Parallax

16 December, 1773

The destruction of the tea in Boston harbour

In three hours of quiet, methodical work, men with soot on their faces tipped forty-six tons of Chinese tea into the sea, swept the decks, and replaced a padlock they had broken.

Griffin’s Wharf, Boston, Massachusetts

The deadline was midnight. The ship Dartmouth had entered Boston harbour on 28 November 1773 carrying 114 chests of East India Company tea, and under customs law a cargo on which duty had not been paid within twenty days could be seized and landed by the authorities. Two more tea ships, the Eleanor and the brig Beaver, lay beside her at Griffin’s Wharf. For nearly three weeks a volunteer watch had kept the tea aboard, while the governor, Thomas Hutchinson, refused to let the ships leave without unloading. On Thursday 16 December the twenty days ran out.

That morning some five thousand people, about a third of the town’s population together with many from the countryside, crowded into and around the Old South Meeting House in cold rain. They sent the Dartmouth’s young owner, Francis Rotch, to ride seven miles to the governor’s country house at Milton and ask one last time for a pass to sail. He came back at about a quarter to six, in candlelight, to report that Hutchinson had refused. Samuel Adams rose and said that he did not see what more the inhabitants could do to save their country.

From the doorway and the gallery came war whoops. Men who had daubed their faces with lampblack and grease and wrapped themselves in blankets, loosely got up as Mohawks, headed for the waterfront, and much of the meeting followed to watch. Between one and two hundred went aboard the three ships. Divided into parties, each with a leader, they demanded the keys and candles from the mates, hoisted the chests on deck with block and tackle, split them with hatchets and shovelled the tea over the side. It was low tide, and the leaves piled up so high in the shallows that boys were sent wading in to push them out.

By nine o’clock 340 chests, more than 92,000 pounds of tea worth about 9,659 pounds sterling, had gone into the harbour. Nothing else was touched. One man who filled his coat lining with tea was stripped of the coat and kicked along the wharf. No one was hurt. Warships lay a few hundred yards away and did not intervene, since the admiral could not have fired without hitting the crowd.

‘This is the most magnificent Movement of all,’ John Adams wrote in his diary the next day. ‘There is a Dignity, a Majesty, a Sublimity, in this last Effort of the Patriots, that I greatly admire.’ Paul Revere was already riding south with the news.

How it came to this

The argument was a decade old. Britain had emerged from the Seven Years’ War in 1763 with a doubled national debt and an army to maintain in America, and Parliament tried to raise part of the cost from the colonists: by a stamp duty in 1765, repealed after riots, and by the Townshend duties on imports in 1767. The colonists replied that they could be taxed only by assemblies in which they were represented. In 1770 all the Townshend duties were withdrawn except threepence a pound on tea, kept to assert the principle. Most Americans went on drinking tea, much of it smuggled from the Dutch.

The crisis of 1773 began in Asia. The East India Company, having taken over the revenues of Bengal, was close to bankruptcy, with some seventeen million pounds of unsold tea in its London warehouses. Lord North’s Tea Act allowed it to ship directly to America through chosen agents, free of British duties, so that its tea would undersell the smugglers’ even with the threepence added. To the colonial opposition this was a bribe to accept taxation and a monopoly in the making. The Boston agents included two of the governor’s sons.

How each side saw it

Governor Hutchinson and the Loyalists

Thomas Hutchinson was a fifth-generation New Englander and the colony’s historian. In the third volume of his History of Massachusetts Bay, written in exile, he explains that he had no power to grant the pass: the law forbade clearing a ship with dutiable goods still aboard, and he was sworn to uphold it. He described the destruction as the boldest stroke yet struck in America and believed a small faction had manoeuvred the town into it by intimidation. His house had been gutted by a mob in 1765. He sailed for England in 1774 expecting to return, and died in London in 1780. Another Loyalist, Peter Oliver, wrote a bitter history calling the affair the work of smugglers and demagogues.

Parliament and the British government

In London even the colonists’ friends were shocked by an attack on private property. Lord Chatham called it criminal; Benjamin Franklin, the colony’s agent, thought the tea should be paid for. Lord North told the Commons that the dispute was no longer about taxation but about whether Britain had any authority in America at all. Parliament closed the port of Boston until compensation was paid, rewrote the Massachusetts charter and allowed officials to be tried outside the colony. Edmund Burke argued instead for repealing the tea duty and returning to the old practice of leaving the colonies untaxed. He was heavily outvoted.

The Mohawk, in whose name it was done

No Native people took part. The disguise fooled nobody and was not meant to; the historian Philip Deloria reads it as a way for colonists to claim an American identity distinct from Britain while doing something Englishmen were not supposed to do. The actual Mohawk, one of the six Haudenosaunee nations, mostly sided with the Crown in the war that followed, judging the King a better guarantor of their lands than the settlers. Led by Joseph Brant, many fought as British allies, saw their towns burned, and after 1783 moved to the Grand River in Canada, their homeland ceded without their consent.

Bengal and Canton

The tea came from China, mostly cheap black Bohea from the Wuyi hills of Fujian, bought at Canton with silver. The Company that owned it had ruled Bengal since 1765, and its tax collection is widely held to have worsened the famine of 1769-70, in which a large part of the population died; contemporary estimates ran as high as ten million. Its victims left almost no record of their own. Americans knew of it from the London press. The Pennsylvania pamphleteer John Dickinson warned in 1773 that a company which had brought such ruin to Asia was now casting its eyes on America.

