Parallax

11 October, 1531

Zwingli dies on the field at Kappel

The reformer of Zurich marched out with the city’s banner and was killed in less than an hour’s fighting. His enemies quartered and burned the body; his death fixed the religious map of Switzerland for centuries.

Kappel am Albis, Switzerland

The news reached Zurich on 9 October 1531 that the five Catholic cantons of the Swiss interior, Lucerne, Uri, Schwyz, Unterwalden and Zug, had declared war and were already marching. The city was not ready. For months its council had argued about what to do with neighbours it was trying to starve into accepting Protestant preaching, and its militia officers were divided and resentful. An advance guard of about 1,200 men was sent to hold the border near the monastery of Kappel, a morning’s walk south of the city over the Albis ridge.

The main banner did not leave Zurich until the morning of 11 October, with far fewer men than the muster rolls promised. Huldrych Zwingli went with it. He was forty-seven, the preacher at the Grossmünster who had led the city out of the Roman church over the previous twelve years, and he rode as field chaplain, wearing a helmet and carrying a sword, as Zurich’s clergy customarily did. Friends recorded that he expected not to return.

The reinforcements arrived exhausted in the afternoon to find perhaps 7,000 Catholic troops facing fewer than half that number. The Zurich commanders judged the day too far gone for a battle. Around four o’clock a Catholic captain led a party through a beech wood that had been left unguarded on the Zurich flank, and the main body followed. The fight was over within the hour. About 500 Zurichers were killed, among them twenty-five clergy and many members of the city’s councils, against roughly a hundred of their opponents.

Zwingli was found among the wounded as the light failed. According to the account his successor Heinrich Bullinger later assembled, soldiers who did not recognise him asked whether he wanted a priest to confess him, and when he shook his head told him to call on the Mother of God. He refused. A captain from Unterwalden named Vokinger killed him with a sword.

The body was identified next morning. A court of the victors condemned it as that of a heretic and traitor; the executioner of Lucerne quartered it and burned the pieces, and the ashes were scattered so that nothing could be gathered as a relic. The news reached Zurich the same night with the first fugitives. Zwingli’s wife, Anna Reinhart, lost in the one afternoon her husband, a son by her first marriage, a brother and a son-in-law.

How it came to this

Zwingli had come to Zurich in 1519 after years as a parish priest and as chaplain to Swiss mercenaries in Italy, where he saw the carnage of Marignano and turned against the trade in soldiers. Preaching directly from scripture, he persuaded the city council, in public disputations in 1523, to remove images, close monasteries and replace the Mass with a plain commemorative supper. Bern, Basel and other towns followed. The rural cantons of the interior, attached to the old faith and dependent on the mercenary pensions Zwingli denounced, did not.

The Swiss Confederation was a league of thirteen sovereign cantons that also ruled some territories jointly, and it was in these shared lands that the quarrel became unmanageable: who decided the religion of a village governed by both sides? An armed standoff at Kappel in 1529 ended without bloodshed. Zwingli thought the settlement too weak and urged a swift war. Bern preferred an embargo on grain, salt and wine, imposed in May 1531. It hurt ordinary people in the mountain cantons enough to make them fight, and not enough to prevent it.

How each side saw it

The five Catholic cantons

For the men of the inner cantons this was a war of self-defence. They had been denied food and salt by fellow Confederates in a bad year, and their declaration of war listed the blockade and the forcing of new preachers on jointly ruled villages as breaches of the old alliances. The Lucerne chronicler Hans Salat, who served in the campaign, wrote the fullest Catholic account and treated the victory as God’s verdict on a man who had broken the unity of the Church and of the Swiss. The burning of the body followed the law for heretics; to them it was a sentence, not an outrage.

Zurich and the Reformed tradition

Bullinger, who took over the Grossmünster pulpit at twenty-seven, had to explain a defeat that many citizens blamed on clergy meddling in politics. His Reformation history presents Zwingli as a faithful shepherd who went out with his flock and died a martyr, and it preserves the words attributed to him as he fell: that they could kill the body but not the soul. The council drew a different lesson and required that ministers keep out of affairs of state. Zurich still shows the helmet and sword said to be his, returned from Lucerne in the nineteenth century.

Luther and the Anabaptists

Other reformers were unsympathetic. Martin Luther, who had failed to agree with Zwingli over the Lord’s Supper at Marburg in 1529, called the death a judgement and repeatedly quoted the saying that those who take the sword perish by it. The Swiss Brethren, the first Anabaptists, had their own reasons. They had begun as Zwingli’s followers and broke with him over infant baptism and the use of force in religion. With his approval the Zurich council decreed death for rebaptism, and Felix Manz was drowned in the Limmat in January 1527. Their descendants’ chronicles remember Zwingli as a persecutor.

What is disputed

Whether Zwingli fought or only ministered is unresolved: Reformed writers stressed the chaplain, Catholic ones the armed man, and the weapons prove only that he carried them. His last words come from his own side and cannot be checked. Figures for the armies vary between accounts. Historians also differ on his responsibility. G. R. Potter and others note that he opposed the blockade as the worst of both courses; Bruce Gordon’s recent biography, subtitled ‘God’s Armed Prophet’, argues that he had nonetheless tied the gospel to the power of the Zurich state in a way that made war likely.

