Parallax

11 December, 1688

James II slips out of Whitehall

A king of England left his palace by a back stair in the middle of the night, dropped the Great Seal in the Thames, and was caught the next day by fishermen who took him for a Jesuit.

London and Faversham, England

In the early hours of Tuesday 11 December 1688, by the old-style calendar England then used, James II got out of bed in Whitehall Palace, told the lord in waiting not to open the door until the usual hour, and went down a private staircase to a waiting hackney coach. With him was Sir Edward Hales, a Catholic convert. They crossed the river in a small boat from the Horse Ferry to Vauxhall. Somewhere in midstream the King took out the Great Seal of England, without which no parliament could lawfully be summoned and no grant passed, and let it go over the side. He had already burned the writs for the parliament he had promised.

It was the act of a man who had come apart. Five weeks earlier his nephew and son-in-law, William of Orange, had landed in Devon with a Dutch army. James marched to Salisbury with a larger force, suffered violent nosebleeds, could not decide to fight, and watched his officers ride over to the enemy, among them John Churchill, his ablest soldier. His younger daughter Anne slipped away from London to join the rebels. ‘God help me,’ he said, ‘my own children have forsaken me.’ On the night of 9 December he sent his queen, Mary of Modena, and their six-month-old son to France.

James and Hales rode through the night into Kent and boarded a customs boat near Faversham. Before it could sail it was boarded by a party of local seamen out hunting fugitive Catholics. They did not recognise the King. They searched him roughly for valuables, took his money and watch, called him a hatchet-faced old Jesuit, and carried him ashore to an inn, where at last someone knew him. He was held there for three days, alternately weeping and lecturing his captors.

London, meanwhile, had no government. On the night of the flight crowds sacked Catholic chapels and burned the Spanish ambassador’s house. The hated Lord Chancellor Jeffreys was seized in a Wapping alehouse disguised as a sailor. A group of peers met at the Guildhall, took charge and invited William to the capital.

Then came the awkward sequel that the tidy version leaves out. James was brought back, and on 16 December he re-entered London to cheering crowds and bonfires. William, who needed him gone rather than martyred, sent Dutch guards to surround Whitehall and a midnight message advising the King to leave for his own safety. James asked to go to Rochester. The house there was left conspicuously unguarded at the back, and on 23 December he walked out through the garden and took ship for France.

How it came to this

James had been a brave soldier and a competent Lord High Admiral, but his conversion to Catholicism around 1669 made him an object of fear in a country that associated that faith with the fires of Mary Tudor, the Gunpowder Plot and the absolutism of Louis XIV. Parliament tried three times between 1679 and 1681 to exclude him from the succession. He nevertheless came to the throne peacefully in 1685 and crushed the Duke of Monmouth’s rebellion, after which Judge Jeffreys hanged some 250 West Country rebels.

He then set about freeing his co-religionists from the laws that barred them from office. He used his prerogative to suspend those laws, appointed Catholic army officers and privy councillors, forced a Catholic president on Magdalen College, Oxford, and in 1688 prosecuted seven bishops who petitioned against reading his Declaration of Indulgence from the pulpit. A jury acquitted them on 30 June. Twenty days before, the Queen had given birth to a son, which meant a Catholic dynasty. The same night as the acquittal, seven leading men sent William a secret invitation to intervene.

How each side saw it

James II

In the memoirs compiled from his papers and published in 1816 as The Life of James the Second, the King explains that he fled because he remembered his father. Charles I had stayed, been taken, tried and beheaded in 1649, when James was fifteen. He believed that a king in his enemies’ hands was a dead man, and that by leaving he kept his cause and his son’s alive. He never accepted that he had abdicated. He maintained that he had sought only liberty of conscience for all his subjects, Catholic and Dissenter alike, and had been betrayed by an Anglican establishment that preached obedience and practised rebellion.

The Williamites and the Whig tradition

Bishop Gilbert Burnet, who landed with William and wrote the History of His Own Time, presented the events as a providential deliverance of Protestantism and law from popery and arbitrary power. The Convention of 1689 resolved that James had broken the original contract between king and people and, by withdrawing, had abdicated. In the nineteenth century Macaulay made this the founding story of English liberty: a revolution that was bloodless, conservative and lawful, and that spared Britain the upheavals of the Continent. The dropping of the Great Seal was read as James’s own confession that he had abandoned the government.

Ireland and the Scottish Highlands

Nothing about it was bloodless there. Catholic Ireland rallied to James, who landed at Kinsale in 1689; the war that followed, through Derry, the Boyne, Aughrim and Limerick, killed tens of thousands and ended in the penal laws that excluded Catholics from land, office and education for a century. Irish-language poets mourned the Stuarts in the aisling tradition for generations, though popular memory also gave James a contemptuous nickname for running from the Boyne. In Scotland the revolution brought the Jacobite rising of 1689 and the massacre of the MacDonalds at Glencoe in 1692.

The Dutch

For the Dutch Republic this was a military operation undertaken for Dutch reasons. William needed England’s fleet, money and manpower for the coming war against Louis XIV, and the States General financed an armada several times larger than the Spanish one of 1588. The historian Jonathan Israel has stressed that William entered London at the head of a foreign army, ordered English regiments out of the capital, and kept Dutch guards at Whitehall and St James’s for many months. English tradition preferred not to remember a successful invasion.

