Parallax

24 December, 1888

Van Gogh is found bleeding in the Yellow House

On the morning of Christmas Eve the police of Arles climbed the stairs of a rented house and found a Dutch painter unconscious in a blood-soaked bed. What had happened the night before has been argued over ever since, because the only witness who wrote it down was Paul Gauguin.

Arles, France

Vincent van Gogh had been in Arles since February 1888. He was thirty-five, had sold almost nothing, and lived on an allowance from his younger brother Theo, an art dealer in Paris. In May he rented four rooms in a yellow-painted house on the Place Lamartine, near the station, and began to imagine it as a studio where painters would live and work together in the southern light. The one he most wanted was Paul Gauguin. Theo made it possible by offering Gauguin 150 francs a month in return for pictures. Vincent painted sunflowers to hang in the guest room. Gauguin arrived on 23 October.

For some weeks it worked. They painted the same subjects side by side, the Roman cemetery, the night cafe and its owner Madame Ginoux, shared the cooking and the expenses, and went together to the brothels. But Gauguin was domineering and sure of his own superiority, and he preached painting from memory and imagination, where Vincent needed the thing in front of him. By December it was raining, they were shut indoors together, and they quarrelled. Vincent wrote to Theo that their arguments were of an excessive electricity and left them drained. Gauguin told a friend he would have to leave.

On the evening of Sunday 23 December Gauguin went out alone. Late that night, in the house, Vincent took a razor and cut off his left ear. He stanched the bleeding, wrapped the ear in paper, pulled a hat down over the wound, and walked to a licensed brothel a few streets away. There he asked for a young woman called Rachel and handed her the package. The local newspaper reported the following Sunday that he told her to keep the object carefully. She fainted when she opened it. He went home and lay down.

Alerted by the brothel, the police came to the Yellow House on the morning of the 24th. There were bloodstained towels downstairs and marks along the stairway wall. Gauguin, who had spent the night at a hotel, arrived to find a crowd in the square and was for a moment treated as a suspect. Vincent was carried to the town hospital, the Hotel-Dieu, where a twenty-three-year-old intern, Felix Rey, dressed the wound. It was too late to reattach the ear.

Gauguin telegraphed Theo, who took the night train, sat with his brother for a few hours on Christmas Day, and returned to Paris the same evening with Gauguin. The two painters exchanged letters afterwards, friendly ones, but never met again.

How it came to this

Van Gogh came to painting late, after failing as an art dealer’s clerk, a schoolmaster and a lay preacher among Belgian miners. He taught himself to draw in his late twenties, and in two years in Paris, from 1886, absorbed Impressionism and the Japanese prints that made him long for strong sun and flat colour. He went south to find them. In Arles he worked at a furious rate, producing some two hundred paintings in fifteen months, often eating badly and drinking too much, and he had almost no company. His letters speak of loneliness and of fits of anxiety.

Gauguin, five years older, was a former stockbroker who had left his wife and five children to paint. He was in Brittany, in debt and ill, when Theo’s offer came, and he accepted for the money and for the hope that Theo would sell his work. The two men admired each other’s pictures and had exchanged self-portraits. Around the day of the crisis Vincent also learned that Theo, on whom he depended for everything, had become engaged to be married.

How each side saw it

Paul Gauguin

Gauguin told the story twice. Days afterwards he gave an account to the painter Emile Bernard, who put it in a letter: Vincent had run after him in the street, asked whether he was leaving, and turned back. Fifteen years later, in his memoir Avant et apres, Gauguin added that Vincent had come at him with an open razor and that he had stopped him with a look. The memoir presents Gauguin as the calm master and Vincent as a grateful, unstable pupil. Its author had an interest in explaining why he had walked away from a wounded friend without seeing him.

Vincent van Gogh

He said he remembered almost nothing. His letters to Theo in January 1889 play the episode down as an artist’s fit of madness, apologise for the trouble and the expense, and worry about the cost of the blood-stained linen. He wrote warmly to Gauguin and proposed that they exchange pictures. But in a letter of 17 January he let his resentment show, comparing Gauguin to Bonaparte, who had likewise left his army in difficulty and gone back to Paris. He never accused Gauguin of anything worse, and never gave any explanation of his own for what he had done.

The neighbours

To the people of the Place Lamartine he was not an artist but a frightening man who lived among them. In February 1889, after he had been released and had suffered another breakdown, thirty residents signed a petition to the mayor asking that he be returned to his family or confined. The police took statements: witnesses said that he drank, followed women and children, and spoke incoherently. The petition survives in the Arles archives. He was locked in a hospital cell and his house was sealed. He wrote that it was a blow to find so many people banded together against one sick man.

The young woman called Rachel

She left no account. The police and the newspaper give only a first name, and for more than a century she was assumed to be a prostitute. The researcher Bernadette Murphy identified her in 2016 as Gabrielle Berlatier, a farmer’s daughter of about nineteen who cleaned at the brothel. She had been badly bitten by a rabid dog early that year and treated at the Pasteur Institute in Paris, leaving her family in debt. Murphy suggests that Vincent, who knew her, meant the gift as some confused act of sympathy for another damaged person. Her descendants asked that she not be named for many years.

