Parallax

31 December, 1720

A Stuart heir is born in a borrowed Roman palace

The boy whose birth was celebrated with bonfires by exiled Jacobites would come within 130 miles of London at 24, and die in the same Roman palace as a broken man of 67.

Palazzo Muti, Rome

Charles Edward Louis John Casimir Silvester Severino Maria Stuart was born in Rome on 31 December 1720, which in Britain, still on the old Julian calendar, was 20 December. His father, James Francis Edward Stuart, called himself King James III of England and VIII of Scotland; his mother, Maria Clementina Sobieska, was a granddaughter of the Polish king who had relieved Vienna from the Ottomans. The pope, Clement XI, had given the exiled family the Palazzo Muti near the church of the Holy Apostles, paid them a pension, and recognised their royal titles.

The birth was a matter of state. James had himself been the subject of rumours in 1688 that he was a changeling smuggled into his mother’s bed in a warming pan, and care was taken to have the birth witnessed. Jacobites in Rome, Paris and the Scottish Highlands drank to the new Prince of Wales; British diplomats and spies reported every detail to London. The child was baptised within hours.

He grew up handsome, athletic and badly educated, in a household divided by his parents’ quarrels. At thirteen he served at the Spanish siege of Gaeta and was praised for his coolness under fire. In 1744 France prepared an invasion of England with him at its head, but a storm wrecked the transports and the plan was dropped. The next year he went without French permission, landing on the Hebridean island of Eriskay in July 1745 with a handful of companions, the Seven Men of Moidart.

At Glenfinnan in August he raised his father’s standard before a few clan regiments. Edinburgh fell in September, a government army was routed at Prestonpans in a quarter of an hour, and in November the Jacobite army of about 5,500 men invaded England. On 4 December it reached Derby. English Jacobites had not risen, French troops had not landed, and two government armies were closing in. His council of officers, led by Lord George Murray, insisted on retreat, and Charles never forgave them.

On 16 April 1746, on Drummossie Moor near Culloden, his tired and hungry army of about 5,000 was destroyed in less than an hour by the Duke of Cumberland’s force of some 8,000. Charles escaped and spent five months hiding in the Highlands and islands with a price of 30,000 pounds on his head that nobody claimed. In June Flora MacDonald took him over the sea to Skye disguised as her Irish maid, Betty Burke. In September a French ship took him off from the same loch where he had landed.

How it came to this

His grandfather, James II and VII, had been driven from the throne in 1688 by his Protestant son-in-law William of Orange, with the support of most of the English political class, who feared a Catholic monarchy. The Act of Settlement of 1701 barred Catholics from the throne, and in 1714 the crown passed to the Elector of Hanover, George I. Those who remained loyal to the exiled line were called Jacobites, from Jacobus, the Latin for James.

Jacobitism was strongest in Ireland, in parts of north-east England, among Tories and Non-Jurors, and in Scotland, where many resented the Union of 1707 and where Episcopalian and Catholic Highland clans had their own grievances. Risings in 1689, 1715 and 1719 had failed. By the 1740s the exiled court in Rome depended on French support, and France backed it only when war with Britain made a diversion useful. The birth of a son in 1720 mattered because it promised the cause a further generation, and a younger brother, Henry, followed in 1725.

How each side saw it

The Gaelic Highlands

Gaelic poets such as Alasdair mac Mhaighstir Alasdair, who served in the rising, wrote of the prince as a rightful king returning to free the Gael, and a large body of Gaelic song mourned him afterwards. But Highland society was split. Many clans stayed out or fought for the government, and some who came out did so under pressure from chiefs who threatened to burn tenants’ houses. After Culloden the region paid heavily: houses burned, cattle driven off, prisoners transported, and the Highland way of life targeted by law.

The Hanoverian government and Lowland Presbyterians

To the government and to most Lowland Scots, especially Presbyterians who remembered persecution under the Stuarts, the rising was a Catholic rebellion backed by France in the middle of a European war. The Kirk preached against it and Glasgow refused to support it. Many Scots fought for King George at Culloden. Cumberland, who had orders to end the threat for good, was celebrated in London as a deliverer, and Handel’s oratorio Judas Maccabaeus was composed in his honour. In Scotland he was remembered as the Butcher.

Historians of Jacobitism

For much of the twentieth century the Forty-Five was treated as a doomed romantic adventure by a backward fringe. Historians such as Bruce Lenman, Frank McLynn, Murray Pittock and Christopher Duffy have since treated Jacobitism as a serious European political movement with real support. Duffy and others argue that the army at Derby could have reached London, where there was panic and a run on the Bank of England; sceptics reply that without French troops or an English rising it could not have held the capital.

