Parallax

18 December, 1915

The President marries Mrs Galt

A widowed president married a Washington jeweller’s widow in her own front room. Four years later she stood between a paralysed man and the government of the United States, and nobody has quite agreed since on what she did there.

Washington, DC, United States

The wedding was at half past eight on a Saturday evening, at 1308 Twentieth Street, the bride’s house near Dupont Circle. About forty people were there, nearly all family. There was no music and no attendants. An Episcopal rector from the bride’s church and the pastor of the groom’s Presbyterian congregation shared the service. Woodrow Wilson was fifty-eight and had been President of the United States for nearly three years. Edith Bolling Galt was forty-three, a Virginian, the widow of the owner of Galt’s, the capital’s best-known jewellers, and a familiar sight in Washington at the tiller of her own electric motor car.

They had known each other for nine months. Wilson’s first wife, Ellen, had died in the White House in August 1914, in the same week that Europe went to war, and he had told friends he hoped someone would shoot him. In March 1915 his cousin Helen Bones brought her friend Mrs Galt back to the White House for tea. He proposed on 4 May. She thought it too soon, and said so. Through the summer of the Lusitania crisis he wrote to her daily, sometimes twice, and sent her state papers to read.

His advisers were alarmed. An election was due in 1916, and a president remarrying little more than a year after burying his wife seemed a gift to his opponents. His son-in-law, William McAdoo, tried to frighten him off with a story that a woman he had once written to warmly, Mary Hulbert Peck, was about to sell his letters. Wilson went to Edith and told her about the correspondence himself. The engagement was announced on 6 October, together with a statement that he would vote for women’s suffrage in his home state of New Jersey.

After the ceremony they slipped out to a private railway car and went to Hot Springs, Virginia. The Secret Service man who travelled with them recorded the President next morning dancing a jig in the corridor and whistling a music-hall tune.

What made the marriage a matter of history came later. On 2 October 1919, worn out by a speaking tour for the League of Nations, Wilson suffered a stroke that paralysed his left side. For weeks he saw almost no one but his wife and his doctor, Cary Grayson. Edith decided which papers and which visitors reached him, and returned documents with notes in her own hand of what the President wished. The public was told he was suffering from nervous exhaustion. He remained in office until March 1921.

How it came to this

Wilson had come to politics late, from the presidency of Princeton, and was elected in 1912 on a split Republican vote. He leaned heavily on the women of his household. Ellen Axson Wilson, a painter, had been his confidante for thirty years, and her death from kidney disease left him, by his own account, unable to think. The war in Europe meanwhile forced on him decisions about neutrality, trade and submarines that no American president had faced. When a German U-boat sank the Lusitania on 7 May 1915, three days after he proposed to Edith Galt, 128 Americans were among the dead.

Edith Bolling had grown up in a large, impoverished Virginia family that traced its descent from Pocahontas. She had two years of formal schooling. Her first husband, Norman Galt, died in 1908 and left her the business, which she ran through a manager and which made her independent. She had no interest in politics before 1915 and, by her own telling, could not have named the candidates in 1912.

How each side saw it

Edith Wilson

Her book My Memoir, published in 1939, is the origin of the word she preferred for the months after the stroke: a stewardship. She wrote that the doctors told her any strain might kill her husband and that his resignation would remove his reason for living, so she undertook to shield him. She insisted that she never made a single decision on public affairs herself, and that her only choice was what was important enough to put before him and when. She presented this as a wife’s duty, not a political act, and to the end of her life she resented the suggestion that it had been anything else.

The men she shut out

Wilson’s secretary Joseph Tumulty, his adviser Colonel Edward House and his Secretary of State Robert Lansing all found the door closed. House’s letters went unanswered and, he believed, unopened. Lansing, who called the Cabinet together on his own authority while the President was incapacitated, was dismissed for it in February 1920. In their diaries and memoirs these men describe a government adrift, with appointments unfilled and questions unanswered for months, and a wife who judged every issue by its likely effect on her husband’s health and by her own likes and dislikes, of which they were some.

The Senate opposition

Republican senators suspected that the country had no functioning president. Albert Fall of New Mexico told colleagues that the United States had a petticoat government and that Mrs Wilson was president. In December 1919 the Senate sent Fall and a Democrat, Gilbert Hitchcock, to the sickroom to see for themselves; Wilson, propped up and carefully lit with his paralysed arm under the covers, carried the interview off. To Henry Cabot Lodge and his allies, the treaty fight was a constitutional contest over the Senate’s rights, and they held that an isolated invalid, not they, had refused every compromise.

Suffragists

The woman later called, half in jest, the first female president did not want women to have the vote. When members of the National Woman’s Party began picketing the White House in 1917, she wrote of them with open contempt and was angered when her husband had them offered shelter from the weather. Alice Paul and her colleagues, jailed and force-fed that year, saw in the Wilsons a household that spoke of democracy abroad and denied it at home. The irony that a woman exercised power in 1919 only as a wife, unelected and unacknowledged, was pointed out by feminists at the time.

