By tradition the bishop of Myra, a harbour town on the south coast of Asia Minor, died on 6 December in or about the year 343 and was buried in a church outside the walls. That sentence contains nearly everything that can be said of him with any confidence, and even the year is a later calculation. What survives is a body of stories that people in his region were telling within two centuries of his death.
The earliest of them is not a nativity or a martyrdom but a legal drama. Three citizens of Myra have been condemned to death by a governor who has taken a bribe. Nicholas runs to the place of execution, seizes the sword from the executioner’s hand, unties the men and denounces the governor to his face. Three imperial officers who witness this are later falsely accused in Constantinople and call on him from prison; he appears in a dream to the emperor Constantine and frightens him into releasing them. This tale, the ‘Affair of the Generals’, circulated on its own in Greek by the sixth century.
The story that made him the patron of gift-giving comes from the first full Life, written by a monk called Michael the Archimandrite in the eighth or ninth century. Nicholas, born to rich Christian parents at nearby Patara and orphaned young, learns that a neighbour who has lost his money means to put his three daughters into prostitution because he cannot give them dowries. On three nights Nicholas throws a bag of gold through the window and hurries away. On the third the father catches him and is sworn to silence.
Other episodes followed: sailors saved in a storm, a famine relieved by persuading the captains of imperial grain ships to unload part of their cargo, which was then found undiminished. Seafarers adopted him. So did prisoners, merchants, children, pawnbrokers and, in time, whole nations, Russia and Greece among them.
His tomb at Myra exuded a liquid that pilgrims collected, and it drew visitors for seven centuries. In the spring of 1087, with the coast newly overrun by Seljuk Turks, sailors from the Italian port of Bari broke open the floor of the church, lifted out the bones over the protests of the monks on guard, and carried them home. They reached Bari on 9 May, a date the city still celebrates.
How it came to this
If Nicholas lived when tradition says, his life spanned the hinge of Christian history in the Roman world. Under Diocletian, from 303, churches were demolished and clergy imprisoned; later accounts say Nicholas was among those jailed. Under Constantine, from 313 in the east after 324, the faith was tolerated and then favoured, bishops became public figures with the ear of governors, and the emperor summoned them to Nicaea in 325 to settle the dispute over the teaching of the priest Arius. A bishop in this new order was expected to be an advocate for his town, which is exactly the part Nicholas plays in the earliest story.
The evidence for his cult is solid well before the evidence for his biography. The historian Procopius records that the emperor Justinian built a church dedicated to him at Constantinople in the sixth century. A second Nicholas, abbot of the monastery of Holy Sion near Myra, who died in 564 and whose Life survives, further complicates matters: several episodes later told of the bishop, including some concerning his childhood and a sea voyage, appear to have been borrowed from the abbot.