Parallax

18 October, 1812

Napoleon gives the order to leave Moscow

For five weeks he had waited in a burned city for a peace offer that never came. A surprise Russian attack on a Sunday morning ended the waiting, and the retreat began at dawn the next day.

Moscow, Russia

On the morning of 18 October 1812, by the western calendar, Napoleon was in a courtyard of the Kremlin reviewing the infantry of Marshal Ney’s corps when an aide rode in with news from the south. At dawn the Russians had fallen on Marshal Murat’s cavalry camp near the village of Vinkovo, forty miles away. Murat, who had settled into an informal truce with the Cossack outposts and posted few sentries, had been caught asleep. He cut his way out, but lost some three thousand men and more than thirty guns.

It was a small defeat, and Napoleon had already been making preparations to go. But it settled the matter. The Russian army he had beaten at Borodino six weeks earlier was not broken; it had been resting and filling its ranks in a camp at Tarutino while his own strength drained away. He finished the review, went inside, and dictated orders through the afternoon. The army would march the next morning.

He had entered Moscow on 14 September expecting a delegation of nobles with the keys of the city. No one came. Most of the population had left, and within hours fires broke out that burned for four days and destroyed perhaps two thirds of the buildings. He stayed anyway, convinced that Tsar Alexander would negotiate. He wrote to the Tsar; he sent General Lauriston to Field Marshal Kutuzov’s headquarters to ask for an armistice. Kutuzov received the envoy politely and forwarded the letters. Alexander answered none of them. The first snow fell on 13 October.

On the 19th about a hundred thousand soldiers filed out through the Kaluga gate. With them went a column of vehicles that witnesses found hard to describe: army wagons, private carriages, carts and wheelbarrows, loaded with furs, silver, icons, paintings and bolts of cloth taken from the ruins, and several thousand civilians, among them French residents of Moscow, actresses, wounded men and soldiers’ wives. Count de Segur, who was there, compared it to a caravan or a horde returning from a raid. Marshal Mortier stayed behind with orders to blow up the Kremlin; rain and Russian civilians put out most of the fuses.

Napoleon meant to go south-west through Kaluga, where the country had not been stripped. On 24 October the Russians blocked him at Maloyaroslavets in a fight that changed hands eight times. He turned back onto the road he had come by, past the unburied dead of Borodino, towards Smolensk. The hard frosts came in early November. By the time the remnants crossed the Niemen in December, fewer than one in ten of the men who had marched east in June were still under arms.

How it came to this

France and Russia had been allies of a kind since the treaty of Tilsit in 1807. The alliance required Russia to join Napoleon’s embargo on British trade, which ruined Russian exporters, and by the end of 1810 Alexander had stopped enforcing it. Napoleon also alarmed the Tsar by enlarging the Duchy of Warsaw, which looked to St Petersburg like the beginning of a restored Poland. Both sides spent 1811 preparing for war.

The army that crossed the Niemen from 24 June 1812 was the largest Europe had seen, somewhere between 450,000 and 600,000 men depending on how the reserves are counted. Fewer than half were French. Napoleon expected a decisive battle near the frontier. The Russian commanders withdrew instead, and the invaders marched for weeks through heat, dust and dysentery, losing men and horses by the thousand before any great battle was fought. Borodino on 7 September cost the two sides something like seventy thousand casualties in a day and decided nothing. Kutuzov gave up Moscow to save his army.

How each side saw it

The Russian command

Kutuzov has been presented, most famously by Tolstoy in War and Peace, as the wise old man who let time and distance do the work. His own generals did not all see it so. Bennigsen, who led the attack on Murat, accused him of holding back the reserves out of jealousy, and the British liaison officer Sir Robert Wilson complained that he let Napoleon escape. Dominic Lieven has argued from Russian archives that the outcome owed less to instinct or winter than to planning: a strategy of retreat agreed in advance, superior light cavalry, and a supply system that kept the Russian army fed while the French starved.

The soldiers who were not French

Poles, Germans, Italians, Dutch, Swiss, Croats and Portuguese made up more than half the invading army, most of them conscripted by rulers who were Napoleon’s clients. The Poles alone had a cause of their own, the hope of a restored kingdom. Jakob Walter, a stonemason from Wurttemberg serving as a private, left one of the few memoirs by a common soldier. It has almost nothing to say about strategy or emperors. It is an account of looking for food, of men killing each other over a horse’s liver, and of walking home.

Muscovites and the Russian peasantry

About 270,000 people lived in Moscow before the invasion; most fled, and those who stayed, largely the poor, servants and the wounded, endured looting and hunger. In the countryside peasants killed foragers and stragglers. Russian tradition, and later Soviet historians such as Yevgeny Tarle, called this a people’s war of national feeling. Others note that villagers were defending their own grain and animals from soldiers who took everything, and that the government feared armed serfs almost as much as it feared the French. Serfdom outlasted the victory by half a century.

Napoleon’s entourage

Armand de Caulaincourt, the Emperor’s Master of the Horse and a former ambassador to Russia, had warned him before the campaign that Alexander would retreat to Kamchatka sooner than sign a peace on Russian soil. His memoirs record Napoleon in Moscow reading novels, lingering over dinner and insisting that the autumn was milder than at Fontainebleau. Segur’s history of 1824 painted a commander who had lost his old decisiveness. General Gourgaud, loyal to the Emperor’s memory, published a rebuttal, and the two men fought a duel over it.

