Parallax

19 December, 1154

Henry of Anjou is crowned King of England

A red-haired Frenchman of twenty-one, already master of half of France, was crowned at Westminster after nineteen years of civil war. England had waited six weeks for him without a king and, to general surprise, without a fight.

Westminster Abbey, England

King Stephen died at Dover on 25 October 1154. His appointed heir was not in England. Henry, Duke of Normandy and Aquitaine and Count of Anjou, was besieging a rebellious vassal’s castle on the Norman frontier, and he finished the siege before he turned for the coast. Then the wind kept him at Barfleur for a month. He crossed in rough weather on 7 December with his wife, Eleanor of Aquitaine, who was seven months pregnant, and a company of barons and bishops.

What struck contemporaries was what did not happen in the interval. For some six weeks the kingdom had no crowned ruler, in a country where a generation had grown up amid private war, and no one moved. The chronicler Henry of Huntingdon, an archdeacon then near the end of a long life, wrote that England remained at peace, whether from love or from fear of the king who was coming. Archbishop Theobald of Canterbury held the government together and waited.

Henry went first to Winchester, where the treasure was, and then to London. On Sunday 19 December Theobald anointed and crowned him in Westminster Abbey in the presence of the English and Norman magnates and prelates from both sides of the Channel. Several chroniclers imply that Eleanor was crowned with him, though none describes it. Huntingdon closed his history at this point with a Latin poem of welcome to the new king. The Peterborough monk who wrote the last entries of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle recorded that Henry was received with great honour and held a great court in London.

The new king was stocky, freckled and restless, careless of dress, and so impatient that he was said never to sit down except to eat or ride. He spoke French and Latin and understood English without speaking it. Within days he issued a charter confirming the liberties and customs of his grandfather, Henry I. It did not mention Stephen at all. The nineteen years between were treated as a gap in lawful government, and that was to be the policy of the reign.

He moved fast. Stephen’s Flemish mercenaries were ordered out of the country. Castles built without licence during the war were to be pulled down, and royal lands and fortresses that had passed into baronial hands were to come back. Most barons complied; the few who did not were besieged in person during 1155. In January, on Theobald’s advice, the king took as his chancellor a clever London-born archdeacon named Thomas Becket.

How it came to this

Henry I died in 1135 leaving one legitimate child, his daughter Matilda, widow of a German emperor and wife of Geoffrey, Count of Anjou. The barons had sworn to accept her. Instead her cousin Stephen of Blois crossed the Channel and was crowned within three weeks. Matilda landed in 1139 to claim her inheritance, captured Stephen in 1141, was driven from London before she could be crowned, and lost her advantage. The war that followed was fought castle by castle, mostly in the south and west, while her husband conquered Normandy. The Peterborough chronicler wrote that men said openly that Christ and his saints slept.

Her son took up the claim. Henry was knighted by his great-uncle, the King of Scots, in 1149, became Duke of Normandy in 1150 and Count of Anjou in 1151. In May 1152 he married Eleanor, heiress of Aquitaine, eight weeks after her marriage to Louis VII of France was annulled. He invaded England in 1153. Neither army wanted a battle, and when Stephen’s elder son Eustace died suddenly that August, the bishops brokered a settlement: Stephen would reign for life and Henry would succeed him.

How each side saw it

The English chroniclers

Almost everything written in England about 1154 comes from monks and clergy, who had suffered in the war and wanted order. Henry of Huntingdon, the Peterborough chronicler and, a generation later, William of Newburgh all present the accession as deliverance. Newburgh says the people, worn down by long misery, hoped for better things from the new prince. These writers were not neutral: church property had been plundered by both sides, and a strong king promised restitution. Their picture of unrelieved anarchy under Stephen was drawn largely from the worst-hit regions, such as the Fens, where Peterborough lay.

Stephen’s party

The losers left little testimony. Stephen had a surviving son, William, who was passed over by his father’s treaty and compensated with the family’s vast estates. Gervase of Canterbury reports a plot among the Flemish soldiers in 1154 to kill Henry, of which William was said to know. The Gesta Stephani, a chronicle written by a supporter of Stephen, changes sides in its last pages and calls Henry the lawful heir, a sign of how completely the cause had collapsed. To those who had fought for a crowned and anointed king for nineteen years, the charter that erased his reign was a rewriting of the record.

The Scots and the Welsh

Henry’s neighbours had done well out of English weakness. David I of Scotland had taken Cumbria and Northumbria, and in 1149 the young Henry had sworn at Carlisle that if he became king the Scots should keep them. In 1157 he made David’s grandson, the sixteen-year-old Malcolm IV, hand them back. In Wales, Owain of Gwynedd and Rhys ap Gruffydd of Deheubarth had recovered lands lost to Norman lords. The Welsh chronicle Brut y Tywysogion records Henry’s invasions of 1157 and 1165 from the receiving end, including the mutilation of Welsh hostages after the second one failed.

The Empress Matilda

The claim was hers. Matilda had been promised the crown, had come within days of a coronation in 1141, and was mocked by hostile chroniclers for an arrogance they would have praised in a king. She did not attend her son’s coronation and never returned to England, governing Normandy for him from Rouen until her death in 1167. Her epitaph called her great by birth, greater by marriage, greatest in her offspring. No source records what she thought of a settlement that gave England to her son while she lived, on the strength of a right that had been denied to her.

