Parallax

2 October, 1187

Saladin takes Jerusalem without a massacre

Eighty-eight years after crusaders stormed the city and killed its people, a Kurdish sultan stood outside the same walls having sworn to do the same. He was talked out of it by a knight who threatened to burn the place down.

Jerusalem

Balian of Ibelin had not meant to defend Jerusalem. He had escaped the disaster at Hattin in July and asked Saladin for safe conduct to fetch his wife, Maria Comnena, and their children from the city, promising to stay a single night and never to bear arms against the sultan again. When he arrived the patriarch and the townspeople would not let him leave. There were, by the account of his squire Ernoul, only two other knights in the place. Balian wrote to Saladin to explain that he was breaking his oath under compulsion. Saladin accepted the excuse and sent an escort to take Balian’s family to the coast.

The city was full of refugees, sixty thousand people if the Arab chroniclers are right, most of them women and children. Balian knighted the sons of townsmen and boys of noble family to make up numbers. Saladin’s army arrived on 20 September and attacked the western wall for five days without result. He then moved his camp to the north-east, where the crusaders themselves had broken in during 1099, set his siege engines to work and sent sappers under the wall. On 29 September a stretch of it collapsed.

The defenders had already asked for terms and been refused. Saladin had sworn, he said, to take Jerusalem by the sword as the Franks had taken it. Balian went out to him in person. According to the Arab historian Ibn al-Athir, he told the sultan that if no mercy was offered the garrison would kill their own families, burn their goods, slaughter the five thousand Muslim prisoners they held, pull down the Dome of the Rock and the Aqsa mosque, and then come out to die fighting. Saladin consulted his emirs and his jurists, who found that a negotiated surrender after a breach could count as satisfying his oath.

The price was ten dinars for a man, five for a woman and one for a child, to be paid within forty days. For seven thousand of the poor Balian handed over thirty thousand dinars, money that Henry II of England had deposited with the Hospitallers. On Friday 2 October, the 27th of Rajab in the Muslim calendar and the anniversary of the Prophet’s night journey to the city, Saladin’s banners went up on the walls.

There was no killing. Guards were posted in the streets. The gilded cross that the crusaders had set on the Dome of the Rock was taken down, the Aqsa mosque, which had been the Templars’ headquarters, was washed with rose water, and a pulpit made years earlier in Aleppo for this day was installed. The ransomed left in three columns for the coast. Those who could not pay did not.

How it came to this

The First Crusade had taken Jerusalem in July 1099 and killed most of the Muslims and Jews it found there. The kingdom founded afterwards survived for decades because its neighbours were divided: Fatimid Egypt and the Syrian cities fought each other as readily as the Franks. That ended when Saladin, a Kurdish officer in the service of the ruler of Damascus, made himself master of Egypt in 1171 and then, over the next fifteen years, of Damascus, Aleppo and Mosul. He presented each step as preparation for holy war, though his critics noted how much of it was fought against other Muslims.

The Franks meanwhile were ruled by Baldwin IV, a capable king dying of leprosy, and after 1186 by his sister Sibylla and her husband Guy of Lusignan, whom much of the nobility despised. When Reynald of Chatillon attacked a Muslim caravan in breach of a truce, Saladin had his cause. On 4 July 1187, at the Horns of Hattin above the Sea of Galilee, he destroyed the kingdom’s field army, captured the king and the relic of the True Cross, and had the Templar and Hospitaller prisoners beheaded. The castles and ports had been stripped of men to fill that army. Most of them fell within weeks.

How each side saw it

Saladin’s secretaries and the Arab chroniclers

Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani, who was with the sultan, and Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad, his later biographer, describe the day as the cleansing of the third holiest city of Islam after ninety years of pollution, timed by God to the anniversary of the night journey. They stress Saladin’s restraint and generosity, and Imad ad-Din complains that greedy officials let the ransom money leak away. Ibn al-Athir, who served the rival Zengid dynasty of Mosul and was no admirer, records the same facts but criticises Saladin for letting so many Franks go free to Tyre, where they gathered and held out.

The Franks of Jerusalem

The chronicle attributed to Ernoul, Balian’s squire, and the Old French continuations of William of Tyre tell it as a shameful loss redeemed by one man’s nerve. They are bitter about the patriarch Heraclius and the military orders, who paid their own ransoms and left with the church plate while thousands of the poor stayed behind. They also record, with some surprise, that Saladin’s brother al-Adil asked for a thousand captives as a gift and freed them, and that the sultan released the old and gave money to the widows and orphans of knights.

Those who were not ransomed

The people for whom no one paid left no account. Imad ad-Din gives their number as about fifteen thousand, seven thousand men and eight thousand women and children, and describes their sale into slavery in language that celebrates the humiliation of the women. Modern admirers of Saladin’s clemency tend to pass over them. Even some who reached Christian territory were robbed on the road or turned away from the gates of Tripoli, according to the Frankish writers, so that many fared worse among their own side than they had under the sultan’s escort.

Eastern Christians and Jews

Greek Orthodox, Syrian and Armenian Christians had been second-class under the Latin church, which had taken their shrines. They were allowed to stay on payment of the poll tax, and the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, closed for three days, was handed to the Orthodox clergy. Latin writers accused the Greeks of having plotted to open the gates. Jews, who had been barred from living in the city under the crusaders, were permitted to return; the poet Judah al-Harizi, visiting some thirty years later, credits Saladin with the invitation, though how many came at once is not known.

