Parallax

7 October, 1571

Two galley fleets destroy each other at Lepanto

In four hours off the coast of Greece some forty thousand men died, more than in any sea battle before it. Christian Europe rang its bells for a generation. The Ottoman grand vizier said his master had merely had his beard trimmed.

Gulf of Patras, off Lepanto (Nafpaktos), Greece

The fleets sighted each other soon after dawn on Sunday 7 October, at the mouth of the Gulf of Patras. The Holy League, an alliance of Spain, Venice and the papacy assembled by Pope Pius V, had a little over two hundred galleys under Don John of Austria, the twenty-four-year-old illegitimate son of the emperor Charles V. The Ottoman fleet under Muezzinzade Ali Pasha was somewhat larger in hulls, with more than two hundred galleys and several dozen smaller craft, but lighter in guns and in armoured infantry. It was late in the season. Many Ottoman soldiers had already gone home for the winter, and Ali Pasha, a court favourite with little experience at sea, came out to fight on orders from Constantinople against the advice of some of his captains.

Don John had the iron rams sawn off his galleys so that the bow guns could be aimed lower. He went along the line in a fast boat holding up a crucifix, and had the banner of the League, blessed by the pope, raised on his flagship, the Real. Ahead of the line he had towed six Venetian galleasses, converted merchant galleys, high-sided and slow, carrying far heavier guns than any warship present.

The galleasses opened fire as the Ottoman line swept past them, and broke its order before the fleets met. Near the shore the Venetian left under Agostino Barbarigo was nearly outflanked through the shallows; Barbarigo lifted his visor to shout an order and took an arrow in the eye, but his galleys held and drove their opponents aground. In the centre the Real and Ali Pasha’s Sultana rammed each other and locked together. Spanish infantry and janissaries fought across the two decks for more than an hour, each side fed with reinforcements from the galleys astern, until Ali Pasha was killed. His head was raised on a pike and the Ottoman fleet’s great banner was hauled down.

On the seaward wing the battle nearly turned. The Algerian corsair Uluj Ali drew the Genoese admiral Gian Andrea Doria out to the south, then cut back through the gap, overran the galleys of Malta and took their standard. The League’s reserve under the Marquis of Santa Cruz closed the hole, and Uluj Ali escaped with thirty or forty ships, the only Ottoman squadron to do so.

By four in the afternoon the water was covered with wreckage and bodies. Some twelve thousand Christian slaves were freed from the Ottoman rowing benches. Aboard the galley Marquesa, a Spanish soldier of twenty-four who had left his sickbed to fight was hit twice in the chest and once in the left hand, which he never used again. He was Miguel de Cervantes.

How it came to this

The Ottoman Empire had been the leading power in the eastern Mediterranean for a century and by the 1560s was pressing west, in alliance with the corsair states of North Africa. Malta had barely survived a siege in 1565. In 1570 Sultan Selim II demanded that Venice hand over Cyprus, a rich island deep inside Ottoman waters, and when the republic refused he invaded it. Nicosia was stormed that September and some twenty thousand of its people were killed.

Venice, which usually preferred trade with the Ottomans to war, needed allies. Pius V spent a year coaxing Philip II of Spain, whose real concern was North Africa and who distrusted the Venetians, into a league signed in May 1571. While the fleet gathered at Messina, the last Venetian fortress on Cyprus, Famagusta, surrendered on terms after an eleven-month siege. The Ottoman commander, Lala Mustafa Pasha, then accused the Venetian governor, Marcantonio Bragadin, of having killed Muslim prisoners. He had Bragadin’s officers beheaded and Bragadin himself flayed alive. The news reached the League’s fleet at sea a few days before the battle.

