Parallax

5 October, 1795

Bonaparte’s guns clear the streets of Paris

An unemployed brigadier of twenty-six, recently struck off the list of generals, was handed the defence of the French government against its own capital. Two hours of cannon fire made his career and taught the Republic to settle its politics with the army.

Paris, France

On the evening of 12 Vendemiaire, Year IV, by the revolutionary calendar, the National Convention learned that its commander in Paris had failed it. General Menou had been sent to disarm the Le Peletier section, the wealthy district around the stock exchange that was leading a revolt of the city’s neighbourhood assemblies. Instead he had parleyed with the rebels and withdrawn. The deputies dismissed him and gave the command to one of their own, Paul Barras, who had organised the armed side of Robespierre’s overthrow the year before. Barras was a politician, not a gunner. He sent for officers he knew, and among them was Napoleon Bonaparte.

Bonaparte had met Barras at the siege of Toulon in 1793, where his handling of the artillery had won him promotion to brigadier general. Since then his luck had turned. He had been briefly arrested as a friend of the Robespierres, had refused a posting against the peasant rebels of the Vendee, and three weeks earlier had been removed from the list of serving generals. He was thinking of taking service with the Ottoman sultan.

The Convention had perhaps five or six thousand troops to hold the Tuileries palace, where it sat, against sectional National Guards numbering some twenty to twenty-five thousand. What it lacked was artillery. The nearest guns, forty of them, were parked at the Sablons camp at Neuilly, a few miles to the west. Around midnight Bonaparte ordered a cavalry major named Joachim Murat to fetch them. Murat’s three hundred horsemen reached the park just ahead of a column sent by the sections on the same errand, and had the cannon back at the Tuileries by dawn. Bonaparte placed them to cover the bridges and every street leading to the palace.

All through 5 October the two sides faced each other in the rain. The rebels hoped the soldiers would refuse to fire, as soldiers had in 1789. Shooting began at about half past four in the afternoon in the rue Saint-Honore. Guns loaded with case shot swept the street and the steps of the church of Saint-Roch, where the insurgents had gathered. A second column, coming along the quay on the left bank to cross the Pont Royal, was broken up by batteries firing across the river.

By six o’clock it was nearly over, and the last barricades were cleared the next morning. The dead on both sides numbered a few hundred. Within three weeks Bonaparte was a full general commanding the Army of the Interior, and Parisians had a nickname for him: General Vendemiaire.

How it came to this

The Convention had governed France since 1792. It had executed the king, organised the Terror and then, in July 1794, destroyed Robespierre. By 1795 it was despised from both directions. The poor of Paris, who had risen in the spring demanding bread and the democratic constitution of 1793, had been crushed by the army in May and their districts disarmed. On the right, royalists and moderate property owners, strong in the western sections of the city, expected the coming elections to sweep the old deputies away.

The deputies had no intention of being swept. In August they completed a new constitution with a five-man Directory and two chambers, and attached to it a decree that two-thirds of the new legislators must be chosen from among themselves. They feared, with reason, that a free election would return a royalist majority and that they would be made to answer for the king’s death. Both measures were put to a vote and declared carried, though the count on the two-thirds decree was widely thought to be rigged and most Paris sections rejected it. When the results were announced in late September, the sections called out their National Guard.

How each side saw it

The Paris sections

The insurgents did not call themselves royalists, and many were not. Their proclamations speak of the sovereignty of the people, the right of electors to choose freely, and a Convention of ‘drinkers of blood’ clinging to power by decree. They were lawyers, shopkeepers, clerks and returned moderates, the people who had been frightened and silenced under the Terror. Royalist agents were certainly active among them and hoped to turn a victory to the benefit of the exiled Louis XVIII. The sections’ own records show less a plot than a crowd of citizen soldiers with no artillery, divided leaders, and a belief that the troops would come over.

Paul Barras

Barras’s memoirs, written long after Bonaparte had discarded him, insist that the victory was his. He commanded, he gave the orders, and Bonaparte was merely one of several officers he employed, a thin, shabby young man glad of the work. Contemporary documents support him on the formal point: the official report to the Convention barely singled Bonaparte out, and it was Barras who then put his name forward for promotion. Barras was also the patron who introduced him to Josephine de Beauharnais. His account is coloured throughout by resentment, and historians use it with caution.

Bonaparte

On the night itself he wrote to his brother Joseph a short, flat letter: the enemy attacked, we killed many of them, we disarmed the sections, as usual I have not a scratch, happiness is mine. The grander version came later. In the memoirs dictated on St Helena he is the man who took every decision, sent Murat for the guns and saved the Republic. He also claimed to have hesitated, weighing whether to make himself the scapegoat for the Convention’s crimes. To his admirers this day proves his decisiveness; to his critics, that his rise began with firing on French civilians.

The Paris poor

The working districts of the east, which had made every great revolutionary day from 1789 to 1793, stayed out of this one. They had been starved through the winter and shot down in May, and had no love for a Convention that had done it. But they liked the well-dressed sections less. The Convention released jailed Jacobins and armed some fifteen hundred of them as a battalion of ‘Patriots of 89’ to help defend the Tuileries. Their views survive mostly in police reports. It was the last time the government would look to them for support; after this it looked to generals.

