Parallax

14 December, 1799

George Washington is bled to death’s door

A sore throat on Friday, dead by Saturday night. His doctors took something like five pints of blood from him in twelve hours, and he thanked them for it.

Mount Vernon, Virginia

On Thursday 12 December 1799 George Washington spent about five hours on horseback riding round his farms in snow, hail and freezing rain. He was 67, two and a half years out of the presidency, and as punctual as ever; finding dinner waiting, he sat down in his damp clothes. The next day he had a sore throat but went out in the snow to mark trees for felling. That evening he read the newspapers aloud, as far as his hoarseness allowed. His secretary, Tobias Lear, suggested he take something for the cold. Washington said he never took anything for a cold: ‘Let it go as it came.’

Between two and three on Saturday morning he woke his wife and told her he was very ill. He could barely speak and struggled to breathe, but would not let Martha get up to call for help in case she caught a chill herself. At daybreak Caroline, an enslaved housemaid, came to light the fire and was sent for Lear. Washington asked for one of his overseers, George Rawlins, who was practised in bleeding livestock and people, and had him open a vein. When Rawlins hesitated the General said, ‘Don’t be afraid,’ and then, ‘More, more.’

Three physicians arrived in the course of the day: his old friend James Craik, Gustavus Brown and the young Elisha Dick. They bled him three more times, applied a blister of Spanish fly to his throat, dosed him with calomel and an emetic, and gave him an enema. Dick argued against the final bleeding and proposed cutting an opening in the windpipe, a new and risky operation. He was overruled. In all about eighty ounces of blood were taken, perhaps two-fifths of all he had.

By late afternoon Washington knew the outcome. He had Martha fetch two wills from his desk and burn the older. ‘Doctor, I die hard,’ he told Craik, ‘but I am not afraid to go.’ He thanked the doctors and asked them to trouble themselves no further. Around ten he gave Lear his last instruction with great effort: he was to be decently buried, and his body was not to be put into the vault until three days after his death. He had a dread of being buried alive. Lear nodded. ‘Do you understand me?’ Lear said he did. ‘’Tis well.’

He felt for his own pulse, and his hand fell away. Standing by the door were his valet Christopher Sheels and the housemaids Caroline, Molly and Charlotte, all four of them enslaved.

How it came to this

Washington had left office in March 1797, the first head of a modern republic to hand over power voluntarily after an election, and gone home to an estate of some eight thousand acres on the Potomac. He farmed scientifically, built one of the largest whiskey distilleries in the country, entertained a stream of uninvited visitors, and in 1798 reluctantly accepted nominal command of a new army when war with France seemed likely. On the day he fell ill he had been writing to Alexander Hamilton about a military academy.

The plantation ran on forced labour. In 1799 there were 317 enslaved people at Mount Vernon. Washington owned 123 of them outright; 153 were ‘dower’ slaves belonging to the estate of Martha’s first husband, whom he had no legal power to free, and the two groups had intermarried. He had come to regard slavery as wrong and economically ruinous and had stopped selling people, but he had also, as president, signed the Fugitive Slave Act and pursued those who escaped from his own household. In July 1799 he wrote a new will, in his own hand, to deal with the question.

How each side saw it

The enslaved people of Mount Vernon

None of the four who watched him die left a word on record. The will freed the 123 people Washington owned, but only on Martha’s death; she released them early, on 1 January 1801, telling Abigail Adams she did not feel safe among people whose freedom depended on her dying. The dower slaves stayed in bondage and were divided among her grandchildren, so that families were split. The fullest testimony comes from Ona Judge, Martha’s maid, who escaped from Philadelphia in 1796 and, interviewed by abolitionist newspapers in the 1840s, said she had never regretted it, poor as she was, and had received no schooling or religious instruction from the Washingtons.

The Seneca and the Haudenosaunee

Among the Iroquois nations Washington bore the name Conotocarious, Town Destroyer, inherited from his great-grandfather and earned afresh in 1779, when he ordered General John Sullivan to lay waste the country of the nations allied with Britain. Some forty towns, with their orchards and cornfields, were burned. The Seneca leader Cornplanter told him to his face in 1790, in an address preserved in the American state papers: ‘When your name is heard, our women look behind them and turn pale.’ Yet the Seneca prophet Handsome Lake, in the religious code still recited in longhouses, placed Washington alone among white men in a house near the gate of heaven, for letting the Iroquois keep some of their land.

The physicians

Craik and Dick published their account in the newspapers within days, describing the illness as cynanche trachealis, an inflammation of the upper windpipe, and the treatment as vigorous but orthodox. By the standards of 1799 it was: heroic bleeding was taught by Benjamin Rush, the most eminent American physician of the day. Criticism began almost at once. A doctor named James Brickell wrote that so old a man should never have been bled so heavily. Brown later admitted in a letter to Craik that Dick had probably been right, and that had they taken no more blood their patient might have lived.

What is disputed

Did the doctors kill him? The most widely accepted modern diagnosis, argued by David Morens in the New England Journal of Medicine in 1999, is acute bacterial epiglottitis, which could well have suffocated him whatever was done; the loss of so much blood can only have weakened him. The deathbed scene depends almost entirely on two accounts by Tobias Lear, which differ in small ways. No clergyman was sent for and no prayers are recorded, a silence used in the long argument over whether Washington was a believing Christian or a deist. The pious deathbed and the cherry tree alike come from Parson Weems, his inventive early biographer.