How each side saw it

The Holy League and Catholic Europe

For Pius V the victory was the work of the Virgin Mary, obtained by the rosary processions he had ordered in Rome, and he established a feast on 7 October that is still kept as Our Lady of the Rosary. Venice painted it on the walls of the Doge’s Palace, Titian painted an allegory for Philip II, and Cervantes later called it the greatest occasion that past or present ages had seen. The allies themselves were less united than the paintings suggest. Venetians accused Doria of hanging back to save his own hired galleys, and Spain refused to follow up the victory in the east.

The Ottoman court and chroniclers

Ottoman historians such as Selaniki, Pecevi and later Katib Celebi called it the ‘routed fleet’ and treated it as a misfortune with human causes: an inexperienced admiral, a fleet out too long, crews depleted, orders from the capital that ignored the sailors. The grand vizier Sokollu Mehmed Pasha is reported by the Venetian envoy Barbaro to have said that in taking Cyprus the sultan had cut off Venice’s arm, while Venice in defeating the fleet had only shaved his beard, which would grow back thicker. The shipyards built some 150 galleys over the winter, and Uluj Ali took them to sea in 1572.

The men at the oars

Most of those present were rowers, and most of the rowers were not free. Ottoman galleys were pulled by Christian captives and conscripted villagers; Spanish and papal galleys by convicts and Muslim slaves; only Venice still relied largely on paid oarsmen. Before the battle Don John had the convicts unchained and promised them freedom if they fought. The Muslim slaves on his ships stayed in their chains. They left no testimony, and neither did the Greek rowers conscripted on the Ottoman side. Greeks of the Peloponnese who rose in the League’s support after the battle were left to face the reprisals alone.

Modern historians

Fernand Braudel argued that Lepanto changed little on the map but ended a real inferiority, breaking the belief that the Turks could not be beaten at sea. Andrew Hess, working from Ottoman and North African records, replied that the true outcome of these years was Ottoman: Cyprus kept, Tunis taken for good in 1574, and the Mediterranean divided along a line that then held. John Guilmartin stressed something neither government could quickly replace, the loss of thousands of trained archers, gunners and seamen. Few scholars now accept the old claim that the battle saved Europe from conquest.

What is disputed

Ship counts vary between sources by a dozen or more on each side, but the Ottoman fleet was the larger in vessels; older accounts that reverse this are mistaken. Casualties are estimates: perhaps 7,500 to 8,000 League dead and 25,000 to 30,000 Ottoman dead, with well over a hundred galleys captured. The vizier’s remark about the beard comes only from the Venetian side. Whether Doria’s move to seaward was prudence, incompetence or bad faith was argued at the time and never settled. The date is in the Julian calendar, then in use everywhere in Europe. The larger dispute is over significance, between a tradition that sees a turning point and historians who see a costly battle that confirmed a stalemate.

What followed

The League broke up. Venice made a separate peace in March 1573, giving up Cyprus and paying an indemnity, terms a victor does not usually accept. Don John took Tunis that year and the Ottomans took it back the next. Spain and the Ottoman Empire, each with wars elsewhere, agreed a truce in 1580 and left the inland sea to corsairs. Lepanto was the last great battle fought between oared ships. Cyprus stayed Ottoman until 1878, and the settlement of Turks there after 1571 is where the island’s Turkish community began.

Read further

  • Niccolo Capponi, Victory of the West: The Story of the Battle of Lepanto (2006)
  • Roger Crowley, Empires of the Sea: The Final Battle for the Mediterranean, 1521-1580 (2008)
  • Fernand Braudel, The Mediterranean and the Mediterranean World in the Age of Philip II (1949)
  • John Francis Guilmartin, Gunpowder and Galleys: Changing Technology and Mediterranean Warfare at Sea in the Sixteenth Century (1974)
  • Andrew C. Hess, ‘The Battle of Lepanto and Its Place in Mediterranean History’, Past and Present (1972)

Same day, other years

1763

George III draws a line down the Appalachians

London, and British North AmericaThe Americas

Britain had just won most of France’s North American empire, and with it a war on the frontier: that summer Native nations around the Great Lakes, under the Odawa leader Pontiac among others, had taken most of the British forts in the west. The Royal Proclamation issued on 7 October organised the new territories and declared the lands beyond the crest of the Appalachian mountains reserved to the Indian nations, ‘under our sovereignty, protection and dominion’. Colonists were forbidden to settle there, those already present were told to leave, and no private person could buy Indian land. Only the Crown could acquire it, at a public meeting held for the purpose.

