Parallax

22 October, AD 180

Commodus rides into Rome

The first emperor born to a reigning emperor came home from the Danube at nineteen to a city that adored him. Almost everything we know about what he did next was written by men who had reason to hate him.

Rome

In the autumn of 180 the people of Rome walked out along the roads to the north to meet their new emperor. Lucius Aurelius Commodus was nineteen, fair-haired, and by every account strikingly good-looking. The historian Herodian, who was a child at the time, says that senators and commoners went out together carrying laurel branches and every flower then in season, and that they loved him as one of their own: unlike any ruler before him he had been born in the palace, the son and grandson of emperors.

He had been away for more than two years. His father, Marcus Aurelius, had taken him to the Danube front in 178 to finish a long war against the Marcomanni, the Quadi and the Sarmatian Iazyges. Marcus died in camp on 17 March 180. Commodus had already been joint emperor for three years, so there was no interregnum and no dispute. What surprised the army was his next decision. Within months he had made terms with the tribes and announced that he was going home.

The terms were not soft. The Marcomanni and Quadi were to hand back deserters and captives, supply grain, provide thousands of recruits for the Roman army, keep away from the river and hold assemblies only once a month under the eye of a centurion. But the garrisons that Marcus had planted beyond the Danube were withdrawn, and whatever plan there had been to keep the conquered land was dropped. His father’s old advisers, led by his brother-in-law Claudius Pompeianus, urged him to stay and finish the war. Herodian has him answer, in effect, that business could be done as well from Rome.

On 22 October he entered the city in triumph. The one hostile detail the sources preserve from that day is that his chamberlain Saoterus, a Greek from Bithynia, rode behind him in the triumphal chariot, and that the emperor kept turning round to kiss him. He gave money to the people, made the usual sacrifices on the Capitol, and settled into the palace.

For a year or two little went wrong. Then, probably in 182, his sister Lucilla organised a plot. The young man chosen to do the killing stepped out in the entrance to the amphitheatre, showed his dagger, and announced that the Senate had sent it, which gave the guards time to seize him. Lucilla was exiled and put to death. From then on Commodus trusted the Senate with nothing. He governed through a succession of favourites, and spent his time at the games.

How it came to this

For most of a century Rome had been ruled by emperors who had no surviving sons and adopted capable men as their heirs: Nerva chose Trajan, Trajan was succeeded by Hadrian, Hadrian chose Antoninus Pius and required him to adopt the boy who became Marcus Aurelius. Later writers, Edward Gibbon above all, treated this as a system and the period as a golden age. It was more accident than design. Marcus had a son who lived, and no Roman would have understood passing him over. Commodus was made Caesar at five and co-emperor at fifteen.

The empire he inherited was under strain. A pandemic, probably smallpox, brought back by troops from the east in the 160s, had killed a large share of the population and kept returning. Germanic peoples had broken through the Danube frontier and reached northern Italy around 170, the first invasion of the peninsula in nearly three centuries. Marcus spent most of his last decade in army camps, where he wrote the notebook known as the Meditations, and sold palace furniture to pay for the war.

How each side saw it

The Senate, through Cassius Dio

Dio was a senator in Rome throughout the reign and wrote as an eyewitness. For him the accession marked the descent from a kingdom of gold to one of iron and rust. He describes Commodus as not wicked by nature but simple and cowardly, led by his companions into cruelty. His most famous passage has the emperor, having killed an ostrich in the arena, walk up to the senators’ seats holding the severed head and his sword, grinning. Dio says he chewed laurel leaves from his wreath to stop himself laughing, since laughter would have meant death.

The people and the soldiers

They left no histories, but there are signs that they saw a different emperor. Commodus was generous with grain and handouts and gave the city the spectacles it loved. When he presented himself as Hercules, with lion skin and club, he was using a language of divine protection that ordinary people and provincials understood, and dedications to him in that guise come from across the empire. After his murder the praetorians were sullen, and within three months they had killed his successor Pertinax. The historian Olivier Hekster argues that the policy was coherent: an appeal over the heads of the Senate to everyone else.

The Christians

Marcus Aurelius’s reign had seen the martyrdoms at Lyon in 177. Under his son, Christian writers record a respite. Eusebius says the churches enjoyed peace throughout the world. Hippolytus of Rome tells how Marcia, the emperor’s concubine, whom he calls God-loving, obtained the release of Christians condemned to the mines of Sardinia, among them the future bishop of Rome Callistus. Persecution did not stop entirely: the Scillitan martyrs were executed at Carthage in July 180. But the emperor whom pagan senators remembered as a monster appears in Christian memory as a ruler who mostly left them alone.

The peoples beyond the Danube

The Marcomanni, Quadi and Iazyges have no voice in the record. We know them through Dio’s summary of the treaty and through the reliefs on the Column of Marcus Aurelius in Rome, which show Roman soldiers burning villages, beheading bound prisoners and leading away women and children. The settlement of 180 ended that. It held, more or less, for half a century, which is the main reason many modern historians regard the peace not as the whim of a lazy boy but as a reasonable end to a war that was exhausting the empire.