What followed

He was buried at Mount Vernon on 18 December. Congress heard Henry Lee call him ‘first in war, first in peace, and first in the hearts of his countrymen’, mock funerals were held in hundreds of American towns, and Napoleon ordered ten days of mourning in France. Washington was the only slaveholding president among the founders to free everyone he owned, a fact used both to honour him and to measure how little he did while he lived. Martha burned almost all their letters. Mount Vernon, bought by a women’s association in 1858, now interprets the lives of the enslaved alongside his.

Read further

  • Ron Chernow, Washington: A Life (2010)
  • Tobias Lear, Letters and Recollections of George Washington (1906)
  • Erica Armstrong Dunbar, Never Caught: The Washingtons’ Relentless Pursuit of Their Runaway Slave, Ona Judge (2017)
  • Colin G. Calloway, The Indian World of George Washington (2018)
  • Mary V. Thompson, ‘The Only Unavoidable Subject of Regret’: George Washington, Slavery, and the Enslaved Community at Mount Vernon (2019)

Same day, other years

1542

A week-old girl becomes Queen of Scots

Falkland Palace, Fife, ScotlandEurope

James V of Scotland died at Falkland aged thirty, three weeks after his army had been routed by a much smaller English force in the marshes at Solway Moss. He had not been at the battle. He had taken to his bed with a fever, and contemporaries said the humiliation finished him. Six days earlier his French queen, Mary of Guise, had given birth at Linlithgow to their only surviving legitimate child, a daughter. The infant Mary was now queen. Henry VIII at once demanded her as a bride for his son Edward, and when the Scots refused he sent armies to burn Edinburgh and the Border abbeys.

Seen from elsewhere. John Knox and the chronicler Pitscottie have the dying king say of the Stewart crown that it came with a lass and would pass with a lass. Neither was present and the line is probably legend. Modern historians think he died of dysentery or cholera, not despair. The Scots called Henry’s campaign the Rough Wooing and sent Mary to France.

1911

Amundsen’s party reaches the South Pole

South Pole, AntarcticaWorldwide

Roald Amundsen, Olav Bjaaland, Helmer Hanssen, Sverre Hassel and Oscar Wisting arrived at the Pole on skis at about three in the afternoon, with their surviving dogs, and planted the Norwegian flag together, five hands on the staff. They had set out with fifty-two dogs and had shot most of them on the way, as planned, to feed the rest and themselves. They spent three days taking sightings to be sure of the position, left a tent with a letter for the King of Norway and a note asking Robert Scott to forward it, and were back at their base in ninety-nine days. Scott found the tent on 18 January 1912 and died on the return.

Seen from elsewhere. Many in Britain thought Amundsen had behaved shabbily: he had announced an Arctic voyage and told Scott of his change of plan only by telegram from Madeira. Norwegians note that his methods, skis, dogs and fur clothing, were learned largely from the Netsilik Inuit. Because he had crossed the date line without adjusting his calendar, the day is sometimes given as 15 December.

1960

The UN declares colonialism must end

United Nations, New YorkWorldwide

Seventeen newly independent states, sixteen of them African, had joined the United Nations in the course of 1960 and shifted its balance. On 14 December the General Assembly adopted Resolution 1514, drafted by forty-three Asian and African members. It declared that the subjection of peoples to alien domination was a denial of fundamental human rights, that all peoples had the right to self-determination, and that inadequate political or educational preparedness should never serve as a pretext for delaying independence. Eighty-nine states voted in favour and none against. The declaration became the legal charter of decolonisation, cited in almost every independence dispute that followed.

Seen from elsewhere. Nine states abstained: Britain, France, Belgium, Portugal, Spain, South Africa, Australia, the Dominican Republic and the United States. Portugal insisted that Angola and Mozambique were overseas provinces, not colonies. A clause protecting the territorial integrity of states was later invoked by new governments against their own secessionists, in Katanga and Biafra among other places.

1971

The killing of Bengal’s intellectuals

Dhaka, East Pakistan (now Bangladesh)Asia

Two days before the Pakistani army surrendered in Dhaka, with Indian forces closing on the city, men of the Al-Badr militia went from house to house with lists. They took away university teachers, journalists, doctors and writers, blindfolded, in a mud-smeared minibus. The bodies of many were found afterwards in the brickfields at Rayerbazar and at Mirpur, hands tied. Among them were the playwright Munier Chowdhury, the novelist Shahidullah Kaiser, the cardiologist Fazle Rabbi and the journalist Selina Parvin. Bangladesh counts more than two hundred taken in those final days and around a thousand intellectuals killed during the nine months of war, and keeps 14 December as Martyred Intellectuals Day.

Seen from elsewhere. Pakistan’s own commission of inquiry heard officers deny any plan to kill intellectuals, though a list of names was found in the papers of General Rao Farman Ali. In 2013 a Bangladeshi tribunal sentenced two former Al-Badr leaders to death in their absence. The Islamist party Jamaat-e-Islami calls the trials political, and international human rights groups criticised their procedures.

Also on 14 December