Parallax

21 December, 1192

The Lionheart is caught outside Vienna

The most celebrated soldier in Christendom, travelling home from crusade in disguise, was arrested in a village inn by the men of a duke he had insulted. Getting him back cost England a quarter of everything it owned.

Erdberg, near Vienna, Austria

Richard I of England left Acre on 9 October 1192, a month after making a truce with Saladin. The safe roads home were closed to him. The King of France was his enemy, and so was the German emperor, Henry VI, who controlled most of Italy. Richard put in at Corfu, hired galleys, and was driven by storms onto the marshy coast at the head of the Adriatic, somewhere between Aquileia and Venice. He had a handful of companions and several hundred miles of hostile country between him and the lands of his brother-in-law in Saxony.

The party travelled as pilgrims returning from Jerusalem, with the king passing as a merchant. It was a poor disguise. They spent too freely, and at the first town the local count, who was a kinsman of a man Richard was suspected of having murdered, was sent a ruby ring as a gift and guessed at once whose it was. Richard got away, leaving most of his men to be taken. For three days and nights he rode north with a knight named William de l’Etang and a boy who spoke German, and stopped, exhausted and probably feverish, at a house in Erdberg, on the Danube outside the walls of Vienna.

The boy was sent into the city to buy food. He paid in gold coin from the East, behaved grandly, and on a later trip was seen with a pair of fine gloves in his belt of a kind worn only by great lords. He was seized and made to talk. A few days before Christmas, on 20 or 21 December, armed men surrounded the house. German chroniclers relate with relish that the King of England was found in the kitchen turning a spit, dressed as a servant and given away by the ring on his finger. The English account says that he refused to give up his sword to anyone but the duke in person.

The duke came. Leopold V of Austria had been at the siege of Acre the year before and had his own reasons to want this prisoner. He sent Richard up the Danube to the castle of Durnstein, on its crag above the river, and wrote to his overlord. On 28 December the emperor announced the news to Philip of France in a letter that survives, describing Richard as the enemy of the empire and the disturber of Philip’s kingdom.

In March 1193 Leopold handed him over to Henry VI for a share of the ransom. Before the imperial court at Speyer, Richard answered a list of charges so ably that even a French chronicler admired it. It made no difference to the price: 100,000 marks of silver for his release, more than twenty tonnes, with hostages for a further 50,000.

How it came to this

Richard had taken the cross in 1187, after Saladin captured Jerusalem, and became King of England two years later. He reached the Holy Land in June 1191 and within weeks Acre fell to the combined crusader armies. Over the next fifteen months he beat Saladin in the field at Arsuf and Jaffa, but twice turned back from Jerusalem, judging that he could take it but not hold it. The treaty of September 1192 left the coast in Christian hands and gave pilgrims access to the holy city.

He made enemies on the way. In Sicily he had recognised King Tancred, whose throne Henry VI claimed through his wife. At Acre his men threw down the banner that Leopold of Austria had raised on the walls beside those of the kings, denying the duke a share of the plunder. In April 1192 Conrad of Montferrat, newly chosen King of Jerusalem and a cousin of Leopold, was stabbed to death by two Assassins, and many believed Richard had arranged it. Meanwhile Philip of France had gone home early and was conspiring with Richard’s brother John.

How each side saw it

Leopold and the Austrian chroniclers

The Austrian and German sources present the arrest as justice. Leopold had commanded what remained of Frederick Barbarossa’s German crusade and had fought at Acre for months before Richard arrived. The casting of his standard into the ditch was a public insult to him and to the Empire, and it had cost his men their reward. He also held Richard responsible for the death of his cousin Conrad and for the imprisonment of another kinsman, the ruler of Cyprus. The chronicler Otto of St Blasien tells the kitchen story to show a proud man brought low, and treats the capture as God’s judgment.

The Emperor Henry VI

For Henry the prisoner was a stroke of fortune. Richard was the ally and financier of the Welf princes who led the opposition in Germany, and the supporter of the king who kept Henry out of Sicily. The charges read at Speyer, preserved by the English chronicler Roger of Howden, accused him of betraying the Holy Land by his truce with Saladin, of plotting Conrad’s murder and of insulting the German nation. The court dropped them once terms were agreed. The ransom paid for the army with which Henry conquered Sicily in 1194, and Richard was made to hold England as a fief of the Empire.

The Papacy

A crusader’s person and property were under the protection of the Church until he returned home, and to seize one was sacrilege. Pope Celestine III excommunicated Leopold and threatened France with interdict if Philip attacked Richard’s lands. He did not excommunicate the emperor, whose armies stood on the borders of the papal state. Three letters in the name of Richard’s mother, Eleanor of Aquitaine, styling herself queen ‘by the wrath of God’, reproach the Pope for sending no legate and doing nothing while her son lay in chains. Whether they were ever sent, or are literary exercises by her secretary Peter of Blois, is debated.

Those who paid

The money was raised in England and Normandy by a levy of a quarter of every person’s income and movable goods, a year’s wool from the Cistercian monasteries, and the gold and silver plate of the churches. Eleanor, then about seventy, oversaw the collection, and the treasure was stored in chests at St Paul’s Cathedral. William of Newburgh and Ralph of Diceto record the hardship and the suspicion that collectors took their own share. No peasant or townsman’s opinion survives. The chroniclers who complain of the burden were churchmen who had lost their chalices, and they blamed the emperor’s greed, not the king’s journey.

