Parallax

27 December, 1831

The Beagle leaves Plymouth with a seasick passenger

A naval survey brig sailed for South America carrying chronometers, three young Fuegians being taken home, and a 22-year-old Cambridge graduate who had been invited along mainly as company for the captain.

Plymouth, England

HMS Beagle had been ready since November, but westerly gales drove her back into Plymouth Sound twice. On the morning of 27 December 1831 the wind finally swung round, and at about eleven o’clock the ten-gun brig, 90 feet long and carrying some 74 people, slipped out past the breakwater. Her captain, Robert FitzRoy, was 26. Her passenger list included Charles Darwin, who had first written to decline the place because his father objected, and had been rescued by his uncle Josiah Wedgwood, who persuaded the doctor that natural history was a respectable pursuit for a future clergyman.

Darwin was not on the Admiralty’s payroll. FitzRoy, whose uncle had cut his own throat and whose predecessor in command of the Beagle had shot himself in the gloom of Tierra del Fuego, wanted a gentleman of his own class to dine with, someone to talk to on a voyage of years. The Cambridge botanist John Stevens Henslow suggested Darwin. FitzRoy, a believer in reading character from faces, nearly turned him down because of the shape of his nose. Darwin paid his own way and kept his specimens as his own property.

He was seasick within hours and stayed miserable across the Bay of Biscay, lying in a hammock slung over the chart table in the poop cabin he shared with two officers. At Tenerife the ship was refused landing because of cholera in England, and Darwin watched the peak he had longed to climb disappear astern. His first real work ashore came in January at Santiago in the Cape Verde Islands, where a white band of shells running through the black volcanic cliffs, well above the sea, set him thinking about land that rises and falls over time.

Also on board were three Fuegians, whom FitzRoy had taken from Tierra del Fuego on his previous voyage and had educated in England at his own expense. The English called them York Minster, Fuegia Basket and Jemmy Button. They had been presented to King William IV and Queen Adelaide. With them travelled a young missionary, Richard Matthews, who was to found a Christian settlement among their people.

The voyage that was meant to last two years lasted nearly five. Darwin spent more than three of them on land, riding across the pampas, climbing the Andes, feeling the earthquake that wrecked Concepcion in 1835 and visiting the Galapagos for five weeks that autumn. The Beagle came home to Falmouth on 2 October 1836.

How it came to this

The Beagle’s job was hydrographic. Britain’s trade with the newly independent republics of South America was growing fast, and the Admiralty needed accurate charts of the coasts of Patagonia, Tierra del Fuego, Chile and Peru. FitzRoy was also to carry a set of 22 chronometers around the world, fixing longitudes by comparing their times, an exercise in measurement as much as in exploration. Naturalists on such voyages were common; the ship’s surgeon, Robert McCormick, expected to be the official collector and left in disgust at Rio when he found Darwin had the better position.

Darwin himself had drifted. He had abandoned medicine at Edinburgh, found surgery without anaesthetic unbearable, and gone to Cambridge to prepare for ordination. There he became a passionate beetle collector and a protege of Henslow and the geologist Adam Sedgwick, with whom he spent the summer of 1831 in north Wales. He took with him the first volume of Charles Lyell’s Principles of Geology, which argued that slow, ordinary processes acting over immense time could explain the shape of the earth.

How each side saw it

The Fuegians

The three were Yamana and Kawesqar people taken in 1830, partly as hostages after a stolen boat, and Jemmy Button was bought for a mother-of-pearl button. A fourth, Boat Memory, died of smallpox in England. Their own words survive only through FitzRoy, Darwin and later missionaries. Returned in 1833, they soon resumed their own lives; the mission collapsed within days. In 1859 Jemmy Button’s people killed most of a later mission party at Wulaia. Their story has been retold by Nick Hazlewood and others as one of abduction and failed experiment rather than benevolence.

Robert FitzRoy

FitzRoy’s own account, the Narrative published in 1839, ends with a chapter arguing that the evidence he and Darwin had collected fitted the Flood of Genesis. He later felt that he had carried on his ship the man who undermined scripture, and at the 1860 meeting of the British Association in Oxford he is reported to have held up a Bible and urged the audience to believe God rather than man. He became the first head of what is now the Met Office, invented the public weather forecast, and cut his own throat in 1865.

South American states

To the governments of Argentina and Chile, British survey ships were tools of commercial and naval influence. The Beagle called at the Falkland Islands in March 1833, weeks after a British force had expelled the Argentine garrison and reasserted a British claim, and again in 1834, when Darwin recorded the killings and disorder of the months between. Argentina has protested British possession ever since. Darwin also watched the campaigns of General Rosas against the Indigenous peoples of the pampas in 1833 and recorded with horror that captured women were killed in cold blood.

