Parallax

10 December, 1936

Edward VIII signs away the throne

In a country house on the edge of Windsor Great Park, with his three brothers as witnesses, a king of less than eleven months put his name to a document no English monarch had signed before.

Fort Belvedere, Windsor, England

At about ten in the morning on Thursday 10 December 1936, in the drawing room of Fort Belvedere, Edward VIII sat down at a desk and signed six copies of a short typed statement. It declared his ‘irrevocable determination to renounce the Throne for Myself and for My descendants’. His brothers Albert, Henry and George signed beneath him as witnesses. Albert, Duke of York, a shy man with a severe stammer who had never expected or wanted the crown, would be king by the following afternoon. He told his cousin Louis Mountbatten that he had never even seen a state paper.

The cause was a woman from Baltimore. Wallis Simpson was 40, had divorced one husband and was in the process of divorcing a second; her decree nisi had been granted at Ipswich on 27 October. The King, who had known her since 1931, intended to marry her as soon as it became absolute. British newspapers, by agreement among their proprietors, had printed nothing of what American and European readers had been following for months. The silence broke on 3 December, after the Bishop of Bradford made a speech regretting the King’s want of religious devotion.

The Prime Minister, Stanley Baldwin, had already told Edward that the country would not accept Mrs Simpson as queen. The King proposed a morganatic marriage, in which she would be his wife but not queen. Baldwin put it to the cabinet and to the governments of the Dominions, and brought back their refusal. That left three courses: give her up, marry against his ministers’ advice and see them resign, or go. Edward never seriously wavered. Mrs Simpson, who had fled to Cannes under a storm of abuse, issued a statement offering to withdraw. He telephoned to say it would make no difference.

That afternoon Baldwin read the King’s message to a packed House of Commons and gave a plain account of their conversations. The abdication bill went through all its stages the next day, and at 1.52 pm on 11 December Edward ceased to be king. That evening, not on the day of signing as is often said, he drove to Windsor Castle and broadcast to the Empire, introduced by Sir John Reith as ‘His Royal Highness Prince Edward’. He said he had found it impossible to carry the burden of kingship ‘without the help and support of the woman I love’.

He left Portsmouth in the small hours aboard the destroyer HMS Fury and went to Austria to wait out her divorce. They were married in France on 3 June 1937. No member of his family attended.

How it came to this

Edward had been the most popular Prince of Wales in memory: a slight, fair-haired man who had served on the Western Front staff, toured the Empire to huge crowds and spoken with apparent feeling about unemployed miners. Those who worked for him saw someone else. His assistant private secretary, Alan Lascelles, had resigned in 1929 in despair at his neglect of duty and his affairs with married women. George V is reported to have predicted that after his own death the boy would ruin himself within a year. He succeeded on 20 January 1936.

The difficulty was not that Mrs Simpson was American or a commoner. The King was Supreme Governor of the Church of England, which did not then permit the remarriage of divorced people whose former spouses were alive, and she had two. Divorce law itself made matters worse: a decree could be refused if collusion was shown, and the Simpsons’ divorce was widely understood to have been arranged. Ministers also had private worries about the King’s indiscretion with state papers and about his openly expressed sympathy for Germany.

How each side saw it

Baldwin, the cabinet and the Dominions

Baldwin’s account, given to the Commons on 10 December and never substantially challenged, was that he had acted as a friend and had left the choice to the King. The decisive voices were overseas. The prime ministers of Australia, Canada and South Africa told London that their people would not accept Mrs Simpson as queen or as a morganatic wife; the Australian Joseph Lyons was especially firm. Ministers believed the monarchy was the one institution binding a self-governing Commonwealth together, and that a king who put a private wish above the advice of all his governments could not remain.

Wallis Simpson

In her memoir The Heart Has Its Reasons, and more candidly in private letters published after her death, Wallis presents herself as a woman carried along by a man who would not be refused. She wrote to him from Cannes urging him not to abdicate, and to friends that she felt like a hunted animal. Her letters to her former husband Ernest Simpson suggest real regret at what she had lost. She received sacks of hate mail and stones through her window. For the rest of her life she was denied the style Her Royal Highness, a decision she and the Duke regarded as an act of spite by his family.

The King’s supporters

Winston Churchill pleaded in the Commons for time and was howled down; the press lords Beaverbrook and Rothermere backed the King, and crowds outside Buckingham Palace sang ‘For he’s a jolly good fellow’. Letters preserved in the Baldwin papers and elsewhere, studied by the historian Susan Williams, show much working-class sympathy for a king who wished to marry for love and who had said of the Welsh unemployed that something must be done. To these people the affair looked like a king hustled out by politicians, bishops and courtiers. Edward’s own memoir, A King’s Story, takes a similar line.

The Irish Free State

Eamon de Valera, head of the Irish government, saw an opportunity where London saw a crisis. He recalled the Dail and in two days pushed through an amendment removing every mention of the king from the Free State’s constitution, together with an act retaining the Crown only as an instrument for external relations. Republican opponents said he had recognised the new king after all; Britain chose not to object. A new constitution followed in 1937.