What is disputed

The numbers come from interested parties and do not agree: the count of those enslaved ranges from about eleven thousand in the Frankish tradition to fifteen thousand or more in Imad ad-Din. Balian’s speech is reported by Ibn al-Athir, who was not present. Historians also differ on Saladin’s motives. The older view, shaped by Walter Scott and by Stanley Lane-Poole, made him a model of chivalry; Andrew Ehrenkreutz portrayed a calculating dynast, and Malcolm Lyons and D. E. P. Jackson a pragmatist for whom a ransomed city was worth more than a ruined one.

What followed

Pope Gregory VIII called a new crusade within the month. Richard I of England and Philip II of France reached the coast in 1191, retook Acre and fought Saladin to a standstill, but Richard never attacked Jerusalem. The treaty of 1192 left the city Muslim and open to Christian pilgrims. Saladin died the following March. Apart from two spells under treaty between 1229 and 1244, Jerusalem stayed under Muslim rule until 1917. Both the massacre of 1099 and the surrender of 1187 are still invoked in arguments over the city.

Read further

  • Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad, The Rare and Excellent History of Saladin, translated by D. S. Richards (2001)
  • Francesco Gabrieli, Arab Historians of the Crusades (1969)
  • Malcolm Cameron Lyons and D. E. P. Jackson, Saladin: The Politics of the Holy War (1982)
  • Jonathan Phillips, The Life and Legend of the Sultan Saladin (2019)
  • Carole Hillenbrand, The Crusades: Islamic Perspectives (1999)

Same day, other years

1836

Darwin comes home

Falmouth, EnglandEurope

HMS Beagle anchored at Falmouth on a wet, stormy night after four years and nine months at sea. Charles Darwin, who had joined at twenty-two as an unpaid naturalist and companion to the captain, left the ship at once and took the mail coach for Shrewsbury, arriving at his father’s house two days later. He had been seasick for most of the voyage. He brought back thousands of specimens, notebooks on the geology of South America, and the finches and mockingbirds of the Galapagos, whose significance he had not yet grasped. He never left Britain again. The theory he drew from the voyage stayed in his desk for more than twenty years.

Seen from elsewhere. Robert FitzRoy, the Beagle’s captain and a devout man, came to regret having carried him. At the Oxford debate of 1860 he is reported to have stood holding a Bible and begged the audience to believe God rather than man. The three Fuegians FitzRoy had taken to England and returned on this voyage left no account of their own.

1904

Von Trotha orders the destruction of the Herero

Osombo-Windimbe, German South West Africa (Namibia)Africa

Seven weeks after defeating the Herero at the Waterberg and driving the survivors into the waterless Omaheke, the German commander, Lieutenant General Lothar von Trotha, issued a proclamation to them. The Herero, it said, were no longer German subjects and must leave the country. Any Herero found within the German borders, with or without a gun, with or without cattle, would be shot, and he would take in no more women or children but drive them back to their people or have them fired on. Patrols sealed the waterholes along the desert’s edge. Berlin withdrew the order in December, and survivors were put in camps where about half of the prisoners died.

Seen from elsewhere. An estimated 65,000 of 80,000 Herero died, and some 10,000 Nama. Von Trotha defended it as a race war that had to be finished; his own governor, Theodor Leutwein, objected. Germany acknowledged a genocide in 2021 and offered 1.1 billion euros in aid. Many Herero and Nama leaders rejected the deal as negotiated without them and as avoiding the word reparations.

1958

Guinea walks out of the French empire

Conakry, GuineaAfrica

Four days earlier, Charles de Gaulle had asked every French colony in Africa to vote on joining a new French Community. All said yes but one. In Guinea, urged on by the trade unionist Ahmed Sekou Toure, more than ninety-five per cent voted no, and on 2 October the territory declared itself an independent republic with Toure as president. He had told de Gaulle to his face in August that Guineans preferred poverty in freedom to riches in slavery. France’s reply was immediate. Officials, doctors and teachers were withdrawn, aid was stopped, and departing staff took files, equipment and, by many accounts, even the light bulbs.

Seen from elsewhere. Paris held that Guinea had chosen secession and must bear its cost; the punishment deterred no one, and most of France’s African colonies were independent within two years. Toure ruled until 1984 as head of a one-party state. Thousands of Guineans, the number is disputed, died in his prison at Camp Boiro, and a large part of the population went into exile.

1968

Troops fire on a student rally at Tlatelolco

Mexico City, MexicoThe Americas

Ten days before Mexico was to open the Olympic Games, several thousand students and local residents gathered in the Plaza de las Tres Culturas, in the Tlatelolco housing estate, after a summer of marches against police violence and one-party rule. Soldiers and armoured cars surrounded the square. At about ten past six in the evening flares dropped from a helicopter and shooting began, some of it from men in civilian clothes wearing a white glove on one hand, members of a presidential guard unit called the Olimpia Battalion. The firing went on for more than an hour. Hundreds of people were arrested, stripped and beaten. The Games opened on schedule.

Seen from elsewhere. The government of Gustavo Diaz Ordaz said armed students had fired first and put the dead at about two dozen. Witnesses and foreign reporters spoke of some three hundred. Documents released after 2000 showed that government snipers began the shooting; researchers have so far confirmed around forty-four deaths by name. No one was convicted.

Also on 2 October