Parallax

9 December, 1868

Gladstone’s first government takes office

He was chopping down a tree when the telegram came. He read it, went back to the axe, and then announced what he meant to do with the British Empire’s most intractable problem.

London and Hawarden, Britain

On the afternoon of 1 December 1868 William Ewart Gladstone, aged 58, was in his shirtsleeves in the park at Hawarden, his wife’s family estate in north Wales, taking an axe to a tree. Felling timber was his recreation, as theology and Homer were his study. A telegram was brought out to him. It said that General Grey, the Queen’s private secretary, was on his way from Windsor. Evelyn Ashley, a young guest who was holding Gladstone’s coat, recorded what followed. Gladstone read the message, remarked ‘Very significant’, and went on chopping. After some minutes he rested on the axe and said, with great earnestness: ‘My mission is to pacify Ireland.’ Then he finished the tree.

The summons was no surprise. The general election of November 1868, the first held under the wider franchise of the Second Reform Act, had given the Liberals a majority of more than a hundred. Gladstone himself had been beaten in South-West Lancashire and came in for Greenwich instead. Benjamin Disraeli, the Conservative Prime Minister, did something no predecessor had done: he resigned at once on the verdict of the voters, without waiting to be defeated in the Commons.

Gladstone went to Windsor and kissed hands on 3 December. The following days were spent assembling a cabinet out of Whig grandees, former followers of Peel and one genuine Radical, the Quaker manufacturer John Bright, who had to be coaxed into taking the Board of Trade. On 9 December the new ministers received their seals of office and the government formally began. On his birthday at the end of the month Gladstone wrote in his diary: ‘I ascend a steepening path, with a burden ever gathering weight. The Almighty seems to sustain and spare me for some purpose of His own, deeply unworthy as I know myself to be.’

The government that followed was among the most productive of the century. It disestablished the Anglican Church of Ireland in 1869, so that Irish Catholics no longer lived under a state church to which barely one in eight of the population belonged. An Irish Land Act of 1870 gave tenants compensation for eviction and for improvements. In Britain, Forster’s Education Act created elected school boards; most of the civil service was opened to competitive examination; Edward Cardwell abolished the purchase of army commissions; religious tests at Oxford and Cambridge were removed; and in 1872 voting became secret.

Each reform made enemies. Nonconformists resented an education settlement that subsidised church schools, brewers and publicans hated the Licensing Act, trade unionists found picketing criminalised. By 1872 Disraeli could look along the Treasury bench and compare it to ‘a range of exhausted volcanoes’. Gladstone called a sudden election in January 1874 on a promise to abolish income tax, and lost heavily. ‘We have been borne down in a torrent of gin and beer,’ he told his brother.

How it came to this

Gladstone had entered Parliament in 1832 as a Tory of the strictest kind, the son of a Liverpool merchant whose fortune rested partly on slave-worked plantations in the West Indies; his first major speech defended his father’s treatment of the people he had enslaved. He served under Sir Robert Peel, followed him out of the Conservative party over free trade in 1846, and as Chancellor of the Exchequer in the 1850s and 1860s made the annual budget a public event. By degrees, and with much agonising, he moved towards the Liberals and towards a wider franchise.

Ireland forced the pace. In 1867 the Fenians, a secret republican brotherhood with strong Irish-American support, attempted a rising in Ireland, killed a police sergeant in Manchester while freeing prisoners from a van, and blew down the wall of Clerkenwell prison in London, killing twelve people. Gladstone drew the conclusion that Irish grievances had to be addressed rather than merely policed, and in the spring of 1868 he carried resolutions in the Commons for disestablishing the Irish Church. Disraeli, in a minority, dissolved Parliament, and the election was fought on that issue.

How each side saw it

Irish nationalists and tenant farmers

Pacification was Gladstone’s word, not Ireland’s. Disestablishment was welcomed by the Catholic bishops, but the Land Act of 1870 left landlords free to raise rents and did not stop evictions, and it was accompanied by a coercion act suspending ordinary legal protections in disturbed districts. Fenian prisoners were released only slowly and some on condition of exile. In 1870 the Protestant barrister Isaac Butt founded the Home Government Association, arguing that no Westminster ministry, however well-meaning, could govern Ireland well. Nationalist newspapers such as The Nation treated Gladstone’s measures as proof that concessions came only when Britain was frightened.

Queen Victoria and the Conservatives

The Queen disliked the disestablishment of a church of which she was supreme governor, and came to dislike Gladstone personally; she is reported to have complained that he addressed her as if she were a public meeting. Disraeli, who charmed her, is credited with the remark that his rival had ‘not a single redeeming defect’. Conservatives saw in Gladstone a man who clothed party advantage in the language of conscience and was dismantling the institutions that held the country together: the church establishment, the landed interest and an officer corps drawn from gentlemen. Lord Salisbury thought that concessions made to Irish violence would only teach the lesson that violence paid.

Working-class radicals and trade unionists

The new urban voters of 1867 had put Gladstone in, and many working men revered him as ‘the People’s William’. Their leaders were less satisfied. The Trade Union Act of 1871 gave unions legal status, but the Criminal Law Amendment Act passed with it made almost any picketing an offence, and gas stokers were jailed in London in 1872. The Reform League’s veterans and the new Trades Union Congress campaigned for repeal and withheld support in 1874. It was Disraeli’s government, not Gladstone’s, that legalised peaceful picketing in 1875, a fact Conservative speakers did not let the Liberals forget.

