Parallax

25 December, AD 800

A Frankish king becomes emperor at Christmas mass

In St Peter’s in Rome, a pope who had recently been beaten in the street placed a crown on the head of the man who had rescued him, and the crowd hailed a Roman emperor in the West for the first time in three centuries.

St Peter’s Basilica, Rome

On 25 April 799 Pope Leo III was riding in procession through Rome when a band of men led by relatives of his predecessor dragged him from his horse, tried to cut out his tongue and blind him, and shut him in a monastery. He escaped over the wall at night and made his way north across the Alps to Paderborn, in the newly conquered land of the Saxons, where Charles, king of the Franks and the Lombards, was holding court. His enemies sent their own envoys after him, accusing him of perjury and adultery.

Charles sent the pope back to Rome under escort and followed in his own time. He arrived in late November 800 and was met twelve miles outside the city by Leo himself, an honour that ancient custom reserved for an emperor. For three weeks a council of clergy and Roman nobles sat in St Peter’s to examine the charges. Nobody, the bishops said, could sit in judgment on the apostolic see. On 23 December Leo cleared himself by swearing an oath on the Gospels, in public, that he was innocent.

Two days later Charles came to St Peter’s for the Christmas mass. As he rose from prayer before the tomb of the apostle, Leo placed a crown on his head. The Roman congregation, apparently on cue, shouted three times the acclamation recorded in the Frankish annals: to Charles Augustus, crowned by God, great and peaceful emperor of the Romans, life and victory. According to the same annals the pope then knelt before him in the old ceremonial gesture of homage owed to an emperor.

Charles was somewhere in his fifties, his birth year uncertain, and he had been at war almost every summer for thirty years. He ruled from the Ebro to the Elbe and from the North Sea to the edge of Rome. Within days of the coronation the men who had attacked Leo were tried as traitors against the emperor and condemned to death; at the pope’s request the sentence was commuted to exile.

Charles stayed in Italy until Easter and then went home to Aachen. He did not go back to Rome again. In his remaining fourteen years he used the new title on his documents, sent his son Louis to be crowned in 813 at Aachen without any pope present, and spent much effort persuading the emperor in Constantinople to admit that there could be two.

How it came to this

The last emperor in the West, Romulus Augustulus, had been set aside in 476, and for three centuries the only Roman emperor was the one in Constantinople. The popes were in theory his subjects. In practice Byzantine power in Italy had collapsed, and from the 750s the popes looked instead to the Franks, whose kings Pippin and then Charles had defeated the Lombards, guaranteed the papacy’s lands and in return received papal blessing for a new dynasty.

In 797 the empress Irene had her own son, Constantine VI, blinded and deposed, and ruled in Constantinople in her own name. To many western churchmen a woman could not hold the imperial office, so the throne of the Romans could be described as empty. Charles’s adviser Alcuin wrote in 799 that the papacy, the empire in the East and the Frankish kingship were the three highest powers in the world, and that the first two were in disgrace. Only Charles was left standing.

How each side saw it

Einhard, Charles’s courtier and biographer

Writing in the 820s, Einhard claimed that Charles disliked the title so much at first that he said he would not have entered the church that day, even though it was a great feast, if he had known what the pope intended. Historians have argued over this line for two centuries. It may be the stock modesty of a classical biography modelled on Suetonius, or a real irritation that the pope had made himself the giver of the crown, or a later attempt to play down a quarrel with Constantinople. Einhard does not say which.

The papal court

The Life of Leo III in the Liber Pontificalis, the official papal history, presents the day as an act of God through the pope. In its telling, Leo crowned Charles with his own hands and the faithful Romans, seeing how much he had loved and defended the Church, cried out together by the will of God. For later popes the order of events mattered more than anything else in the ceremony: the pope crowned first and the people acclaimed afterwards. That sequence became the basis of claims that emperors held their office from the papacy.

Constantinople

To the Byzantine court there already was a Roman emperor, and the coronation was a usurpation by a barbarian king. The chronicler Theophanes the Confessor, writing a few years later, notes that Leo crowned Charles and anointed him with oil from head to foot, and treats the episode as an outrage, the pope repaying the Franks for avenging him. Constantinople refused recognition for twelve years. In 812 envoys of Michael I finally acclaimed Charles as basileus at Aachen, though not as emperor of the Romans, a title Byzantium kept for itself.

The Saxons

The Saxons left no written account of their conquest. What we know comes from their conquerors: the Royal Frankish Annals, Einhard, and Charles’s own law for Saxony, the Capitulatio de partibus Saxoniae, which set death as the penalty for refusing baptism, eating meat in Lent or cremating the dead. The annals record that in 782 at Verden some 4,500 Saxons were handed over and put to death in a single day. Saxon resistance under Widukind and others lasted more than thirty years, which is itself the strongest evidence of how the conquest was received.

