Parallax

20 December, AD 69

Vitellius is dragged through Rome

The third emperor to die in a single year tried to resign and was not allowed to. Two days later he was hauled half-naked along the Sacred Way while the city, in the middle of its winter festival, looked on.

Rome

On 18 December in the year 69, Aulus Vitellius, emperor for eight months, came down from the Palatine in mourning clothes with his small son carried beside him in a litter. He told the crowd in the Forum that he was giving up power for the sake of peace and the state, and held out his dagger, the symbol of his authority over life and death, to the consul. The consul would not take it. Nor would anyone else. His soldiers and a large part of the Roman populace blocked every street except the one that led back to the palace, and he went back.

The abdication had been negotiated. The armies of the eastern general Vespasian had beaten Vitellius’s legions in northern Italy in October and were now a few days’ march from Rome. Vespasian’s elder brother, Flavius Sabinus, happened to be prefect of the city, and he had agreed terms with Vitellius: his life, a fortune and a quiet retirement in Campania. When the handover collapsed, Sabinus and his supporters, with Vespasian’s eighteen-year-old son Domitian, took refuge on the Capitol. The next day Vitellian soldiers stormed the hill. In the fighting the Temple of Jupiter, the holiest building in Rome, burned to the ground. Sabinus was taken to the palace steps and cut down. Domitian escaped disguised as a worshipper of Isis.

On 20 December the Flavian army under Antonius Primus entered the city in three columns. It was the Saturnalia. Tacitus, who was a boy at the time, describes the population watching the street fighting as if it were a show in the arena, cheering one side and then the other, while the baths and wine shops stayed open and looters followed the troops. The last resistance was at the Praetorian camp, where Vitellius’s men died facing the enemy.

Vitellius had himself carried to his wife’s house on the Aventine, meaning to slip away to his brother’s army. Then, from indecision, he returned to the palace and found it deserted. Suetonius says he hid in the doorkeeper’s lodge with a belt of gold coins round his waist. A tribune pulled him out. His hands were tied behind him and a noose put round his neck, and he was led through the Forum with a sword point under his chin to make him show his face, while people threw dung and shouted insults about his belly and his limp.

At the Gemonian Stairs, where Sabinus’s body had lain the day before, he was killed slowly. According to Tacitus his one reply to a jeering officer was that he had, all the same, been his emperor. The body was dragged to the Tiber on a hook. The following day the Senate voted Vespasian, who was in Egypt, all the customary powers.

How it came to this

Nero’s suicide in June 68 ended the dynasty founded by Augustus and exposed, in Tacitus’s phrase, the secret that an emperor could be made elsewhere than at Rome. The elderly Galba, proclaimed by the armies in Spain, was murdered in the Forum on 15 January 69 by guardsmen acting for Otho. By then the legions on the Rhine had already hailed their own commander, Vitellius. His generals crossed the Alps, defeated Otho near Cremona in April, and Otho killed himself. Vitellius reached Rome in the summer.

On 1 July the legions in Egypt swore allegiance to Titus Flavius Vespasianus, a sixty-year-old general of modest Italian family who was then putting down the Jewish revolt in Judaea. Syria and the Danube armies followed. Vespasian stayed in Alexandria, controlling the grain supply, while the governor of Syria marched west. The Danube legions did not wait: led by Antonius Primus, they invaded Italy on their own initiative, won a night battle outside Cremona in late October, and sacked that city for four days.

How each side saw it

Tacitus and Suetonius

Our picture of Vitellius as a glutton and a sluggard comes from two authors writing a generation later, under emperors who owed their position to his fall. Suetonius lists the banquets, including a vast dish of pike livers and flamingo tongues; Tacitus calls him the slave of his appetites. Both drew on histories composed under the Flavians. Yet Tacitus, whose own career began under Vespasian, is not a simple partisan. He records that Vitellius was open-handed and without malice, calls the burning of the Capitol the most shameful crime in Rome’s history without clearing the Flavians of it, and describes the victors’ conduct in the city as no better than the vanquished.

The soldiers and the crowd

The men who refused to let Vitellius abdicate left no account, and are known only through writers who despised them. The Rhine legions had made him emperor and stood to lose everything with him. The city populace seems to have liked him: he had honoured Nero’s memory, which was still popular with ordinary Romans, attended the theatre and the races, and kept the capital supplied. Tacitus treats their loyalty as fickleness and servility. It is at least as likely that they feared, correctly, what the entry of a hostile army fresh from the sack of an Italian city would mean for them.

The Flavian version

Vespasian’s side told it as a rescue. Josephus, the Jewish commander who had gone over to the Romans and wrote his Jewish War under the patronage of Vespasian and Titus, says the general accepted power reluctantly, pressed by soldiers who drew their swords. In this telling the Capitol was burned by Vitellians and the blame for the bloodshed in Rome lay with a tyrant’s obstinacy. Primus, who had actually won the war and let his troops loose on Cremona, was eased aside once the regime was secure, which allowed Vespasian to take the victory and disown its methods.

Judaea

For Jews the rise of Vespasian was bound up with catastrophe. His bid for the throne was launched from the army besieging their country, and the son he left behind, Titus, took Jerusalem in the summer of 70 and destroyed the Temple. The spoils were carried in triumph through Rome and, as a reconstructed inscription indicates, paid for the amphitheatre later called the Colosseum. Jews throughout the empire were made to pay a new tax to the rebuilt temple of Jupiter. Rabbinic tradition remembers Vespasian chiefly through the story of Yohanan ben Zakkai, who hailed him as emperor and was allowed a school at Yavneh.

