Parallax

4 December, 1642

Richelieu dies, and the provinces light bonfires

For eighteen years a sickly cardinal had governed France in the king’s name, broken its nobles, starved out its Protestants and taxed its peasants into revolt. Asked on his deathbed to forgive his enemies, he said he had none but the state’s.

Palais-Cardinal, Paris

Armand-Jean du Plessis, Cardinal-Duke of Richelieu, had been dying for most of the year. Ulcers on his right arm had left him unable to write, and he had spent the summer of 1642 being carried across France in a litter so large that walls were knocked down to let it into the houses where he slept. From that litter he had directed the siege of Perpignan and the destruction of the last conspiracy against him. In September the king’s young favourite, the Marquis of Cinq-Mars, went to the block in Lyon for plotting with Spain, and the cardinal came home to Paris.

At the end of November he developed a pain in his side and began to cough blood. His doctors bled him repeatedly. On 2 December Louis XIII came to the Palais-Cardinal, the great house Richelieu had built opposite the Louvre, and by the usual account fed him two egg yolks with his own hand. The cardinal told the king that he left his kingdom at the highest point of glory it had known and all its enemies beaten down, and recommended as his successor an Italian-born diplomat in his service, Jules Mazarin.

When the parish priest of Saint-Eustache brought the last sacraments and asked whether he forgave his enemies, Richelieu is reported to have answered that he had never had any other than those of the state. Looking at the host he said, ‘Here is my judge, who will soon pronounce my sentence.’ Onlookers were divided between those who were edified by so much assurance and those who were appalled by it.

On 4 December he sent away his niece, the Duchess of Aiguillon, the person he loved best, so that she should not watch. He died about midday, aged fifty-seven. The king, told the news, is said to have remarked only that a great politician was dead.

Paris was quiet. In several provinces people lit bonfires. He was buried in the chapel of the Sorbonne, the college he had rebuilt at his own cost, and the fortune he left was the largest any French subject had yet assembled, some twenty million livres. The Palais-Cardinal itself he had already made over to the crown, and it is the Palais-Royal today. Louis XIII kept his ministers, kept his policies, and followed him to the grave five months later.

How it came to this

Richelieu was born in 1585 into the minor nobility of Poitou and was meant for the army. He became a bishop instead at twenty-one, by papal dispensation, to keep the see of Lucon in the family. He rose through the patronage of the queen mother, Marie de Medici, was made a cardinal in 1622, and entered the royal council in 1624. Louis XIII, a shy and difficult man who did not much like him, kept him there until death, most famously on the Day of Dupes in 1630, when the queen mother thought she had secured his dismissal and found by evening that she had secured her own exile.

He stated his aims himself: to ruin the Huguenot party, to humble the pride of the great, to bring all subjects to their duty, and to raise the king’s name among foreign nations. The first meant the year-long siege of La Rochelle in 1627-28, which the city entered with some 27,000 inhabitants and ended with about 5,000. The last meant fighting the Habsburgs of Spain and Austria, which a cardinal of the Roman church did by subsidising Protestant Sweden and, from 1635, by open war.

How each side saw it

The great nobility

To the high aristocracy he was a tyrant who had made himself master of a weak king and killed their kind by judicial murder. He had the Count of Chalais beheaded in 1626, the Count of Montmorency-Bouteville in 1627 for duelling in defiance of an edict, the Duke of Montmorency in 1632, Cinq-Mars and his friend de Thou in 1642, several of them tried by special commissions rather than their peers. The memoirs of Cardinal de Retz and La Rochefoucauld, written by men who had conspired, present a France where birth no longer protected anyone. The king’s own brother Gaston plotted against him repeatedly and was repeatedly forgiven.

The Huguenots

French Protestants remembered La Rochelle as a slow massacre by hunger. The Peace of Ales in 1629 took away their fortified towns and their assemblies, the guarantees that had made the Edict of Nantes more than a promise. Richelieu left their worship and civil rights intact and employed Protestant generals, and some Huguenot writers of the time thanked him for it. Later Protestant historians drew the line differently: once the walls were gone the community existed on royal sufferance, and Louis XIV withdrew the sufferance in 1685. Whether Richelieu intended that end or would have opposed it is argued both ways.

The peasants who paid

The war was financed by roughly trebling direct taxes in a decade, collected with the help of soldiers. The result was the largest wave of rural revolt in French history before 1789: the Croquants of the south-west in 1636-37 and the Nu-pieds, the barefoot ones, of Normandy in 1639, who rose against a rumoured extension of the salt tax. Their manifestos, which survive, protest loyalty to the king and blame evil ministers and tax farmers. Richelieu sent troops, and the chancellor Seguier toured Normandy holding summary trials. The bonfires of December 1642 were lit in this France.

Devout Catholics and Rome

The party at court known as the devots held that a Catholic king’s first duty was to fight heresy alongside Spain, not to fight Spain alongside heretics, and that the cardinal put reason of state above religion. Spanish pamphleteers and the Flemish theologian Cornelius Jansen, in his Mars Gallicus of 1635, said so at length. The remark attributed to Pope Urban VIII, that if there is a God the cardinal has much to answer for and if not he did very well, is almost certainly a later invention, but it captures the Roman view. Richelieu’s own Political Testament argues that states, unlike souls, have no afterlife.

