Parallax

10 October, AD 732

The battle between Tours and Poitiers

A Frankish army on foot stood its ground against the cavalry of al-Andalus and killed its governor. Whether that saved Christian Europe or merely ended a large raid has been argued over ever since.

Between Tours and Poitiers, Frankish Gaul

In 732 Abd al-Rahman al-Ghafiqi, governor of al-Andalus for the Umayyad caliph in Damascus, led an army over the western Pyrenees into Aquitaine. He was a veteran: eleven years earlier he had brought the survivors home after a defeat under the walls of Toulouse. This time he beat Duke Odo of Aquitaine near the Garonne, a slaughter so great, wrote a Christian chronicler in Spain, that God alone knew the number of the dead. Bordeaux was sacked and its churches burned. The army then moved north towards the richest shrine in Gaul, the basilica of St Martin at Tours.

Odo had spent years resisting the Franks to his north. Now he fled to their leader, Charles, and asked for help. Charles was not a king. He was mayor of the palace, the officer who governed in the name of the powerless Merovingian monarchs, and he had won that position by a decade of fighting his own kin and neighbours. He marched south with a force raised from the Frankish heartlands and placed it across the old Roman road somewhere between Poitiers and Tours.

For about seven days the two armies watched each other and skirmished. Abd al-Rahman’s strength was in mounted men, Arabs and Berbers; the Franks fought mainly on foot with shields, spears and long swords. When the attack came, the Frankish line did not break. The fullest description is by an anonymous Christian writing in Spain in 754, who says the northerners stood motionless like a wall, like a belt of ice frozen together, and put the Arabs to the sword. Abd al-Rahman was killed in the fighting.

Night ended it. At dawn the Franks formed up again and saw the enemy tents still standing in rows. Suspecting a trap, they sent scouts, who found the camp empty. The army of al-Andalus had gone in the dark, leaving much of its plunder. Charles did not pursue. He divided the spoils among his men and went home to the north, leaving Odo to reoccupy what remained of his duchy. The survivors of the governor’s army made their way back over the Pyrenees, and a successor was sent out from North Africa the following year.

That is nearly all the sources say. The battle may have been fought near the village now called Moussais-la-Bataille, but nobody is certain. The name by which Charles is known, Martellus, the Hammer, does not appear in writing until the ninth century, long after anyone who fought beside him was dead.

How it came to this

Arab and Berber forces had crossed from North Africa in 711 and destroyed the Visigothic kingdom of Spain within a few years. By 720 they had taken Narbonne, the Visigoths’ last province north of the Pyrenees, and from it they raided up the Rhône as far as Autun in 725. The frontier was not a simple line between faiths. Duke Odo, who had beaten a Muslim army at Toulouse in 721, afterwards married his daughter to Munuza, a Berber commander in the Pyrenees who had rebelled against the governor in Córdoba. Abd al-Rahman destroyed Munuza first and then turned on his father-in-law.

The Frankish kingdom, meanwhile, was a family business in dispute. Charles was the son of the mayor Pippin by a woman other than his chief wife, was imprisoned by his stepmother Plectrude on his father’s death in 714, escaped, and fought his way to control of both Frankish realms by 718. He paid his followers partly with lands taken from churches, a practice for which later churchmen did not forgive him.

How each side saw it

The Arabic tradition

Arab historians gave the battle little space. Ibn Abd al-Hakam, writing in Egypt in the ninth century, says only that Abd al-Rahman raided the Franks and that he and his companions died as martyrs. Later Andalusi writers, preserved by Ibn Idhari and al-Maqqari, call the place Balat al-Shuhada, the Pavement of the Martyrs, and say the call to prayer could still be heard there. Some blame the defeat on soldiers anxious for their loot. For these authors the catastrophes of the age were elsewhere: the failed siege of Constantinople in 717-18 and the great Berber revolt of 740, which shook Muslim rule in the west far more than any Frankish army.

Aquitaine

The Aquitanians left no chronicle of their own. Their duke appears in Frankish sources written for Charles’s family, where he is a faithless ally who invited the Saracens in, a charge most historians reject as an excuse for what followed. Odo had defeated a Muslim army at Toulouse eleven years before Charles did, and the papal record in Rome celebrated him for it. For his duchy the events of 732 meant ruin twice over: sacked by one army and placed in debt to another. After Odo died in 735 Charles invaded, and his son and grandson spent thirty years reducing Aquitaine to a Frankish province.

The Carolingian court and the Church

The Continuations of the Chronicle of Fredegar, written under the direction of Charles’s half-brother Count Childebrand, present the victory as won ‘with Christ’s help’ by a prince who scattered the tents of the Ishmaelites. It is family history, composed while that family was replacing the Merovingian kings. Churchmen were more divided. Charles had taken ecclesiastical estates to reward his soldiers, and a ninth-century story, the Vision of Eucherius, showed him suffering in hell for it. The image of a champion of Christendom was built later, by his descendants and their admirers.

What is disputed

The day is not recorded. A Saturday in October 732 is the usual reading, and 10 October a convention; some reckonings from the Arabic month give 25 October, and a few scholars, Roger Collins among them, have argued for 733. No reliable numbers exist: a medieval figure of 375,000 Saracen dead is fantasy, and modern guesses of fifteen to thirty thousand a side are only guesses. The larger dispute is about meaning. Edward Gibbon imagined that without the victory the Koran would be taught at Oxford. Many modern historians see a plundering expedition aimed at Tours, not a conquest, and place the true limit of expansion in the Berber revolt and the caliphate’s own civil wars.

