Parallax

15 December, 1809

Napoleon and Josephine dissolve their marriage

Before the whole imperial family, an emperor read out that he still loved his wife and was leaving her. She tried to read her reply, and could not get through it.

Tuileries Palace, Paris, France

At nine in the evening on Friday 15 December 1809 the Bonaparte family assembled in full court dress in the Emperor’s study at the Tuileries. Napoleon’s mother was there, with his brothers and sisters, who had disliked his wife from the first and did not trouble to hide their satisfaction. So were Josephine’s two children by her first marriage, Eugene and Hortense, both in tears. The Arch-Chancellor of the Empire, Cambaceres, presided, with a secretary to record what was said.

Napoleon spoke first, from a paper. The interests of France, he said, required that he leave children to inherit the throne on which Providence had placed him. He had lost hope of having them by his beloved wife. ‘God knows what such a resolution has cost my heart,’ he read; she had ‘adorned fifteen years of my life’. Josephine, in a plain white dress without jewels, rose to read her own declaration, that she was proud to give the greatest proof of devotion ever offered on earth. After a few sentences her voice failed. She handed the paper to the secretary, Regnaud de Saint-Jean d’Angely, who finished it for her. Everyone signed the register. Her signature is firm.

She had known for two weeks. On 30 November he had told her after a silent dinner, and she had collapsed on the carpet. A palace official, Bausset, was called to help carry her down a narrow staircase to her rooms; he recorded afterwards that as he struggled with her she murmured that he was holding her too tightly, and that he was no longer sure how far the faint was real.

The reasons were dynastic. Josephine was 46 and had borne Napoleon no child in thirteen years. For a long time he had wondered whether the fault was his. Then a brief liaison in 1806 produced a son, and in the autumn of 1809 his Polish mistress, Marie Walewska, was pregnant. In July he had defeated Austria at Wagram, and in October a German student had tried to stab him at Schonbrunn. The empire hung on one life, and he wanted an heir of his own blood with a mother from one of the old reigning houses.

The Senate dissolved the civil marriage the next day. Josephine left the Tuileries in the rain for Malmaison, her house west of Paris, keeping the title of Empress, an income of three million francs a year and her debts paid. Napoleon went to the Trianon and for some days wrote to her daily. Within four months he had married the eighteen-year-old Archduchess Marie Louise of Austria.

How it came to this

Marie-Josephe-Rose Tascher de la Pagerie was born in 1763 on a sugar plantation in Martinique and sent to France at sixteen to marry a viscount, Alexandre de Beauharnais. The marriage was unhappy and ended in separation. During the Terror both were imprisoned; he was guillotined in July 1794 and she escaped the same fate by days when Robespierre fell. A widow with two children, no money and useful friends, she met General Bonaparte, six years her junior, in 1795. They married in a civil ceremony in March 1796, both giving false ages, and two days later he left to command the army in Italy.

He wrote her feverish letters; she was unfaithful with a young officer, and he, on learning of it in Egypt, began affairs of his own. By the time he took power in 1799 the balance had reversed and it was she who feared being put aside. On the eve of the coronation in December 1804 she let the Pope know they had never been married in church, and a hurried religious ceremony was performed in private by Napoleon’s uncle, Cardinal Fesch. Its irregularities would later prove convenient.

How each side saw it

Josephine and her children

Her letters, and the memoirs of her daughter Hortense and her lady-in-waiting Claire de Remusat, show a woman who had dreaded this for a decade and consented because refusal was impossible. She negotiated hard for her household and for Eugene’s future, and she remained on affectionate terms with Napoleon, who visited Malmaison and consulted her about his new wife. Hortense, herself miserably married to Napoleon’s brother Louis, wrote that her mother’s tears on the night were real but that there was relief in them too. Josephine devoted her last years to her gardens and her collection of rare plants, and went on spending beyond her means.

The Catholic Church

A civil divorce did not free a Catholic to marry an Austrian archduchess. Pope Pius VII, the proper judge of a sovereign’s marriage, was Napoleon’s prisoner at Savona and was not asked. Instead the diocesan court of Paris declared the religious marriage of 1804 null in January 1810, on the grounds that it had lacked witnesses and the parish priest and that the Emperor had not truly consented. Many churchmen thought the finding absurd. Thirteen cardinals stayed away from the wedding to Marie Louise in protest; Napoleon stripped them of their red robes and their incomes, and they were known afterwards as the black cardinals.

The Habsburgs

Marie Louise had been brought up to regard Bonaparte as the ogre who had twice driven her family from Vienna; she was a great-niece of Marie Antoinette. She wrote to a friend that merely to see the man would be the worst of torments. Her father, the Emperor Francis, and his minister Metternich gave her to him four months after Wagram to buy a beaten monarchy time, and she obeyed. She bore the desired son in March 1811, proved a dutiful consort, and after 1814 did not follow Napoleon into exile. Vienna regarded the match as a necessary sacrifice and dropped it when it could.

Martinique

On the island of her birth Josephine is remembered less as a discarded wife than as the daughter of a plantation whose labourers were enslaved. In 1802 Napoleon restored slavery in the French colonies where the Revolution had abolished it, and Caribbean tradition has long held that she urged him to do so. Historians have found no evidence that she did. Her marble statue in Fort-de-France was beheaded by unknown hands in 1991, left headless and splashed with red paint for decades, and pulled down by demonstrators in July 2020.