What is disputed

The day comes from a list of dates in the life of Commodus in the Historia Augusta, a late Roman collection notorious for invention, though this particular notice is generally accepted. Whether Marcus really intended to annex new provinces called Marcomannia and Sarmatia rests on the same source and is doubted. Where Marcus died is disputed, at Vindobona or near Sirmium, and so is the cause: probably the epidemic, though Dio repeats a rumour that his doctors hastened it to please Commodus. All three narrative sources are hostile, and how much of the later reign’s madness is senatorial caricature is an open question.

What followed

Commodus renamed the months after his own titles, called Rome his colony, and in 192 fought as a gladiator in public. On the last night of that year he was given poison by Marcia and then strangled in his bath by a wrestler. The Senate condemned his memory and had his statues pulled down. Four years of civil war followed. The winner, Septimius Severus, a soldier from Africa, found it useful to declare himself the son of Marcus Aurelius and brother of Commodus, and had the dead emperor made a god.

Read further

  • Cassius Dio, Roman History, books 72-73
  • Herodian, History of the Empire from the Death of Marcus, book 1
  • Historia Augusta, Life of Commodus
  • Olivier Hekster, Commodus: An Emperor at the Crossroads (2002)
  • Anthony Birley, Marcus Aurelius: A Biography (1987)

Same day, other years

AD 794

The Japanese court moves to the future Kyoto

Heian-kyo, JapanAsia

Emperor Kanmu had moved his capital from Nara to Nagaoka only ten years earlier, partly to escape the power of the great Buddhist temples. The new site proved unlucky. The official in charge of building it was assassinated; the emperor’s brother, Prince Sawara, was accused, exiled and starved himself to death; then came floods, epidemics and deaths in the imperial family, which diviners blamed on the prince’s angry spirit. Kanmu abandoned Nagaoka for a basin ringed by hills a few miles to the north-east and entered it in the autumn of 794. The city was laid out as a grid on the model of the Chinese capital Chang’an and named Heian-kyo, capital of peace and tranquillity. Emperors lived there until 1868.

Seen from elsewhere. The date needs a caution. The chronicles give the 22nd day of the tenth month of the lunar calendar, which fell in mid-November 794 by the Julian reckoning. Modern Kyoto celebrates its founding on 22 October with the Jidai Matsuri procession, keeping the number and not the season, and Western almanacs have followed.

1844

The Great Disappointment

North-eastern United StatesThe Americas

William Miller, a farmer and Baptist lay preacher from upstate New York, had concluded from the prophecies of the Book of Daniel that Christ would return in about 1843. His lectures, spread by an energetic publicist named Joshua Himes through newspapers and camp meetings, gathered a following usually estimated at fifty to a hundred thousand. When 1843 passed, a younger preacher, Samuel Snow, recalculated the date as the Jewish Day of Atonement, 22 October 1844. Believers settled debts, left crops unharvested and gave away possessions. They waited through the day and the night. One of them, Hiram Edson, wrote that they wept and wept until the day dawned.

Seen from elsewhere. Newspapers mocked them with tales of people in white ‘ascension robes’ on rooftops, which historians have found little evidence for. Miller admitted his error. Others decided the date had been right and the event misunderstood, a change in heaven and not on earth; from that group grew the Seventh-day Adventist Church, now more than twenty million strong.

1947

Tribal fighters cross into Kashmir

Muzaffarabad, KashmirAsia

Two months after the partition of British India, the princely state of Jammu and Kashmir, with a Muslim majority and a Hindu maharaja, had joined neither India nor Pakistan. On 22 October 1947 several thousand Pashtun tribesmen from the north-west frontier, carried in lorries, crossed the border at Muzaffarabad and drove up the road towards Srinagar. They stopped to loot the town of Baramulla, where many civilians were killed, including nuns and patients at a mission hospital. Maharaja Hari Singh fled the capital and asked India for troops. India required him to accede first. The Instrument of Accession is dated 26 October, and Indian soldiers were flown into Srinagar the next morning. The fighting lasted until a ceasefire on 1 January 1949.

Seen from elsewhere. India holds that Pakistan planned the invasion, and a Pakistani general, Akbar Khan, later described his part in organising it. Pakistan maintains that the tribesmen went to defend fellow Muslims, who had risen in Poonch and were being massacred in Jammu that autumn. The plebiscite both governments promised Kashmiris has never been held.

1962

Kennedy announces missiles in Cuba

Washington and CubaThe Americas

At seven in the evening on 22 October 1962 President Kennedy told a television audience that Soviet medium-range nuclear missiles were being installed in Cuba, ninety miles from Florida. American reconnaissance aircraft had photographed the sites eight days earlier, and he had spent the week in secret discussion with his advisers, some of whom wanted an immediate air strike. He announced instead a naval ‘quarantine’ of the island and said that any missile launched from Cuba would be treated as a Soviet attack on the United States. American forces went to their highest alert short of war. Six days later Nikita Khrushchev agreed to withdraw the weapons in exchange for a public pledge not to invade Cuba and a secret promise to remove American missiles from Turkey.

Seen from elsewhere. Moscow and Havana pointed out that the United States had sponsored an invasion of Cuba in 1961, was plotting to kill Fidel Castro, and kept its own missiles on Soviet borders. Castro was not consulted about the settlement and was furious at it. Cubans call the episode the October Crisis; Russians, the Caribbean Crisis.

Also on 22 October