Parallax

24 October, 1648

The Peace of Westphalia is signed

It took four years of talks in two towns, with the armies still fighting, to end a war that had killed perhaps a fifth of the people of Germany. What exactly the diplomats agreed has been argued about ever since.

Munster, Westphalia

On Saturday 24 October 1648 the envoys of the Holy Roman Emperor, of France and of Sweden did not meet in one room to end the Thirty Years War. They signed in their separate lodgings in the cathedral city of Munster, and secretaries carried the documents through the streets from one house to the next for most of the afternoon. When the last seal was on, towards nine in the evening, the cannon on the walls fired three salvoes, seventy guns each time. There was no ceremony beyond that. Too many questions of precedence stood in the way of one.

There were two treaties, because there had been two congresses. Catholic France would not sit down with the Protestant powers under the eye of a papal mediator, so since 1644 the French had negotiated with the Emperor at Munster, and the Swedes thirty miles away at Protestant Osnabruck, with couriers riding between. In all, some hundred and nine delegations came, representing nearly every state in Europe except England, Russia and the Ottoman Empire. It was the largest diplomatic gathering the continent had seen, and it had no chairman, no agenda and no rules.

It also had no armistice. The war went on outside, and every victory or defeat changed what the envoys were prepared to concede. The first six months were spent on who might be addressed as ‘Excellency’ and who entered a room first. The leading imperial envoy, Count Maximilian von Trauttmansdorff, did most of the real work in 1646 and 1647 and went home exhausted before the end. The mediators, the papal nuncio Fabio Chigi and the Venetian Alvise Contarini, passed proposals between men who would not meet.

The terms ran to hundreds of clauses. The religious settlement of 1555 was extended to Calvinists. Church lands were to belong to whichever confession had held them on 1 January 1624, and a ruler who changed his faith could no longer compel his subjects to follow. Sweden received western Pomerania, the bishoprics of Bremen and Verden, and five million thalers to pay off its soldiers. France obtained the Habsburg rights in Alsace. The Swiss cantons were recognised as outside the Empire. The German princes kept the right to make alliances, provided these were not aimed at the Emperor.

Even on the day of signing the Swedes were still fighting for Prague, where students and townsmen held the Charles Bridge against them. News of the peace reached the city some days later. Across Germany church bells were rung and thanksgiving services held, though the foreign garrisons did not leave until they had been paid, which in some places took until 1654.

How it came to this

The war began in Bohemia in May 1618, when Protestant nobles threw two of the Habsburg king’s Catholic governors out of a window of Prague Castle and elected a Calvinist prince in his place. The Emperor Ferdinand II crushed the revolt at the White Mountain in 1620, confiscated the rebels’ estates and set about restoring Catholicism by force, first in his own lands and then, as his armies advanced, across northern Germany. That drew in Denmark, and in 1630 Sweden under Gustavus Adolphus.

What had started as a quarrel over religion and the constitution of the Empire became a contest among the European powers fought on German soil. From 1635 Catholic France, directed by Cardinal Richelieu, fought openly beside Protestant Sweden against the Catholic Habsburgs of Vienna and Madrid. Armies lived off the land they crossed, friend’s or enemy’s, and brought typhus, plague and famine with them. The sack of Magdeburg in 1631, in which some twenty thousand people died, became a byword. By the 1640s there was little left to take, and no party believed any longer that it could win outright.

How each side saw it

The papacy

Rome’s representative at Munster, Fabio Chigi, refused to put his name to a treaty that gave bishoprics and monasteries to Protestants and recognised heresy in law, and lodged a formal protest. Pope Innocent X followed with the brief Zelo Domus Dei, dated November 1648, which declared the religious articles null, void, unjust and without effect for all time. The negotiators had foreseen this: the treaties contain a clause stating that no protest, from any quarter, shall be valid against them. Catholic rulers ignored the brief. It marks the point at which the papacy ceased to be a party to European peace-making.

The Bohemian exiles

The war had begun as a Bohemian Protestant revolt, and the peace left Bohemia to the Habsburgs. The date fixed for restoring church property, 1624, fell after the Catholic reconquest there, and the Emperor refused any concession in his hereditary lands. Some 150,000 Protestants had already emigrated. Their most famous spokesman, the educator and bishop of the Unity of Brethren Jan Amos Comenius, wrote bitterly to the Swedish chancellor Axel Oxenstierna that his people, who had trusted Sweden, had been abandoned. Czech national tradition long remembered the following century and a half as the time of darkness.

Soldiers and villagers

Two diaries give the view from below. Peter Hagendorf, a mercenary who marched some fifteen thousand miles in twenty-five years, records the battles in a line or two and the deaths of his first wife and most of his children at greater length; when peace came his regiment was paid off and he had to look for work. Hans Heberle, a shoemaker from a village near Ulm, counted thirty times that he and his family fled behind the city walls. He noted the thanksgiving festival for the peace and added that people had celebrated it as heartily as any Christmas.

German nationalist historians

For writers of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries the peace was a national catastrophe. In their account it sealed the division of Germany into some three hundred petty states, handed German land to Sweden and France, and gave foreign powers a legal right to meddle in German affairs for the next century and a half. The view was pushed to an extreme under National Socialism, which described the treaty as the origin of French designs on the Rhine. Since 1945 German historians have largely reversed the judgment, presenting the Empire after 1648 as a working system of law that kept the peace among its members.

