On 25 April 799 Pope Leo III was riding in procession through Rome when a band of men led by relatives of his predecessor dragged him from his horse, tried to cut out his tongue and blind him, and shut him in a monastery. He escaped over the wall at night and made his way north across the Alps to Paderborn, in the newly conquered land of the Saxons, where Charles, king of the Franks and the Lombards, was holding court. His enemies sent their own envoys after him, accusing him of perjury and adultery.
Charles sent the pope back to Rome under escort and followed in his own time. He arrived in late November 800 and was met twelve miles outside the city by Leo himself, an honour that ancient custom reserved for an emperor. For three weeks a council of clergy and Roman nobles sat in St Peter’s to examine the charges. Nobody, the bishops said, could sit in judgment on the apostolic see. On 23 December Leo cleared himself by swearing an oath on the Gospels, in public, that he was innocent.
Two days later Charles came to St Peter’s for the Christmas mass. As he rose from prayer before the tomb of the apostle, Leo placed a crown on his head. The Roman congregation, apparently on cue, shouted three times the acclamation recorded in the Frankish annals: to Charles Augustus, crowned by God, great and peaceful emperor of the Romans, life and victory. According to the same annals the pope then knelt before him in the old ceremonial gesture of homage owed to an emperor.
Charles was somewhere in his fifties, his birth year uncertain, and he had been at war almost every summer for thirty years. He ruled from the Ebro to the Elbe and from the North Sea to the edge of Rome. Within days of the coronation the men who had attacked Leo were tried as traitors against the emperor and condemned to death; at the pope’s request the sentence was commuted to exile.
Charles stayed in Italy until Easter and then went home to Aachen. He did not go back to Rome again. In his remaining fourteen years he used the new title on his documents, sent his son Louis to be crowned in 813 at Aachen without any pope present, and spent much effort persuading the emperor in Constantinople to admit that there could be two.
How it came to this
The last emperor in the West, Romulus Augustulus, had been set aside in 476, and for three centuries the only Roman emperor was the one in Constantinople. The popes were in theory his subjects. In practice Byzantine power in Italy had collapsed, and from the 750s the popes looked instead to the Franks, whose kings Pippin and then Charles had defeated the Lombards, guaranteed the papacy’s lands and in return received papal blessing for a new dynasty.
In 797 the empress Irene had her own son, Constantine VI, blinded and deposed, and ruled in Constantinople in her own name. To many western churchmen a woman could not hold the imperial office, so the throne of the Romans could be described as empty. Charles’s adviser Alcuin wrote in 799 that the papacy, the empire in the East and the Frankish kingship were the three highest powers in the world, and that the first two were in disgrace. Only Charles was left standing.