Parallax

17 December, 1599

A king and queen of France are unmarried

After twenty-seven years, a wedding that had been followed within a week by a massacre was declared never to have been a marriage at all. The queen it set aside outlived the king and ended as a friend of his children.

Paris, France

On 17 December 1599 three churchmen sitting in Paris as commissioners of Pope Clement VIII pronounced that Henri IV of France and Marguerite de Valois had never been validly married. The commissioners were Cardinal de Joyeuse, the papal nuncio and the Archbishop of Arles. Their sentence rested on three grounds: the couple were related within the forbidden degrees and had wed before any papal dispensation arrived; Henri’s godfather had been Marguerite’s father, which created a spiritual kinship; and the bride had not freely consented. It was an annulment, not a divorce, though the word divorce was used at the time and has stuck.

Neither party was in the room. Marguerite had not seen her husband for some seventeen years. Since 1586 she had lived in the fortress of Usson, on a volcanic rock in the Auvergne, first as a prisoner of her brother Henri III and then, having won over the garrison, as its mistress. She was questioned there by a deputy of the commission and stated that her mother, Catherine de’ Medici, and her brother Charles IX had compelled her to marry. Witnesses old enough to remember 1572 were found to say the same.

The case had dragged on since 1593. Henri, who had fought his way to the throne and turned Catholic to keep it, had no legitimate heir, and his cousin the Prince of Conde stood next in line with a contested birth. Marguerite accepted in principle that she must give way, and bargained hard over her debts, her income and her title. What she would not do was make room for the king’s mistress, Gabrielle d’Estrees, whom Henri meant to marry and whose sons he meant to legitimise. Rome was no keener. Then, on 10 April 1599, Gabrielle died in convulsions while pregnant, a few days before the wedding Henri had promised her.

With Gabrielle gone, the obstacle went too. Marguerite signed a fresh power of attorney, the Pope issued his brief in September, and the commission did its work in a few weeks. Henri wrote to her afterwards in warm terms, promising to be a brother to her in deed as well as name. She kept the style of queen and became Duchess of Valois, with her debts paid and a large pension.

The king wasted no time. He had already, that autumn, given a written promise of marriage to a new mistress, Henriette d’Entragues, should she bear him a son. His ministers looked elsewhere, to Florence, where the Medici held a great deal of French royal debt. Henri married Marie de’ Medici by proxy in October 1600 and in person at Lyon that December. Their son, the future Louis XIII, was born in September 1601.

How it came to this

The marriage had been made as a peace treaty. In 1572, after a decade of civil war between French Catholics and Protestants, Catherine de’ Medici arranged for her daughter Marguerite, a Catholic princess of nineteen, to marry Henri of Navarre, the eighteen-year-old leader of the Huguenot party. The wedding took place on 18 August outside Notre-Dame, on a platform, so that the Protestant groom need not hear Mass. The tale that Charles IX pushed his sister’s head forward to make her nod her consent appears only in later writers. Six days afterwards the St Bartholomew’s Day massacre began, and thousands of the Protestants who had come to Paris for the wedding were killed. Henri saved himself by abjuring his faith and spent nearly four years as a captive at court.

The couple were allies more than spouses. Both took lovers openly, and they had no children. They kept a joint court at Nerac in Gascony from 1578 to 1582, then separated. In 1585 Marguerite threw in her lot with the Catholic League against both her husband and her brother, lost, and was shut up in Usson.

How each side saw it

Marguerite de Valois

Her Memoirs, written at Usson and published in 1628, are the first full autobiography by a French royal woman. They stop in 1582 and say nothing of the annulment, but they insist on her loyalty: she records that days after the massacre her mother offered to have the marriage dissolved, and that she refused because she believed it would cost her husband his life. Her letters from the 1590s show a negotiator, not a victim. She conceded the principle early and held out for terms, and she told the king’s envoys plainly that she would not yield her place to a woman of Gabrielle d’Estrees’s reputation.

Henri IV and his ministers

For the king’s council the matter was the survival of the state. France had just come through thirty-six years of religious war, largely because the Valois line had failed. A king of forty-six with no lawful son invited another war of succession the moment he died. The Duke of Sully, in his memoirs, presents the annulment and the Florentine marriage as his own sober policy pursued against a master led by his passions, and claims to have torn up the king’s promise to Henriette d’Entragues. Sully wrote to magnify himself, and historians treat his details with care, but the reasoning was shared by the whole council.

Rome

Clement VIII had absolved Henri of heresy only in 1595, against Spanish opposition, and wanted a Catholic dynasty secured in France. He was also conscious of the precedent of Henry VIII of England, whose annulment suit Rome had refused seventy years earlier at the cost of a kingdom. The Curia would not act while the beneficiary was to be Gabrielle d’Estrees, since that meant legitimising children born in double adultery. Once the proposed bride was a Medici princess, canon lawyers found the defects in the 1572 wedding entirely convincing. The grounds were real enough: the dispensation had indeed arrived after the ceremony.

The pamphleteers and the later legend

Marguerite’s enemies wrote the version that lasted. A pamphlet known as Le Divorce satyrique, circulating around 1607 and put in the king’s mouth, listed her lovers by the dozen and accused her of every vice. Alexandre Dumas drew on that tradition for his 1845 novel, which gave her the nickname Margot that nobody but her brother Charles had used in her lifetime. The historian Eliane Viennot has argued since the 1990s that the nymphomaniac queen is a construction of Protestant and misogynist polemic, and that the documents show a learned patron and a competent politician.