What is disputed

Who planned the ceremony is the central argument. Older scholarship, especially German and French, saw a papal surprise; most recent historians, among them Janet Nelson and Rosamond McKitterick, think it had been arranged since Paderborn and that Einhard’s story of reluctance is literary. Charles’s birth year is uncertain, 742, 747 and 748 all being proposed, so his age in 800 was somewhere between 52 and 58. The Verden figure of 4,500 is the annals’ own number, and some scholars have suggested the word for beheaded is a copying error for relocated, though most still accept the killing.

What followed

Charles died at Aachen in 814. His empire was divided among his grandsons by the Treaty of Verdun in 843, along lines that roughly anticipate France and Germany. The title passed in the tenth century to the German kings, beginning with Otto I in 962, and the institution later known as the Holy Roman Empire lasted until 1806. Both France and Germany claim Charles as a founder, and since 1950 the city of Aachen has awarded a Charlemagne Prize for services to European unity.

Read further

  • Einhard, The Life of Charlemagne
  • Bernhard Walter Scholz (trans.), Carolingian Chronicles: Royal Frankish Annals and Nithard’s Histories (1970)
  • Janet L. Nelson, King and Emperor: A New Life of Charlemagne (2019)
  • Rosamond McKitterick, Charlemagne: The Formation of a European Identity (2008)
  • Cyril Mango and Roger Scott (trans.), The Chronicle of Theophanes Confessor (1997)

Same day, other years

1492

The Santa Maria runs aground off Hispaniola

Northern coast of Hispaniola (Haiti)The Americas

Shortly before midnight on Christmas Eve, with the helmsman having handed the tiller to a ship’s boy, Columbus’s flagship drifted onto a reef off the north coast of Hispaniola and by Christmas morning could not be saved. The Taino cacique Guacanagari sent canoes and people to unload the cargo, and Columbus wrote that nothing was stolen. Unable to take everyone home in the two remaining ships, he built a fort from the wreck’s timbers, named it La Navidad, and left 39 men behind with orders to trade for gold when he sailed for Spain. It was the first European settlement in the Americas since the Norse.

Seen from elsewhere. When Columbus returned in November 1493 the fort was burned and all 39 men were dead. Guacanagari said another cacique, Caonabo, had killed them; Taino informants told the Spanish the men had seized women and gold. Almost all we know of the Taino side passes through Spanish writers such as Columbus and Las Casas.

1968

The Kilvenmani massacre

Kilvenmani, Thanjavur district, Tamil Nadu, IndiaAsia

In the rice-growing Cauvery delta, Dalit agricultural labourers organised by a Communist-led union had been demanding higher wages, measured in paddy, from the landowners. On the night of 25 December 1968 a group of armed men linked to the landowners’ association attacked the labourers’ hamlet of Kilvenmani. Women, children and old people took refuge in a single hut; it was set on fire and 44 people, most of them women and children, burned to death. Survivors and the union named the landowners’ leader as the organiser. It became one of the defining atrocities of caste violence in independent India.

Seen from elsewhere. The trial court convicted several accused, but in 1973 the Madras High Court acquitted all of them, finding it hard to believe that wealthy landowners would personally take part. Dalit and left-wing writers have treated that judgment as proof of caste bias in the courts; the landowners presented the clash as a law and order conflict stirred up by agitators.

1974

Cyclone Tracy flattens Darwin

Darwin, Northern Territory, AustraliaOceania

In the early hours of Christmas Day a small but extremely intense tropical cyclone passed directly over Darwin. A gust of 217 kilometres an hour was recorded at the airport before the instrument failed. Around seventy per cent of the city’s houses were destroyed or badly damaged, and about seventy people were killed on land and at sea. Within a week more than 30,000 of the roughly 47,000 residents had been flown or driven out, the largest peacetime evacuation in Australian history. The city was rebuilt over several years under far stricter building codes.

Seen from elsewhere. Warnings had been broadcast, but many residents assumed the storm would miss, as an earlier one had weeks before. The counting of the dead has been questioned because some people lost at sea were never identified, and the decision to empty the city and control who could return was resented by many who wanted to stay and rebuild.

1991

Gorbachev resigns and the red flag comes down

The Kremlin, MoscowEurope

Mikhail Gorbachev announced on television that he was ceasing his activity as President of the Soviet Union. Four days earlier the leaders of eleven republics had agreed at Alma-Ata to form a Commonwealth of Independent States, leaving him with no state to preside over. He did not formally dissolve the union, saying only that the policy of dismemberment had prevailed. He handed the nuclear command codes to Boris Yeltsin, President of Russia. That evening the Soviet flag was lowered over the Kremlin and replaced with the Russian tricolour. The Soviet parliament formally dissolved the union the next day.

Seen from elsewhere. In the West Gorbachev was praised for letting the empire go without a general war. Many Russians blamed him for economic collapse and national humiliation, and Vladimir Putin later called the end of the Soviet Union the greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the century. In the Baltic states and elsewhere the date marks liberation rather than loss.

Also on 25 December