Parallax

12 December, 1889

Robert Browning dies in a Venetian palace

His last book was published in London on the day he died in Venice. He was told that evening that it was selling out, and had about three hours left to enjoy the news.

Ca’ Rezzonico, Venice, Italy

In the autumn of 1889 Robert Browning, aged 77, was staying at Asolo, the hill town in the Veneto that he had first walked into as a young man and had put into his early poem Pippa Passes. He was correcting the proofs of a new collection and named it after the place: Asolando. At the end of October he moved down to Venice, to the Ca’ Rezzonico, the enormous baroque palace on the Grand Canal that his only son, Pen, had lately bought with the fortune of his American wife, Fannie Coddington.

He kept up the habits of a vigorous man, walking every day on the Lido. Late in November he came back from one of these walks with a cold. It went to his chest; the doctors diagnosed bronchitis and then a failing heart. He was put to bed in a small room on the mezzanine, complaining mildly that he felt perfectly well.

On Thursday 12 December Asolando was published in London by Smith, Elder. Its closing poem, the ‘Epilogue’, describes its author as ‘One who never turned his back but marched breast forward, / Never doubted clouds would break’. He had read those lines aloud in proof to his sister and daughter-in-law and remarked that they sounded like bragging, but that they were the simple truth and should stand. That evening a telegram arrived from his publisher reporting excellent reviews and an edition nearly exhausted. Pen read it to him. He is reported to have answered, ‘How gratifying.’ He died at about ten o’clock.

He had wanted to lie in Florence beside his wife, Elizabeth Barrett Browning, who had died there in 1861. The Protestant cemetery where she was buried had been closed to new burials, and the Italian authorities could not make an exception quickly enough. Venice gave him a public funeral, with the coffin carried by municipal barge across the lagoon to the cemetery island of San Michele. Then a message came from the Dean of Westminster. The body went by train to London, and on 31 December Browning was buried in Poets’ Corner. Henry James, who was in the Abbey that day, thought there was something faintly comic in so unconventional a spirit being received with such ceremony.

The city of Venice set a tablet on the palace wall with two lines from one of his own poems: ‘Open my heart and you will see / Graved inside of it, Italy.’

How it came to this

Browning was born in 1812 in Camberwell, then a village south of London, the son of a Bank of England clerk who owned some six thousand books and let the boy read all of them. He lived with his parents into his thirties and published at his family’s expense. Sordello (1840), a long poem about a medieval troubadour, was so hard to follow that it damaged his name for twenty years; Tennyson is said to have claimed that he understood only the first line and the last, and that both were lies. In shorter pieces such as ‘My Last Duchess’ he was meanwhile perfecting the dramatic monologue, in which a speaker gives himself away.

In January 1845 he wrote to a poet far better known than himself, an invalid of 38 who seldom left her room in Wimpole Street. They married in secret in September 1846 and left for Italy, settling at Casa Guidi in Florence. Her father never spoke to her again. After her death Browning returned to London with their son, and The Ring and the Book (1868-69), a Roman murder case told by a dozen voices, finally made him famous.

How each side saw it

Elizabeth Barrett Browning

During the marriage she was the celebrity and he the poet’s husband. Her name was put forward for Poet Laureate in 1850; Sonnets from the Portuguese and the verse-novel Aurora Leigh outsold anything of his. Her letters show a happy marriage with real disagreements. She believed in spiritualism and he thought the medium Daniel Home a fraud; she idolised Napoleon III as Italy’s liberator and he did not; she dressed their son in velvet and long curls, which Browning had cut off within days of her death. Her reputation then sank beneath his for a century, until feminist critics from the 1970s onwards restored Aurora Leigh to the canon.

Edward Moulton-Barrett

Elizabeth’s father left no account of himself; he is known through his children’s letters, which describe a devout, affectionate and immovable man who forbade all his adult sons and daughters to marry and cut off the three who did. He returned Elizabeth’s letters unopened until his death in 1857. A popular play of 1930, The Barretts of Wimpole Street, made him a monster, which the family resented. His wealth came from Jamaican sugar estates worked by enslaved people. Elizabeth, an abolitionist, wrote to John Ruskin in 1855 that she belonged to a family of West Indian slaveholders and would fear a curse if she believed in them.

The critics, then and since

Many contemporaries found him crabbed and wilfully obscure; a Browning Society was founded in 1881 partly to explain him, to his amused embarrassment. Oscar Wilde wrote that Meredith was a prose Browning, ‘and so is Browning’. Henry James, puzzled that the hearty diner-out and the subtle poet could be one person, wrote a story, ‘The Private Life’, in which a writer turns out to be two men. The next generation revised the verdict: Ezra Pound and T. S. Eliot learned the dramatic monologue from him, and modern critics value the villains, casuists and failures of his poems over the optimism that Victorians admired.

What is disputed

The deathbed remark comes from family recollection and is reported in slightly different words. Whether Browning proposed marriage to the wealthy Lady Ashburton in 1869, and insulted her by saying his heart was buried in Florence, rests on hostile letters and is read in opposite ways by biographers. How tyrannical Mr Barrett really was remains argued. Julia Markus has proposed that Elizabeth believed her family had African ancestry through its Jamaican past and that this helps to explain her father’s ban on marriage; most scholars regard the evidence as thin. Suggestions of similar ancestry on Browning’s side, through a grandmother born in the West Indies, are equally unproven.