What is disputed

His birth date depends on the calendar: 31 December in Rome, 20 December in Britain. Figures for Culloden vary: Jacobite dead are put at between about 1,250 and 2,000, many killed in the pursuit and after the battle, against perhaps 50 government soldiers killed and some 250 wounded. Whether wounded Jacobites were killed on Cumberland’s orders is still argued. The Flora MacDonald episode is well documented but much embroidered, and claims about his later drunkenness come mainly from his estranged wife and from British agents.

What followed

Expelled from France in 1748, Charles drifted through Europe, quarrelled with nearly every supporter and drank heavily. He secretly visited London in 1750. In 1772 he married Louise of Stolberg-Gedern, who left him for the poet Vittorio Alfieri. He died in the Palazzo Muti on 31 January 1788, aged 67. In Scotland the government disarmed the clans, banned Highland dress until 1782 and abolished the chiefs’ private courts, and Walter Scott’s Waverley later turned the defeated cause into a national romance.

Read further

  • Frank McLynn, Charles Edward Stuart: A Tragedy in Many Acts (1988)
  • Christopher Duffy, The ‘45 (2003)
  • Murray Pittock, Culloden (2016)
  • Jacqueline Riding, Jacobites: A New History of the ‘45 Rebellion (2016)
  • Walter Scott, Waverley (1814)

Same day, other years

AD 406

Vandals, Alans and Suebi cross the Rhine

Rhine frontier, probably near MainzEurope

According to the chronicler Prosper of Aquitaine, on the last day of 406 a coalition of Vandals, Alans and Suebi crossed the Rhine into the Roman provinces of Gaul. The frontier was thinly held, since troops had been withdrawn to defend Italy against the Goths. The Franks, allied to Rome, fought them and killed the Vandal king, but were beaten when the Alans came up. Over the next three years the invaders moved across Gaul, and in 409 they crossed into Spain. Some of the Vandals later passed into North Africa and took Carthage in 439.

Seen from elsewhere. Edward Gibbon assumed the Rhine was frozen, which no source says. The historian Michael Kulikowski has argued that the crossing happened a year earlier, in 405. Older histories made it the moment the western empire fell; others stress that Roman government in Gaul and Spain carried on, adapting to new rulers.

1600

Elizabeth I charters the East India Company

London, EnglandEurope

Elizabeth I granted a royal charter to the Governor and Company of Merchants of London trading into the East Indies, a group of some two hundred investors led by the alderman Thomas Smythe. It gave them a fifteen-year monopoly of English trade east of the Cape of Good Hope. The first fleet sailed in 1601 for the spice islands of Indonesia, where the Dutch were already stronger. Over two and a half centuries the company moved from pepper to cotton and tea, and from trading posts to ruling much of the Indian subcontinent with its own army.

Seen from elsewhere. Its defenders saw commerce and orderly government; Indian historians and economists such as Romesh Chunder Dutt described the drain of wealth, the Bengal famine of 1770 under company rule and the dismantling of local industry. After the rising of 1857 the British crown took over its territories, and the company was dissolved in 1874.

1981

Jerry Rawlings seizes power in Ghana for the second time

Accra, GhanaAfrica

Flight Lieutenant Jerry Rawlings, who had led a junior officers’ coup in 1979, organised a ‘house-cleaning’ in which eight senior officers including three former heads of state were executed, and then handed power to an elected government, overthrew that government on New Year’s Eve 1981. He announced on radio that this was not a coup but a revolution. His Provisional National Defence Council suspended the constitution, banned political parties and set up people’s tribunals. Rawlings ruled for nineteen years, from 1992 as an elected president, and stepped down after his two terms in 2001.

Seen from elsewhere. Supporters credit him with fighting corruption and, after 1983, with economic recovery under IMF reforms. Opponents recall arbitrary detentions and the abduction and murder of three High Court judges and a retired army officer in 1982 by men linked to the regime. He was also credited with handing over power peacefully in 2001.

1999

Panama takes control of the canal

Panama Canal, PanamaThe Americas

At noon on 31 December 1999 the United States handed full control of the Panama Canal and the remaining land of the former Canal Zone to Panama, under the treaties signed by Jimmy Carter and Omar Torrijos in 1977. The Zone had been American territory in all but name since 1903, when the United States backed Panama’s secession from Colombia and secured the strip in perpetuity through a treaty signed by a French engineer on Panama’s behalf. Panamanians had campaigned for decades for its return, and in 1964 more than twenty were killed in riots over the right to fly the Panamanian flag there.

Seen from elsewhere. Many American conservatives opposed the handover as a giveaway of a national asset; Ronald Reagan campaigned against it. Panamanians saw the end of a colonial enclave that had split their country in two. The canal’s management since has generally been judged efficient, and it was enlarged in 2016.

Also on 31 December