What is disputed

The date is by the new calendar; Protestant Germany, still on the old one, wrote 14 October. Population loss in the Empire is variously estimated: older accounts spoke of half or more, while Peter Wilson and others now put it at fifteen to twenty per cent overall, some five million people, with far worse in regions such as Pomerania and Wurttemberg. The larger dispute is over what the peace meant. Textbooks of international relations date the system of sovereign, equal states from 1648. Historians such as Andreas Osiander and Derek Croxton point out that the treaties say nothing of the kind and call this the ‘Westphalian myth’.

What followed

The peace did not end all the fighting: France and Spain continued their war until 1659. Within the Empire the settlement held. The rules on religion, enforced through the imperial courts, largely ended confessional warfare in Germany, and the treaties were treated as the Empire’s fundamental law until Napoleon dissolved it in 1806. The Habsburgs, checked in Germany, turned their attention to the Danube. Sweden emerged as a great power and France as the strongest state in Europe. The congress itself set a pattern followed at Utrecht, Vienna and Versailles: a general war ended by a general conference.

Read further

  • Peter H. Wilson, Europe’s Tragedy: A History of the Thirty Years War (2009)
  • C. V. Wedgwood, The Thirty Years War (1938)
  • Derek Croxton, Westphalia: The Last Christian Peace (2013)
  • Geoffrey Parker (editor), The Thirty Years’ War (1984)
  • Hans Jakob Christoffel von Grimmelshausen, Simplicissimus (1668)

Same day, other years

1260

Baybars kills the sultan and takes his place

Near al-Salihiyya, EgyptMiddle East

Seven weeks earlier the Mamluk army of Egypt had beaten a Mongol force at Ain Jalut in Palestine, the first serious check to the Mongols in the west. The sultan, Qutuz, was on his way home in triumph when he turned aside to hunt on the edge of the Nile delta. A group of his own emirs rode up to him; one took his hand as if to kiss it and held it while the others struck. Among them was Baybars, a Kipchak Turk sold into slavery as a boy, who had commanded the vanguard in the battle and, it is said, been refused the governorship of Aleppo. The army accepted him as sultan the same day. He reigned for seventeen years.

Seen from elsewhere. Baybars’s own secretary and biographer, Ibn Abd al-Zahir, says his master struck the fatal blow himself and treats it as no stain. To the Crusader states he was a destroyer who took Caesarea, Jaffa and Antioch and enslaved their people. In Arabic popular tradition he became the hero of a vast folk epic still recited in the twentieth century.

1871

A mob lynches Chinese residents of Los Angeles

Los Angeles, CaliforniaThe Americas

Los Angeles in 1871 was a town of under six thousand people with a Chinese quarter of fewer than two hundred, crowded into an alley known as Calle de los Negros. On the evening of 24 October a gunfight between two rival Chinese associations led to the shooting of a white rancher who had joined a policeman in the pursuit. Word spread that the Chinese were killing whites. A crowd of about five hundred men surrounded the alley, broke through roofs and doors, and dragged out anyone they found. Seventeen or eighteen Chinese men and boys were shot or hanged from gateposts and wagons, among them a respected doctor, Gene Tong. Almost none had had anything to do with the feud.

Seen from elsewhere. Eight rioters were convicted of manslaughter. The California Supreme Court overturned the verdicts on a flaw in the indictment, and no one was retried. Chinese witnesses could not testify against white defendants under state law. The city largely forgot the event for over a century; a memorial was commissioned only in the 2020s.

1964

Northern Rhodesia becomes Zambia

Lusaka, ZambiaAfrica

At midnight the Union flag came down at the Independence Stadium in Lusaka and the new republic’s green flag with its orange eagle went up. Kenneth Kaunda, a former teacher who had been jailed by the colonial government five years earlier, became president at forty. The territory had been run first by Cecil Rhodes’s chartered company and then by the Colonial Office, and from 1953 to 1963 had been tied against the wishes of most Africans to white-ruled Southern Rhodesia in a federation that took much of its copper revenue. The company still held the mineral royalties; it surrendered them in a deal concluded only hours before independence. The new state had about a hundred African university graduates.

Seen from elsewhere. Independence was not peaceful for everyone. That summer the government had sent troops against the Lumpa Church of the prophetess Alice Lenshina, whose followers refused party membership; more than seven hundred died. Kaunda made Zambia a one-party state in 1972, sheltered the liberation movements of its neighbours at great cost, and gave up power after losing an election in 1991.

1975

The women of Iceland take the day off

Reykjavik, IcelandEurope

The United Nations had declared 1975 International Women’s Year, and Icelandic women’s organisations decided to mark it by showing what happened when women stopped working. On Friday 24 October about ninety per cent of the women in the country did no paid work, no cooking, no cleaning and no childcare. Some twenty-five thousand, in a nation of 220,000, gathered in the centre of Reykjavik. Banks, schools, nurseries, fish factories and telephone exchanges closed or ran short. Newspapers did not appear because the typesetters were women. Fathers took children to the office, and shops are said to have sold out of sausages, the easiest thing to cook. Parliament passed an equal rights law the following year.

Seen from elsewhere. The radical Red Stockings had wanted a strike. It was called a ‘day off’ to bring in conservative women and to protect participants from dismissal, and that compromise is credited with its scale. The pay gap did not close: Icelandic women have repeated the action several times, most recently in 2023, when the prime minister joined them.

Also on 24 October