What is disputed

The deathbed sayings come from pious contemporary accounts and were polished in the retelling; the reply about the enemies of the state is early and widely reported, but no version can be called a transcript. The authenticity of the Political Testament was denied by Voltaire and is now generally accepted, with parts drafted by assistants. The larger argument is over what he built. An older French tradition made him the architect of the absolute monarchy and the modern state. Joseph Bergin and others show a minister improvising from crisis to crisis, governing through a network of relatives and clients, and enriching himself by the methods he condemned in others.

What followed

Mazarin carried the war to its conclusion: French victory at Rocroi in 1643, the Peace of Westphalia in 1648, and peace with Spain in 1659, which left France the leading power in Europe. The resentments Richelieu had held down exploded in the Fronde of 1648-53, the last revolt of nobles and judges against the crown. The Academie francaise, which he founded in 1635, still sits. In 1793 revolutionaries broke open his tomb and a bystander carried off the front of his skull; it was returned to the Sorbonne in 1866.

Read further

  • Joseph Bergin, Cardinal Richelieu: Power and the Pursuit of Wealth (1985)
  • J. H. Elliott, Richelieu and Olivares (1984)
  • R. J. Knecht, Richelieu (1991)
  • Anthony Levi, Cardinal Richelieu and the Making of France (2000)
  • Cardinal Richelieu, Testament politique, edited by Louis Andre (1947)

Same day, other years

1563

The Council of Trent closes after eighteen years

Trento, northern ItalyEurope

The council that Rome had called to answer Luther first met in December 1545, a generation after his protest, and sat in three widely separated periods interrupted by plague, war and papal reluctance. Its twenty-fifth and last session ended on 4 December 1563 with the bishops shouting acclamations and, by one account, weeping. It had defined Catholic teaching on scripture and tradition, justification, the seven sacraments and the Mass, in terms that excluded the Protestant positions, and ordered practical reforms: bishops to live in their dioceses, a seminary to train priests in each one, and an end to the sale of indulgences.

Seen from elsewhere. Protestants had asked for a free council on German soil; a few envoys appeared in 1552 and were given no vote. The Venetian friar Paolo Sarpi, in a history published in London in 1619, portrayed the whole affair as managed from Rome to strengthen the papacy. The split it was summoned to heal became permanent.

1829

The East India Company outlaws the burning of widows

Calcutta, Bengal Presidency, IndiaAsia

Regulation XVII, issued by the governor-general Lord William Bentinck on 4 December 1829, declared the practice of sati, the burning or burying alive of a Hindu widow with her husband’s body, illegal and punishable in the criminal courts, with those who assisted liable for culpable homicide. Company officials had recorded some eight thousand cases in the Bengal Presidency between 1815 and 1828, concentrated around Calcutta and among higher castes. Earlier governors had feared that interference with religion would provoke the army. Bentinck acted after canvassing his officers, and with the arguments of the Bengali reformer Ram Mohan Roy, who had shown that the scriptures did not require it.

Seen from elsewhere. Orthodox Hindus led by Radhakanta Deb petitioned the Privy Council in London, pleading the Company’s promise of religious non-interference; they lost in 1832. Roy himself had advised persuasion rather than law. The historian Lata Mani observes that officials, reformers and traditionalists all argued over texts, and that the widows’ own voices are almost absent from the record.

1969

Chicago police kill Fred Hampton in his bed

Chicago, United StatesThe Americas

Hampton was twenty-one, chairman of the Illinois chapter of the Black Panther Party, and a gifted organiser who had brokered a truce among Chicago street gangs and set up free breakfasts for children. At about 4.45 am on 4 December, fourteen officers assigned to the Cook County state’s attorney raided his flat on West Monroe Street with a warrant for illegal weapons. They fired more than ninety shots. Hampton, asleep beside his pregnant fiancee, was killed, as was Mark Clark, who was on guard. Ballistics later showed that at most one shot had come from the Panthers.

Seen from elsewhere. State’s Attorney Edward Hanrahan described a fierce gun battle begun by the occupants, and no officer was convicted. It later emerged that Hampton’s head of security was an FBI informant who had supplied a floor plan marking the bed. The families’ civil suit was settled in 1982 for 1.85 million dollars, paid by city, county and federal governments.

1977

Bokassa crowns himself emperor

Bangui, Central African EmpireAfrica

Jean-Bedel Bokassa, a former captain in the French colonial army who had seized power in 1966, had declared his landlocked and very poor country an empire a year earlier. On 4 December 1977, in a sports stadium in Bangui, he placed a diamond-studded crown on his own head in a ceremony copied in detail from Napoleon’s, with a gilded throne in the shape of an eagle, an ermine-trimmed robe, and a coach drawn by horses flown in from Europe. The cost has been put at around twenty million dollars, a large fraction of the state’s yearly budget. France paid much of the bill.

Seen from elsewhere. Bokassa said a monarchy would win his country respect, and Paris, which valued its uranium and its bases, indulged him. Hardly any foreign heads of state came. After schoolchildren were killed in custody in 1979, French paratroopers removed him. He was later convicted of murder, acquitted of the cannibalism widely alleged, and formally rehabilitated by his country in 2010.

Also on 4 December