What is disputed

The day is given as 20 December by some sources and 21 by others; the chroniclers say only that it was shortly before Christmas. The kitchen and the spit appear in German and French writers hostile to Richard, and the English version, taken down by Ralph of Coggeshall from the king’s chaplain, has none of it. The tale of the minstrel Blondel finding his master by singing under castle windows first appears around 1260 and is fiction; Richard’s whereabouts were never secret. That he was held at Durnstein rests on good but not contemporary evidence. No proof ever connected him with Conrad’s murder.

What followed

Richard was freed at Mainz on 4 February 1194, after John and Philip had offered the emperor money to keep him longer. Philip is said to have warned John: look to yourself, the devil is loose. Leopold died that December from a crushed foot, still excommunicate, after using his share to build new walls for Vienna and found Wiener Neustadt. Richard spent his last five years recovering lost castles in France and was killed by a crossbow bolt in 1199. The taxes devised for his ransom became a model for royal finance.

Read further

  • John Gillingham, Richard I (1999)
  • Roger of Howden, Chronica
  • Ralph of Coggeshall, Chronicon Anglicanum
  • Jean Flori, Richard the Lionheart: King and Knight (2006)
  • Ralph V. Turner and Richard R. Heiser, The Reign of Richard Lionheart: Ruler of the Angevin Empire, 1189-1199 (2000)

Same day, other years

1866

The Hundred in the Hand

Near Fort Phil Kearny, Wyoming, United StatesThe Americas

The United States Army had built three forts along the Bozeman Trail, a road to the Montana goldfields that cut through the Powder River country, the last great hunting ground of the Lakota, Northern Cheyenne and Arapaho. On a freezing morning a small party of warriors attacked a wood-cutting detail near Fort Phil Kearny and drew the relief column, eighty-one men under Captain William Fetterman, over a ridge and out of sight of the fort. Well over a thousand warriors were waiting. No soldier survived, and it was over in less than an hour. Lakota tradition places the young Crazy Horse among the decoys. Two years later the army abandoned the forts.

Seen from elsewhere. The army called it the Fetterman Massacre and blamed a reckless officer; his supposed boast that eighty men could ride through the whole Sioux nation was probably attached to him afterwards. To the Lakota and Cheyenne it was a battle, named for a seer’s vision of a hundred soldiers in his hands, fought on land a treaty of 1851 had recognised as theirs.

1907

Soldiers fire on strikers at the Santa Maria school

Iquique, ChileThe Americas

Chile’s wealth came from the nitrate mines of the northern desert, largely owned by British and other foreign capital. In December 1907 thousands of miners walked down to the port of Iquique with their wives and children to demand wages paid in money of fixed value instead of company tokens, and safer conditions. Many were Peruvian and Bolivian. They were lodged in the Domingo Santa Maria school. The companies refused to negotiate under pressure. On the afternoon of 21 December General Roberto Silva Renard gave the strikers an hour to leave, and when they stayed, ordered his troops to open fire with rifles and machine guns on the school and the square.

Seen from elsewhere. The general reported about 140 dead and wrote that he had acted to protect the city from a mob. Witnesses and later historians put the figure between 1,000 and more than 3,000. The government censored the press, and the event went untaught for decades until a 1970 cantata made it widely known. Chile declared a day of national mourning on the centenary.

1979

The Lancaster House Agreement ends the Rhodesian war

London, EnglandAfrica

After fourteen weeks of talks chaired by the British Foreign Secretary, Lord Carrington, the parties to the war in Rhodesia signed a settlement at Lancaster House. The guerrilla leaders Robert Mugabe and Joshua Nkomo signed for the Patriotic Front, and Bishop Abel Muzorewa for the government in Salisbury, in which Ian Smith’s white minority still held the levers. The war had lasted seven years in earnest and killed more than 20,000 people. The agreement brought a ceasefire, a brief return to British rule under a governor, and elections. Mugabe’s party won them decisively, and Zimbabwe became independent in April 1980.

Seen from elsewhere. Mugabe said he signed under pressure from the neighbouring presidents who sheltered his army, and resented the clause that protected white-owned farmland from compulsory purchase for ten years. British and American promises to fund land purchase were vague and are remembered differently in London and Harare. Ian Smith called the settlement a betrayal by Britain and South Africa.

1988

Pan Am Flight 103 falls on Lockerbie

Lockerbie, ScotlandEurope

A Boeing 747 bound from London to New York broke apart at 31,000 feet a little after seven in the evening, thirty-eight minutes after take-off. All 259 people on board died, among them thirty-five students of Syracuse University going home for Christmas, and eleven residents of the Scottish town of Lockerbie were killed when the wings and fuel tanks fell on their street. Investigators searching 845 square miles of countryside found that a bomb of plastic explosive had been hidden in a radio-cassette player in a suitcase. In 2001 a Scottish court sitting in the Netherlands convicted a Libyan intelligence officer, Abdelbaset al-Megrahi, and acquitted his co-accused.

Seen from elsewhere. Megrahi protested his innocence until his death in 2012. Libya paid compensation in 2003 while its officials said it was buying an end to sanctions, not admitting guilt. Some British relatives of the dead, notably Jim Swire, believe the conviction unsound and point to Iran, whose airliner an American warship had shot down that July. Scottish courts rejected a posthumous appeal in 2021.

Also on 21 December