Parallax

28 October, 1533

A Medici orphan marries into the French royal house

Two fourteen-year-olds were married by the pope in Marseille to seal an alliance that collapsed within a year. The bride outlived it by half a century and became the most reviled queen in French history.

Marseille, France

Pope Clement VII sailed into Marseille in October 1533 with a fleet of galleys, a train of cardinals and the girl he had spent years trying to marry well. Catherine de’ Medici was fourteen. Her parents had both died within weeks of her birth in Florence in 1519, and she had been raised as the last legitimate heir of the senior Medici line, a valuable and vulnerable piece on Italy’s board. During the siege of Florence in 1529 and 1530, when the city had expelled the Medici, the republican government held her in a convent, and there was talk of using her as a hostage on the walls.

The groom was Henri, Duke of Orleans, second son of Francis I, born a few weeks before her. He had spent four years of his childhood as a hostage in Spain, exchanged with his elder brother for their captured father after the battle of Pavia, and had come back a silent, withdrawn boy. The marriage was a bargain between his father and her kinsman. Francis wanted papal support for his ambitions in Italy against the emperor Charles V. Clement wanted a French alliance and a crown for his family.

The contract was signed on 27 October, and on the 28th the pope himself celebrated the marriage. The dowry was 100,000 ecus in gold, with jewels including large pearls that would later pass to Mary, Queen of Scots, and secret promises of Italian territories that were never delivered. A widely repeated report has Francis staying to see the marriage consummated that night, and the pope visiting the couple the next morning, both concerned that nobody could later claim the match had not been completed.

Within a year the bargain looked bad. Clement died in September 1534, and his successor, Paul III, refused to pay the rest of the dowry or honour the promises. A Medici, the merchant family of Florence, had married a son of France and brought nothing that lasted. At court Catherine was called the Italian, and worse. Then, in 1536, Henri’s elder brother the dauphin died suddenly after a game of tennis and a cold drink, and the obscure bride was suddenly married to the heir to the throne.

For ten years she had no children, while Henri gave his devotion to Diane de Poitiers, a widow some twenty years his senior. There was serious talk of divorce. Catherine survived it by courting the king and keeping on good terms with Diane. From 1544 she had ten children in twelve years. Three of her sons would become kings of France.

How it came to this

The Medici had risen through banking in fifteenth century Florence and ruled the city in all but name. They were expelled in 1494, restored in 1512, expelled again in 1527 and restored once more in 1530 by the armies of Charles V, the same emperor who had sacked Rome in 1527 and held Clement prisoner. Two Medici popes, Leo X and Clement VII, had turned the family into a European dynasty, but they lacked the royal blood that ancient houses respected. Catherine’s mother was French, a La Tour d’Auvergne, which made her acceptable as a bride, though only just.

France and the Habsburgs had fought over Italy since 1494. Francis I had been captured by Charles V’s army at Pavia in 1525 and released only after handing over his two eldest sons as hostages. He was eager for any ally against the emperor, including, at times, the Ottoman sultan. The marriage was a move in that larger game, and both sides assumed it would bring France territory in Italy. It brought instead a woman who, as queen mother, would govern France through a generation of civil war.

How each side saw it

Huguenot pamphleteers

Catherine’s black legend was largely written by French Protestants after the St Bartholomew’s Day massacre of 1572. A pamphlet of 1575, the Discours merveilleux, presented her as a scheming Italian steeped in Machiavelli, a poisoner and a corrupter of her sons, who had planned the destruction of the Huguenots for years. Its themes, foreignness, low merchant birth, sorcery and sexual intrigue, set the image that Dumas and countless popular histories, including the book behind this entry, have repeated. It was propaganda written by the victims of a massacre, which explains both its anger and its distortions.

Catherine’s own letters

Catherine wrote or dictated thousands of letters, published in ten volumes between 1880 and 1909. They show a ruler working ceaselessly, often to keep an impossible peace: she backed the Colloquy of Poissy in 1561, where Catholic and Protestant theologians met, and the edict of January 1562 that allowed Protestant worship outside towns. She thought of politics in terms of keeping the crown and her children on top, not of doctrine, and she spent years on the road, touring the kingdom with Charles IX from 1564 to 1566 to show the young king to his subjects.

The French nobility

To the great houses of France, the Guises, the Bourbons and the Montmorencys, Catherine was first a foreigner of insufficient birth and then an obstacle. Each faction wanted to control the young kings, and each accused her of favouring the others. The Catholic League eventually saw her as too soft on heresy, the Protestants as its chief persecutor. Brantome, a courtier who admired her, wrote in his memoirs of her intelligence, her love of hunting and riding, and her household of beautiful ladies, which later writers turned into the legend of a flying squadron of seductive spies.

Modern historians

Since the 1960s historians such as N. M. Sutherland and Robert Knecht have rebuilt Catherine as a pragmatic politician who tried compromise, failed and then made catastrophic decisions under pressure. Most now hold that she, with Charles IX and his council, ordered the killing of the Huguenot leaders in August 1572, fearing their revenge after the botched assassination of Admiral Coligny, but that the general slaughter in Paris and the provinces went far beyond what the court planned. Some see in the old portrait as much misogyny as evidence.