What is disputed

The cutting took place late on 23 December; the 24th is the day he was found. Whether he removed the whole ear or part of it was long uncertain: his sister-in-law and the painter Signac spoke of the lobe, but a sketch made by Dr Rey in 1930, rediscovered by Murphy, shows almost the entire ear gone. Two German historians, Hans Kaufmann and Rita Wildegans, argued in 2008 that Gauguin, a fencer, severed it with a sword and that both men kept silent; the Van Gogh Museum rejects this. Martin Bailey holds that news of Theo’s engagement was the trigger. The underlying illness has been diagnosed as epilepsy, bipolar disorder and several other conditions, none proven.

What followed

Van Gogh left hospital on 7 January and painted himself with the bandage on. In May 1889 he entered the asylum at Saint-Remy of his own accord, where he painted The Starry Night, and in July 1890 he died at Auvers, north of Paris, two days after shooting himself in the chest. Theo died six months later. It was Theo’s widow, Johanna van Gogh-Bonger, who placed the paintings, published the letters and made the reputation. The Yellow House was destroyed by Allied bombing in 1944.

Read further

  • Vincent van Gogh, The Letters, edited by Leo Jansen, Hans Luijten and Nienke Bakker (2009)
  • Bernadette Murphy, Van Gogh’s Ear: The True Story (2016)
  • Martin Gayford, The Yellow House: Van Gogh, Gauguin and Nine Turbulent Weeks in Arles (2006)
  • Martin Bailey, Studio of the South: Van Gogh in Provence (2016)
  • Paul Gauguin, Avant et apres (1903)

Same day, other years

1524

Vasco da Gama dies at Cochin

Kochi, IndiaAsia

The navigator who had opened the sea route from Europe to India in 1498 returned for the third time in September 1524 as viceroy, sent by the King of Portugal to stamp out corruption among the officials of the trading empire that had grown up in his wake. He was in his fifties or sixties and ruled with a severity that alarmed his own countrymen. Within three months he fell ill, probably with malaria, and he died on Christmas Eve. He was buried in the Franciscan church at Cochin, where the empty tomb is still shown; his remains were taken to Portugal in 1539 and now lie at Belem.

Seen from elsewhere. On the Malabar coast he is remembered for his second voyage, in 1502, when he burned a ship of pilgrims returning from Mecca with several hundred people aboard and bombarded Calicut. Portuguese eyewitnesses recorded both. The sixteenth-century Malabar scholar Zayn al-Din described the Portuguese arrival as a calamity for the region’s Muslims and called for resistance.

1865

The Ku Klux Klan is formed

Pulaski, Tennessee, United StatesThe Americas

Six young Confederate veterans in a small Tennessee town founded a secret club with a name adapted from the Greek word for circle, invented titles and costumes, and rode about at night in disguise. Within two years, as Congress gave the vote to Black men in the South, it had become something else. A convention at Nashville in 1867 organised it across the former Confederacy, with the cavalry general Nathan Bedford Forrest at its head. Its members whipped, raped and murdered freedpeople and white Republicans, burned schools and churches, and drove Black voters from the polls. Federal laws and troops broke the organisation in 1871-72.

Seen from elsewhere. The founders and later sympathetic writers described a harmless social club that others corrupted, or a defence of order in a defeated land. Thirteen volumes of testimony taken by Congress in 1871, much of it from Black survivors, record what its victims experienced. The Christmas Eve founding date is traditional; no document fixes it, and some accounts place it in 1866.

1914

The guns fall quiet in Flanders

Western Front, Belgium and FranceEurope

After five months of war, British and German soldiers faced each other from flooded trenches sometimes less than a hundred yards apart. On Christmas Eve, along parts of the line south of Ypres, German troops set small candlelit trees on their parapets and sang carols. The British answered. On Christmas morning men climbed out, met between the lines, exchanged tobacco, buttons and addresses, and buried the dead who had lain there for weeks. Letters home mention kickabouts with a football. Tens of thousands of men took part, mostly along the British sector. In some places the quiet lasted until New Year.

Seen from elsewhere. It was never general. Elsewhere on the front the fighting went on and men were killed that day. French and Belgian soldiers, whose countries were occupied, joined in far less. Commanders on both sides forbade any repetition and ordered artillery fire at later Christmases. The story of an organised football match rests on thin evidence.

1951

Libya becomes independent

Benghazi, LibyaAfrica

From the balcony of a palace in Benghazi, Idris al-Senussi, head of a Sufi order that had led resistance to colonial rule, proclaimed the United Kingdom of Libya. It joined three provinces, Tripolitania, Cyrenaica and Fezzan, which Italy had taken from the Ottoman Empire in 1911 and lost in the Second World War. The Italian conquest of the interior had been savage: around 1930 much of the population of eastern Libya was herded into desert camps, where tens of thousands died. Unable to agree on the territory’s future, the great powers handed the question to the United Nations, which set a deadline for independence. Libya was then among the poorest countries on earth.

Seen from elsewhere. Nationalists in Tripoli, the most populous province, wanted a unitary republic and regarded the federal monarchy as a British arrangement to secure military bases. Their leader was deported after the first election. Muammar Gaddafi, who overthrew Idris in 1969, abolished the holiday in favour of the date of his own coup. It was restored after 2011.

Also on 24 December