Vincent van Gogh had been in Arles since February 1888. He was thirty-five, had sold almost nothing, and lived on an allowance from his younger brother Theo, an art dealer in Paris. In May he rented four rooms in a yellow-painted house on the Place Lamartine, near the station, and began to imagine it as a studio where painters would live and work together in the southern light. The one he most wanted was Paul Gauguin. Theo made it possible by offering Gauguin 150 francs a month in return for pictures. Vincent painted sunflowers to hang in the guest room. Gauguin arrived on 23 October.
For some weeks it worked. They painted the same subjects side by side, the Roman cemetery, the night cafe and its owner Madame Ginoux, shared the cooking and the expenses, and went together to the brothels. But Gauguin was domineering and sure of his own superiority, and he preached painting from memory and imagination, where Vincent needed the thing in front of him. By December it was raining, they were shut indoors together, and they quarrelled. Vincent wrote to Theo that their arguments were of an excessive electricity and left them drained. Gauguin told a friend he would have to leave.
On the evening of Sunday 23 December Gauguin went out alone. Late that night, in the house, Vincent took a razor and cut off his left ear. He stanched the bleeding, wrapped the ear in paper, pulled a hat down over the wound, and walked to a licensed brothel a few streets away. There he asked for a young woman called Rachel and handed her the package. The local newspaper reported the following Sunday that he told her to keep the object carefully. She fainted when she opened it. He went home and lay down.
Alerted by the brothel, the police came to the Yellow House on the morning of the 24th. There were bloodstained towels downstairs and marks along the stairway wall. Gauguin, who had spent the night at a hotel, arrived to find a crowd in the square and was for a moment treated as a suspect. Vincent was carried to the town hospital, the Hotel-Dieu, where a twenty-three-year-old intern, Felix Rey, dressed the wound. It was too late to reattach the ear.
Gauguin telegraphed Theo, who took the night train, sat with his brother for a few hours on Christmas Day, and returned to Paris the same evening with Gauguin. The two painters exchanged letters afterwards, friendly ones, but never met again.
How it came to this
Van Gogh came to painting late, after failing as an art dealer’s clerk, a schoolmaster and a lay preacher among Belgian miners. He taught himself to draw in his late twenties, and in two years in Paris, from 1886, absorbed Impressionism and the Japanese prints that made him long for strong sun and flat colour. He went south to find them. In Arles he worked at a furious rate, producing some two hundred paintings in fifteen months, often eating badly and drinking too much, and he had almost no company. His letters speak of loneliness and of fits of anxiety.
Gauguin, five years older, was a former stockbroker who had left his wife and five children to paint. He was in Brittany, in debt and ill, when Theo’s offer came, and he accepted for the money and for the hope that Theo would sell his work. The two men admired each other’s pictures and had exchanged self-portraits. Around the day of the crisis Vincent also learned that Theo, on whom he depended for everything, had become engaged to be married.