What is disputed

The day is reconstructed from Tacitus’s narrative, which points to 20 December; some reference works give 22 December. Vespasian himself dated his reign from 1 July, not from the Senate’s vote. Tacitus admits he does not know whether the besiegers or the defenders set fire to the Capitol. The stories of Vitellius’s gluttony belong to a standard repertoire of abuse aimed at fallen emperors, and historians such as Gwyn Morgan and Kenneth Wellesley read him as a mediocre but not monstrous ruler. Whether Primus invaded Italy against Vespasian’s orders or with his private blessing is unresolved.

What followed

Vitellius’s brother was executed, and his young son was put to death the following year. Vespasian reached Rome in the autumn of 70 and ruled for ten years, restoring the finances and founding a dynasty that lasted until his son Domitian was murdered in 96. A bronze tablet recording the law that conferred his powers survives in Rome. The year 69 established what every later emperor understood: the office belonged to whoever the armies would follow.

Read further

  • Tacitus, Histories, Book 3
  • Suetonius, Lives of the Caesars: Vitellius and Vespasian
  • Gwyn Morgan, 69 A.D.: The Year of Four Emperors (2006)
  • Barbara Levick, Vespasian (1999)
  • Kenneth Wellesley, The Long Year A.D. 69 (1975)

Same day, other years

1860

South Carolina declares the Union dissolved

Charleston, South Carolina, United StatesThe Americas

Six weeks after Abraham Lincoln won the presidency without a single Southern electoral vote, a convention of 169 delegates met in Charleston and voted unanimously to take South Carolina out of the United States. The ordinance was a single sentence. It was signed that evening before a cheering crowd, and the Charleston Mercury had a broadsheet on the streets within minutes headed ‘The Union is Dissolved!’. Six more states of the lower South followed by 1 February 1861, and together they formed the Confederate States. In April South Carolina’s guns opened fire on the federal garrison at Fort Sumter in Charleston harbour.

Seen from elsewhere. The convention’s own declaration of causes named the Northern states’ hostility to slavery; later Southern tradition recast the quarrel as one over states’ rights and tariffs. The majority of South Carolina’s people, some 400,000, were enslaved and had no say. A local Unionist, James Petigru, remarked that the state was too small for a republic and too large for a lunatic asylum.

1917

The Bolsheviks found the Cheka

Petrograd, RussiaEurope

Six weeks after seizing power, Lenin’s government created the All-Russian Extraordinary Commission for Combating Counter-Revolution and Sabotage, known by its initials as the Cheka. The decree was dated 7 December by the Russian calendar then in use, 20 December in the West. Its head was Felix Dzerzhinsky, a Polish revolutionary of noble birth who had spent eleven years in Tsarist prisons and exile. It began with a few dozen staff and no power to pass sentence. Within a year, after an attempt on Lenin’s life and the proclamation of the Red Terror, it was shooting hostages and suspects without trial. By 1921 it employed well over 100,000 people.

Seen from elsewhere. The Bolsheviks defended it as a temporary weapon in a civil war their enemies fought just as brutally. One Cheka official’s published count of executions was under 13,000; historians’ estimates run from several tens of thousands to 200,000 or more. Rival socialists were among the first victims. Russia’s security services still mark 20 December as their professional holiday.

1987

The ferry Dona Paz burns in the Tablas Strait

Off Mindoro, PhilippinesAsia

The Dona Paz left Tacloban on the island of Leyte for Manila packed with people going to the capital for Christmas. At about ten at night, in the Tablas Strait, she collided with the Vector, a small tanker carrying 8,800 barrels of petrol and other fuel. The cargo ignited and spread across the water. Both ships sank within hours in shark-inhabited seas. Twenty-six people were picked up alive, two of them from the tanker. The ferry’s manifest listed about 1,500 passengers, but many more had bought tickets on board or travelled unlisted. A later inquiry put the dead at 4,386, the worst peacetime loss of life at sea on record.

Seen from elsewhere. The owners, Sulpicio Lines, denied the ship was overloaded and blamed the tanker. The Philippine Supreme Court eventually held the Vector’s operators liable: the tanker had been sailing without a valid licence, a lookout or a qualified master. Survivors said the ferry’s life jackets were locked away and its officers were not on the bridge. Many families never received compensation.

1989

The United States invades Panama

Panama City, PanamaThe Americas

Shortly after midnight some 27,000 American troops attacked the Panamanian Defence Forces in Operation Just Cause. Their target was General Manuel Noriega, the country’s ruler, a former paid informant of the CIA who had been indicted in Florida for drug trafficking and had annulled an election his candidate lost that May. Guillermo Endara, the winner of that election, was sworn in as president on an American base. The poor district of El Chorrillo, beside Noriega’s headquarters, burned down. Noriega took refuge in the Vatican embassy, which American soldiers surrounded with loudspeakers playing rock music, and gave himself up on 3 January. Twenty-three American servicemen were killed.

Seen from elsewhere. The Pentagon counted about 500 Panamanian dead, some 200 of them civilians; Panamanian and church groups have put the civilian toll far higher, and mass graves were still being examined decades later. The UN General Assembly condemned the invasion as a violation of international law. Many Panamanians welcomed Noriega’s fall. In 2022 Panama made 20 December a day of national mourning.

Also on 20 December