What is disputed

The book used as an index here puts the famous broadcast on 10 December; it was made on the evening of the 11th. More seriously, writers disagree about whether the marriage was the real issue. Some have argued that the government wanted rid of a king with pro-German leanings and populist instincts and used Mrs Simpson as the occasion. His official biographer Philip Ziegler and most historians find no evidence of a plot and think the marriage was a sufficient cause. It is also argued, by Ziegler among others, that Edward had long disliked his role and was not sorry to be released from it.

What followed

George VI and Queen Elizabeth restored the monarchy’s standing, above all during the war. The Duke of Windsor visited Germany in October 1937 and met Hitler. In 1940 German agents in Lisbon tried to keep him in Europe as a possible puppet king; captured documents on the episode were published in 1957, and how far he encouraged the approach is still argued. Churchill sent him to govern the Bahamas until 1945. He and the Duchess then lived in Paris. He died in 1972 and she in 1986. The crown passed in 1952 to his niece, Elizabeth II.

Read further

  • Philip Ziegler, King Edward VIII: The Official Biography (1990)
  • Frances Donaldson, Edward VIII (1974)
  • The Duke of Windsor, A King’s Story (1951)
  • The Duchess of Windsor, The Heart Has Its Reasons (1956)
  • Susan Williams, The People’s King: The True Story of the Abdication (2003)

Same day, other years

1520

Luther burns the Pope’s bull

Wittenberg, SaxonyEurope

The papal bull Exsurge Domine had given Martin Luther sixty days to recant forty-one of his propositions or be excommunicated. On the morning the time ran out, his colleague Philip Melanchthon posted a notice inviting students to a bonfire outside the Elster Gate, where the town burned the clothing of plague victims. Volumes of canon law and scholastic theology went on first. Then Luther stepped forward and dropped a printed copy of the bull into the flames. The students spent the rest of the day parading through the streets with a mock bull on a pole. The formal excommunication was issued in Rome on 3 January 1521.

Seen from elsewhere. The papal side had lit its fires first: Luther’s books had been publicly burned at Louvain and Cologne that autumn on the authority of the nuncio Girolamo Aleander. To Rome, a friar who burned the law of the Church had declared himself outside it. Luther wrote that he had trembled beforehand and was afterwards more pleased than by any other act of his life.

1898

Spain sells the Philippines to the United States

Paris, FranceAsia

The treaty that ended the Spanish-American War was signed in Paris after ten weeks of negotiation. Spain gave up its claim to Cuba, ceded Puerto Rico and Guam, and transferred the Philippines to the United States for twenty million dollars. It was the end of an empire that had begun with Columbus. No Cuban, Puerto Rican or Filipino sat at the table. Felipe Agoncillo, sent by the Philippine revolutionary government that had declared independence six months earlier and controlled most of the archipelago outside Manila, was refused a hearing by the commissioners. The US Senate ratified the treaty in February 1899 with one vote to spare.

Seen from elsewhere. Fighting between American troops and Filipino forces broke out two days before that vote. The war that followed lasted officially until 1902 and killed some 4,200 American soldiers, at least 16,000 Filipino fighters and a number of civilians usually estimated at 200,000 or more, mostly from famine and disease. American opponents, Mark Twain among them, called it a betrayal of the country’s founding principles.

1948

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Paris, FranceWorldwide

Shortly before midnight the UN General Assembly adopted a declaration of thirty articles setting out rights belonging to every person: life, liberty, freedom from torture and slavery, a fair trial, freedom of thought, work, education and an adequate standard of living. Forty-eight states voted in favour and none against. The drafting committee, chaired by Eleanor Roosevelt, included the French jurist Rene Cassin, the Lebanese philosopher Charles Malik, the Chinese diplomat and playwright P. C. Chang and the Canadian lawyer John Humphrey, who wrote the first draft. It was a declaration, not a treaty, and bound no one in law.

Seen from elsewhere. Eight states abstained: six of the Soviet bloc, which wanted more on economic rights and state sovereignty; South Africa, then building apartheid; and Saudi Arabia, which objected to the articles on changing religion and equal rights in marriage. Much of Africa and Asia was still under colonial rule and had no vote. The American Anthropological Association had warned that one culture’s values were being presented as universal.

1979

The Kaohsiung Incident

Kaohsiung, TaiwanAsia

Taiwan had been under martial law for thirty years when the staff of Formosa Magazine, the rallying point for opponents of one-party Nationalist rule, organised a Human Rights Day rally in the southern port of Kaohsiung. The authorities refused a permit. Thousands came anyway, riot police and military police hemmed them in, and the evening ended in tear gas and street fighting. Within days almost every prominent opposition figure was arrested. Eight were tried by a military court in 1980 for sedition; Shih Ming-teh received a life sentence and the others, including Annette Lu and Chen Chu, twelve years or more.

Seen from elsewhere. The government said rioters had attacked the police and announced 183 officers injured and no civilians. Defendants testified that confessions had been extracted under duress, and their supporters maintain the clash was provoked. The trial, reported in detail, discredited its authors: the defendants and their lawyers, among them Chen Shui-bian, went on to found the party that won the presidency in 2000.

Also on 10 December