Parallax

29 October, 1618

Walter Raleigh goes to the block

Executed on a fifteen-year-old sentence to please the king of Spain, the last great adventurer of Elizabeth’s court turned his own death into a performance that the crowd never forgot.

Old Palace Yard, Westminster, London

Sir Walter Raleigh spent his last night in the Gatehouse prison at Westminster, talking with friends, smoking his pipe and writing. He was in his mid-sixties and still technically a dead man, condemned for treason in 1603 and never pardoned. The day before, he had been brought before the judges of the King’s Bench, told that the old sentence would now be carried out, and refused the chance to speak at length in his defence. He spent part of the night writing a short poem on time and the grave that was later found in his Bible.

On the morning of 29 October he was taken to a scaffold built in Old Palace Yard, between Westminster Hall and the Abbey. It was the day of the Lord Mayor’s show in the City, and the authorities seem to have hoped the crowds would be elsewhere. They were not. Raleigh, feverish and afraid that his shaking might be taken for fear, asked to speak, and the sheriffs let him go on for a long time.

He answered the charges point by point. He denied that he had ever plotted against King James, that he had meant to desert his men or go to France, that he had spoken disloyally, that he had rejoiced at the death of the old earl of Essex years before. He forgave the kinsman, Sir Lewis Stukeley, who had betrayed his attempt to escape. He asked the lords around him to pray with him, and then took off his gown.

He asked to see the axe. Running his finger along it, he made a remark that witnesses recorded in slightly different forms, calling it a sharp medicine but a cure for all diseases. Asked which way he wished to lie, he is reported to have said that it mattered little which way the head lay so long as the heart was right. When the executioner hesitated, he told him to strike. It took two blows.

His head was shown on both sides of the scaffold and then given to his widow, Elizabeth, who had it embalmed and is said to have kept it with her for the rest of her life. His body was buried in St Margaret’s church beside the Abbey. A man in the crowd is said to have remarked that England had not had such another head to cut off, and the government soon found it had to publish a pamphlet explaining why it had been cut off at all.

How it came to this

Raleigh was a younger son of Devon gentry who rose by war, wit and the favour of Elizabeth I. He fought in Ireland, where he took part in the killing of the surrendered garrison at Smerwick in 1580, and was rewarded with vast estates in Munster. He sponsored the Roanoke colonies, wrote fine verse and sailed to Guiana in 1595 in search of El Dorado. His secret marriage to one of the queen’s maids of honour, Elizabeth Throckmorton, cost him her favour for years. Many at court, including the powerful Robert Cecil, distrusted him.

When James VI of Scotland became king of England in 1603, Raleigh was accused of involvement in the Main Plot to replace James with his cousin Arabella Stuart, with Spanish help. Convicted at Winchester on the written testimony of Lord Cobham, whom he was never allowed to face, he spent thirteen years in the Tower, where he wrote his History of the World. In 1616 he was let out to lead an expedition to find a gold mine on the Orinoco, on the strict condition that he did not attack Spanish subjects. It was a condition he could hardly keep.

How each side saw it

King James and his government

James was negotiating to marry his son Charles to a Spanish princess and wanted peace with Spain above almost anything. The Spanish ambassador, Count Gondomar, demanded Raleigh’s punishment after his men attacked the Spanish settlement of Santo Tome on the Orinoco. Within weeks of the execution the government published a Declaration of the Demeanour and Carriage of Sir Walter Raleigh, setting out that he had broken his promises, invented the mine as a pretext for piracy and planned to flee to France. In James’s view he was a convicted traitor who had been given a second chance and wasted it.

Spain

To Spain Raleigh was a pirate who had raided Cadiz in 1596 and whose Guiana voyages were an invasion of Spanish territory. In January 1618 his men, led by his deputy Lawrence Keymis and including his son Wat, attacked Santo Tome de Guayana and burned it; the Spanish governor was killed, and so was Wat Raleigh. Spanish reports to Madrid treated the raid as proof that English promises meant nothing. Gondomar’s insistence on the old sentence was, from Spain’s side, a matter of a treaty being honoured.

Ireland and Guiana

In Irish memory Raleigh is less a romantic adventurer than a soldier at Smerwick and one of the largest beneficiaries of the confiscation of Munster after the Desmond rebellion. In Guiana he presented himself to the local peoples as an enemy of Spain and made alliances with leaders such as the elderly chief he called Topiawari. Their side of these meetings survives only in Raleigh’s own Discovery of Guiana and in Spanish reports, each written for its own purpose.

The public and Parliament

The execution made Raleigh a martyr to the anti-Spanish feeling that ran deep in Protestant England. Accounts of his speech circulated widely in manuscript. Under Charles I, his History of the World, which James had suppressed in 1614 for being too free in judging princes, became a favourite of the king’s critics. Oliver Cromwell recommended it to his son. Raleigh came to stand for an England of sea power and liberty betrayed by a pro-Spanish court, a reading that suited the parliamentarians.

