Parallax

13 December, 1784

Samuel Johnson dies at Bolt Court

The man who had feared death all his life refused opium at the end so as to meet it with a clear head, and left most of what he owned to a servant who had been born enslaved in Jamaica.

Bolt Court, Fleet Street, London

For most of his seventy-five years Samuel Johnson was terrified of dying. He did not doubt that there was a judgement, and he doubted very much that he would pass it. When Boswell once suggested that the fear might be overcome, Johnson answered that the whole of life was but keeping away the thoughts of it. In June 1783 a stroke woke him in the night and took away his speech. To find out whether his mind had gone too, he composed a prayer in Latin verse; the lines were not good, he judged, but he knew they were not good, and concluded that his faculties were intact.

By the autumn of 1784 his body was failing on several fronts. His lungs were ruined, his legs were swollen with dropsy and he could not sleep lying down. He travelled to Lichfield and Oxford to see old friends for the last time and came home in November to his house in Bolt Court, a narrow passage off Fleet Street. There he set his affairs in order. He burned a great mass of private papers, including, to the lasting regret of biographers, two volumes of his own diary. He made a will. After a few small legacies he left an annuity of seventy pounds and the residue of his estate to Francis Barber, who had been with him for more than thirty years.

He asked his physician, Richard Brocklesby, to tell him plainly whether he could recover. Told that he could not without a miracle, he said that he would take no more physic, not even opiates, ‘for I have prayed that I may render up my soul to God unclouded’. He kept to it for most of his last days. Impatient with the surgeon’s caution, he took a lancet and scissors to his own swollen legs to let the fluid out, and lost a good deal of blood.

On Monday 13 December a young woman, the daughter of a friend, came to the door to ask his blessing. Barber took her in. Johnson turned in the bed and said, ‘God bless you, my dear.’ These are the last words anyone recorded with confidence. He sank into a doze, and at about a quarter past seven in the evening Barber and Mrs Desmoulins, a member of the household, noticed that the laboured breathing had stopped.

A post-mortem found the lungs distended, the heart enlarged and a stone in the gall bladder. A week later he was buried in Westminster Abbey, near the grave of his old pupil David Garrick.

How it came to this

Johnson was born in 1709 above his father’s bookshop in Lichfield. An infection caught in infancy left him scarred, half-blind in one eye and partly deaf, and he was subject all his life to convulsive tics and long depressions. Poverty forced him out of Oxford after thirteen months. He married a widow twenty years his senior, failed as a schoolmaster, and in 1737 walked to London with Garrick to live by his pen. For years he wrote parliamentary reports, biographies and poems for booksellers, often without enough money for a lodging.

The Dictionary of the English Language made his name. He contracted for it in 1746 and delivered it in 1755, with some 40,000 entries illustrated by more than 100,000 quotations, the work of one man and half a dozen copyists where the French Academy had employed forty scholars for decades. Essays, the tale Rasselas, an edition of Shakespeare and the Lives of the Poets followed. A royal pension of 300 pounds from 1762 freed him to do what he liked best, which was to talk. In 1763 a young Scot named James Boswell began writing the talk down.

How each side saw it

James Boswell

Boswell was in Scotland when Johnson died and learned of it by letter. His Life of Samuel Johnson, published in 1791, built from journals in which he had reconstructed conversations within hours or days, is the reason Johnson is remembered as a voice as much as a writer. It is also a partial portrait. Boswell knew Johnson only for his last twenty-one years and was in his company, scholars calculate, on perhaps four hundred days. He arranged scenes, provoked his subject with planted questions, and played down friends he saw as rivals. His Johnson is the Tory sage of the tavern and the club, seen always through an admirer’s eyes.

Hester Thrale Piozzi

For sixteen years Johnson all but lived with the brewer Henry Thrale and his wife Hester at Streatham. She nursed him through breakdowns, and her Anecdotes of 1786 show a domestic Johnson: tender with children, rude at table, afraid of solitude and of madness. Among her papers was a padlock he had entrusted to her, which has prompted much speculation. When, as a widow, she married the Italian singer Gabriel Piozzi in July 1784, Johnson wrote her a furious letter and she replied with dignity that her husband’s birth was not meaner than her first husband’s. He softened, but they did not meet again. Boswell’s circle never forgave her.

Francis Barber

Barber left no memoir. He was born enslaved on a Jamaican sugar estate around 1742, brought to England as a child, freed, and placed with Johnson in 1752. Johnson paid for his schooling and, when Barber ran off to sea, had him discharged from the navy. What we know of him comes through Boswell, who interviewed him, and through Johnson’s executor Sir John Hawkins, who thought the legacy a scandalous indulgence of a Black servant and said so in print. Johnson detested slavery; he once toasted the next insurrection of the enslaved in the West Indies. Barber moved to Lichfield, spent the money and died poor in 1801. His descendants still live in Staffordshire.

American colonists and Scots

Not everyone mourned. In Taxation No Tyranny (1775), written for the government, Johnson had dismissed the American case entirely and asked why ‘we hear the loudest yelps for liberty among the drivers of negroes’. Americans remembered him as a pensioned hireling. Scots resented a lifetime of gibes, the dictionary’s definition of oats as a grain given to horses in England but in Scotland supporting the people, and his insistence that James Macpherson’s Ossian poems were a fabrication, on which he has been largely vindicated.

