Parallax

21 October, 1805

Trafalgar

In five hours off the Spanish coast a British fleet took or destroyed eighteen enemy ships without losing one of its own, and lost the admiral who had planned it.

Off Cape Trafalgar, Spain

At daybreak on 21 October 1805 the lookouts of the British fleet saw the sails of thirty-three French and Spanish ships of the line strung along the horizon to the east, some twenty miles off Cape Trafalgar. The wind was light and from the west, with a long swell that old hands knew meant a gale coming. Vice-Admiral Lord Nelson had twenty-seven ships. He formed them into two columns and pointed them at right angles to the enemy line, and for the next six hours the two fleets closed at the pace of a man walking.

It was a dangerous way to attack. Ships of that age carried their guns along their sides, so the leading British vessels would be under fire for the better part of an hour without being able to reply. Nelson accepted that in exchange for what would follow: once through the line, his ships could fire down the length of the enemy’s decks, cut off the rear and centre, and overwhelm them before the van could turn back. He had explained it to his captains three weeks earlier. He went below to write a prayer in his diary and a codicil to his will asking the nation to provide for Emma Hamilton and their daughter.

Shortly before noon he had a signal hoisted to the fleet. He had asked for ‘England confides that every man will do his duty’; the signal lieutenant, John Pasco, suggested ‘expects’, which was in the code book and needed fewer flags. Vice-Admiral Collingwood, leading the other column in Royal Sovereign, is reported to have grumbled that he wished Nelson would stop signalling, since they all knew what to do. Collingwood broke the line first, at about midday.

Victory passed under the stern of the French flagship Bucentaure and fired a broadside through her cabin windows that is thought to have put several hundred men out of action. She then ran aboard the Redoutable, whose captain, Jean-Jacques Lucas, had trained his crew in musketry and boarding. At about a quarter past one a ball fired from the Redoutable’s mizzen-top struck Nelson in the left shoulder and lodged in his spine. He was carried below with a handkerchief over his face so that the men would not know.

He lived for three hours in the cockpit, long enough to be told that fourteen or fifteen of the enemy had struck. The surgeon William Beatty recorded that he asked Captain Hardy to kiss him, and that his last coherent words were that he thanked God he had done his duty. By five the fighting was over. Seventeen prizes were in British hands and one French ship, the Achille, had blown up. The storm arrived that night and blew for most of a week.

How it came to this

Britain and Napoleonic France had been at war again since May 1803. Napoleon assembled an army of well over a hundred thousand men on the Channel coast around Boulogne, with two thousand landing craft, and needed only a few days’ control of the Channel to get them across. His plan for 1805 was that the French and Spanish squadrons should escape the British blockades, draw the Royal Navy to the West Indies, then double back and unite. Admiral Pierre de Villeneuve got out of Toulon, reached Martinique with Nelson in pursuit, and returned, but after an indecisive action off Finisterre in July he put into Cadiz instead of sailing for Brest.

By then the plan was dead. At the end of August Napoleon broke up the camp at Boulogne and marched east against Austria. Villeneuve was ordered to take the fleet into the Mediterranean. He learned that an admiral was on the road to replace him, and on 19 October he began to leave harbour, against the advice of his Spanish colleagues, who thought their ill-manned ships should stay where they were.

How each side saw it

The Spanish

Spain supplied fifteen of the thirty-three ships, including the four-decked Santisima Trinidad, the largest warship afloat. Her officers were experienced but her crews had been filled out with soldiers and men swept from the streets of Cadiz after an epidemic. At a council of war on 8 October the Spanish commanders, Federico Gravina among them, argued against sailing. Gravina was mortally wounded; Cosme de Churruca of the San Juan Nepomuceno died on his quarterdeck. Spanish tradition, shaped by Benito Perez Galdos’s novel Trafalgar, remembers a brave fleet sacrificed to a foreign ally’s orders and a French admiral’s pride.

The French

Villeneuve had fought at the Nile and had no illusions. In his final instructions he told his captains almost exactly what Nelson would do, and admitted that he had no way to prevent it except that any captain not under fire was not at his post. Most of the van under Rear-Admiral Dumanoir did not turn back in time, for which Dumanoir was later court-martialled and acquitted. Captain Lucas’s report on the Redoutable, which lost over five hundred of her 643 men, is the fullest French account. Napoleon’s newspapers barely mentioned the battle. Villeneuve was found stabbed to death at an inn in Rennes in April 1806; it was ruled a suicide.

The lower deck

Victory’s muster book lists some 820 men from the British Isles and more than twenty other countries, Americans, Italians, Africans, West Indians and a few Frenchmen among them. Perhaps half the seamen in the fleet had been pressed. Their accounts are scarce but exist: letters home, and memoirs such as that published under the name ‘Jack Nastyface’ by William Robinson of the Revenge, who described the surgeon’s cockpit, the throwing of the dead overboard, and his contempt for flogging officers. A small number of women were aboard some ships. After the battle British crews risked their lives in the gale to take Spanish and French wounded off sinking prizes.