What followed

Raids did not stop. Muslim forces took Avignon in 737 and held Narbonne until 759, when it fell to Charles’s son Pippin. The lasting result was inside the Frankish world: the victory gave Charles the standing to rule without a king at all from 737, and to pass power to his sons. Pippin took the crown in 751, and his son Charlemagne an imperial title in 800. Since Gibbon the battle has been used as a symbol in arguments about Europe and Islam, most recently by nationalist movements, a use most specialists in the period regard as unhistorical.

Read further

  • Kenneth Baxter Wolf, Conquerors and Chroniclers of Early Medieval Spain (1990), which translates the Chronicle of 754
  • J. M. Wallace-Hadrill (ed.), The Fourth Book of the Chronicle of Fredegar with its Continuations (1960)
  • Paul Fouracre, The Age of Charles Martel (2000)
  • Roger Collins, The Arab Conquest of Spain, 710-797 (1989)
  • Hugh Kennedy, Muslim Spain and Portugal: A Political History of al-Andalus (1996)

Same day, other years

AD 680

Husayn is killed at Karbala

Karbala, IraqMiddle East

When the Umayyad caliph Muawiya died in 680 and his son Yazid succeeded him, Husayn ibn Ali, grandson of the Prophet Muhammad, refused to swear allegiance. Invited by the people of Kufa to lead them, he set out from Mecca with his family and a small band of supporters. The Kufans, cowed by the governor Ubayd Allah ibn Ziyad, did not rise. An army of several thousand intercepted the caravan on the plain of Karbala and cut it off from the Euphrates. On 10 Muharram of the year 61, 10 October 680, Husayn and about seventy men of his party were killed. His head was sent to Damascus and the women and children were led away captive.

Seen from elsewhere. For Shia Muslims Karbala is the central act of sacrifice in history, mourned each year at Ashura. Sunni tradition also honours Husayn and condemns his killers, but does not draw the same conclusions about rightful leadership. Umayyad loyalists treated him as a rebel against an acknowledged caliph. The main early narrative, by Abu Mikhnaf, survives through al-Tabari.

1760

The Ndyuka Maroons win a treaty from the Dutch

SurinameThe Americas

For decades people who escaped the sugar and coffee plantations of Dutch Suriname had built communities deep in the rainforest, and raided the estates for tools, guns and recruits. The colony’s expeditions against them were expensive failures. On 10 October 1760 the governor’s envoys concluded a peace with the Ndyuka, also called the Okanisi, on the upper Marowijne and Tapanahony rivers. The colony recognised their freedom and their territory and promised regular deliveries of goods. It was signed with a blood oath in the African manner as well as on paper, a century before slavery ended in Suriname in 1863. Similar treaties with the Saamaka and Matawai followed.

Seen from elsewhere. The price was written into the text: the Ndyuka undertook to hand back people who fled the plantations in future, and the Dutch hoped to turn them into a border guard. In practice returns were patchy. Ndyuka oral tradition remembers a victory forced on the whites; 10 October is now Maroon Day in Suriname.

1868

The Cry of Yara opens Cuba’s first war of independence

La Demajagua, near Manzanillo, CubaThe Americas

On the morning of 10 October 1868 Carlos Manuel de Céspedes, a lawyer and planter in eastern Cuba, rang the bell of his small sugar mill, La Demajagua, gathered the people he held in slavery and told them they were free and invited to fight. He then proclaimed independence from Spain. His first attack, on the town of Yara, was beaten off, but the rising spread across the east. The Ten Years’ War followed. It produced a republic in arms, a constitution, and commanders such as the Dominican Máximo Gómez and the Afro-Cuban Antonio Maceo, and it ended in 1878 with a compromise peace at Zanjón. Deaths are usually put between 100,000 and 200,000.

Seen from elsewhere. Spain and the loyalist volunteer militias in Havana saw separatists backed from the United States and feared a second Haiti. Within the rebellion, abolition was at first cautious and conditional, to avoid alarming western planters. Maceo refused the peace of Zanjón at Baraguá precisely because it brought neither independence nor an end to slavery.

1911

Mutiny at Wuchang brings down the Qing

Wuchang (Wuhan), Hubei, ChinaAsia

On 9 October 1911 a bomb being assembled by revolutionaries went off by accident in the Russian concession at Hankou. Police seized membership lists naming soldiers in the modernised New Army garrison across the river at Wuchang. Faced with arrest, an engineering battalion mutinied on the evening of 10 October, seized the armoury and stormed the governor-general’s offices; he escaped through a hole in the rear wall. The rebels had no leader of note and pressed a reluctant brigade commander, Li Yuanhong, into the role. Within seven weeks most provinces had declared against the dynasty. Sun Yat-sen, who read the news in a newspaper in Denver, returned to become provisional president, and the last emperor abdicated in February 1912.

Seen from elsewhere. For Manchu families in garrison cities the revolution brought massacre, in Wuchang and far more at Xi’an. The date is the national day of the Republic of China on Taiwan, the ‘Double Tenth’, while the People’s Republic honours it as an incomplete bourgeois revolution. Historians stress how much the outcome owed to provincial elites and the general Yuan Shikai.

Also on 10 October