What is disputed

Whether Marguerite was truly forced to marry is doubtful. Her own Memoirs describe reluctance, not coercion, and the testimony of 1599 was what all parties needed to hear. The nod extracted by Charles IX is first told decades later. How many lovers she had cannot be known: most names come from hostile pamphlets, and claims that she bore illegitimate children rest on no solid evidence. Sully’s account of his own role is self-serving. The rumour that Gabrielle d’Estrees was poisoned to clear the way was widespread in 1599; modern medical opinion favours eclampsia.

What followed

Marguerite returned to Paris in 1605, built a mansion on the left bank facing the Louvre, and held one of the leading literary salons of the capital. She was on affectionate terms with Marie de’ Medici and made the young Louis XIII her heir. Henri was stabbed to death by Francois Ravaillac in 1610; she died in 1615, the last of the Valois. The Bourbon line secured by the annulment ruled France until 1792 and again from 1814 to 1830, and its Spanish branch still reigns.

Read further

  • Marguerite de Valois, Memoirs (first published 1628)
  • Eliane Viennot, Marguerite de Valois: histoire d’une femme, histoire d’un mythe (1993)
  • David Buisseret, Henry IV (1984)
  • Robert J. Sealy, The Myth of the Reine Margot: Toward the Elimination of a Legend (1994)
  • Maximilien de Bethune, duc de Sully, Oeconomies royales

Same day, other years

1398

Timur breaks the army of Delhi

Delhi, IndiaAsia

Timur, the Turco-Mongol conqueror known in Europe as Tamerlane, had crossed the Indus in September with a cavalry army from Samarkand. Outside Delhi he met the forces of Sultan Nasir-ud-Din Mahmud Tughlaq, whose line of armoured war elephants was the weapon his men most feared. His court historians say he had trenches dug and sent camels loaded with burning straw towards the elephants, which turned and trampled their own side. The sultan fled. Timur entered the city, and within days his troops sacked it. Delhi, one of the richest cities in Asia, was emptied of people and goods and took generations to recover.

Seen from elsewhere. The Zafarnama, written for Timur’s heirs, presents the campaign as holy war against a sultanate too indulgent to Hindus, and states that he had some 100,000 captives killed before the battle, a figure modern historians doubt. Most of Delhi’s dead were themselves Muslims. Indo-Persian chroniclers describe famine and plague in the ruins.

1830

Bolivar dies on his way into exile

Santa Marta, ColombiaThe Americas

Simon Bolivar had led the wars that ended Spanish rule from Venezuela to Bolivia. By 1830 the great republic he had built, Colombia, was coming apart: Venezuela and Ecuador were seceding, his chosen successor Sucre had been murdered, and he had resigned the presidency in the spring. Ill with what his French doctor, Alexandre Reverend, took to be consumption, he travelled down the Magdalena meaning to sail for Europe. He got no further than an estate outside Santa Marta lent to him by a Spaniard, where he died at about one in the afternoon, aged forty-seven. Weeks earlier he had written that those who served the revolution had ploughed the sea.

Seen from elsewhere. Many of his contemporaries did not mourn. Liberals in Bogota remembered that he had ruled as dictator from 1828 and survived their attempt to kill him; Venezuela’s congress had barred his return. His cult came later, and was claimed by every Venezuelan government since. Hugo Chavez had the body exhumed in 2010 to test a poisoning theory, without a conclusive result.

1903

Four flights over the sand

Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina, United StatesThe Americas

Orville and Wilbur Wright, bicycle makers from Dayton, Ohio, had spent four years on gliders, a home-built wind tunnel and a method of control that twisted the wingtips. On a cold, windy Thursday near Kitty Hawk their powered machine left its launching rail at 10.35 with Orville lying at the controls and stayed up for twelve seconds, covering 120 feet. They took turns three more times. On the last flight Wilbur stayed airborne for 59 seconds and 852 feet. Five local men watched, and one of them, John Daniels, took the photograph. A gust then wrecked the machine, and it never flew again.

Seen from elsewhere. The Smithsonian long credited its own secretary, Samuel Langley, with the first machine capable of flight, and the Wrights’ aircraft went to a London museum until 1948 in protest. Many Brazilians hold that Alberto Santos-Dumont’s public, unassisted take-off in Paris in 1906 was the first true flight. Claims for Gustave Whitehead in 1901 are rejected by most historians.

2010

A street vendor sets himself alight

Sidi Bouzid, TunisiaAfrica

Mohamed Bouazizi, twenty-six, supported his mother and siblings by selling fruit and vegetables from a barrow in a poor town in the Tunisian interior. On the morning of 17 December municipal inspectors confiscated his scales and produce. He went to the governor’s office to complain and was not received. Shortly before noon he stood in the road outside, poured fuel over himself and lit it. Protests began in the town the same day and spread, filmed on mobile phones, across the country. He died of his burns on 4 January 2011. Ten days later President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali, in power for twenty-three years, fled to Saudi Arabia.

Seen from elsewhere. Faida Hamdi, the inspector widely reported to have slapped him, denied it, spent months in prison and was acquitted when the complaint was withdrawn. Early reports that Bouazizi was an unemployed graduate were wrong. Some residents of Sidi Bouzid later said that the revolution made in his name brought them little, and his family left the town.

Also on 17 December