What followed

A second defeat on the Gubel a fortnight later forced peace. The treaty of 20 November 1531 let each canton keep its own faith and protected Catholic minorities, though not Protestant ones, in the shared territories. It froze the Reformation’s advance in German-speaking Switzerland and set a pattern of religious coexistence by territory that the Empire adopted at Augsburg in 1555. Under Bullinger, Zurich remained a centre of Reformed thought and joined forces with Calvin’s Geneva in 1549. In 2004 the Reformed church of Zurich formally asked forgiveness of the Anabaptists’ descendants.

Read further

  • G. R. Potter, Zwingli (1976)
  • Ulrich Gäbler, Huldrych Zwingli: His Life and Work (1986)
  • Bruce Gordon, The Swiss Reformation (2002)
  • Bruce Gordon, Zwingli: God’s Armed Prophet (2021)

Same day, other years

1138

An earthquake wrecks Aleppo

Aleppo, SyriaMiddle East

On 11 October 1138 a violent earthquake struck northern Syria, a region then divided between the Muslim atabeg Zengi and the Crusader principality of Antioch. The Damascus chronicler Ibn al-Qalanisi, a contemporary, records a first shock followed by scores more over the following weeks. Aleppo’s walls and citadel were badly damaged and people fled to the open country. West of the city the fortress of Atharib collapsed, killing its garrison of several hundred, and the Crusader castle at Harim was ruined. The shocks were felt as far as Damascus. The disaster lies on the Dead Sea fault system, the same family of faults that produced the earthquake of February 2023.

Seen from elsewhere. The death toll of 230,000 that puts this event on lists of the deadliest earthquakes in history comes from Ibn Taghribirdi, writing in Egypt three centuries later. Seismologists such as Nicholas Ambraseys think it merges several separate earthquakes of 1137-39, including one at Ganja in the Caucasus. The real figure is unknown.

1865

The Morant Bay rising in Jamaica

Morant Bay, JamaicaThe Americas

Slavery had ended in Jamaica in 1838, but a generation later the freed people and their children had little land, high taxes, no vote in practice and magistrates drawn from the planters. On 11 October 1865 Paul Bogle, a Baptist deacon from Stony Gut, led several hundred men and women to the courthouse at Morant Bay to protest. The militia fired on them; the crowd burned the building and killed eighteen people, including the chief magistrate. Governor Edward Eyre declared martial law. Troops and Maroon auxiliaries killed 439 people, flogged some 600 men and women and burned about a thousand homes. Bogle was hanged, as was George William Gordon, a mixed-race member of the assembly tried by court martial.

Seen from elsewhere. Eyre said he had saved the white population from a second Haiti, and Carlyle, Dickens and Tennyson defended him. John Stuart Mill, Darwin and Huxley tried to have him prosecuted for murder and failed. Jamaica lost its elected assembly and became a crown colony. Bogle and Gordon are now National Heroes there.

1899

The South African War begins

Transvaal and Natal, South AfricaAfrica

At five in the afternoon of 11 October 1899 an ultimatum from Paul Kruger’s South African Republic expired, and the Transvaal and its ally the Orange Free State were at war with the British Empire. The Boer republics had demanded that British troops be withdrawn from their borders; behind the dispute lay the gold of the Witwatersrand and the political rights of the foreign miners who dug it. Boer commandos invaded Natal and the Cape and besieged Ladysmith, Kimberley and Mafeking. Britain eventually put almost 450,000 men in the field. After two years of guerrilla war, farm burning and internment camps, the republics surrendered in May 1902.

Seen from elsewhere. Afrikaners remember the Second War of Freedom and the roughly 28,000 Boer civilians, most of them children, who died in British camps. At least 20,000 Black Africans died in separate camps, long left out of both sides’ histories. Britain claimed to fight for equal rights; the peace left the question of Black political rights to the defeated.

1962

The Second Vatican Council opens

Vatican CityWorldwide

On 11 October 1962 some 2,400 bishops from every continent processed into St Peter’s Basilica to open the twenty-first ecumenical council of the Catholic Church, the first in ninety-two years. Pope John XXIII, aged eighty and already ill with cancer, told them that the Church should today prefer the medicine of mercy to that of severity, and distanced himself from the ‘prophets of doom’ who saw only ruin in the modern world. Over four autumn sessions, concluded under Paul VI in 1965, the council approved worship in local languages, affirmed religious freedom, opened dialogue with other churches and, in the declaration Nostra aetate, rejected the charge that the Jewish people were collectively guilty of Christ’s death.

Seen from elsewhere. Traditionalists led by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre held that the council had broken with settled teaching, above all on liturgy and religious liberty, and blamed it for the collapse of vocations that followed. Others argue that its reforms were stalled by Rome afterwards. Whether it was a rupture or a development is still the central argument within Catholicism.

Also on 11 October