Balian of Ibelin had not meant to defend Jerusalem. He had escaped the disaster at Hattin in July and asked Saladin for safe conduct to fetch his wife, Maria Comnena, and their children from the city, promising to stay a single night and never to bear arms against the sultan again. When he arrived the patriarch and the townspeople would not let him leave. There were, by the account of his squire Ernoul, only two other knights in the place. Balian wrote to Saladin to explain that he was breaking his oath under compulsion. Saladin accepted the excuse and sent an escort to take Balian’s family to the coast.
The city was full of refugees, sixty thousand people if the Arab chroniclers are right, most of them women and children. Balian knighted the sons of townsmen and boys of noble family to make up numbers. Saladin’s army arrived on 20 September and attacked the western wall for five days without result. He then moved his camp to the north-east, where the crusaders themselves had broken in during 1099, set his siege engines to work and sent sappers under the wall. On 29 September a stretch of it collapsed.
The defenders had already asked for terms and been refused. Saladin had sworn, he said, to take Jerusalem by the sword as the Franks had taken it. Balian went out to him in person. According to the Arab historian Ibn al-Athir, he told the sultan that if no mercy was offered the garrison would kill their own families, burn their goods, slaughter the five thousand Muslim prisoners they held, pull down the Dome of the Rock and the Aqsa mosque, and then come out to die fighting. Saladin consulted his emirs and his jurists, who found that a negotiated surrender after a breach could count as satisfying his oath.
The price was ten dinars for a man, five for a woman and one for a child, to be paid within forty days. For seven thousand of the poor Balian handed over thirty thousand dinars, money that Henry II of England had deposited with the Hospitallers. On Friday 2 October, the 27th of Rajab in the Muslim calendar and the anniversary of the Prophet’s night journey to the city, Saladin’s banners went up on the walls.
There was no killing. Guards were posted in the streets. The gilded cross that the crusaders had set on the Dome of the Rock was taken down, the Aqsa mosque, which had been the Templars’ headquarters, was washed with rose water, and a pulpit made years earlier in Aleppo for this day was installed. The ransomed left in three columns for the coast. Those who could not pay did not.
How it came to this
The First Crusade had taken Jerusalem in July 1099 and killed most of the Muslims and Jews it found there. The kingdom founded afterwards survived for decades because its neighbours were divided: Fatimid Egypt and the Syrian cities fought each other as readily as the Franks. That ended when Saladin, a Kurdish officer in the service of the ruler of Damascus, made himself master of Egypt in 1171 and then, over the next fifteen years, of Damascus, Aleppo and Mosul. He presented each step as preparation for holy war, though his critics noted how much of it was fought against other Muslims.
The Franks meanwhile were ruled by Baldwin IV, a capable king dying of leprosy, and after 1186 by his sister Sibylla and her husband Guy of Lusignan, whom much of the nobility despised. When Reynald of Chatillon attacked a Muslim caravan in breach of a truce, Saladin had his cause. On 4 July 1187, at the Horns of Hattin above the Sea of Galilee, he destroyed the kingdom’s field army, captured the king and the relic of the True Cross, and had the Templar and Hospitaller prisoners beheaded. The castles and ports had been stripped of men to fill that army. Most of them fell within weeks.