Parallax

6 December, AD 343

A bishop dies in Myra, and the stories begin

Nicholas of Myra is among the most widely venerated saints in Christendom and the remote ancestor of Santa Claus. No document written in his lifetime mentions him.

Myra, Lycia (now Demre, Turkey)

By tradition the bishop of Myra, a harbour town on the south coast of Asia Minor, died on 6 December in or about the year 343 and was buried in a church outside the walls. That sentence contains nearly everything that can be said of him with any confidence, and even the year is a later calculation. What survives is a body of stories that people in his region were telling within two centuries of his death.

The earliest of them is not a nativity or a martyrdom but a legal drama. Three citizens of Myra have been condemned to death by a governor who has taken a bribe. Nicholas runs to the place of execution, seizes the sword from the executioner’s hand, unties the men and denounces the governor to his face. Three imperial officers who witness this are later falsely accused in Constantinople and call on him from prison; he appears in a dream to the emperor Constantine and frightens him into releasing them. This tale, the ‘Affair of the Generals’, circulated on its own in Greek by the sixth century.

The story that made him the patron of gift-giving comes from the first full Life, written by a monk called Michael the Archimandrite in the eighth or ninth century. Nicholas, born to rich Christian parents at nearby Patara and orphaned young, learns that a neighbour who has lost his money means to put his three daughters into prostitution because he cannot give them dowries. On three nights Nicholas throws a bag of gold through the window and hurries away. On the third the father catches him and is sworn to silence.

Other episodes followed: sailors saved in a storm, a famine relieved by persuading the captains of imperial grain ships to unload part of their cargo, which was then found undiminished. Seafarers adopted him. So did prisoners, merchants, children, pawnbrokers and, in time, whole nations, Russia and Greece among them.

His tomb at Myra exuded a liquid that pilgrims collected, and it drew visitors for seven centuries. In the spring of 1087, with the coast newly overrun by Seljuk Turks, sailors from the Italian port of Bari broke open the floor of the church, lifted out the bones over the protests of the monks on guard, and carried them home. They reached Bari on 9 May, a date the city still celebrates.

How it came to this

If Nicholas lived when tradition says, his life spanned the hinge of Christian history in the Roman world. Under Diocletian, from 303, churches were demolished and clergy imprisoned; later accounts say Nicholas was among those jailed. Under Constantine, from 313 in the east after 324, the faith was tolerated and then favoured, bishops became public figures with the ear of governors, and the emperor summoned them to Nicaea in 325 to settle the dispute over the teaching of the priest Arius. A bishop in this new order was expected to be an advocate for his town, which is exactly the part Nicholas plays in the earliest story.

The evidence for his cult is solid well before the evidence for his biography. The historian Procopius records that the emperor Justinian built a church dedicated to him at Constantinople in the sixth century. A second Nicholas, abbot of the monastery of Holy Sion near Myra, who died in 564 and whose Life survives, further complicates matters: several episodes later told of the bishop, including some concerning his childhood and a sea voyage, appear to have been borrowed from the abbot.

How each side saw it

The Orthodox churches

In the Christian East Nicholas has no connection with Christmas presents. He is the Wonderworker, the model of a bishop, named in the liturgy every Thursday and painted on more icons than any saint but the Virgin. Russians, who received his cult from Byzantium, made him protector of travellers and peasants. Orthodox tradition also tells that at Nicaea he was so angered by Arius that he struck him in the face and was briefly stripped of his office. The tale first appears about a thousand years after the council, but it expresses what the East values in him: zeal for right belief joined to mercy for the poor.

Bari, Venice and Myra

The Bari sailors’ own account, written by a cleric named Nikephoros soon after, presents the removal as a rescue of holy relics from unbelievers, sanctioned by the saint. The Greek monks in the same account call it theft and weep. Venetians, who arrived in 1100, claimed to have found the remaining bones and built their own shrine on the Lido; an anatomical examination in the twentieth century suggested the two sets could belong to one man. Turkish authorities have repeatedly asked for the remains to be returned to Demre, and in 2017 Turkish archaeologists suggested an undisturbed tomb may still lie under the church floor.

The Protestant reformers

Luther and his successors rejected the invocation of saints, and with it the custom, well established in Germany and the Low Countries by the later Middle Ages, of giving children presents on Nicholas’s eve. Luther encouraged the idea that the gifts came from the Christ child, the Christkind, and moved them to Christmas. The Calvinist authorities of the Dutch Republic banned St Nicholas markets and the baking of his image in gingerbread. The bans failed. Dutch families kept Sinterklaas at home, and the Christkind, travelling to America with German settlers, became in English ‘Kris Kringle’, another name for the figure he had been meant to replace.

Modern critics of the feast

In the Netherlands Sinterklaas arrives each November by steamboat with a servant, Zwarte Piet, traditionally played by white people in black face paint, curly wig and red lips. The character dates from a picture book of 1850 by the Amsterdam teacher Jan Schenkman. Since the 2010s Dutch citizens of Surinamese and Antillean descent, among others, have campaigned against it as a caricature rooted in slavery; defenders call it a harmless children’s tradition and say the black is chimney soot. A UN committee criticised the figure in 2015, and most cities and broadcasters have since switched to soot-smudged Piets.

