Parallax

19 October, 1781

A British army lays down its arms at Yorktown

Cornwallis pleaded illness and sent his deputy. The deputy tried to hand the sword to a Frenchman. The last great act of the American war was a quarrel about etiquette, conducted in front of sixteen thousand men.

Yorktown, Virginia

At about two in the afternoon on 19 October 1781 the British garrison of Yorktown marched out along the Hampton road between two lines of troops that stretched for more than a mile. On one side stood the French, in white uniforms faced with regimental colours. On the other stood the Americans: the Continental regulars in front, in what uniforms they had, and the Virginia militia behind them in hunting shirts.

The terms had been settled the day before in a farmhouse belonging to a man named Moore, and they were deliberately harsh on one point. When the Americans surrendered Charleston in 1780 the British had refused them the customary honours of war. Washington now refused the same to Cornwallis. The British were to come out with their colours cased, not flying, and their bands were to play a British or German march, not a tune of the victors as a compliment between equals.

Lord Cornwallis did not appear. He sent word that he was unwell, and his second in command, Brigadier Charles O’Hara of the Guards, rode at the head of the column. O’Hara made for the Comte de Rochambeau, the French commander, and offered his sword. Rochambeau indicated Washington across the road. Washington, seeing that he was being asked to receive a deputy, pointed in turn to his own second, Benjamin Lincoln, the general who had been humiliated at Charleston. Lincoln took the sword, held it a moment, and gave it back.

The regiments then filed into a field ringed by French hussars and grounded their muskets. American and French witnesses noted that many of the British seemed drunk or sullen and threw their weapons down hard, as if to break them, until Lincoln stopped it. The German regiments from Ansbach and Hesse marched with more composure. About seven thousand soldiers and several hundred seamen became prisoners.

It had taken three weeks. Cornwallis had fortified Yorktown, a tobacco port on a bluff above the York River, in August, expecting the Royal Navy to supply him or take him off. Instead a French fleet under Admiral de Grasse arrived from the Caribbean and on 5 September fought the British squadron off the Chesapeake capes and kept the bay. Washington and Rochambeau marched their armies some four hundred and fifty miles from the Hudson. Siege guns opened on 9 October. On the night of the 14th, French grenadiers and an American column led by Alexander Hamilton stormed the two outlying redoubts with the bayonet. An attempt to ferry the garrison across the river was wrecked by a squall. On the morning of the 17th a drummer climbed onto the British parapet and beat for a parley.

How it came to this

By 1781 the war in America was six years old and neither side could see how to end it. The British held New York and had shifted their effort to the southern colonies, where they expected loyalists to rally. They took Savannah and Charleston and won at Camden, but could not hold the countryside. Cornwallis chased Nathanael Greene’s army across the Carolinas, won a costly battle at Guilford Courthouse in March 1781, and then marched into Virginia on his own initiative, to the irritation of his superior in New York, Sir Henry Clinton. The two generals blamed each other for what followed for the rest of their lives.

The American cause was in poor condition too. The currency was worthless, parts of the Continental Army had mutinied over pay that winter, and Washington’s own preference was for an attack on New York. What changed the position was France, an ally since 1778. Rochambeau’s corps had been at Newport for a year, and in the summer of 1781 de Grasse sent word that he would bring his whole fleet north, to the Chesapeake, until mid-October.

How each side saw it

The British command

Cornwallis wrote to Clinton the day after the surrender that he had been promised relief and that the post had been untenable without it. Clinton replied, at pamphlet length, that he had never ordered him to Yorktown. A fleet carrying seven thousand reinforcements sailed from New York on the very day of the capitulation and arrived five days late. In London Lord North is reported by the memoirist Nathaniel Wraxall, at second hand, to have taken the news like a ball in the breast and cried out that it was all over. George III wanted to fight on. Parliament did not.

The French

Counting the sailors of de Grasse’s fleet, considerably more Frenchmen than Americans took part in the campaign. The siege artillery, the engineers who laid out the trenches and the money that paid the Continental troops on the march south were French as well. Rochambeau’s memoirs treat Yorktown as a formal siege conducted by professionals, with the Americans as willing pupils. French officers were courteous to the defeated British, dined with them and lent Cornwallis money, which the Americans noticed and resented. The war left the French crown with debts that weighed on it through the decade before 1789.

Black Virginians

Several thousand enslaved people had fled to Cornwallis’s army, drawn by British offers of freedom to those who left rebel masters. They dug the fortifications at Yorktown. Smallpox spread among them, and when food ran short the British drove many out of the lines to die between the armies; a Hessian officer, Johann Ewald, wrote of his shame at it. After the surrender, slaveholders, Washington among them, came to the camp to reclaim people they owned. On the allied side Black soldiers served in the ranks, notably in the Rhode Island Regiment.

Loyalists and German soldiers

Cornwallis asked that Americans who had joined the British should not be punished. Washington refused, saying it was a matter for the civil authorities, but allowed one sloop, the Bonetta, to sail for New York unsearched. It carried as many loyalists and deserters as could be packed aboard. The German troops, hired out by their princes, left diaries of their own: Johann Conrad Dohla of the Ansbach-Bayreuth contingent recorded the bombardment and the long march into captivity in Maryland and Virginia. A good number of the Germans never went home.