What followed

Pen Browning, an indifferent painter, kept his parents’ papers and died at Asolo in 1912; the following year the love letters, manuscripts and furniture were scattered at a London auction, and scholars have spent a century reassembling them, largely at Baylor University in Texas. The Ca’ Rezzonico is now Venice’s museum of the eighteenth century. Browning’s method outlived his opinions: the poem spoken by a character who reveals more than he intends became a standard form of twentieth-century verse in English. The courtship, told in some 570 surviving letters, remains one of the best-documented love affairs in literature.

Read further

  • Philip Kelley and others (eds), The Brownings’ Correspondence (1984 onwards)
  • Clyde de L. Ryals, The Life of Robert Browning: A Critical Biography (1993)
  • Margaret Forster, Elizabeth Barrett Browning: A Biography (1988)
  • Julia Markus, Dared and Done: The Marriage of Elizabeth Barrett and Robert Browning (1995)
  • Iain Finlayson, Browning: A Private Life (2004)

Same day, other years

1098

The crusaders sack Ma’arrat al-Numan

Ma’arrat al-Numan, SyriaMiddle East

After taking Antioch, the armies of the First Crusade were starving and quarrelling over who should hold it. In late November 1098 Raymond of Toulouse and Bohemond of Taranto laid siege to Ma’arra, a walled Syrian town on the road south. A siege tower got men onto the walls on the evening of 11 December, and on the 12th the town was sacked. The inhabitants were killed or sold as slaves, including, by the crusaders’ own account, notables to whom Bohemond had promised safety. Several Latin chroniclers, among them Fulcher of Chartres and Ralph of Caen, record that in the famine that followed some crusaders ate the flesh of the dead.

Seen from elsewhere. The Arab historian Ibn al-Athir, writing a century later, put the dead at 100,000, far more than the town can have held, and says little about cannibalism. Modern historians disagree on whether it was the desperation of the starving poor or, as Jay Rubenstein has argued, partly a deliberate display of terror. In modern Arab writing Ma’arra became an emblem of Frankish barbarity.

1901

Marconi hears three dots from across the Atlantic

St John’s, NewfoundlandThe Americas

In a disused hospital on Signal Hill, with an aerial wire held aloft by a kite in a gale, the 27-year-old Guglielmo Marconi pressed a telephone earpiece to his head and listened for the Morse letter S, three short clicks, which his station at Poldhu in Cornwall was sending over and over across some 3,400 kilometres of ocean. At about half past twelve he heard it, and handed the earpiece to his assistant George Kemp, who heard it too. Leading physicists had held that radio waves would travel in straight lines and be lost over the curve of the Earth. Their reflection from the upper atmosphere was not yet understood.

Seen from elsewhere. There was no recording and no independent witness, and some engineers have long doubted that a signal of that wavelength could have been heard in daylight; Marconi may have picked up atmospheric static. He settled the matter with recorded shipboard tests in February 1902. The cable company holding Newfoundland’s telegraph monopoly threatened to sue, and he moved his work to Nova Scotia.

1936

Chiang Kai-shek is kidnapped by his own generals

Xi’an, ChinaAsia

Chiang had flown to Xi’an to order one more campaign against the Communists, by then penned into the barren north-west after the Long March. The troops meant to carry it out were Manchurians whose homeland Japan had occupied, and their commander, Zhang Xueliang, wanted to fight the invader instead. Before dawn his men attacked Chiang’s quarters at the Huaqing hot springs. The Generalissimo escaped over a wall in his nightshirt, without his false teeth, and was found hiding on the hillside. After two weeks of negotiation, in which the Communist Zhou Enlai took a leading part, he was released on Christmas Day, having agreed in substance to end the civil war.

Seen from elsewhere. Communist histories honour Zhang as a patriot whose act made a united front against Japan possible; Nationalists long held that he had saved a beaten enemy who went on to take China. Stalin, who wanted Chiang alive to fight Japan, pressed for his release. Zhang flew back with his prisoner and was held under house arrest for more than fifty years.

1963

Kenya becomes independent

Nairobi, KenyaAfrica

At midnight, before an immense crowd at what is now Uhuru Gardens, the Union Jack was lowered and the black, red and green flag of Kenya raised. The Prime Minister was Jomo Kenyatta, in his seventies, whom the British had imprisoned for almost nine years as the alleged manager of the Mau Mau rebellion and whom a colonial governor had called a leader to darkness and death. He asked the country to forgive and to work together under the slogan Harambee. The European settlers, who had expected to rule a white man’s country, were invited to stay, and many did. Kenya became a republic exactly a year later.

Seen from elsewhere. The forest fighters gained little. Kenyatta said that all had fought for freedom, Mau Mau remained a banned organisation until 2003, and much settler land passed to the well connected. Research by Caroline Elkins and David Anderson documented torture and killings in British detention camps; in 2013 the British government expressed regret and paid compensation to more than five thousand survivors.

Also on 12 December