What is disputed

Many popular accounts, including the book this entry starts from, say the army left Moscow on 18 October. It left on the 19th; the 18th is the day of the Russian attack at Vinkovo and of the order to march. In the Russian calendar of the time these are 6 and 7 October. Who burned Moscow is still argued. The governor, Fyodor Rostopchin, had removed the fire engines and released convicts, and at first accepted the credit; in 1823 he published a denial. The claim that winter destroyed the army is also challenged: most of its losses came before the severe cold, from disease, hunger, desertion and battle.

What followed

Napoleon left the army on 5 December and reached Paris in thirteen days. Estimates of the invaders’ dead and missing run to 400,000 or more; Russian military deaths were perhaps 200,000, and nobody counted the civilians. Prussia changed sides within weeks and Austria followed in 1813. Russian troops entered Paris in March 1814. In Russia the campaign became the Patriotic War, the founding story of national unity, and it supplied the name for the war of 1941-45. Officers who had marched to Paris and seen constitutional government led the Decembrist revolt of 1825.

Read further

  • Dominic Lieven, Russia Against Napoleon: The Battle for Europe, 1807 to 1814 (2009)
  • Adam Zamoyski, 1812: Napoleon’s Fatal March on Moscow (2004)
  • Armand de Caulaincourt, With Napoleon in Russia (1935)
  • Jakob Walter, The Diary of a Napoleonic Foot Soldier, edited by Marc Raeff (1991)
  • Philippe-Paul de Segur, Histoire de Napoleon et de la Grande Armee pendant l’annee 1812 (1824)

Same day, other years

1009

The Church of the Holy Sepulchre is demolished

JerusalemMiddle East

The Fatimid caliph al-Hakim bi-Amr Allah, who ruled from Cairo, ordered the destruction of the church built over the place where Christians believed Jesus had been crucified and buried. The Christian chronicler Yahya of Antioch, writing a generation later, says the workmen pulled down the building and tried to break up the rock-cut tomb itself with picks, leaving only what they could not remove. Church property was seized. The order was part of a wider campaign in which al-Hakim demolished churches and synagogues across his territories and forced Christians and Jews to wear distinguishing dress. He later relented, and his successors allowed the church to be rebuilt with Byzantine money by about 1048.

Seen from elsewhere. The date is the one usually given; Yahya’s own dating points to late September. Al-Hakim’s motives are obscure, and he also placed harsh restrictions on Sunni Muslims. The Druze revere him as a manifestation of God. In France the news was blamed on the Jews, and the chronicler Rodulfus Glaber records attacks on them.

1540

De Soto’s army destroys Mabila

Central AlabamaThe Americas

Hernando de Soto had landed in Florida in 1539 with some six hundred men and spent a year marching through the chiefdoms of the south-east, seizing food, porters and women as he went. In October 1540 he took hostage a powerful chief, Tascalusa, who led the Spaniards to a stockaded town called Mabila. Warriors were waiting inside. In the fighting that followed the Spaniards were driven out, lost their baggage, then set the town on fire and cut down those who fled. Their own chroniclers put the dead at between 2,500 and 3,000, against about twenty Spaniards killed and most of the rest wounded. De Soto concealed that ships were waiting on the coast and marched his men north.

Seen from elsewhere. No account from Tascalusa’s people survives; everything comes from four Spanish narratives that disagree on the numbers, and the site has never been found. Within a century and a half the great chiefdoms de Soto saw had gone, broken by disease and upheaval. The Choctaw, Creek and Chickasaw nations formed from their survivors.

1860

British troops burn the Old Summer Palace

Beijing, ChinaAsia

The Yuanmingyuan, north-west of Beijing, was a complex of palaces, libraries, temples and gardens covering more than eight hundred acres, the main residence of the Qing emperors. In the last weeks of the Second Opium War, French and British troops reached it and looted it for days. Then news came that about twenty members of a party of envoys and their escort, seized by the Qing while under a flag of truce, had died in captivity after being bound and tortured. The British plenipotentiary, Lord Elgin, ordered the palace destroyed in reprisal. On 18 October 1860 some 3,500 soldiers set it alight. It burned for two days. The Xianfeng emperor had already fled.

Seen from elsewhere. Elgin said he had chosen a punishment that fell on the emperor and not on the people of Beijing. Victor Hugo wrote in 1861 of two bandits, France and England, entering a cathedral of Asia. In China the ruins are preserved as a memorial of national humiliation, and the return of looted objects is still demanded.

1929

Canadian women are ruled to be ‘persons’

London, for CanadaThe Americas

Canada’s constitution said that ‘qualified persons’ could be summoned to the Senate. Successive governments had held that this meant men. Five Alberta women, Emily Murphy, Nellie McClung, Irene Parlby, Louise McKinney and Henrietta Muir Edwards, petitioned for a ruling, and in 1928 the Supreme Court of Canada decided unanimously against them. They appealed to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London, then Canada’s highest court. On 18 October 1929 Lord Sankey announced that the exclusion of women from public office was a relic of days more barbarous than ours, and that the constitution was a living tree capable of growth. Cairine Wilson became the first woman senator in 1930.

Seen from elsewhere. The ruling did nothing for the many women who could not vote at all: most Asian Canadians were barred until the late 1940s and status Indians until 1960. The reputation of the five has also been questioned. Several of them campaigned for Alberta’s 1928 law permitting the sterilisation of people judged mentally unfit.

Also on 18 October