What is disputed

Whether Nicholas existed is not seriously doubted, since the cult at Myra is early and local, but nothing in his legend can be verified. The death year 343 is one of several proposed between 335 and 352. His name is missing from the oldest lists of bishops at Nicaea and present in some later ones. The scholar Gustav Anrich showed in 1913-17 how far his Life absorbed that of Nicholas of Sion. In 1969 Rome did not remove him from the calendar, as is often said; it made his feast an optional memorial. The idea that he is a Christianised Odin or Poseidon is a nineteenth-century speculation without evidence.

What followed

The road from Myra to the North Pole runs through New York. Washington Irving’s comic history of the city in 1809 gave its Dutch founders a pipe-smoking St Nicholas who flew over rooftops in a wagon. The anonymous poem of 1823 beginning ‘Twas the night before Christmas’, usually credited to Clement Clarke Moore, supplied the sleigh, the reindeer, the chimney and the date of 24 December. The cartoonist Thomas Nast drew the fat, bearded figure from the 1860s. The bishop’s mitre survives in the Low Countries, central Europe and wherever children still put out a shoe on the night of 5 December.

Read further

  • Charles W. Jones, Saint Nicholas of Myra, Bari, and Manhattan: Biography of a Legend (1978)
  • Adam C. English, The Saint Who Would Be Santa Claus: The True Life and Trials of Nicholas of Myra (2012)
  • Gerry Bowler, Santa Claus: A Biography (2005)
  • Gustav Anrich, Hagios Nikolaos: Der heilige Nikolaos in der griechischen Kirche (1913-17)

Same day, other years

1240

Kiev falls to the Mongols

KyivEurope

The army of Batu, grandson of Genghis Khan, had already destroyed the principalities of north-eastern Rus. In the autumn of 1240 it surrounded Kiev, the old capital on the Dnieper, whose prince had fled leaving a commander named Dmitro in charge. The chronicle says the noise of carts, camels and horses was such that people inside could not hear one another speak. Siege engines broke the wall by the Polish Gate; the last defenders crowded into the Church of the Tithes, which collapsed under them. The city fell on 6 December. A papal envoy passing through six years later counted barely two hundred houses standing.

Seen from elsewhere. Mongol sources treat the campaign as one conquest among many and barely name the city. Another chronicle dates the fall to 19 November. How heavy and how lasting the ‘Tatar yoke’ was is disputed between Russian traditions that lament it and historians who stress trade and accommodation; Russia and Ukraine also contest who inherits the Kiev that fell.

1921

The Anglo-Irish Treaty is signed in Downing Street

LondonEurope

After two and a half years of guerrilla war and five months of truce, Irish delegates led by Arthur Griffith and Michael Collins had been negotiating in London since October. On 5 December Lloyd George told them that they must sign that night or face war within three days. At about ten past two on the morning of the 6th they signed. The treaty created an Irish Free State of twenty-six counties with its own army and parliament and the standing of Canada within the British Empire, required an oath of fidelity to the king, and let the six north-eastern counties opt out, which they at once did.

Seen from elsewhere. Eamon de Valera, who had stayed in Dublin, rejected a document signed without reference to him that abandoned the republic declared in 1916. Collins argued that it gave the freedom to achieve freedom. The Dail approved it by 64 votes to 57. Civil war followed within six months, and Collins was killed in it.

1928

The army fires on striking banana workers at Cienaga

Cienaga, Magdalena, ColombiaThe Americas

Workers on the plantations of the Boston-based United Fruit Company had been on strike since November, asking for written contracts, a six-day week and wages in cash instead of company scrip. Thousands gathered with their families in the square by the railway station at Cienaga on the night of 5 December, expecting the governor. Instead General Carlos Cortes Vargas arrived with troops, had a decree read declaring them a mob, gave them five minutes to disperse, and in the early hours of the 6th opened fire with rifles and machine guns. Killing continued through the banana zone for days.

Seen from elsewhere. Cortes Vargas reported nine dead, later forty-seven, and said he had forestalled a landing by American marines. The United States legation cabled Washington that the company’s own representative put the number above a thousand. The figure of three thousand in Gabriel Garcia Marquez’s One Hundred Years of Solitude was, he admitted, chosen for the novel. No full count was ever made.

1992

A crowd demolishes the Babri mosque

Ayodhya, Uttar Pradesh, IndiaAsia

The mosque at Ayodhya had been built in 1528-29 under the first Mughal emperor, Babur. Many Hindus hold that it stood on the birthplace of the god Ram, on the site of a temple destroyed to make room for it. A campaign to build a temple there, led by the Vishwa Hindu Parishad and the Bharatiya Janata Party, brought well over a hundred thousand volunteers to the town on 6 December 1992 for what leaders had promised the courts would be a symbolic ceremony. Around midday men broke through the cordon and, with hammers, bars and bare hands, brought down the three domes in a few hours. Riots across India killed about two thousand people, most of them Muslims.

Seen from elsewhere. For Indian Muslims it was the destruction of a place of worship while the state looked on. Organisers called it a spontaneous outburst; a judicial commission in 2009 called it planned. The Supreme Court in 2019 ruled the demolition unlawful yet awarded the site for a temple, which opened in 2024. A court acquitted all the surviving accused in 2020.

Also on 6 December