in 310, linking it to the pagan Apollo vision.

What is disputed

The battle itself was fought on 28 October 312: Lactantius ties it to the anniversary of Maxentius’s accession, and the Roman calendar of 354 marks 28 October as the expulsion of the tyrant. The book behind this entry places the battle on the 27th and a fiery cross at noon on the 26th, merging Eusebius’s later story with the battle date. Lactantius does not say which night the dream came. ‘In hoc signo vinces’ is a later Latin rendering of Eusebius’s Greek. Whether the sign was a Chi-Rho or a cross, and how far Constantine’s faith was sincere in 312, remain open.

What followed

Early in 313 Constantine and Licinius, who ruled the East, met at Milan and agreed on full toleration for Christians and the return of their property, the policy known as the Edict of Milan. The two fell out, and Constantine defeated Licinius in 324 to rule the whole empire. He called the Council of Nicaea in 325, founded Constantinople in 330 and was baptised only on his deathbed in 337. The Milvian Bridge became the founding story of a Christian Roman empire, which is why every detail of it has been fought over.

Read further

  • Lactantius, On the Deaths of the Persecutors (c. 315)
  • Eusebius of Caesarea, Life of Constantine
  • Timothy D. Barnes, Constantine and Eusebius (1981)
  • Raymond Van Dam, Remembering Constantine at the Milvian Bridge (2011)
  • Paul Stephenson, Constantine: Unconquered Emperor, Christian Victor (2009)

Same day, other years

1553

Michael Servetus is burned in Geneva

Champel, GenevaEurope

Michael Servetus, a Spanish physician and theologian, had denied the doctrine of the Trinity in print since his twenties. In his book The Restoration of Christianity, published secretly in 1553, he also described the passage of blood through the lungs, the first such account in Europe. Condemned by the Catholic Inquisition at Vienne in France, he escaped, and for reasons still unclear turned up in Calvin’s Geneva, where he was recognised at a sermon and arrested. John Calvin supplied the evidence against him. The city council, after consulting other Swiss Protestant churches, sentenced him to death, and he was burned alive with a copy of his book.

Seen from elsewhere. Calvin asked for a quicker death by beheading and was refused, and most Protestant leaders approved the verdict. The humanist Sebastian Castellio replied that to kill a man is not to defend a doctrine but to kill a man. In 1903 Geneva’s Calvinists raised an expiatory monument on the spot.

1838

Missouri orders the Mormons expelled or exterminated

Missouri, United StatesThe Americas

After months of clashes between Latter-day Saint settlers in north-west Missouri and their neighbours, culminating in a skirmish at Crooked River on 25 October, Governor Lilburn Boggs issued Executive Order 44. It declared that the Mormons must be treated as enemies and must be exterminated or driven from the state if necessary for the public peace. Three days later a militia force attacked the settlement at Haun’s Mill and killed seventeen people, including a boy of ten. Joseph Smith was arrested, and over the winter some 8,000 to 10,000 Latter-day Saints were forced out, most of them to Illinois.

Seen from elsewhere. Missourians feared the newcomers’ bloc voting, their growing numbers and their supposed anti-slavery views, and pointed to raids by the Mormon Danite band. Historians such as Stephen LeSueur find violence on both sides, but the expulsion fell on an entire community. The order was formally rescinded only in 1976.

1958

Ayub Khan takes power in Pakistan

Karachi, PakistanAsia

Earlier that month President Iskander Mirza had abolished Pakistan’s 1956 constitution, dismissed the government and declared martial law, naming the army commander, General Ayub Khan, as its chief administrator. The partnership lasted twenty days. On the night of 27 October three generals called on Mirza and obliged him to resign; he was flown into exile in London. Ayub became president and ruled for over ten years, promoting industrial growth, land reform and a system of indirect elections he called Basic Democracies, until mass protests forced him out in 1969 and he handed power to another general, Yahya Khan.

Seen from elsewhere. Supporters saw an end to a decade of unstable governments and seven prime ministers. Critics date to that night the army’s habit of taking power, and argue that rule from West Pakistan’s officer class deepened the grievances of East Pakistan, which broke away as Bangladesh in 1971.

1971

Congo becomes Zaire

Kinshasa, ZaireAfrica

Joseph-Desire Mobutu, who had seized power in 1965, renamed the Democratic Republic of the Congo as the Republic of Zaire. The river and the currency took the same name. It was part of a campaign he called authenticity, which aimed to strip away colonial culture. Cities had already lost their Belgian names, Leopoldville becoming Kinshasa. Christian first names were soon banned, and Mobutu himself became Mobutu Sese Seko. Western suits gave way to the abacost, a high-collared jacket worn without a tie, whose name came from a French phrase meaning down with the suit.

Seen from elsewhere. Admirers saw a recovery of African dignity. Critics noted that the campaign fed a personality cult around a ruler who, with Western backing during the Cold War, plundered the state. The name Zaire itself came from a Portuguese rendering of a Kikongo word for river. It was dropped in 1997 when Laurent Kabila overthrew Mobutu.

Also on 27 October