Seen from elsewhere. Colonial settlers and land speculators, George Washington among them, treated the line as a temporary nuisance, and it became a grievance on the road to revolution. First Nations in Canada regard the Proclamation as recognising their title, and it is cited in the constitution of 1982. Its assertion of British sovereignty over their lands was made without asking them.

1944

The Sonderkommando revolt at Auschwitz-Birkenau

Auschwitz-Birkenau, German-occupied PolandEurope

The Sonderkommando were Jewish prisoners forced to work in the gas chambers and crematoria, and they were themselves killed at intervals. In the autumn of 1944, with the transports slowing and a selection of their own number under way, the men at Crematorium IV attacked their guards with hammers, axes and stones and set the building on fire. At Crematorium II others killed a German kapo and cut through the fence. Several hundred got out; all were hunted down. About 450 prisoners were killed that day and three SS men died. The gunpowder for their home-made grenades had been smuggled, a few spoonfuls at a time, by Jewish women working in a nearby munitions factory.

Seen from elsewhere. Four of those women, Roza Robota, Ala Gertner, Ester Wajcblum and Regina Safirsztajn, were hanged in January 1945, less than two weeks before the camp was evacuated. After the war the Sonderkommando were often judged as collaborators, a view Primo Levi questioned in his essay on the ‘grey zone’. Notes buried in the ash by Zalman Gradowski and Zalman Lewental give their own account.

1958

Pakistan’s president abolishes the constitution

Karachi, PakistanAsia

Pakistan’s first constitution was two and a half years old and the first general election under it was due within months when President Iskander Mirza cancelled both. On the evening of 7 October he abrogated the constitution, dismissed the government of Feroz Khan Noon, dissolved the national and provincial assemblies, banned political parties and declared martial law, naming the army commander, General Mohammad Ayub Khan, as its chief administrator. Mirza said the politicians had brought the country to ruin. Twenty days later Ayub’s generals called on Mirza at night and put him on an aeroplane to exile in London. Ayub ruled for more than ten years, the first of four military rulers in the country’s history.

Seen from elsewhere. Ayub called it a revolution, and many Pakistanis, tired of seven prime ministers in eleven years, welcomed it at first. The Supreme Court ruled that a successful coup creates its own legality. In East Pakistan, where most Pakistanis lived, the cancelled election was seen as a denial of the Bengali majority’s turn in power, a grievance that ended in the break-up of 1971.

2001

The United States begins bombing Afghanistan

Kabul, Kandahar and Jalalabad, AfghanistanAsia

Twenty-six days after the attacks of 11 September, American and British aircraft and cruise missiles struck Taliban air defences and al-Qaeda camps around Kabul, Kandahar and Jalalabad. President George W. Bush said the Taliban had been given the chance to hand over Osama bin Laden and close the camps, and had refused. On the ground the fighting was done largely by the Afghan forces of the Northern Alliance, with American special forces and air power in support. Kabul fell on 13 November and Kandahar in December. Bin Laden escaped into Pakistan. Foreign troops stayed for twenty years, and the Taliban returned to Kabul in August 2021 as the last of them left.

Seen from elsewhere. The Taliban had offered to discuss handing bin Laden to a third country if shown evidence, which Washington rejected as stalling. The United States cited self-defence under the UN Charter; some international lawyers argued that this did not cover overthrowing a government. Brown University’s Costs of War project counts more than 46,000 Afghan civilians among the dead of the war.

Also on 7 October