What is disputed

The phrase ‘a whiff of grapeshot’ is Thomas Carlyle’s, coined in 1837; Bonaparte never said it. How much the cannon actually did is debated. Some historians doubt that guns could have raked the church steps of Saint-Roch from the narrow side street as the legend has it, and think musketry did most of the killing there. Casualty figures are guesses, from about two hundred dead in all to three hundred on each side, with higher totals in some accounts. Bonaparte’s own share of the credit is contested between his version and that of Barras. Whether the rising was a royalist conspiracy or a constitutional protest that royalists exploited divides historians of the right and left in France to this day.

What followed

The repression was light: the sections were disarmed, and only two rebel leaders were executed. The two-thirds decree stood, and the Directory took office within weeks. Bonaparte married Josephine in March 1796 and left days later to command the Army of Italy. The regime he had saved went on calling in soldiers against its opponents, in 1797 and again in 1799, when the general summoned to help was Bonaparte, and he kept the power for himself. The crowd of Paris did not overthrow a government again until 1830.

Read further

  • Thomas Carlyle, The French Revolution: A History (1837)
  • Paul Barras, Memoirs of Barras, Member of the Directorate (1895-96)
  • Georges Lefebvre, The Thermidorians and the Directory (1964)
  • Philip Dwyer, Napoleon: The Path to Power, 1769-1799 (2007)
  • Martyn Lyons, France under the Directory (1975)

Same day, other years

1864

A cyclone drowns Calcutta’s river villages

Calcutta (Kolkata) and the Hooghly delta, IndiaAsia

A cyclone came up the Bay of Bengal and struck the mouth of the Hooghly on the morning of 5 October, driving a wall of water up the river ahead of it. The surge, by some reports as much as twelve metres above the normal level, went over the low embankments of the delta and reached Calcutta, then the capital of British India, about ten in the morning. Of some two hundred ships in the port, the great majority were torn from their moorings and many were wrecked or driven ashore. In the villages of the lower river whole communities were swept away. About sixty thousand people are thought to have died, many of them from cholera and hunger in the weeks that followed.

Seen from elsewhere. The official inquiry counted ships and cargoes with care and the rural dead only roughly; almost none of the drowned villagers are named in any record. The government’s response was India’s first storm-warning system for the port, set up in 1865, and later a national weather service. The people of the delta, who had suffered most, gained least from a system designed to protect shipping.

1877

Chief Joseph surrenders forty miles from Canada

Bear Paw Mountains, Montana TerritoryThe Americas

For nearly four months some 750 Nez Perce, most of them women, children and the old, had outrun and outfought the United States army across more than 1,100 miles of Idaho, Wyoming and Montana. They had refused to move from their homeland in the Wallowa valley to a reservation a fraction of its size, and after young men killed settlers in June they fled, hoping to reach Sitting Bull in Canada. Colonel Nelson Miles caught them in the snow at the Bear Paw Mountains, a two-day ride from the border. After a five-day siege, with most of the war leaders dead, Joseph gave up his rifle. About four hundred people surrendered. Others slipped away north with White Bird.

Seen from elsewhere. The speech ending ‘I will fight no more forever’ was written down by an army lieutenant, Charles Erskine Scott Wood, a poet, and scholars doubt Joseph spoke it in that form. Miles promised the Nez Perce they could go home. Washington overruled him and sent them to Kansas and Indian Territory, where many died. Joseph was never allowed back to the Wallowa.

1910

Portugal becomes a republic

Lisbon, PortugalEurope

After two nights of fighting in which sailors, a few army units and armed civilians of the secret society known as the Carbonaria held the centre of Lisbon against loyal troops, the republic was proclaimed from the balcony of the city hall on the morning of 5 October. Warships in the Tagus had shelled the royal palace. King Manuel II, aged twenty, who had come to the throne when his father and elder brother were shot in a Lisbon square in 1908, left from the fishing beach at Ericeira on the royal yacht and went into exile in England. The writer Teofilo Braga headed a provisional government. Portugal became one of only a handful of republics in a Europe of monarchies.

Seen from elsewhere. Monarchists and much of the Catholic north saw a coup by a Lisbon minority. The new government expelled the Jesuits, closed the religious orders and separated church and state within months, which the Vatican condemned. The republic went through some forty-five governments in sixteen years before the army overthrew it in 1926, opening the way to Salazar.

1988

Chile votes No to Pinochet

Santiago, ChileThe Americas

General Augusto Pinochet, who had ruled since the coup of 1973, had written a plebiscite into his own constitution: after eight years the voters would be asked to approve another eight for the junta’s candidate, who turned out to be himself. An alliance of opposition parties, from Christian Democrats to Socialists, ran a campaign for No, with a cheerful television slot each night under a rainbow emblem. More than seven million Chileans voted, and No won by about 56 per cent to 44. The count stalled for hours that night. According to the air force commander, Fernando Matthei, Pinochet asked the junta for emergency powers and was refused. Matthei told reporters on his way in that No had won.

Seen from elsewhere. More than four voters in ten wanted Pinochet to stay, crediting him with order and economic growth after the turmoil of the Allende years. He left the presidency in 1990 but stayed army commander until 1998. State commissions later counted more than three thousand people killed or disappeared and tens of thousands imprisoned and tortured under his rule.

Also on 5 October