What is disputed

The old claim that Trafalgar saved Britain from invasion does not survive the dates: Napoleon had marched away from the Channel two months earlier and on the day before the battle accepted the surrender of an Austrian army at Ulm. N. A. M. Rodger and others see its importance as longer-term, removing any prospect of a rival fleet for a generation. Nelson’s request to Hardy is well attested by three men who were present, and the suggestion that he said ‘Kismet’ is a later invention. His tactics are argued over by naval historians, some of whom think the head-on approach succeeded only because enemy gunnery was poor.

What followed

The gale wrecked or sank most of the prizes; four reached Gibraltar. About 450 British and some 4,400 French and Spanish seamen had been killed, and many more of the latter drowned in the storm. Nelson’s body was brought home in a cask of spirits and buried in St Paul’s Cathedral in January 1806. Napoleon won at Austerlitz six weeks after Trafalgar and dominated the Continent for seven more years, but he never again challenged Britain at sea, turning instead to the trade blockade that drew him into Spain and Russia.

Read further

  • Roy Adkins, Trafalgar: The Biography of a Battle (2004)
  • N. A. M. Rodger, The Command of the Ocean: A Naval History of Britain, 1649-1815 (2004)
  • William Beatty, Authentic Narrative of the Death of Lord Nelson (1807)
  • Roger Knight, The Pursuit of Victory: The Life and Achievement of Horatio Nelson (2005)
  • Benito Perez Galdos, Trafalgar (1873)

Same day, other years

1600

Sekigahara

Sekigahara, Mino province, JapanAsia

The death of the warlord Toyotomi Hideyoshi in 1598 left Japan to a five-year-old heir and a council of regents. The strongest of them, Tokugawa Ieyasu, was soon opposed by a coalition organised by the administrator Ishida Mitsunari in the child’s name. The two armies, well over 150,000 men between them, met on 21 October 1600 in a fog-filled valley on the road between Kyoto and the east. Several western contingents never moved. In the early afternoon Kobayakawa Hideaki, posted on a hill above the western flank, changed sides and charged downhill into his own allies, and the line collapsed. Ishida was caught and beheaded in Kyoto. Ieyasu was named shogun in 1603, and his family ruled until 1868.

Seen from elsewhere. The story was written by the winners: Edo-period war tales made Ishida a schemer, though he claimed to be defending Hideyoshi’s heir. Some recent Japanese historians doubt the famous detail that Ieyasu fired on Kobayakawa to force his hand. The defeated domains of Choshu and Satsuma kept their grievance and led the overthrow of the shogunate.

1867

The Medicine Lodge treaty

Medicine Lodge Creek, KansasThe Americas

Railways and settlers were pushing across the southern plains, and a peace commission sent by Congress met some five thousand Kiowa, Comanche, Plains Apache, Cheyenne and Arapaho at a traditional gathering place in Kansas. On 21 October 1867 the Kiowa and Comanche leaders put their marks to a treaty under which they would move to a reservation in what is now south-western Oklahoma, receive annual goods, schools and farming tools, and keep the right to hunt buffalo to the south of the Arkansas River. The Kiowa chief Satanta told the commissioners that he did not want to settle; he loved to roam the prairie, and when his people settled down they grew pale and died.

Seen from elsewhere. Many bands were absent, the terms passed through several interpreters, and it is doubtful the signers understood them as a surrender of land. Rations arrived late and hide hunters destroyed the buffalo within a decade. In 1903 the Supreme Court ruled against the Kiowa leader Lone Wolf that Congress could break the treaty at will.

1966

The Aberfan disaster

Aberfan, South WalesEurope

Above the mining village of Aberfan the National Coal Board had for years tipped colliery waste onto a hillside, and the seventh tip had been started over a known spring. At about a quarter past nine on the morning of 21 October 1966, after days of rain, it liquefied and slid down the mountain. The black slurry buried a farm, a row of houses and Pantglas Junior School, where lessons had just begun on the last day before half-term. Miners came up from the pit to dig with their hands. No one was brought out alive after eleven o’clock. The dead numbered 144, of whom 116 were children, most between seven and ten.

Seen from elsewhere. The Coal Board’s chairman, Lord Robens, at first said the spring could not have been known. A tribunal found that it was on maps, that warnings had been ignored, and that the Board was wholly to blame. Nobody was dismissed or prosecuted, and money was taken from the public disaster fund to clear the remaining tips. It was repaid in 1997.

1969

The army takes power in Somalia

Mogadishu, SomaliaAfrica

Six days after President Abdirashid Ali Shermarke was shot dead by one of his own bodyguards, and hours after his funeral, army units occupied the key points of Mogadishu before dawn on 21 October 1969. There was no resistance. Ministers were arrested, parliament and the constitution were suspended, and a Supreme Revolutionary Council under the army commander, Major-General Mohamed Siad Barre, announced an end to corruption and clan politics. A year later he declared the country socialist and aligned it with the Soviet Union. His government gave the Somali language a written standard and ran mass literacy campaigns. It also built a security apparatus that ruled by fear for twenty-one years.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Somalis welcomed the coup at the time: the previous election had been contested by more than sixty parties, mostly clan vehicles, amid open vote-buying. The verdict changed. In 1988 Siad Barre’s air force and artillery destroyed the northern city of Hargeisa, killing tens of thousands, which people in Somaliland regard as genocide.

Also on 21 October