What is disputed

Clement VII is usually called Catherine’s uncle; he was in fact her father’s cousin. The report of Francis watching the consummation, and the quip attributed to him that he had received the girl quite naked, are late and unverified. The book’s anecdotes of potions of mule’s urine and a spy hole above Diane’s bedroom come from hostile or much later sources. The claim that she brought the fork to France is a nineteenth century legend. The book’s lines attributed to Philip II and an unnamed contemporary could not be traced to a reliable source and are left out here.

What followed

Henri became king in 1547 and died after a jousting accident in 1559. Catherine then governed, formally or in practice, through the reigns of Francis II, Charles IX and Henri III, across eight wars of religion. She died at Blois in January 1589, days after Henri III had the Duke of Guise murdered there; her last son was assassinated that August and the Valois line ended. She left the Tuileries palace in Paris, the long gallery over the Cher at Chenonceau, and a reputation that historians are still repairing.

Read further

  • R. J. Knecht, Catherine de’ Medici (1998)
  • Leonie Frieda, Catherine de Medici (2003)
  • N. M. Sutherland, The Massacre of St Bartholomew and the European Conflict, 1559-1572 (1973)
  • Mack P. Holt, The French Wars of Religion, 1562-1629 (1995)

Same day, other years

1492

Columbus reaches Cuba

North-east coast of CubaThe Americas

Sixteen days after his first landfall in the Bahamas, Christopher Columbus sailed into a harbour on the north-eastern coast of a large island its Taino inhabitants called Cuba. He wrote in his journal that it was the most beautiful land human eyes had seen, and he believed he might have reached the mainland of Asia, sending two men inland to look for the court of the Great Khan. They found villages and people smoking rolled leaves of tobacco. Spain conquered the island from 1511 under Diego Velazquez, and within a few decades the Taino population had collapsed from violence, forced labour and disease.

Seen from elsewhere. The Taino left no written account; much of what we know of the conquest comes from Bartolome de las Casas, who took part in it and later became its fiercest critic. He recorded the burning of the chief Hatuey in 1512. The exact landing place is disputed between Bariay Bay and Gibara.

1918

Czechoslovakia is proclaimed in Prague

Prague, BohemiaEurope

As the Habsburg monarchy disintegrated in the last weeks of the First World War, the Czech National Committee in Prague took over the grain office, then the government of the Czech lands, and declared an independent Czechoslovak state. Its leaders abroad, Tomas Masaryk and Edvard Benes, had already won Allied recognition, helped by the Czechoslovak Legion’s fighting in Russia. Two days later Slovak leaders meeting at Martin declared that Slovakia would join. Masaryk returned in December as president of the new republic, one of the few in central Europe that remained a democracy through the 1930s.

Seen from elsewhere. About three million German speakers in Bohemia and Moravia declared their own provinces and wanted to join Austria; Czech troops occupied them, and protests in March 1919 left over fifty dead. Many Slovaks later felt the state was run by and for Czechs, a grievance that outlived it.

1922

The king refuses to stop the March on Rome

Rome, ItalyEurope

Through the night of 27 October Fascist squads seized prefectures and telegraph offices across northern and central Italy, while columns of Blackshirts, poorly armed and soaked by rain, gathered at points outside Rome. The prime minister, Luigi Facta, prepared a decree of martial law and the army was ready to enforce it. On the morning of the 28th King Victor Emmanuel III refused to sign. Facta resigned. Mussolini, who had stayed in Milan close to the Swiss border, was invited to form a government and arrived in Rome by sleeping car on the 30th. His followers marched in afterwards.

Seen from elsewhere. Fascism made the March its founding myth of a revolution seized by force. Historians generally see a bluff that worked because the king, conservatives and army leaders preferred Mussolini to the risk of confrontation. The king’s reasons, fear of civil war or of his pro-Fascist cousin the Duke of Aosta, are still debated.

1962

Khrushchev agrees to remove the missiles from Cuba

Moscow and HavanaThe Americas

On the thirteenth day of the crisis, Radio Moscow broadcast a message from Nikita Khrushchev to John F. Kennedy: the Soviet Union would dismantle its missiles in Cuba and ship them home under United Nations verification, in return for an American pledge not to invade the island. A further concession, the withdrawal of American Jupiter missiles from Turkey, had been agreed the night before by Robert Kennedy and the Soviet ambassador, Anatoly Dobrynin, on condition that it stay secret. It did, for decades, and the public story became one of Soviet retreat.

Seen from elsewhere. Fidel Castro heard the news on the radio and was furious that Moscow had decided over his head. He refused UN inspectors on Cuban soil and issued his own five demands, including the return of Guantanamo Bay. To many Cubans the deal confirmed that the superpowers saw the island as a pawn.

Also on 28 October