Parallax

3 December, 1368

The birth of a king who would forget he was one

Charles VI of France was born the well-loved heir to a recovering kingdom. He reigned for forty-two years, was out of his mind for much of thirty of them, and ended by signing his crown over to the King of England.

Hotel Saint-Pol, Paris

The boy born at the Hotel Saint-Pol in Paris on 3 December 1368 was the long-awaited son of Charles V and Jeanne de Bourbon, who had been married eighteen years and buried their earlier children. His father gave him the Dauphine, the Alpine province bought by the crown in 1349, and he was the first heir to the French throne to bear the title of dauphin from his cradle. He was eleven when his father died in 1380, and for eight years his uncles, the dukes of Anjou, Berry and Burgundy, ruled in his name and helped themselves to the treasury.

At twenty he dismissed them and recalled his father’s old officials. He was tall, athletic, open-handed and fond of tournaments, and Parisians called him the Well-Beloved. In 1385 he had married Isabeau of Bavaria, who was about fifteen, three days after first seeing her.

On 5 August 1392 he was riding with an army through the forest near Le Mans, on his way to punish the Duke of Brittany, on a day of great heat. According to the monk of Saint-Denis who kept the official chronicle, a ragged man ran out, seized his bridle and shouted that he was betrayed. Some time later a drowsy page let a lance fall against another’s helmet. At the clang the king drew his sword, shouted that he was being delivered to his enemies, and charged his own household. He killed several men, four by Froissart’s count, before his chamberlain caught him from behind. He lay for two days in a stupor.

He recovered, and five months later was nearly burned alive. At a court masque in January 1393 he and five companions danced disguised as wild men in costumes of linen soaked in pitch and stuck with flax. A torch came too close. Four of the dancers died; the king was saved by the young Duchess of Berry, who smothered him in her skirts.

The attacks returned that summer and kept returning for the rest of his life, lasting weeks or months. In them, the chroniclers say, he did not know his wife or children, denied that he was king, said his name was Georges, and ran through the palace until he dropped. At one period he refused to wash or change his clothes for months. In between he was lucid, gentle, and aware of what was happening to him. Each time he sank, his relatives fought over who should govern, and each time he surfaced he signed what the winner put in front of him. He died on 21 October 1422, with, it was noted, no prince of his blood at the funeral.

How it came to this

France in 1368 was halfway through what later generations called the Hundred Years War. Charles’s grandfather John II had been captured by the English at Poitiers in 1356 and had died a prisoner in London; the treaty of 1360 handed Edward III a third of the kingdom. Charles V, a frail and bookish man who never led an army, spent his reign undoing that. Using his constable Bertrand du Guesclin, steady taxation and a refusal to fight pitched battles, he had recovered most of the lost territory by his death.

The system depended on a functioning king. Royal government in France was personal: the king’s signature and seal authorised spending, appointments and war, and there was no agreed procedure for a monarch who was alive, adult and intermittently incapable. Around the throne stood very rich princes with their own territories, above all the king’s uncle Philip of Burgundy and, as he grew up, the king’s younger brother Louis of Orleans. Jeanne de Bourbon, the king’s mother, had herself suffered a breakdown in 1373, and her family had a history of such illness, a point that contemporaries noticed.

How each side saw it

The monk of Saint-Denis and the people of Paris

Michel Pintoin, the monk who wrote the semi-official chronicle of the reign, records the illness with pity rather than contempt, as an affliction sent by God for the sins of the kingdom, and lists the processions, fasts and prayers ordered for the king’s cure. Sorcerers were also tried, and two were executed when they failed. The anonymous Parisian who kept a journal through these years describes ordinary people weeping in the streets at the funeral in 1422 and crying that they would never see good times again. The king was mourned by subjects who blamed everything on the men around him.

Burgundians and Armagnacs

Each of the two parties that tore France apart claimed to be protecting the king from the other. In 1407 John the Fearless, Duke of Burgundy, had Louis of Orleans cut down in a Paris street, and then hired a theologian, Jean Petit, to argue publicly that it was the lawful killing of a tyrant. The Orleanists, called Armagnacs after their leader, replied in kind when their men killed John on the bridge at Montereau in 1419, in the presence of the king’s son. Burgundian chroniclers such as Monstrelet and their opponents tell the reign as two incompatible stories of loyalty and treason.

Isabeau of Bavaria

The queen was left to preside over a council of feuding princes while bearing twelve children to a husband who in his attacks could not bear the sight of her. Later tradition made her a spendthrift adulteress who sold France at Troyes and declared her own son a bastard. Almost none of this is in sources written before her death. Historians including R. C. Famiglietti and Tracy Adams trace the legend to Burgundian propaganda and to later writers looking for a foreign woman to blame, and read her record as that of a mediator with very little power of her own.

The English

For Henry V the French king’s condition was an opportunity sanctioned by God. He invaded in 1415, destroyed a French army at Agincourt, and conquered Normandy town by town. By the Treaty of Troyes in May 1420 Charles VI gave Henry his daughter Catherine, named him heir and regent, and set aside ‘the so-called dauphin’. English lawyers held the treaty perfectly valid, sealed by a crowned king and ratified by the estates. The French argument that a madman under Burgundian control could not give away a crown that was not his to give became the legal foundation of the eventual recovery.

