Parallax

29 December, 1170

Four knights kill an archbishop at vespers

Thomas Becket refused to bar the cathedral doors against the king’s men, and his murder on the floor of Canterbury made him the most popular saint in England within three years.

Canterbury Cathedral, Kent, England

Henry II kept Christmas 1170 at Bur-le-Roi, near Bayeux in Normandy. Three English bishops arrived there with news: Archbishop Thomas Becket, back in England after six years of exile, had suspended or excommunicated them for crowning Henry’s eldest son in the summer, a right that belonged to Canterbury. The king flew into one of his rages. The monk Edward Grim, who was not there but spoke to those who were, reports him shouting that he had nourished and promoted miserable drones and traitors in his household who let their lord be treated with such shameful contempt by a low-born clerk.

Four knights of the household, Reginald FitzUrse, Hugh de Morville, William de Tracy and Richard le Breton, left court separately and crossed the Channel. On 28 December they gathered at Saltwood Castle, held by Ranulf de Broc, a royal official who had been occupying Canterbury’s lands and whom Becket had excommunicated on Christmas Day. The next afternoon they rode to Canterbury with a band of de Broc’s men.

They found the archbishop in his chamber after dinner and argued with him, unarmed, for some time. They demanded that he lift the sentences and answer to the king. He refused, and the exchange turned to shouting. The knights went out to arm themselves in the courtyard. Becket’s monks, hearing the noise, almost dragged him through the cloister into the cathedral, where vespers had begun. They tried to bolt the door behind him; he ordered it opened, saying a church was not a fortress.

The knights came in through the cloister door in the gathering dark, calling for the traitor. Becket came down the steps into the north-west transept and answered that he was no traitor but a priest of God. They tried to drag him outside, probably meaning to arrest him rather than kill him in the church, and he clung to a pillar and pushed FitzUrse away, calling him a pander. Then the swords came out. Grim, who was holding the archbishop, had his arm almost cut through by the first blow. Further blows brought Becket to his knees. Le Breton struck the crown of his head so hard that the sword snapped on the paving. A cleric with the knights, Hugh of Horsea, put his foot on the neck and scattered the brains on the floor, saying the man would not get up again.

The knights plundered the archbishop’s palace and rode away. When the monks undressed the body that night they found under the robes a hair shirt crawling with lice, and drawers of haircloth, signs of a penance no one had known about. The townspeople were already dipping cloths in the blood.

How it came to this

Becket, the son of a London merchant, was about thirteen years older than Henry. He rose through the household of Archbishop Theobald, and in 1155 the young king made him chancellor. He was lavish, worldly and devoted to the king’s interests, even leading troops in France. In 1162 Henry made him archbishop of Canterbury, expecting an ally at the head of the English Church. Becket resigned the chancellorship, adopted an austere personal life and set himself against the crown on almost every disputed point.

The central quarrel was over criminous clerks: whether clergy accused of crimes should be tried only in church courts, where they faced penance but not death, or handed over to the king’s courts after being degraded. At Clarendon in January 1164 Henry set down what he called the ancient customs of the realm. Becket first agreed and then repudiated them. After a hostile council at Northampton he fled to France, where he spent six years under the protection of Louis VII and the pope. A truce in July 1170 allowed his return, but the main points were never settled.

How each side saw it

The monks and the hagiographers

Almost everything known about the killing comes from men who believed Becket was a martyr. Edward Grim, William FitzStephen, John of Salisbury, William of Canterbury and Benedict of Peterborough wrote lives within a few years, several of them eyewitnesses. They present a priest who chose death to defend the liberty of the Church, and they record his last words in versions close to Grim’s, that for the name of Jesus and the protection of the Church he was ready to embrace death. Benedict also collected hundreds of miracles reported at the tomb.

Henry II

Henry insisted he had never intended the killing. When news reached him he shut himself away and fasted for three days. He sent envoys to Pope Alexander III to deny responsibility, and in 1172 at Avranches swore that he had neither ordered nor wished the death, while accepting that his words had caused it. He promised to allow appeals to Rome and abandoned the most contested clauses of Clarendon. In July 1174, during a rebellion by his sons, he walked barefoot to the tomb and was whipped by the monks.

Becket’s critics in the Church

Not all bishops saw a saint. Gilbert Foliot, bishop of London and one of those Becket excommunicated, had written him a long letter in 1166 accusing him of seizing the archbishopric through royal favour and dragging the Church into a quarrel it did not need. Many senior clergy regarded Becket as rash and vain. Modern historians are divided along similar lines: Frank Barlow saw an ambitious and stubborn man, while Anne Duggan and others emphasise the consistency of his stand on the Church’s independence.

The Reformation crown

In 1538 Henry VIII, who had made himself head of the English Church, issued a proclamation declaring that Becket had been a rebel against his king rather than a saint. The shrine at Canterbury was dismantled, its jewels and gold carted to the royal treasury, his images ordered defaced and his name struck out of service books. Protestant writers presented him as an example of papal pride. The cult survived among Catholics, and his feast is still kept on 29 December by Catholic and Anglican churches.