What is disputed

Josephine’s influence on the restoration of slavery is asserted in tradition and unsupported by documents; most historians attribute the decision to Napoleon, his colonial ministry and the planter lobby. Whether her collapse on 30 November was genuine depends on Bausset’s memoir alone. Why she had no more children is unknown: she was 32 at the marriage, and imprisonment or a bad fall in 1798 have both been suggested. The validity of the church annulment was contested at the time and since. Napoleon’s supposed dying words at St Helena, ending with her name, come from companions’ recollections that do not agree with one another.

What followed

Josephine died at Malmaison on 29 May 1814, of a chill caught while entertaining Tsar Alexander, a few weeks after Napoleon’s first abdication. The son for whom she was set aside, styled King of Rome, grew up a virtual prisoner in Vienna and died childless at 21. It was her line that prospered. Hortense’s son reigned as Napoleon III, and through Eugene’s daughter, who married the future King of Sweden, Josephine is an ancestor of the present royal families of Sweden, Norway, Denmark, Belgium and Luxembourg. Napoleon said at St Helena that the Austrian marriage had been an abyss covered with flowers.

Read further

  • Andrew Roberts, Napoleon the Great (2014)
  • Philip Dwyer, Citizen Emperor: Napoleon in Power 1799-1815 (2013)
  • Kate Williams, Josephine: Desire, Ambition, Napoleon (2013)
  • Evangeline Bruce, Napoleon and Josephine: An Improbable Marriage (1995)
  • Claire de Remusat, Memoirs of Madame de Remusat, 1802-1808

Same day, other years

AD 533

Belisarius destroys the Vandal kingdom

Tricamarum, near Carthage (modern Tunisia)Africa

The Vandals had ruled Rome’s richest African provinces from Carthage since 439 and had sacked Rome itself in 455. In 533 the emperor Justinian sent his general Belisarius against them with some 15,000 men. Having taken Carthage in September, Belisarius met King Gelimer’s regrouped army about thirty kilometres west of the city in mid-December. Repeated charges by the Byzantine cavalry broke the Vandal centre and killed the king’s brother Tzazon. Gelimer rode off the field, his army dissolved, and its camp, full of a century’s plunder, was looted through the night. He surrendered the following spring and was paraded through Constantinople in a triumph.

Seen from elsewhere. The Vandals left no history of their own; the account is that of Procopius, Belisarius’s secretary, an eyewitness. Elsewhere Procopius wrote that Justinian’s officials ruined Africa with taxes. The Berber peoples of the interior, whom the Romans called Moors, fought the new rulers for decades, and the Arian Christianity of the Vandals was suppressed.

1256

The Mongols take Alamut

Alamut, Alborz mountains, PersiaMiddle East

For more than a century and a half the Nizari Ismailis, a branch of Shia Islam, had held a chain of mountain castles in Persia and Syria from which they defied far stronger Sunni powers, partly by the targeted killing of enemy rulers and ministers. In 1256 Hulagu, grandson of Genghis Khan, came west with a huge army and orders to destroy them. The young imam Rukn al-Din Khurshah surrendered in November, and in mid-December the garrison of Alamut, the headquarters, came down from its rock. The Persian official Juvayni was allowed into its famous library; he saved Qurans and astronomical instruments and burned the rest. The imam was murdered the following year and his followers massacred.

Seen from elsewhere. Nearly everything written about the Nizaris comes from enemies such as Juvayni, or from crusaders and Marco Polo, whose tales of drugged killers gave Europe the word assassin. Scholars led by Farhad Daftary have reconstructed a learned community from surviving Ismaili texts. It was not destroyed: the Nizari line of imams continues today in the Aga Khan.

1890

Sitting Bull is killed by Indian police

Grand River, Standing Rock Reservation, South DakotaThe Americas

Sitting Bull, the Hunkpapa Lakota leader who had helped defeat Custer in 1876, was living in a cabin on the Standing Rock reservation when the Ghost Dance, a religious movement promising the return of the buffalo and the dead, spread among the hungry Lakota. The government agent, James McLaughlin, feared he would put himself at its head and ordered his arrest. Before dawn forty-three Lakota policemen in government service surrounded the cabin. As they brought him out a crowd gathered and one of his followers shot the police lieutenant, Bull Head, who fired into Sitting Bull’s chest as he fell; Sergeant Red Tomahawk shot him through the head. Six policemen died, and seven of his followers with him, among them his teenage son Crow Foot.

Seen from elsewhere. McLaughlin reported a lawful arrest that was resisted. Many Lakota then and since have called it an assassination arranged by an agent who had long wanted him removed, and carried out by setting Lakota against Lakota. Refugees from his camp fled south to join Big Foot’s band; two weeks later the army killed some 250 to 300 of them at Wounded Knee.

1961

Eichmann is sentenced to death

Jerusalem, IsraelMiddle East

Adolf Eichmann, the SS officer who had organised the deportation of Jews from across Europe to the death camps, had been seized by Israeli agents in Buenos Aires in May 1960 and flown secretly to Israel. His trial opened in April 1961 before three judges, with the accused in a bulletproof glass booth. More than a hundred survivors testified, many describing for the first time in public what they had seen, and the proceedings were filmed and broadcast around the world. He was convicted on all fifteen counts, including crimes against the Jewish people and crimes against humanity, and on 15 December was sentenced to hang. The sentence was carried out at Ramla on the night of 31 May 1962.

Seen from elsewhere. His lawyer argued that he had obeyed superior orders, that the kidnapping was unlawful and that Israel was applying a law passed after the events; Argentina protested to the UN Security Council. Hannah Arendt saw in him the ‘banality of evil’, a thoughtless functionary. Later historians, using recordings he made in Argentina, describe a committed antisemite. Martin Buber was among those who asked that he be spared.

Also on 15 December