What is disputed

What ailed him cannot be diagnosed at this distance, though schizophrenia and bipolar illness are the usual suggestions, and poisoning and porphyria have had advocates. The often quoted total of forty-four attacks comes from counting episodes in Pintoin’s chronicle and depends on how one divides them. The belief that he thought himself made of glass, and wore iron rods in his clothes for fear of shattering, rests on Pope Pius II, writing a generation later, and is absent from the French chronicles. The number he killed in the forest ranges from one to four. Whether the Treaty of Troyes actually called the dauphin illegitimate is contested: its text cites his ‘horrible crimes’, not his birth.

What followed

Henry V died seven weeks before his father-in-law, so the double inheritance fell to a baby, Henry VI, proclaimed king of both realms. The disinherited dauphin held out south of the Loire until a peasant girl from Lorraine took him to be crowned at Reims in 1429; the English were gone from all but Calais by 1453. In that year Henry VI, Charles VI’s grandson through Catherine, fell into a stupor that lasted more than a year, and England slid into its own civil war. Catherine’s second family, by Owen Tudor, produced another dynasty.

Read further

  • R. C. Famiglietti, Royal Intrigue: Crisis at the Court of Charles VI, 1392-1420 (1986)
  • Bernard Guenee, La folie de Charles VI: roi Bien-Aime (2004)
  • Jonathan Sumption, Cursed Kings: The Hundred Years War IV (2015)
  • Tracy Adams, The Life and Afterlife of Isabeau of Bavaria (2010)
  • Jean Froissart, Chronicles, translated by Geoffrey Brereton (1968)

Same day, other years

1552

Francis Xavier dies within sight of China

Shangchuan Island, off Guangdong, ChinaAsia

The Basque Jesuit had spent ten years travelling from Goa to the Malabar coast, Malacca, the Moluccas and Japan, baptising by his own reckoning tens of thousands. He concluded that Japan would follow where China led, and in 1552 sailed to Shangchuan, an island where Portuguese smugglers traded, to find someone willing to slip him on to the forbidden mainland. The boatman he paid never came. He fell ill with fever in a hut of branches, attended by a Chinese convert named Antonio, and died on 3 December, aged forty-six. His body, said to be uncorrupted, was carried to Goa, where it remains.

Seen from elsewhere. Xavier’s letters show impatience with the societies he met and reliance on Portuguese power. In 1545 he urged the King of Portugal to send the Inquisition to Goa; established in 1560, it prosecuted thousands of Hindus, Muslims and converted Jews over two and a half centuries. In Goa today he is both a beloved patron and a symbol of forced conversion.

1854

Soldiers storm the Eureka Stockade

Ballarat, Victoria, AustraliaOceania

Gold diggers at Ballarat had to buy a costly licence whether they found gold or not, were hunted for it by police, and had no vote. After the acquittal of a publican accused of killing a miner, thousands met, burned their licences and swore an oath under a blue flag bearing the Southern Cross. About 150 were inside a rough timber stockade before dawn on Sunday 3 December when some 280 soldiers and police attacked. It was over in a quarter of an hour. At least twenty-two diggers and six soldiers died. Thirteen men were tried for high treason in Melbourne and juries acquitted every one.

Seen from elsewhere. Governor Hotham saw sedition led by foreigners; the diggers’ leader Peter Lalor denied being a democrat in any radical sense. Within a year the licence was gone and miners could vote, and Eureka is claimed as a birthplace of Australian democracy by unions and by nationalists alike. The goldfield lay on Wathaurong land, which neither side mentioned.

1967

A human heart is transplanted in Cape Town

Groote Schuur Hospital, Cape Town, South AfricaAfrica

Denise Darvall, twenty-five, was struck by a car while crossing the road to buy a cake and was declared beyond recovery. Her father gave his consent, and in the early hours of 3 December a team led by Christiaan Barnard placed her heart in the chest of Louis Washkansky, a grocer in his fifties dying of heart failure. It began to beat. Barnard became famous overnight. Washkansky lived eighteen days and died of pneumonia, his immune system suppressed by the drugs given to prevent rejection. Barnard’s second patient, a month later, lived for nineteen months.

Seen from elsewhere. The technique had been developed over a decade in California by Norman Shumway and Richard Lower, whose way was barred by American law on when a donor is dead. The second heart came from Clive Haupt, classified ‘Coloured’, and went to a white man under apartheid. Claims that the Black laboratory assistant Hamilton Naki took part in the operation were later withdrawn.

1984

Poison gas rolls over sleeping Bhopal

Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, IndiaAsia

Shortly after midnight on the night of 2-3 December, water entered a storage tank holding some forty tonnes of methyl isocyanate at a pesticide plant run by the Indian subsidiary of Union Carbide. The reaction blew a valve and a heavy cloud spread through the crowded settlements beside the factory wall. People woke choking and blind and ran, many into the gas. The state government’s count of immediate deaths was 3,787. Other estimates put the toll at 8,000 within a fortnight and well over 15,000 in the years since, with more than half a million exposed. It is the deadliest industrial accident on record.

Seen from elsewhere. Union Carbide blamed sabotage by a disgruntled employee and paid 470 million dollars in a 1989 settlement that survivors call a fraction of the harm. Survivors’ groups and Indian investigators point to safety systems switched off to save money. The company’s chairman, Warren Anderson, was never brought to trial; seven Indian managers received two-year sentences in 2010.

Also on 3 December