Parallax

22 December, 1793

Captain Buonaparte is made a general

Three months earlier he had been an unemployed Corsican artillery captain of twenty-four. The siege of a rebel port gave him guns, patrons and a wound, and left behind a city that was shot for its treason.

Toulon, France

On 22 December 1793 the representatives of the National Convention with the army at Toulon promoted the commander of their artillery to general of brigade. His name was still written Napoleone Buonaparte. In September he had been a captain. The promotion was provisional, as all such field promotions were, and Paris confirmed it in February.

He had come to the siege by chance. Toulon, France’s great naval base on the Mediterranean, had revolted against the Jacobin government in the summer and in late August opened its harbour to a British and Spanish fleet under Admiral Lord Hood. With the port went nearly half the French navy. The Republican army sent to retake it was led by a former painter, Carteaux, and when its artillery chief was wounded in mid-September there was no trained gunner to replace him. Buonaparte was passing on the road with a powder convoy. One of the Convention’s representatives, Antoine Saliceti, was a fellow Corsican and knew him. He was appointed on the spot.

He found a few field guns and no plan worth the name. Within weeks he had gathered nearly a hundred pieces from as far as Marseille and Antibes, set up a foundry and workshops, and built batteries to which he gave names such as the Battery of the Men Without Fear. More important, he pressed on three successive generals one idea: Toulon need not be stormed. The inner and outer harbours were both commanded by a promontory on the western side. Take that, mount guns on it, and no fleet could stay. The British had seen the same thing and fortified the height so heavily that the French called it Little Gibraltar.

The third general, Dugommier, a veteran, adopted the plan. In driving rain on the night of 16 to 17 December some 6,000 men attacked the fort. The first assault failed; the reserve went in and carried it by hand-to-hand fighting in the dark. Buonaparte had a horse killed under him and took a British sergeant’s pike or bayonet in the thigh, the only serious wound of his life. By morning French guns looked down on the anchorage.

Hood ordered the evacuation the next day. During the night of 18 December a young British captain, Sidney Smith, set fire to the arsenal and the French ships that could not be taken away, while boats ferried off several thousand terrified citizens. Many more were left on the quays. The Republicans entered on the 19th. Dugommier’s dispatch named Buonaparte among several deserving officers; an old artillery general wrote to the minister that he lacked words to describe the young man’s merit.

How it came to this

In June 1793 the Jacobins expelled their Girondin rivals from the Convention in Paris, and much of provincial France rose against them. Lyon, Marseille, Bordeaux and Toulon all threw off the capital’s authority in what was called the federalist revolt. By August, Marseille had fallen and Lyon was under siege. Toulon’s leaders, short of food, blockaded by the British and expecting no mercy, were pushed by their royalist wing into the arms of the enemy: they proclaimed the imprisoned child Louis XVII and admitted Hood’s fleet, which held the town in his name with British, Spanish, Neapolitan and Piedmontese troops.

Buonaparte had spent the early Revolution trying to make a career in Corsican politics. In June 1793 his family, on the losing side of a feud with the island’s leader Pasquale Paoli, fled to the mainland with almost nothing. That summer he wrote a pamphlet, Le Souper de Beaucaire, arguing that the federalists must submit to the Convention. It was printed at public expense and brought him to the notice of the representatives on mission, including Augustin Robespierre, brother of the most powerful man in France.

How each side saw it

The people of Toulon

Those who had opened the port saw themselves as resisting a faction that had seized Paris by force, not as betraying France. When the allies left, perhaps 7,000 got away on the ships; some drowned in the scramble for boats. The rest faced the representatives Barras and Freron, who had the male population assembled on the parade ground and those identified as collaborators shot in batches. Further executions followed by guillotine. The Convention decreed that the city’s name be abolished and replaced with Port-la-Montagne. Refugees scattered to Italy, Spain and England, and their petitions for relief are a main source for what happened.

The British

Hood had been handed a prize beyond anything a battle could have won, and London failed to send the troops to keep it. He never had more than about 17,000 men, of four nations and uneven quality, to hold a perimeter of fifteen miles. British accounts blame the ministry, the Spanish and one another. The burning of the fleet was hurried and incomplete: more than half the French ships of the line survived to fight again, some of them at the Nile five years later. Horatio Nelson, then a captain serving under Hood, wrote home of the horror of the evacuation.

The Jacobin government

To the Convention, Toulon was the worst crime of the Revolution: Frenchmen had delivered a fleet and a fortress to foreign kings in wartime. Its recapture was celebrated with a national festival in Paris, and the credit went to the people’s representatives and the citizen army. The reprisals were not regarded as an excess but as the law’s answer to treason, and Freron reported his shootings to Paris with pride. The young artillery officer was one name among many. His patrons were Robespierre’s men, and when they fell the following July he was arrested and held for nearly a fortnight.

Historians of the Napoleonic legend

In the memoirs he dictated on St Helena, Napoleon made the plan his alone and the generals fools. Historians have since shown that the importance of the western promontory was grasped by several people, including engineers in Paris working for Lazare Carnot, and that Dugommier commanded the assault. What biographers such as Philip Dwyer do credit to the young officer is the organisation of the artillery from almost nothing, the persistence with which he argued the case, and his talent for being noticed by the right politicians. Toulon is also where he gathered followers, among them Junot and Marmont.