What is disputed

The best-known detail of the day, that the British bands played a tune called ‘The World Turned Upside Down’, does not appear in any account written at the time. It was first printed in 1828 by Alexander Garden, on the word of an officer who had been present, and no single tune of that name can be securely identified; most historians now treat it as unproven tradition. The number of prisoners is given variously between about 7,000 and 8,000 depending on whether seamen and the sick are counted. Whether Cornwallis was truly ill is not known. Whether the disaster was his fault, Clinton’s, or the navy’s has been argued since 1782.

What followed

Yorktown did not end the war by itself: the British still held New York, Charleston and Savannah with some thirty thousand men, and fighting went on at sea and in the south. But in February 1782 the House of Commons voted against further offensive war in America, and North’s ministry fell in March. Peace was signed in Paris on 3 September 1783. Thousands of loyalists and formerly enslaved people who had sided with Britain left for Nova Scotia, the Caribbean and England. Cornwallis’s career survived; he went on to govern India and Ireland.

Read further

  • Jerome A. Greene, The Guns of Independence: The Siege of Yorktown, 1781 (2005)
  • Richard M. Ketchum, Victory at Yorktown: The Campaign That Won the Revolution (2004)
  • Andrew Jackson O’Shaughnessy, The Men Who Lost America (2013)
  • Johann Conrad Dohla, A Hessian Diary of the American Revolution, translated by Bruce E. Burgoyne (1990)
  • Cassandra Pybus, Epic Journeys of Freedom: Runaway Slaves of the American Revolution and Their Global Quest for Liberty (2006)

Same day, other years

AD 439

The Vandals seize Carthage

Carthage, Roman AfricaAfrica

Carthage was the second city of the western Roman empire and the port through which the grain and oil of Africa reached Italy. The Vandals under King Gaiseric had crossed from Spain ten years earlier, and a treaty of 435 had settled them further west as nominal allies of Rome. On 19 October 439 Gaiseric broke the treaty and took the city by surprise, apparently without a siege; later tradition says the inhabitants were at the games. The western government lost its richest province and most of its tax revenue at a stroke. From Carthage the Vandals built a fleet, took Sicily, Sardinia and Corsica, and in 455 sacked Rome. Their kingdom lasted until 534.

Seen from elsewhere. Nearly everything written about the Vandals comes from their enemies, above all the Catholic bishop Victor of Vita, who recorded the persecution of his church by Arian Christian kings. The word ‘vandalism’ was coined in 1794. Archaeology shows Roman baths, schools and Latin poetry continuing in Carthage under their rule.

1950

The Tibetan garrison at Chamdo surrenders

Chamdo, eastern TibetAsia

On 7 October 1950 some forty thousand troops of the Chinese People’s Liberation Army crossed the upper Yangtze into territory governed from Lhasa. The Tibetan army numbered a few thousand, with old rifles and a handful of mountain guns. Its commander in the east, the governor Ngabo Ngawang Jigme, abandoned the town of Chamdo, was cut off, and surrendered on 19 October. The Chinese released most of their prisoners with gifts of money and lectures on socialism, and halted. In May 1951 a delegation led by Ngabo signed a Seventeen Point Agreement in Beijing that acknowledged Chinese sovereignty and promised to leave Tibet’s political system and the position of the Dalai Lama unchanged.

Seen from elsewhere. Beijing describes these events as the peaceful liberation of a part of China from imperialist influence and feudal serfdom. The Tibetan government in exile calls them the invasion of an independent country and says the agreement was signed under threat, with seals made in Beijing. The Dalai Lama repudiated it after fleeing to India in 1959.

1986

Samora Machel dies in a plane crash

Mbuzini, South AfricaAfrica

Samora Machel had led the guerrilla movement Frelimo against Portuguese rule and had been president of Mozambique since independence in 1975. On the night of 19 October 1986 he was flying home from a summit in Zambia in a Soviet-built Tupolev with a Soviet crew. Short of Maputo the aircraft turned away from its course and flew into a hillside at Mbuzini, a few hundred metres inside South Africa. Machel and thirty-three others were killed; ten people survived. Mozambique was then fighting the Renamo insurgency, which South Africa armed, and Pretoria had threatened Machel only days before. His widow, Graca Machel, later married Nelson Mandela.

Seen from elsewhere. A South African commission under Judge Cecil Margo blamed errors by the flight crew. The Soviet investigators said the aircraft had been drawn off course by a false radio beacon. South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission heard evidence in 1998 and could reach no conclusion. Most Mozambicans have never accepted that it was an accident.

1987

Black Monday on the world’s stock markets

New York and other financial centresWorldwide

Selling began in Hong Kong and moved west with the sun. When New York opened on Monday 19 October 1987 there were at first almost no buyers; by the close the Dow Jones Industrial Average had fallen 508 points, or 22.6 per cent, still the largest one-day percentage fall in its history. Hong Kong shut its exchange for the rest of the week. London, which had been closed by a hurricane the previous Friday, lost more than a fifth in two days. The next morning the chairman of the Federal Reserve, Alan Greenspan, issued a one-sentence statement that the Fed stood ready to provide liquidity. The American economy did not go into recession. New Zealand’s market took years to recover.

Seen from elsewhere. No agreed cause has been found. The official Brady report blamed computer-driven ‘portfolio insurance’ that sold automatically into falling prices; others point to a rising trade deficit, a quarrel over the dollar and plain panic. Critics argue that the Fed’s rescue taught investors to expect one every time.

Also on 19 October