What is disputed

The date itself needs care. Gladstone was commissioned by the Queen on 3 December 1868; 9 December, given in many almanacs, is the day his cabinet received the seals. The book used as the index for this entry also credits him with fifteen years as Prime Minister, whereas his four ministries (1868-74, 1880-85, 1886 and 1892-94) add up to a little over twelve. The tree-felling scene rests on Evelyn Ashley’s later recollection and is generally accepted. Disraeli’s ‘redeeming defect’ quip is traditional and hard to source. Historians also differ on Gladstone’s Irish policy: Richard Shannon sees a politician driven by a sense of providential mission, others a pragmatist responding to events.

What followed

Gladstone resigned the party leadership in 1875, returned to it through the Midlothian campaign of 1879-80, and formed three more governments. His conversion to Irish Home Rule in 1885-86 split the Liberal party, sent Joseph Chamberlain and the Liberal Unionists over to the Conservatives, and failed twice in Parliament. He retired in 1894 at 84 and died in 1898. The Irish question he had set out to settle in 1868 ended in partition and war a generation later. The administrative state his first government built, with its examined civil servants, elected school boards and secret ballot, lasted far longer.

Read further

  • H. C. G. Matthew, Gladstone 1809-1874 (1986)
  • John Morley, The Life of William Ewart Gladstone (1903)
  • Roy Jenkins, Gladstone (1995)
  • Richard Shannon, Gladstone: Heroic Minister 1865-1898 (1999)
  • Jonathan Parry, The Rise and Fall of Liberal Government in Victorian Britain (1993)

Same day, other years

1824

Ayacucho ends Spanish rule in South America

Pampa de Ayacucho, PeruThe Americas

On a high plain in the Peruvian Andes, some 3,400 metres up, a patriot army under the 29-year-old Venezuelan general Antonio Jose de Sucre met the last large royalist force on the continent, commanded by the viceroy Jose de la Serna. Sucre’s men, drawn from Colombia, Peru, Chile and the River Plate, were outnumbered, by most accounts roughly 5,800 against 9,000. The royalists came down from the heights of Condorcunca in poorly co-ordinated columns and were broken in a few hours. La Serna was wounded and captured, and his deputy Jose de Canterac signed a capitulation that surrendered every Spanish garrison in Peru.

Seen from elsewhere. Most of the royalist rank and file were Peruvians, many of them Quechua-speaking conscripts, and some Andean communities fought on for the king for years. In Spain the defeated officers were accused of having given the battle away. For Indigenous Peruvians the new republic kept the old tribute under another name.

1917

Jerusalem is surrendered to the British army

JerusalemMiddle East

After four centuries of Ottoman rule, the Turkish garrison withdrew from Jerusalem during the night of 8 December rather than fight in the city. In the morning the mayor, Hussein al-Husseini, walked out with a white flag made from a bedsheet and a letter of surrender. The first British soldiers he met were two sergeants of the London Regiment looking for water, who declined the honour, and he had to offer the city several times before a general accepted it. Two days later Sir Edmund Allenby entered through the Jaffa Gate on foot, a deliberate contrast with the German Kaiser, who had ridden in on horseback in 1898.

Seen from elsewhere. Lloyd George wanted the city as a Christmas present for a war-weary nation. Its Arab inhabitants had been promised good government, but five weeks earlier, in the Balfour Declaration, Britain had committed itself to a Jewish national home in Palestine, a pledge of which most of them knew nothing. Ottoman accounts record an orderly evacuation, not a defeat.

1948

The United Nations outlaws genocide

Paris, FranceWorldwide

Meeting at the Palais de Chaillot, the UN General Assembly unanimously adopted the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. The word was four years old. It had been coined in 1944 by Raphael Lemkin, a Polish-Jewish lawyer who lost dozens of relatives in the Holocaust and who had been arguing since the 1930s, with the Ottoman destruction of the Armenians in mind, that the killing of a people should be a crime in international law. He lobbied delegates in the corridors for two years. The convention defined genocide as acts committed with intent to destroy a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, and came into force in 1951.

Seen from elsewhere. The definition was a bargain. Political groups were left out, with the Soviet Union among those insisting on it, and the destruction of a culture was dropped after objections from states with colonies or Indigenous populations. The United States did not ratify until 1988. No international court convicted anyone of genocide until the Rwanda tribunal in 1998.

1961

Tanganyika becomes independent

Dar es Salaam, TanganyikaAfrica

At midnight the British flag came down in Dar es Salaam and Tanganyika, once German East Africa and since 1919 a territory administered by Britain under international mandate, became a sovereign state. Its Prime Minister was Julius Nyerere, a 39-year-old former schoolteacher whose party, the Tanganyika African National Union, had won almost every seat without a shot being fired. That night an army officer, Alexander Nyirenda, carried a torch and the new flag to the summit of Kilimanjaro, fulfilling Nyerere’s promise of a light that would shine beyond the country’s borders. Tanganyika united with Zanzibar in 1964 to form Tanzania.

Seen from elsewhere. Nyerere is revered as Mwalimu, the teacher, and his country avoided the ethnic wars of its neighbours. Critics, among them Tanzanian economists and peasants who lived through it, point to the one-party state he built and to the villagisation drive of the 1970s, which moved millions of rural people, many by force, and damaged food production.

Also on 9 December