What is disputed

The book used as the index for this day says James never returned to London; he did, five days later, and left for good on 23 December. It also calls William ‘William II’; he was William III of England. The Great Seal was recovered from the river by fishermen, by most accounts some months afterwards. Larger arguments continue. Was 1688 a revolution or an invasion? Steve Pincus argues for a violent, popular and modernising revolution; Israel for a Dutch conquest. Was James an aspiring absolutist, as the Whigs held, or, as John Miller and Scott Sowerby suggest, a clumsy but sincere advocate of toleration?

What followed

The Convention offered the crown jointly to William and Mary in February 1689 together with a Declaration of Rights, enacted that December as the Bill of Rights, which barred the suspension of laws and the keeping of a standing army without parliamentary consent. England was drawn into a quarter-century of war with France and created the Bank of England and a national debt to pay for it. James died at Saint-Germain in 1701. His son and grandson tried to recover the throne in 1715 and 1745. Catholics remain excluded from the British succession by the Act of Settlement of 1701.

Read further

  • Tim Harris, Revolution: The Great Crisis of the British Monarchy, 1685-1720 (2006)
  • Steve Pincus, 1688: The First Modern Revolution (2009)
  • John Miller, James II: A Study in Kingship (1978)
  • Jonathan Israel (ed.), The Anglo-Dutch Moment: Essays on the Glorious Revolution and its World Impact (1991)
  • Gilbert Burnet, History of His Own Time (1724-34)

Same day, other years

1241

The Great Khan dies, and Europe is left alone

MongoliaAsia

Ogedei, third son of Genghis Khan and ruler of the Mongol empire since 1229, died after a night of heavy drinking on a hunting trip. He had built the capital at Karakorum, completed the conquest of north China and sent armies west. That spring those armies, led by his nephew Batu and the old general Subutai, had destroyed a Polish and German force at Legnica and the Hungarian royal army at Mohi within two days of each other, and their scouts had ridden to within sight of Vienna. In the spring of 1242 they turned round and went back to the steppe. They never returned in such strength.

Seen from elsewhere. The friar John of Plano Carpini, who visited the Mongols soon afterwards, linked the withdrawal to the khan’s death and the succession. The Persian historian Rashid al-Din implies the commanders had not yet heard the news. Recent work points instead to a wet spring that turned the Hungarian plain to marsh, to shortage of pasture, and to stone castles that had held out.

1282

The last native Prince of Wales is killed

Cilmeri, near Builth, WalesEurope

Llywelyn ap Gruffudd had been recognised by the English crown in 1267 as Prince of Wales, the only Welsh ruler ever to hold the title by treaty. A first war with Edward I in 1277 stripped him of most of his territory. When his brother Dafydd rose in 1282 he joined the revolt. In December he went south to raise support and, separated from his army near the River Irfon, was run through by an English man-at-arms who did not know who he was. His head was cut off, sent to the King and set on a spike at the Tower of London, crowned with ivy in mockery of a prophecy that a Welshman would be crowned in London.

Seen from elsewhere. To Edward he was a vassal who had broken his oath. The Welsh chronicle hints that he was lured to his death by treachery. The poet Gruffudd ab yr Ynad Coch wrote an elegy in which the sea floods the land and the stars fall, one of the great laments in the Welsh language.

1941

Hitler declares war on the United States

Berlin, GermanyWorldwide

Four days after the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, Hitler went before the Reichstag in the Kroll Opera House and, in a speech of nearly an hour and a half that dwelt on his loathing of Roosevelt, announced that Germany was at war with the United States. Italy followed the same day. The Tripartite Pact did not require it, since Japan had been the attacker. Congress replied with its own declarations within hours, with no dissenting vote. The decision freed Roosevelt from the problem of persuading Americans to fight Germany when it was Japan that had struck them, and joined the European and Pacific wars into one.

Seen from elsewhere. Why Hitler did it is still argued. He believed war with America was coming anyway, wanted his U-boats free to attack American shipping at once, and hoped Japan would tie down US strength. Ian Kershaw sees a calculated gamble by a regime that already faced defeat before Moscow; others see ideology overriding strategy.

1981

The massacre at El Mozote

Morazan, El SalvadorThe Americas

Over three days in December 1981 soldiers of the Atlacatl Battalion, an elite Salvadoran army unit trained by American advisers, killed nearly everyone they found in the village of El Mozote and neighbouring hamlets in the guerrilla-contested north-east. On 11 December they separated the men, the women and the children, and killed them group by group. The Salvadoran state now recognises 978 victims, more than half of them children. Rufina Amaya, who hid behind a tree and heard her own children die, was the principal survivor to testify. Reporters from the New York Times and the Washington Post reached the site in January 1982.

Seen from elsewhere. The Salvadoran army said there had been a battle with guerrillas. Officials of the Reagan administration told Congress that no evidence confirmed a massacre and questioned the reporters’ credibility. Exhumations by Argentine forensic scientists in 1992 found the remains of at least 143 people in one small building, most of them children, killed with American-made ammunition. An amnesty blocked prosecution until it was struck down in 2016.

Also on 11 December