What is disputed

Who conceived the winning plan is the oldest argument, and the honest answer is that it had more than one author. The number executed after the city fell is given as anything from about 800 to 2,000. A boastful letter describing the massacre and signed ‘Brutus Buonaparte’ is a forgery; there is no evidence that he took part in the reprisals, though he was present in the town. Estimates of the refugees carried off range from 7,000 to twice that. The saying attributed to Dugommier, that the young man should be promoted or he would promote himself, is probably a later invention.

What followed

The promotion made him visible. He survived the fall of the Robespierres, and in October 1795 used cannon against a royalist rising in the streets of Paris. Five months later he was given command of the Army of Italy. In 1798 a rebuilt fleet carried him from Toulon to Egypt. The city recovered its name in 1795. The British never again came so close to holding a great French naval base.

Read further

  • Malcolm Crook, Toulon in War and Revolution: From the Ancien Regime to the Restoration, 1750-1820 (1991)
  • Philip Dwyer, Napoleon: The Path to Power, 1769-1799 (2007)
  • Bernard Ireland, The Fall of Toulon: The Last Opportunity to Defeat the French Revolution (2005)
  • Andrew Roberts, Napoleon the Great (2014)
  • Napoleon Bonaparte, Le Souper de Beaucaire (1793)

Same day, other years

1885

Japan gets its first prime minister

Tokyo, JapanAsia

The Meiji government abolished the old Council of State, modelled on a seventh-century Chinese pattern, and replaced it with a cabinet of ministers on European lines. Its first head was Ito Hirobumi, forty-four years old. He had been born a farmer’s son in the domain of Choshu, adopted into the lowest rank of samurai, and smuggled to London as a student in 1863 when leaving Japan was still a capital offence. He went on to draft the constitution of 1889, taking Prussia as his chief model, and served as prime minister four times. Power under his system rested with a small circle of men from two western domains.

Seen from elsewhere. Japan’s popular rights movement objected that the cabinet answered to the emperor and not to any elected body. In Korea, Ito is remembered as the first Resident-General, who imposed a protectorate in 1905 and forced the Korean emperor to abdicate. An Jung-geun, who shot him dead at Harbin in 1909, is honoured as a patriot in both Korean states.

1894

Captain Dreyfus is convicted of treason

Paris, FranceEurope

A court martial sitting behind closed doors found Alfred Dreyfus, a thirty-five-year-old artillery officer on the General Staff, guilty of selling military secrets to Germany. He was an Alsatian and a Jew. The evidence was an unsigned note recovered from the German embassy, whose handwriting the experts could not agree was his, and a file of documents shown secretly to the judges and withheld from the defence. The verdict was unanimous. He was publicly stripped of his rank in January and shipped to Devil’s Island off French Guiana. The real author of the note, Major Ferdinand Esterhazy, was identified in 1896 by the army’s own head of intelligence.

Seen from elsewhere. The army’s defenders, much of the Catholic press and nationalist papers such as La Libre Parole held that reopening the case would dishonour the institution on which France’s safety depended, and many sincerely believed him guilty. Dreyfus was convicted again in 1899, pardoned, and cleared only in 1906. Some on the far right never accepted it.

1987

The Unity Accord closes the Matabeleland killings

Harare, ZimbabweAfrica

Robert Mugabe and Joshua Nkomo, rivals since the liberation war, signed an agreement merging Nkomo’s party into Mugabe’s ruling ZANU-PF. It ended five years of violence in the western provinces of Matabeleland and the Midlands, Nkomo’s heartland. From 1983 the Fifth Brigade, a unit trained by North Korean instructors and answering to the prime minister, had been sent there against armed dissidents and had turned on the rural population with mass shootings, beatings and the withholding of food. The operation was called Gukurahundi, a Shona word for the early rain that washes away the chaff. The dead, mostly Ndebele-speaking civilians, are commonly estimated at about 20,000.

Seen from elsewhere. The government said it was fighting insurgents armed by apartheid South Africa, which did run agents there. Mugabe later spoke of ‘a moment of madness’ but never apologised. A Catholic and legal-aid report of 1997 documented the killings from survivors’ testimony. Many in Matabeleland regard the accord as a surrender that bought peace by ending opposition. Its anniversary is a public holiday.

1997

Forty-five people are killed at prayer in Acteal

Acteal, Chiapas, MexicoThe Americas

In a hamlet in the highlands of Chiapas, members of a Catholic pacifist group of Tzotzil Maya called Las Abejas, the Bees, had gathered in a wooden chapel to fast and pray for peace. They sympathised with the aims of the Zapatista rebels but rejected arms. Late in the morning several dozen men with assault rifles surrounded the chapel and hunted those who fled down the ravine. The shooting went on for hours. Forty-five people died, most of them women and children. A police post stood a short distance away and did not intervene. The attackers belonged to a local paramilitary group aligned with the ruling party.

Seen from elsewhere. The federal government described a feud between communities. Survivors, the diocese of San Cristobal and human rights bodies call it part of a counter-insurgency in which the state armed civilians against Zapatista supporters. In 2009 the Supreme Court freed many of those convicted, citing fabricated evidence. The government acknowledged state responsibility in 2020; Las Abejas refused the settlement.

Also on 22 December