What is disputed

Raleigh’s birth year is given as 1552 or 1554, so his age at death is uncertain. The story of the window pane, on which he scratched a line about fearing to fall and the queen wrote a reply, first appears in Thomas Fuller’s Worthies decades after both were dead and is probably invented. His scaffold remarks survive in several versions. Whether the Orinoco mine existed, whether he meant to attack the Spanish, and whether James had agreed beforehand to sacrifice him if the voyage failed are all argued. His guilt in the Main Plot of 1603 is doubted by most historians.

What followed

The Spanish match that the execution was meant to protect collapsed in 1623, when Charles and Buckingham returned from Madrid without a bride, to bonfires in London. Raleigh’s son Carew spent years trying to recover his father’s estates. The History of the World went through many editions. The search for El Dorado in Guiana went on without him, and the city of Raleigh in North Carolina was named after him in 1792, though he never set foot in North America.

Read further

  • Mark Nicholls and Penry Williams, Sir Walter Raleigh: In Life and Legend (2011)
  • Raleigh Trevelyan, Sir Walter Raleigh (2002)
  • Anna Beer, Patriot or Traitor: The Life and Death of Sir Walter Ralegh (2018)
  • Walter Raleigh, The Discovery of the Large, Rich and Beautiful Empire of Guiana (1596)

Same day, other years

1923

Turkey is declared a republic

Ankara, TurkeyMiddle East

Two weeks after making Ankara its capital, the Grand National Assembly declared Turkey a republic and elected Mustafa Kemal, the commander who had led the war against the Greek army and the Allied occupation, as its first president. The Ottoman sultanate had been abolished a year earlier, and the Treaty of Lausanne in July had won international recognition for the new state’s borders. In March 1924 the caliphate went too, and over the next decade Kemal’s government replaced Islamic law with European codes, the Arabic script with the Latin alphabet, and the fez with the hat.

Seen from elsewhere. Kemalists celebrate the republic as national rebirth. Kurds, whose revolt in 1925 was crushed, and the Greek and Armenian communities reduced by war and the 1923 population exchange saw a state built on one identity. Religious conservatives regarded the abolition of the caliphate as a loss that the republic’s politics still argue over.

1929

Black Tuesday on Wall Street

New York, United StatesThe Americas

After a fall on Thursday the 24th that bankers had briefly checked by buying, and a heavy drop on Monday the 28th, the New York Stock Exchange suffered its worst day yet. More than 16 million shares changed hands, a record that stood for decades, and the Dow Jones average fell about 12 per cent. Ticker machines ran hours behind, so investors did not know what they had lost. Over the following three years stock prices fell by close to nine-tenths from their 1929 peak, and the United States slid into the Great Depression along with much of the world.

Seen from elsewhere. How far the crash caused the Depression is disputed. John Kenneth Galbraith blamed a speculative mania. Milton Friedman and Anna Schwartz argued that the Federal Reserve turned a downturn into catastrophe by letting the money supply collapse, and Ben Bernanke stressed bank failures. Many economists now see the crash as a symptom as much as a cause.

1956

The Kafr Qasim massacre

Kafr Qasim, IsraelMiddle East

On the first day of the Suez war Israeli Border Police imposed a curfew on Arab villages near the Jordanian border, starting at five in the afternoon. The villagers of Kafr Qasim, many at work in the fields, were not told in time. As they came home by foot, bicycle and truck, a platoon shot them down in groups at the village entrance. Forty-eight or forty-nine people were killed, depending on whether an unborn child is counted, among them women and children. The government at first censored the news. In 1958 an Israeli military court convicted eight officers and men.

Seen from elsewhere. The judgment, holding that a soldier must refuse an order over which a black flag of manifest illegality flies, became a landmark of Israeli military law. But the sentences were cut and all were free by 1960; the brigade commander was fined a token one prutah, the smallest coin. Some historians link the killings to a secret plan to expel the region’s Arabs, which others dispute.

1969

The first message crosses the ARPANET

Los Angeles and Menlo Park, CaliforniaThe Americas

At about half past ten at night a student programmer at the University of California, Los Angeles, Charley Kline, tried to log in to a computer at the Stanford Research Institute some 350 miles away over a new network funded by the Pentagon’s Advanced Research Projects Agency. He typed L and O, confirmed by telephone with Bill Duvall at the other end, and then the remote system crashed. The full login worked about an hour later. The network linked four sites by December and was the direct ancestor of the internet.

Seen from elsewhere. Whether this is the internet’s birthday depends on definitions: the protocols that define the internet came in 1983, and packet switching had been conceived independently by Paul Baran in the United States and Donald Davies in Britain, whose own network ran at the National Physical Laboratory. Military funding and academic culture both claim the inheritance.

Also on 29 October