What is disputed

How much power Edith Wilson held is the lasting argument. Phyllis Lee Levin’s Edith and Woodrow argues that she and Grayson concealed a disability that should have ended the presidency, and that her account in My Memoir is untrue in important respects. John Milton Cooper and others reply that she did not make policy and that the real damage was done by Wilson’s own impaired judgment, above all his refusal to accept reservations to the Treaty of Versailles. Whether a healthy Wilson, or a Vice-President Marshall in his place, would have brought the United States into the League of Nations cannot be known.

What followed

The Senate rejected the Treaty of Versailles in November 1919 and again in March 1920, and the United States never joined the League. Wilson died in 1924. Edith guarded his papers and his reputation for thirty-seven years, rode in John F. Kennedy’s inaugural parade in January 1961, and died that December on her husband’s birthday. The question her stewardship raised, who decides when a president cannot serve, was answered only by the Twenty-fifth Amendment in 1967.

Read further

  • Edith Bolling Wilson, My Memoir (1939)
  • John Milton Cooper Jr., Woodrow Wilson: A Biography (2009)
  • Phyllis Lee Levin, Edith and Woodrow: The Wilson White House (2001)
  • A. Scott Berg, Wilson (2013)
  • Edwin A. Weinstein, Woodrow Wilson: A Medical and Psychological Biography (1981)

Same day, other years

1271

Kublai Khan names his empire the Great Yuan

Dadu (Beijing), ChinaAsia

Kublai, a grandson of Genghis Khan, had held the title of Great Khan since 1260, after a civil war with his own brother. He ruled northern China from a new capital that he was building on the site of modern Beijing. By an edict of 18 December 1271 he gave his state a Chinese dynastic name, Da Yuan, taken from the opening of the ancient Book of Changes, where the word denotes the primal source of things. His Chinese adviser Liu Bingzhong had proposed it. No earlier dynasty had been named for an idea instead of a place. The conquest of the Song empire in the south was completed eight years later.

Seen from elsewhere. Song loyalists saw only a foreign conquest dressed in borrowed words, and their resistance literature was treasured for centuries. Mongol traditionalists on the steppe, led by Kublai’s cousin Kaidu, accused him of abandoning nomad ways. Whether the Yuan was a Chinese dynasty or the eastern part of a Mongol empire is still answered differently in Chinese and Mongolian histories.

1865

Slavery is abolished in the United States Constitution

Washington, DC, United StatesThe Americas

Secretary of State William Seward certified that the Thirteenth Amendment had been ratified by three quarters of the states and was now part of the Constitution. Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation of 1863 had been a war measure and applied only to territory in rebellion. The amendment reached everywhere, including the loyal slave states of Kentucky and Delaware, where tens of thousands of people were still legally held as property eight months after the Confederate surrender. Its first section was thirty-two words long. Congress had passed it in January after a close vote in the House; Lincoln, who had pressed for it, was dead before it took effect.

Seen from elsewhere. The text forbade slavery ‘except as a punishment for crime’. In the same weeks Mississippi and South Carolina passed Black Codes that made unemployment and breach of labour contracts offences, and convict leasing grew from that clause. Kentucky rejected the amendment and did not ratify it until 1976; Mississippi’s ratification was formally filed in 2013.

1912

Piltdown Man is presented to science

London, EnglandEurope

At a crowded meeting of the Geological Society, Charles Dawson, a Sussex solicitor and amateur collector, and Arthur Smith Woodward of the British Museum announced the discovery of an early human from a gravel pit at Piltdown. It had a large, modern-looking braincase and an ape-like jaw, which was what many British anatomists expected an ancestor to look like. They named it Eoanthropus dawsoni. It stood in textbooks for forty years. In 1953 chemical tests showed that the skull was a few centuries old, the jaw was an orangutan’s, and both had been stained and filed to match.

Seen from elsewhere. Some scientists, including David Waterston in London and Gerrit Miller in Washington, said from the start that jaw and skull could not belong together. A 2016 study pointed to Dawson alone as the forger; other names have been proposed. The fraud helped British science dismiss the genuine fossils then emerging from Africa, such as Raymond Dart’s Taung child of 1924.

1972

The Christmas bombing of Hanoi begins

Hanoi and Haiphong, North VietnamAsia

With the Paris peace talks stalled, President Richard Nixon ordered the heaviest air attack of the Vietnam War. Over eleven nights, with a pause on Christmas Day, B-52 bombers and smaller aircraft dropped about 20,000 tons of bombs on railway yards, power stations, airfields and depots in and around Hanoi and Haiphong. North Vietnamese missile crews shot down fifteen B-52s. Bombs also fell on the Bach Mai hospital and on Kham Thien street, a crowded residential district. Hanoi counted 1,624 civilians killed in the two cities. Talks resumed in January, and the Paris Peace Accords were signed on the 27th.

Seen from elsewhere. Vietnam remembers the raids as a victory, ‘Dien Bien Phu in the air’. Nixon and Henry Kissinger held that the bombing forced Hanoi back to the table. Critics note that the January terms scarcely differed from the October draft, and that the campaign was also meant to reassure Saigon. Sweden’s prime minister, Olof Palme, compared it to Nazi atrocities.

Also on 18 December