Henry II kept Christmas 1170 at Bur-le-Roi, near Bayeux in Normandy. Three English bishops arrived there with news: Archbishop Thomas Becket, back in England after six years of exile, had suspended or excommunicated them for crowning Henry’s eldest son in the summer, a right that belonged to Canterbury. The king flew into one of his rages. The monk Edward Grim, who was not there but spoke to those who were, reports him shouting that he had nourished and promoted miserable drones and traitors in his household who let their lord be treated with such shameful contempt by a low-born clerk.
Four knights of the household, Reginald FitzUrse, Hugh de Morville, William de Tracy and Richard le Breton, left court separately and crossed the Channel. On 28 December they gathered at Saltwood Castle, held by Ranulf de Broc, a royal official who had been occupying Canterbury’s lands and whom Becket had excommunicated on Christmas Day. The next afternoon they rode to Canterbury with a band of de Broc’s men.
They found the archbishop in his chamber after dinner and argued with him, unarmed, for some time. They demanded that he lift the sentences and answer to the king. He refused, and the exchange turned to shouting. The knights went out to arm themselves in the courtyard. Becket’s monks, hearing the noise, almost dragged him through the cloister into the cathedral, where vespers had begun. They tried to bolt the door behind him; he ordered it opened, saying a church was not a fortress.
The knights came in through the cloister door in the gathering dark, calling for the traitor. Becket came down the steps into the north-west transept and answered that he was no traitor but a priest of God. They tried to drag him outside, probably meaning to arrest him rather than kill him in the church, and he clung to a pillar and pushed FitzUrse away, calling him a pander. Then the swords came out. Grim, who was holding the archbishop, had his arm almost cut through by the first blow. Further blows brought Becket to his knees. Le Breton struck the crown of his head so hard that the sword snapped on the paving. A cleric with the knights, Hugh of Horsea, put his foot on the neck and scattered the brains on the floor, saying the man would not get up again.
The knights plundered the archbishop’s palace and rode away. When the monks undressed the body that night they found under the robes a hair shirt crawling with lice, and drawers of haircloth, signs of a penance no one had known about. The townspeople were already dipping cloths in the blood.
How it came to this
Becket, the son of a London merchant, was about thirteen years older than Henry. He rose through the household of Archbishop Theobald, and in 1155 the young king made him chancellor. He was lavish, worldly and devoted to the king’s interests, even leading troops in France. In 1162 Henry made him archbishop of Canterbury, expecting an ally at the head of the English Church. Becket resigned the chancellorship, adopted an austere personal life and set himself against the crown on almost every disputed point.
The central quarrel was over criminous clerks: whether clergy accused of crimes should be tried only in church courts, where they faced penance but not death, or handed over to the king’s courts after being degraded. At Clarendon in January 1164 Henry set down what he called the ancient customs of the realm. Becket first agreed and then repudiated them. After a hostile council at Northampton he fled to France, where he spent six years under the protection of Louis VII and the pope. A truce in July 1170 allowed his return, but the main points were never settled.