On 17 December 1599 three churchmen sitting in Paris as commissioners of Pope Clement VIII pronounced that Henri IV of France and Marguerite de Valois had never been validly married. The commissioners were Cardinal de Joyeuse, the papal nuncio and the Archbishop of Arles. Their sentence rested on three grounds: the couple were related within the forbidden degrees and had wed before any papal dispensation arrived; Henri’s godfather had been Marguerite’s father, which created a spiritual kinship; and the bride had not freely consented. It was an annulment, not a divorce, though the word divorce was used at the time and has stuck.
Neither party was in the room. Marguerite had not seen her husband for some seventeen years. Since 1586 she had lived in the fortress of Usson, on a volcanic rock in the Auvergne, first as a prisoner of her brother Henri III and then, having won over the garrison, as its mistress. She was questioned there by a deputy of the commission and stated that her mother, Catherine de’ Medici, and her brother Charles IX had compelled her to marry. Witnesses old enough to remember 1572 were found to say the same.
The case had dragged on since 1593. Henri, who had fought his way to the throne and turned Catholic to keep it, had no legitimate heir, and his cousin the Prince of Conde stood next in line with a contested birth. Marguerite accepted in principle that she must give way, and bargained hard over her debts, her income and her title. What she would not do was make room for the king’s mistress, Gabrielle d’Estrees, whom Henri meant to marry and whose sons he meant to legitimise. Rome was no keener. Then, on 10 April 1599, Gabrielle died in convulsions while pregnant, a few days before the wedding Henri had promised her.
With Gabrielle gone, the obstacle went too. Marguerite signed a fresh power of attorney, the Pope issued his brief in September, and the commission did its work in a few weeks. Henri wrote to her afterwards in warm terms, promising to be a brother to her in deed as well as name. She kept the style of queen and became Duchess of Valois, with her debts paid and a large pension.
The king wasted no time. He had already, that autumn, given a written promise of marriage to a new mistress, Henriette d’Entragues, should she bear him a son. His ministers looked elsewhere, to Florence, where the Medici held a great deal of French royal debt. Henri married Marie de’ Medici by proxy in October 1600 and in person at Lyon that December. Their son, the future Louis XIII, was born in September 1601.
How it came to this
The marriage had been made as a peace treaty. In 1572, after a decade of civil war between French Catholics and Protestants, Catherine de’ Medici arranged for her daughter Marguerite, a Catholic princess of nineteen, to marry Henri of Navarre, the eighteen-year-old leader of the Huguenot party. The wedding took place on 18 August outside Notre-Dame, on a platform, so that the Protestant groom need not hear Mass. The tale that Charles IX pushed his sister’s head forward to make her nod her consent appears only in later writers. Six days afterwards the St Bartholomew’s Day massacre began, and thousands of the Protestants who had come to Paris for the wedding were killed. Henri saved himself by abjuring his faith and spent nearly four years as a captive at court.
The couple were allies more than spouses. Both took lovers openly, and they had no children. They kept a joint court at Nerac in Gascony from 1578 to 1582, then separated. In 1585 Marguerite threw in her lot with the Catholic League against both her husband and her brother, lost, and was shut up in Usson.