What is disputed

The famous line ‘Will no one rid me of this turbulent priest?’ does not appear in any medieval source and seems to be a much later paraphrase; Grim’s version of the outburst is longer and different. Whether Henry meant only arrest or something worse is debated. The eyewitness accounts disagree about who struck each blow and in what order, and the role of a fifth man, Hugh of Horsea, is often confused with Ranulf de Broc, who was not in the cathedral. Becket’s change of life in 1162 is read by some as a true conversion and by others as role-playing.

What followed

Pope Alexander III canonised Becket in February 1173, less than three years after his death. Canterbury became one of the great pilgrimage centres of Europe, the setting of Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales two centuries later. The four knights were sent by the pope to do penance, according to tradition in the Holy Land. The case for clerical immunity from royal courts was largely won, and benefit of clergy survived in English law until 1827. T. S. Eliot made the murder the subject of Murder in the Cathedral in 1935.

Read further

  • Michael Staunton (trans.), The Lives of Thomas Becket (2001)
  • Frank Barlow, Thomas Becket (1986)
  • Anne Duggan, Thomas Becket (2004)
  • John Guy, Thomas Becket: Warrior, Priest, Rebel (2012)
  • W. L. Warren, Henry II (1973)

Same day, other years

1890

The killings at Wounded Knee

Wounded Knee Creek, Pine Ridge Reservation, South Dakota, United StatesThe Americas

Soldiers of the US 7th Cavalry had intercepted a band of Miniconjou Lakota under Spotted Elk, also called Big Foot, who was ill with pneumonia, and camped them at Wounded Knee Creek. On the morning of 29 December the troops began disarming the men. A struggle over a rifle, often said to have belonged to a deaf man named Black Coyote, led to a shot, and the soldiers opened fire, including with rapid-firing Hotchkiss guns on the hill above. Between about 250 and 300 Lakota were killed, many of them women and children cut down as they fled. Twenty-five soldiers died.

Seen from elsewhere. The army called it a battle and awarded twenty Medals of Honor, which Lakota groups have long asked to be withdrawn. Survivors’ testimony, collected by agency staff and later historians, describes indiscriminate killing. Some soldiers were probably killed by their own crossfire. The dead were buried in a mass grave on New Year’s Day.

1895

The Jameson Raid crosses into the Transvaal

Pitsani, Bechuanaland, to Doornkop, South African RepublicAfrica

Leander Starr Jameson, administrator for Cecil Rhodes’s British South Africa Company, led about 500 mounted Company police across the border from Bechuanaland towards Johannesburg. The plan, backed by Rhodes and mining magnates, was to support a rising by the foreign uitlanders of the gold fields against President Paul Kruger’s Afrikaner republic, which denied them the vote. The rising never happened. Boer commandos shadowed the column and forced it to surrender at Doornkop on 2 January. Jameson was handed over to Britain for trial and Rhodes had to resign as prime minister of the Cape.

Seen from elsewhere. To Afrikaners the raid proved that Britain intended to take their republics, and it hardened opinion towards the war of 1899. How much the colonial secretary Joseph Chamberlain knew remains argued; a parliamentary inquiry cleared him. The Kaiser’s telegram congratulating Kruger inflamed British opinion against Germany.

1911

Sun Yat-sen is elected provisional president of China

Nanjing, ChinaAsia

Two and a half months after the army mutiny at Wuchang that began the revolution against the Qing dynasty, delegates from the provinces that had declared independence met in Nanjing and elected Sun Yat-sen provisional president of a Chinese republic. Sun had spent most of the previous sixteen years in exile, raising money among overseas Chinese and organising failed uprisings, and had been in the United States when the revolution broke out. He took office on 1 January 1912, which became the first day of the Republic of China’s calendar.

Seen from elsewhere. Real military power lay with Yuan Shikai, commander of the Qing army, and Sun agreed to stand aside for him once he arranged the emperor’s abdication in February. Yuan soon turned against parliament. Sun is honoured as the father of the nation by both the People’s Republic and Taiwan, each in its own terms.

1989

Vaclav Havel is elected president of Czechoslovakia

Prague Castle, CzechoslovakiaEurope

Six weeks after the police beat student marchers in Prague on 17 November, setting off the mass protests of the Velvet Revolution, the Federal Assembly elected the playwright Vaclav Havel president of the republic. The vote was unanimous, cast by a parliament still full of Communist deputies chosen under the old system. Havel had been jailed for nearly five years for his part in the human rights group Charter 77 and had been released from his latest prison term only in May. Alexander Dubcek, leader of the Prague Spring of 1968, had been made speaker the day before.

Seen from elsewhere. Hardline Communists saw a negotiated surrender; some dissidents later felt the round-table deals let the old guard keep money and influence. Slovak opinion was cooler towards a Czech president, and the federation split peacefully in 1993. Havel was elected president of the Czech Republic that year.

Also on 29 December