Parallax

26 October, 1759

Danton, the voice of 1792, is born

A scarred, enormous country lawyer from Champagne became the loudest voice of the French Revolution, helped build its machinery of terror, and was fed to it at thirty-four.

Arcis-sur-Aube, Champagne, France

Georges-Jacques Danton was born on 26 October 1759 in Arcis-sur-Aube, a small market town in Champagne, the son of a minor lawyer who died before the boy was three. As a child he was gored in the face by a bull and later caught smallpox, and he grew up huge, broad and pockmarked, with a voice to match. He was schooled by the Oratorian fathers at Troyes, went to Paris, qualified in law and in 1787 bought, on borrowed money, a post as an advocate before the king’s councils. That year he married Gabrielle Charpentier, the daughter of a cafe owner.

The Revolution made him. In 1789 he became the dominant figure in the Cordeliers district on the Left Bank, home to printers, lawyers and journalists, and later in the club of the same name. He was no great writer and left few papers; his power was in speech, delivered without notes to crowds and assemblies. When the monarchy fell in the insurrection of 10 August 1792, the new government made him Minister of Justice.

Within weeks Prussian armies were advancing on Paris. On 2 September Danton told the Legislative Assembly that what was needed to beat the enemy was audacity, more audacity, always audacity, and the line was printed across France. On the same days crowds broke into the Paris prisons and killed some 1,100 to 1,400 inmates, most of them common criminals, priests and ordinary prisoners rather than conspirators. Danton, the minister responsible for justice, did nothing effective to stop it.

Elected to the National Convention, he voted for the death of Louis XVI in January 1793. In March, with the war going badly, he pressed for an extraordinary criminal court, saying that the state must be terrible so that the people would not need to be; it became the Revolutionary Tribunal. He sat on the first Committee of Public Safety from April to July 1793 and was then left off it. His wife had died in February while he was on mission in Belgium; in June he married a sixteen-year-old, Louise Gely, and that autumn withdrew to Arcis.

He came back to find the Terror at full stretch. Through the winter he and his old friend Camille Desmoulins argued for relaxing it, Desmoulins in his paper Le Vieux Cordelier. To Robespierre and Saint-Just the Indulgents, as they were called, were now a faction. Danton was arrested on the night of 30 to 31 March 1794 and tried alongside men accused of financial fraud. His voice carried out of the courtroom to the crowds on the quay, so the Convention passed a decree allowing the court to silence defendants who resisted it. On 5 April he went to the guillotine. He is reported to have told the executioner to show his head to the people, since it was worth seeing.

How it came to this

Danton’s France was a kingdom that could not pay its debts. By 1788 interest on royal borrowing, much of it run up in the American war, swallowed about half of state revenue, and attempts to tax the privileged had failed. The calling of the Estates-General in 1789 opened politics to men like him: provincial lawyers, educated, ambitious and shut out of the old routes to power. Paris was divided into sections and districts with their own assemblies, and a man who could hold a hall could become a force.

By 1792 the Revolution was at war with Austria and Prussia, and the king was suspected, correctly, of hoping for their victory. The fall of the monarchy and the September killings split the revolutionaries. The Girondins blamed the Paris radicals and Danton among them; the Montagnards, Danton’s allies, purged the Girondins in June 1793. From then on the Committee of Public Safety ruled by emergency, and any group that questioned it, from the left or from the right, risked being named as a conspiracy.

How each side saw it

Robespierre and Saint-Just

The case against Danton was made in Saint-Just’s report to the Convention of 31 March 1794, drafted from notes supplied by Robespierre. It accused him of secret royalism, of dealings with Mirabeau and the court, of shielding the traitor general Dumouriez, of idleness at moments of crisis and of living well off the Revolution. To them, a call for clemency while the Republic was invaded and in civil war was itself a counter-revolutionary act. Robespierre told the Convention that the day would show whether it could break an idol long rotten.

Madame Roland and the Girondins

Manon Roland, whose husband was interior minister in 1792, wrote her memoirs in prison before her own execution in November 1793. Her Danton is coarse, venal and frightening, a man she held responsible for allowing, perhaps encouraging, the September massacres, and for turning the Paris crowd against her friends. The Girondin deputies broadly shared this view. Their account weighed heavily on nineteenth century liberal writers, who were drawn to Danton’s patriotism but could not forget September.

Historians of the Third Republic

The argument over Danton became a quarrel between two great French historians. Alphonse Aulard, who held the first chair of Revolutionary history at the Sorbonne, saw him as the patriot of 1792, a realist who rallied the nation and then tried to end the bloodshed. His pupil turned rival, Albert Mathiez, an admirer of Robespierre, spent years in the archives building the case that Danton took money from the court and from foreign interests. The Third Republic sided with Aulard and put up Danton’s statue in Paris in 1891.

Poland in 1983

Andrzej Wajda’s film Danton, made in France with a Polish cast as the Robespierrists and Gerard Depardieu in the title role, was released while martial law was still in force in Poland. Many viewers read it as an allegory of Solidarity facing a party that claimed to embody the people, though Wajda resisted a simple reading. In France some on the left disliked its picture of revolutionary justice as show trial. A man dead two centuries was still being used to argue about the present.