What is disputed

Whether Eleanor was crowned on the same day is uncertain; the evidence is a few brief phrases. How bad Stephen’s reign really was has been argued for a century: historians such as Edmund King and David Crouch see royal government surviving in much of the country, where older writers saw collapse. The name Plantagenet was not used by Henry or his sons as a surname; it was adopted by Richard, Duke of York, three centuries later. The term Angevin Empire is Victorian, and scholars including W. L. Warren and John Gillingham disagree over whether Henry’s lands were ever governed as a single realm.

What followed

Henry reigned for thirty-four years. His judges, travelling on regular circuits, and his use of sworn local juries laid the foundations of the English common law. His quarrel with Becket ended in the archbishop’s murder at Canterbury in 1170; his wife and sons rebelled against him in 1173. He died at Chinon in 1189, defeated by his son Richard and the King of France. His descendants in the male line held the English throne until Richard III was killed at Bosworth in 1485.

Read further

  • W. L. Warren, Henry II (1973)
  • Henry of Huntingdon, Historia Anglorum, edited and translated by Diana Greenway (1996)
  • Emilie Amt, The Accession of Henry II in England: Royal Government Restored, 1149-1159 (1993)
  • Graeme J. White, Restoration and Reform, 1153-1165: Recovery from Civil War in England (2000)
  • John Gillingham, The Angevin Empire (2001)

Same day, other years

1642

Tasman’s sailors and Maori meet, and four men die

Golden Bay (Mohua), New ZealandOceania

Abel Tasman, sailing for the Dutch East India Company with two ships, had sighted the west coast of a land unknown to Europeans six days earlier. He anchored in a wide bay at the top of the South Island. On the evening of 18 December canoes came out, and the men in them called and blew on an instrument; the Dutch answered with trumpets. Next morning a canoe rammed a small boat rowing between the two ships. Four Dutch sailors were killed. Tasman fired on the canoes, weighed anchor without setting foot ashore, and named the place Murderers’ Bay. No European came back for 127 years.

Seen from elsewhere. The people of the bay were Ngati Tumatakokiri, who were themselves conquered and scattered by other tribes around 1800, so little of their own tradition of the day survives. The anthropologist Anne Salmond suggests the trumpet reply was heard as accepting a challenge to fight. Others think they were defending their cultivations from strangers who looked set to land.

1843

A Christmas Carol goes on sale

London, EnglandEurope

Charles Dickens wrote the story of Ebenezer Scrooge in about six weeks that autumn, walking the London streets at night to work it out. He was short of money, his current novel was selling poorly, and he had been stirred by a parliamentary report on child labour and a visit to a ragged school for destitute children. He paid for the production himself and insisted on a handsome little book with hand-coloured plates by John Leech, priced at five shillings. The first printing of 6,000 copies sold out by Christmas Eve. The costs were so high that his profit was a fraction of what he had expected.

Seen from elsewhere. The Westminster Review asked who went without turkey so that Bob Cratchit could have one, and critics since have noted that the tale cures poverty by a rich man’s change of heart, not by any reform. The claim that Dickens invented the modern Christmas overstates it: the revival was under way, and the first Christmas card appeared the same year.

1961

Portugal’s governor surrenders Goa

Goa, IndiaAsia

Portugal had held Goa since Afonso de Albuquerque took it in 1510, longer than any other European power held anything in Asia. After Indian independence in 1947 the Portuguese dictator Antonio Salazar refused to discuss a transfer, insisting that Goa was not a colony but a province of Portugal. Fourteen years of diplomacy, blockade and unarmed protest marches, some of them fired on, changed nothing. On 18 December 1961 Indian land, sea and air forces moved in. The Portuguese garrison of a few thousand was hopelessly outmatched, and on the evening of the 19th the governor-general, Manuel Vassalo e Silva, surrendered, ignoring Salazar’s order to fight to the last man.

Seen from elsewhere. Lisbon called it an invasion, broke off relations until 1974 and disgraced its governor for sparing his men. Western governments rebuked Nehru, the advocate of non-violence, for using force, and a Security Council resolution against India was vetoed by the Soviet Union. Goans were not consulted in 1961; in a 1967 poll they voted against merging with a neighbouring state.

2001

Argentina’s streets fill with saucepans

Buenos Aires, ArgentinaThe Americas

Three years of recession, a currency pegged one-to-one to the dollar and a foreign debt that could no longer be serviced had brought Argentina to the edge. At the start of December the government limited cash withdrawals from banks. In the days before Christmas, supermarkets were looted in the poor suburbs of Buenos Aires and other cities. On the night of 19 December President Fernando de la Rua declared a state of siege on television. Within minutes people came out onto balconies and then into the streets banging pots, and converged on the Plaza de Mayo. Police repression over the following day left some three dozen dead across the country. De la Rua resigned and left the presidential palace by helicopter.

Seen from elsewhere. De la Rua maintained that the looting was organised by Peronist party bosses and amounted to a civil coup. Protesters’ slogan was aimed at the whole political class: ‘out with all of them’. Courts later convicted senior security officials over the deaths in the capital. How much blame belongs to the International Monetary Fund, which had backed the currency peg, is still argued.

Also on 19 December