Charles Edward Louis John Casimir Silvester Severino Maria Stuart was born in Rome on 31 December 1720, which in Britain, still on the old Julian calendar, was 20 December. His father, James Francis Edward Stuart, called himself King James III of England and VIII of Scotland; his mother, Maria Clementina Sobieska, was a granddaughter of the Polish king who had relieved Vienna from the Ottomans. The pope, Clement XI, had given the exiled family the Palazzo Muti near the church of the Holy Apostles, paid them a pension, and recognised their royal titles.
The birth was a matter of state. James had himself been the subject of rumours in 1688 that he was a changeling smuggled into his mother’s bed in a warming pan, and care was taken to have the birth witnessed. Jacobites in Rome, Paris and the Scottish Highlands drank to the new Prince of Wales; British diplomats and spies reported every detail to London. The child was baptised within hours.
He grew up handsome, athletic and badly educated, in a household divided by his parents’ quarrels. At thirteen he served at the Spanish siege of Gaeta and was praised for his coolness under fire. In 1744 France prepared an invasion of England with him at its head, but a storm wrecked the transports and the plan was dropped. The next year he went without French permission, landing on the Hebridean island of Eriskay in July 1745 with a handful of companions, the Seven Men of Moidart.
At Glenfinnan in August he raised his father’s standard before a few clan regiments. Edinburgh fell in September, a government army was routed at Prestonpans in a quarter of an hour, and in November the Jacobite army of about 5,500 men invaded England. On 4 December it reached Derby. English Jacobites had not risen, French troops had not landed, and two government armies were closing in. His council of officers, led by Lord George Murray, insisted on retreat, and Charles never forgave them.
On 16 April 1746, on Drummossie Moor near Culloden, his tired and hungry army of about 5,000 was destroyed in less than an hour by the Duke of Cumberland’s force of some 8,000. Charles escaped and spent five months hiding in the Highlands and islands with a price of 30,000 pounds on his head that nobody claimed. In June Flora MacDonald took him over the sea to Skye disguised as her Irish maid, Betty Burke. In September a French ship took him off from the same loch where he had landed.
How it came to this
His grandfather, James II and VII, had been driven from the throne in 1688 by his Protestant son-in-law William of Orange, with the support of most of the English political class, who feared a Catholic monarchy. The Act of Settlement of 1701 barred Catholics from the throne, and in 1714 the crown passed to the Elector of Hanover, George I. Those who remained loyal to the exiled line were called Jacobites, from Jacobus, the Latin for James.
Jacobitism was strongest in Ireland, in parts of north-east England, among Tories and Non-Jurors, and in Scotland, where many resented the Union of 1707 and where Episcopalian and Catholic Highland clans had their own grievances. Risings in 1689, 1715 and 1719 had failed. By the 1740s the exiled court in Rome depended on French support, and France backed it only when war with Britain made a diversion useful. The birth of a son in 1720 mattered because it promised the cause a further generation, and a younger brother, Henry, followed in 1725.