What is disputed

How far to trust Boswell is the central question. Donald Greene argued that the Life is unreliable as biography and that its conversations are literary compositions; other scholars, comparing the book with Boswell’s surviving journals, find him careful on substance. Johnson’s politics are argued too: J. C. D. Clark has presented him as a man of Jacobite sympathies, Greene as something close to a sceptical Whig. Modern physicians, beginning with T. J. Murray in 1979, have read his tics as Tourette syndrome, which cannot be proved. Katharine Balderston’s suggestion that his dependence on Mrs Thrale had a masochistic side remains contested. Accounts of his final days by Hawkins, Hoole and others differ in detail.

What followed

Within seven years three biographies had appeared, by Mrs Piozzi, Hawkins and Boswell, and their authors’ quarrels helped to establish biography as a form that shows a subject’s faults. The Dictionary remained the standard authority in English for more than a century, until the Oxford English Dictionary, which borrowed its method of illustrating words by dated quotations. Johnson’s house in Gough Square, where the Dictionary was compiled, is a museum. Boswell’s private papers, long believed destroyed, were found at Malahide Castle in Ireland and at Fettercairn in Scotland in the 1920s and 1930s, allowing the Life to be checked against its raw material.

Read further

  • James Boswell, The Life of Samuel Johnson (1791)
  • Hester Lynch Piozzi, Anecdotes of the Late Samuel Johnson (1786)
  • W. Jackson Bate, Samuel Johnson (1977)
  • Michael Bundock, The Fortunes of Francis Barber (2015)
  • Donald Greene, The Politics of Samuel Johnson (1960)

Same day, other years

1545

The Council of Trent opens

Trent, Prince-Bishopric of TrentEurope

Nearly thirty years after Luther’s theses, the general council that reformers on every side had demanded finally met in a small Alpine city chosen because it lay inside the Holy Roman Empire but on the Italian side of the mountains. Barely thirty bishops attended the opening Mass, most of them Italian. The council sat in three periods over eighteen years, interrupted by plague, war and the death of popes. It defined Catholic teaching against the Protestants on scripture and tradition, justification and the seven sacraments, and ordered practical reform: bishops must live in their dioceses, and every diocese must have a seminary to train its priests.

Seen from elsewhere. The Emperor Charles V had wanted a council that might reconcile the Lutherans; Protestants refused to recognise one summoned and controlled by the Pope, and a brief Lutheran appearance in 1552 led nowhere. The Venetian friar Paolo Sarpi, in a history published in London in 1619, portrayed the council as a triumph of papal management over genuine reform.

1642

Abel Tasman sights New Zealand

West coast of the South Island, New ZealandOceania

Sailing east from Tasmania for the Dutch East India Company in search of new markets, Abel Tasman and the crews of the Heemskerck and Zeehaen saw what his journal calls a large land, uplifted high: the mountains of the South Island’s west coast. They were the first Europeans known to have seen it. Five days later the ships anchored in what is now Golden Bay. Canoes of the Ngati Tumatakokiri came out, and after an exchange of trumpet calls from both sides one of them rammed a Dutch boat passing between the ships. Four sailors were killed. Tasman named the place Murderers Bay and left without setting foot ashore.

Seen from elsewhere. Maori had lived in the islands for some four centuries. Ngati Tumatakokiri were later overrun by other tribes and their own account of the meeting is lost. Historians and Maori scholars suggest that the Dutch trumpets were heard as accepting a ritual challenge, or that the visitors had anchored close to valuable gardens. No European returned until James Cook in 1769.

1937

Nanjing falls and the killing begins

Nanjing, ChinaAsia

Japanese forces entered the Chinese capital on 13 December after the defending army collapsed and its commander fled. Over roughly six weeks, soldiers killed surrendered troops and civilians in very large numbers and raped women and girls throughout the city. A group of about two dozen foreigners who had stayed behind, led by the German businessman John Rabe, a Nazi party member, and including the American missionary teacher Minnie Vautrin, declared a safety zone that sheltered some 200,000 people; their diaries and letters are among the main records. The post-war Tokyo tribunal found that more than 200,000 had been killed and about 20,000 raped. General Matsui Iwane was hanged.

Seen from elsewhere. China’s official figure is 300,000 dead. Japanese historians range widely, from estimates close to the tribunal’s to Hata Ikuhiko’s of about 40,000, and a nationalist fringe denies that a massacre took place, a position rejected by mainstream scholarship in Japan as elsewhere. The treatment of the subject in Japanese school textbooks has repeatedly strained relations with China.

1981

Martial law in Poland

Warsaw, PolandEurope

At six on a snowy Sunday morning Poles turned on their radios and heard General Wojciech Jaruzelski announce that a Military Council of National Salvation had taken power. Telephone lines were dead, tanks stood at crossroads, and during the night police had arrested most of the leadership of Solidarity, the independent trade union that had enrolled nearly ten million members in sixteen months. Some ten thousand people were interned. Strikes were broken by force; at the Wujek coal mine in Katowice on 16 December riot police shot nine miners dead. Martial law was suspended at the end of 1982 and lifted in July 1983. Solidarity survived underground.

Seen from elsewhere. Jaruzelski maintained to his death in 2014 that he had chosen the lesser evil to forestall a Soviet invasion. Records of the Soviet Politburo published after 1991 show its members ruling out intervention that month, and suggest he asked for military help and was refused. His defenders reply that he could not have known Moscow’s mind. Polish opinion remains divided.

Also on 13 December