What is disputed

The popular tale that Darwin saw the Galapagos finches and grasped evolution on the spot is a legend: Frank Sulloway showed in 1982 that he did not label most of them by island and that it was the mockingbirds and the vice-governor’s remark about tortoise shells that struck him. He only became convinced that species change in 1837, after the ornithologist John Gould examined his birds, and found the mechanism after reading Malthus in 1838. Whether FitzRoy really objected to his nose rests on Darwin’s own later Autobiography.

What followed

Darwin came home famous among naturalists through his letters and specimens and never left Britain again. His Journal of Researches, published in 1839, became a bestseller. Twenty years later he published On the Origin of Species, in 1859, after Alfred Russel Wallace sent him a paper outlining the same theory. The voyage gave him his evidence. Some have also blamed it, perhaps through a parasite picked up in Argentina, for the chronic illness that kept him at his house in Kent for most of his life, though the cause is still argued.

Read further

  • Charles Darwin, Journal of Researches (The Voyage of the Beagle) (1839)
  • Robert FitzRoy, Narrative of the Surveying Voyages of His Majesty’s Ships Adventure and Beagle (1839)
  • Janet Browne, Charles Darwin: Voyaging (1995)
  • Adrian Desmond and James Moore, Darwin (1991)
  • Nick Hazlewood, Savage: The Life and Times of Jemmy Button (2000)

Same day, other years

AD 537

Justinian’s Hagia Sophia is consecrated

Constantinople (Istanbul)Europe

Five years after rioters in the Nika revolt burned the previous church on the site, the emperor Justinian dedicated its replacement, built by the mathematicians Anthemius of Tralles and Isidore of Miletus with an army of workers in under six years. Its dome, more than thirty metres across, seemed to float on a ring of windows; the historian Procopius wrote that it looked suspended from heaven by a golden chain. The first dome fell in an earthquake in 558 and was rebuilt higher. For nearly a thousand years it was the largest church in Christendom.

Seen from elsewhere. The famous line that Justinian cried ‘Solomon, I have surpassed you’ comes from a much later legendary account, not a contemporary witness. After 1453 the Ottomans made it a mosque, the Turkish republic a museum in 1934, and the government a mosque again in 2020, to Orthodox and international protest.

1949

The Netherlands transfers sovereignty over Indonesia

Amsterdam and JakartaAsia

In simultaneous ceremonies at the royal palace in Amsterdam and in Jakarta, the Netherlands handed sovereignty over most of the Dutch East Indies to the federal Republic of the United States of Indonesia. The transfer followed the Round Table Conference in The Hague and four years of war after Sukarno and Hatta proclaimed independence on 17 August 1945. Two Dutch military offensives, called police actions in the Netherlands, had brought sanctions threats from the United States and condemnation at the United Nations. Western New Guinea was left out of the deal, and the federal structure was dissolved within a year.

Seen from elsewhere. Indonesians date their independence from 1945, not 1949; Dutch governments accepted the 1945 date politically only in 2005 and more fully in 2023. Indonesia also took over a large share of colonial debt. Dutch inquiries published in 2022 concluded that extreme violence by Dutch forces in the war had been structural, not incidental.

1979

Soviet special forces storm the Afghan presidential palace

Tajbeg Palace, Kabul, AfghanistanAsia

Two days after Soviet troops began landing at Kabul and Bagram, special forces dressed in Afghan uniforms attacked the Tajbeg Palace on the evening of 27 December and killed the Afghan leader, Hafizullah Amin, who had seized power from his communist rival Nur Muhammad Taraki in the autumn. Soviet officers had earlier failed to poison him at lunch the same day. The Soviet leadership installed Babrak Karmal in his place. The operation opened a war that lasted until 1989, drew in American, Pakistani and Saudi support for the mujahideen, and killed somewhere between half a million and two million Afghans.

Seen from elsewhere. Moscow described its forces as a limited contingent invited under the 1978 friendship treaty, and Amin had indeed asked for Soviet troops, though not to remove him. The Politburo feared he would turn to the West. Most Afghans and almost all other governments saw an invasion; the UN General Assembly condemned it by a large majority in January 1980.

2007

Benazir Bhutto is assassinated

Liaquat Bagh, Rawalpindi, PakistanAsia

Benazir Bhutto, twice prime minister of Pakistan and the first woman to lead a Muslim-majority democracy, had returned from exile in October to fight elections under President Pervez Musharraf. Her homecoming procession in Karachi had already been bombed, killing well over a hundred people. On 27 December, leaving a rally in Rawalpindi in an armoured vehicle, she stood up through the escape hatch to wave to supporters. Shots were fired and a suicide bomber detonated his explosives beside the car. She died in hospital shortly after, and more than twenty others were killed. Riots followed across Sindh, and the elections were postponed to February.

Seen from elsewhere. The government blamed the Pakistani Taliban leader Baitullah Mehsud and at first said she died striking her head on the hatch lever. A UN commission in 2010 criticised the authorities for failing to protect her and for hosing down the scene within hours. Her party accused Musharraf; a court in 2017 declared him an absconder.

Also on 27 December