What is disputed

Whether Danton was corrupt is the oldest question. Lafayette and the royal minister Bertrand de Moleville claimed he was paid by the court, and Mathiez found further suggestive evidence, but there is no receipt, and his defenders note how much of the case comes from enemies. His exact responsibility for the September massacres is argued from silence. His last words survive in several versions. The book behind this entry has him born in Arras, which is Robespierre’s birthplace, calls him head of the Committee of Public Safety, which he never was, and gives him scaffold words that are not in the usual record.

What followed

Robespierre followed him to the guillotine less than four months later, after the coup of 9 Thermidor in July 1794, and the Terror ended. Danton’s reputation outlived the man’s. Georg Buchner’s play Danton’s Death, written in 1835, made him the tired sceptic among believers. Under the Third Republic he became the patriotic face of the Revolution, the man of national defence rather than of the guillotine, and his statue still stands at the Carrefour de l’Odeon on the Left Bank, close to where he lived.

Read further

  • Norman Hampson, Danton (1978)
  • David Lawday, The Giant of the French Revolution: Danton, a Life (2009)
  • Ruth Scurr, Fatal Purity: Robespierre and the French Revolution (2006)
  • Georg Buchner, Danton’s Death (1835)
  • Madame Roland, Memoirs (1795)

Same day, other years

1909

An Jung-geun shoots Ito Hirobumi at Harbin

Harbin, ManchuriaAsia

Ito Hirobumi had been prime minister of Japan four times, the chief author of its 1889 constitution and, from 1906 to 1909, the first Resident-General of Korea after Japan forced a protectorate on it. He arrived at Harbin station, in the Russian-run railway zone of Manchuria, for talks with the Russian finance minister. As he walked along the platform a Korean independence fighter, An Jung-geun, stepped out of the crowd and shot him three times. An made no attempt to escape. He was tried by a Japanese court at Port Arthur and hanged in March 1910. Japan annexed Korea that August.

Seen from elsewhere. In both Koreas An is a national hero, and China opened a memorial hall to him at Harbin station in 2014. Japanese officials have called him a terrorist. Some historians argue that Ito, though he built the protectorate, had been cautious about outright annexation, so his killing removed a brake rather than an engine.

1947

The maharaja of Kashmir signs over to India

Jammu and KashmirAsia

Two months after partition, Hari Singh, the Hindu ruler of a Muslim-majority princely state, had still not chosen between India and Pakistan. On 22 October armed Pashtun tribesmen, with support from Pakistani officials, crossed into Kashmir and advanced towards Srinagar, killing and looting on the way, notably at Baramulla. The maharaja fled to Jammu and appealed to India, which would only send troops if he acceded. India’s account is that he signed the Instrument of Accession on 26 October. The governor-general, Lord Mountbatten, accepted it the next day on condition that the people’s wishes be sought once order returned, and Indian troops were flown into Srinagar.

Seen from elsewhere. Pakistan regards the accession as obtained under duress and never valid. The historian Alastair Lamb argued that it was signed only after Indian troops had landed, a claim Indian scholars dispute. The promised reference to the people never took place, and Kashmiris themselves were split, many backing Sheikh Abdullah’s pro-India National Conference.

1977

The last natural case of smallpox

Merca, SomaliaAfrica

Ali Maow Maalin, a 23-year-old hospital cook in the port town of Merca, developed the rash of smallpox after briefly riding in a vehicle with two infected patients. He had never been vaccinated. Health workers isolated him, traced his contacts and vaccinated more than 50,000 people in the district in two weeks. He recovered. No one has caught smallpox naturally since. The disease had killed perhaps 300 million people in the twentieth century alone, and the World Health Assembly declared it eradicated in May 1980. Maalin later worked as a vaccinator in Somalia’s campaign against polio and died of malaria in 2013.

Seen from elsewhere. The last death came later: in 1978 Janet Parker, a medical photographer in Birmingham, caught the virus from a university laboratory and died. Whether the stocks still kept in Atlanta and in Russia should be destroyed has been argued at the WHO for decades without a decision.

2002

Gas ends the Moscow theatre siege

Moscow, RussiaEurope

On 23 October around forty Chechen fighters led by Movsar Barayev seized a Moscow theatre during a performance of the musical Nord-Ost and held some 850 people hostage, demanding the withdrawal of Russian forces from Chechnya. Before dawn on the 26th Russian special forces pumped an aerosol of an opiate-based agent into the building and stormed it. All the hostage-takers were killed, many while unconscious. At least 130 hostages died, almost all from the effects of the gas, made worse by a lack of antidotes and ambulances. The authorities never fully disclosed what the agent was.

Seen from elsewhere. The government said the operation saved hundreds who would otherwise have died in explosions. In 2011 the European Court of Human Rights, in a case brought by survivors and relatives, found that Russia had violated the right to life through poor planning of the rescue. Chechen separatists presented the seizure as a protest against the war.

Also on 26 October