What is disputed

The tradition that Samuel Adams’s words were a pre-arranged signal has been questioned: L. F. S. Upton’s study of a contemporary account suggests that the whoops interrupted the meeting and that Adams tried to continue it. The number of participants and most of their names are uncertain, since they were sworn to secrecy, and the commonly quoted figure of 342 chests is two more than the Company claimed. Motives are debated as well. Loyalists pointed out that smugglers such as John Hancock stood to lose from cheap legal tea; Benjamin Carp and others stress the constitutional principle. The name ‘Boston Tea Party’ is not found in print before the 1820s.

What followed

The punitive laws of 1774, which Americans called the Coercive or Intolerable Acts, did what a decade of pamphlets had not: they united the other colonies behind Massachusetts. Food was sent overland to Boston, a Continental Congress met in Philadelphia in September, and fighting began at Lexington the following April. For half a century respectable Americans were uneasy about the destruction of property, and it was celebrated only after the last participants, such as the shoemaker George Hewes, were discovered as old men in the 1830s. Since then both protesters against taxation and movements of civil disobedience have claimed it as a precedent.

Read further

  • Benjamin L. Carp, Defiance of the Patriots: The Boston Tea Party and the Making of America (2010)
  • Benjamin Woods Labaree, The Boston Tea Party (1964)
  • Alfred F. Young, The Shoemaker and the Tea Party: Memory and the American Revolution (1999)
  • Bernard Bailyn, The Ordeal of Thomas Hutchinson (1974)
  • Philip J. Deloria, Playing Indian (1998)

Same day, other years

1598

Admiral Yi dies in his last victory

Noryang Strait, KoreaAsia

Japan’s invasion of Korea, launched by Toyotomi Hideyoshi in 1592, had devastated the peninsula for seven years. When Hideyoshi died in September 1598 his commanders were ordered home. The Korean admiral Yi Sun-sin, who had never lost a battle and whose fleets had repeatedly cut the invaders’ supply lines, joined the Ming Chinese admiral Chen Lin to block the narrow Noryang Strait against a relief fleet of some five hundred ships under Shimazu Yoshihiro. The allies attacked in the small hours with cannon and fire. By morning perhaps half the Japanese ships were sunk or burning. Yi, beating the drum for the pursuit, was hit by an arquebus ball and died within minutes.

Seen from elsewhere. Korean tradition, deriving from his nephew, has Yi order that his death be kept quiet until the fight was won. Japanese accounts treat Noryang as a costly but successful rearguard action: while Shimazu fought, the garrison he had come to rescue slipped away to sea. The invaders took home thousands of captives, among them potters, and the severed noses buried in Kyoto’s Mimizuka mound.

1653

Cromwell becomes Lord Protector

Westminster Hall, LondonEurope

Four years after the execution of Charles I, England’s republic had run through the remnant of one parliament, expelled by soldiers, and an assembly of nominated godly men that voted itself out of existence on 12 December 1653. Four days later Oliver Cromwell, in a plain black suit and cloak, was installed in Westminster Hall as Lord Protector of England, Scotland and Ireland under the Instrument of Government, drafted by General John Lambert. It was the first written constitution Britain had known, providing for a single head of state for life, a council and regular parliaments. Cromwell refused the title of king in 1657 and governed until his death in 1658.

Seen from elsewhere. Royalists called him a usurper. Republicans who had fought beside him, such as Edmund Ludlow and Sir Henry Vane, saw the betrayal of the cause for which the king had been killed: rule by a single person, resting on the army. In Ireland his name means the storming of Drogheda and Wexford in 1649 and the confiscation of Catholic land that followed.

1838

Blood River, or Ncome

Ncome River, Natal, South AfricaAfrica

Some 470 Dutch-speaking emigrants from the Cape, with their servants, drew sixty-four wagons into a fortified ring between a river and a deep gully in Zulu country. Their leader, Andries Pretorius, had come to avenge the killing of Piet Retief’s delegation at King Dingane’s capital in February and of several hundred settlers and servants in the raids that followed. At dawn on 16 December a Zulu army of between ten and fifteen thousand, commanded by Ndlela kaSompisi, attacked in waves across open ground against muskets and two small cannon. About three thousand Zulu were killed. Three of the defenders were wounded and none died. The river is said to have run red.

Seen from elsewhere. Afrikaners held that a vow sworn beforehand had been answered by God, and kept the day holy, though historians find little sign of its observance before the 1860s. To Zulu memory it is the battle of Ncome, a defence of the kingdom against people come to take its land. The ANC launched its armed wing on 16 December 1961. Since 1995 the date has been the Day of Reconciliation.

1920

The Haiyuan earthquake

Haiyuan, Gansu (now Ningxia), ChinaAsia

At about eight in the evening one of the most powerful earthquakes recorded on land in the twentieth century, with a magnitude now put at around 7.8 or higher, ruptured more than two hundred kilometres of fault across the loess plateau of north-west China. Seismographs registered it around the world, but it was weeks before outsiders learned where it had struck. In the hills, whole slopes of fine wind-blown soil liquefied and flowed, burying villages and damming valleys. Many people in the region, a large proportion of them Hui Muslims, lived in dwellings cut into the loess, which collapsed on them. Survivors faced a hard winter without shelter. Estimates of the dead range from about 200,000 to more than 270,000.

Seen from elsewhere. China was divided among rival warlords, and the government in Beijing had neither the means nor the authority to organise relief; much of what help arrived came from local gentry, Muslim networks and foreign missionaries. Chinese seismologists reviewing county records in recent decades raised the death toll well above the figures reported abroad at the time.

Also on 16 December